fcschoenthal Posted February 22 Report Posted February 22 I got an email from Oneida last week about their new cyclonic dust extractor with MSRP of $1150. It appears to be an amped up shop vac with one of their small Dust Deputy units attached and doesn't come with a hose or any attachments. I've used cyclonic units in conjunction with shop vacs for years and am just finishing up a new cart for my Ridgid 16 gal unit. I just don't see paying this much for something that can be put together for 15% of this price, or even Festool that would be less. There must be something I'm missing. 2 Quote
pkinneb Posted February 22 Report Posted February 22 It does seem high priced but looks to be a pretty powerful little unit with a decent sized collection bin compared to a Festool. I will say this I own a fair amount of Festool equipment and one of the few that I believe are worth what they cost is their dust extractor. In my opinion they are on a different playing field when compared to a shop vac with a cyclone (which I have on my Festool vac). I also have a Onieda shop dust collection system and it has worked pretty much flawless for almost 20 years. I suspect the unit works well in its own use case not sure I see it for my case though 1 Quote
fcschoenthal Posted February 22 Author Report Posted February 22 Well, the Oneida has 128 cfm, the Festool CT48 has 137 and my Ridgid has 161. The Oneida is 14 gal, a CT48 is 12.7 and my Ridgid is 16 gal (even though I'll never see more than the 5 gal from the separator). I use the bag and a HEPA filter, so consider it close enough to compare. I have a CT26 that I use with my Festool tools, but use the Ridgid for cleaning up everything else. I also have a highly Frankenstiened HF dust collector for the larger machines, but have been eyeing an Oneida Supercell as a replacement. I guess that Oneida is going after the bigger Festool extractor market, but their Dust Cobra and Mini Gorilla are only a couple of hundred more. Too many other manufacturers are coming out with HEPA extractors that are half that price. 2 Quote
Popular Post Beechwood Chip Posted February 22 Popular Post Report Posted February 22 I just got a Harbor Freight "Hercules" dust extractor for $370+tax. 155 cfm, 12 gallons, 73db, self cleaning HEPA filters. I've never used any other dust extractors, but I like it a lot more than any shop vac I've owned. 4 Quote
Chet Posted February 23 Report Posted February 23 On 2/22/2026 at 2:43 PM, fcschoenthal said: but have been eyeing an Oneida Supercell as a replacement. Make sure you really look into this and try to find some real world reviews. I had listen to a podcast two or three years back and one of them had purchased the Supercell. They had only had it for a short time but were kind of disappointed with it. 2 Quote
Mark J Posted February 24 Report Posted February 24 20 hours ago, Chet said: They had only had it for a short time but were kind of disappointed with it. Do you remember what the issue was? Quote
Chet Posted February 24 Report Posted February 24 If I recall correctly they felt like it was more of a shop vac then a dust collector, was sub par on longer runs. 2 Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted February 24 Report Posted February 24 On 2/24/2026 at 11:12 AM, Chet said: more of a shop vac then a dust collector, Wait, are talking dust extractors or dust collectors? My understanding is that based on static pressure vs cfm, it goes dust extractor << shop vac << dust collector << air filter, with the collector intended for high cfm, low "suck" and long, large ducts, and the extractor intended for high suck, low cfm, narrow hose. 2 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted February 24 Report Posted February 24 That's my rough understanding as well. According to what I've heard, the Supercell is supposed to have the flow of a dust extractor, combined with the static pressure of a shop vac. Maybe it just becomes a mediocre version of both? Some folks I follow on YT claim its great, but they generally received it as a sponsorship. 1 Quote
Von Posted February 25 Report Posted February 25 On 2/24/2026 at 11:51 AM, Beechwood Chip said: Wait, are talking dust extractors or dust collectors? My understanding is that based on static pressure vs cfm, it goes dust extractor << shop vac << dust collector << air filter, with the collector intended for high cfm, low "suck" and long, large ducts, and the extractor intended for high suck, low cfm, narrow hose. I tend to find marketing and product naming isn't as predictable as my engineer brain would like, but in general I agree with this. I'm not sure "dust extractor" is ubiquitous defined, but I may just have naively lumped it with "dust collector" in my head. And I admit engineers tend to come up with precise but awful names... 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.