Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Questions for Chris Schwarz

Featured Replies

Hey Guildies. I will be interviewing Chris Schwarz in the next week or so for the Guild. The interview is going to be very specifically focused on the Roubo design and how it relates to our upcoming Split Top Roubo build. This isn't so much an interview about what Chris likes to do in his spare time, what flavor coffee he drinks, and how he gets his hair to look so darn good.

So Guild members, please feel free to leave a concise and focused question here so that I can consider including it in the interview.

I've e-mailed him a question simialr to this, but thhink it may be a useful bit of info for everyone:

- In his books he has implored people to build as big & sturdy of a bench as they can. If neither cost nor space were an issue, what would this nominally "Biggest" bench measure out to be?

and a completely different subject:

- Where does he think is a good place to shop/dig/etc for older quick release vises? I'm leaning this way for my end vise, but have found eBay & Craigslist lacking in inventory.

I'm also curious as to what he thinks of the split top vs a monolithic slab, any concerns about flex or vibration.

I see his version has the legs attaching to the top with a through mortise/tenon combo with a dovetail....does he like that better than the Benchcrafted attachment method, advantages/disadvantages of each. Maybe his thoughts on knockdown benches vs permanently glued-up type benches.

How does he like the wagon vise compared to other options.

What would he modify on the Benchcrafted plan, and why.

What dog hole layout does he find most useful. Square, round, both? Does he favor a Swiss cheese approach or does he use a new bench for a bit and then decide where he wants a holdfast hole?

I notice he has used huge wooden screws on some of his leg vises...for pure practicality/utility does he prefer the metal acme threaded rod or the coarse wood threads?

How useful does he find a crochet type device, is it even worth considering or is it merely an affectation?

What on bench storage does he find most useful? Wax or tallow drawer, etc.

All I can think of for now. Thanks.

Chris,

I was looking at doing the whole bench in a River Red Gum (Eucalyptus camaldulensis), however the cost for the cured wood is prohibitive.

I can get maple at about 1/2 the price here in Aus (crazy I know, its cheaper to import maple than use our own hardwoods).

My question is I want to still want to use the Hard Red Gum for the 12/4 pieces, i.e. Vise Chop & End Bloc as well as the dog holes and backing strip on the top.

Do you see any issues in the woods being glued together in the slab & end block ? I am concerned mainly about on the bench top with the woods having different moisture absorption causing eventual splitting or cracking especially in the dog hole backing strip ?

This is a good site below that details the characteristics of red gum and most other Australian hardwoods for those interested.

http://www.hardwood.timber.net.au/species/redgum.htm

http://www.hardwood.timber.net.au/speciesindex.htm

Cheers

Chas

I just got the The Workbench Design book. Good book, more readable, but still rather small print :) The chapter "The Best Bench Never Built" got me thinking again.

My question is related to bench top material:

I recently got a good amount of (mostly) quarter sawn old growth Douglas Fir. These are former floor boards (6" wide, 2 1/2" thick, 6 - 8' long).

if we assume that money is secondary concern, would you recommend building the workbench top from that wood or rather hard maple? And why would Chris recommend a single slab?

--bjorn

Here are some questions:

- Does he see WIA changing? Location? Change from yearly to something else? Can they do something online?

- Where does he think Pop Wood will go without him?

- How did he pay off his mortgage so quickly? I know that ones personal but if you can phrase it in the form of starting of a woodworking/publishing business it might become relevant.

- Can he talk about potential books coming out?

- Does he see a tool void anyway (i.e. are there any tools he'd like to see built)?

Ok, those are some ideas. I won't be offended if none of them make the cut.

-Shawn

Since WIA, has he gone back to looking like a wookie?

Since WIA, has he gone back to looking like a wookie?

At this WIA he looked more relaxed than I've ever seen him before. Quitting a high pressure job can do that. :)

I see his version has the legs attaching to the top with a through mortise/tenon combo with a dovetail....does he like that better than the Benchcrafted attachment method, advantages/disadvantages of each. Maybe his thoughts on knockdown benches vs permanently glued-up type benches.

+1

Also, he was a guest on a couple episodes of the Woodwright's Shop last year. Ask him how annoying it is when Roy keeps trying to grab the piece of wood out of his hands he's demonstrating on. :D Those were good episodes.

Can you ask him why on earth he does he not own a pickup truck of some kind?

Jonathan

==========================================

What are his thoughts or reviews on todays wood planes, No. 8, and No.4?

I was wondering if he would prefer a 20 degree angled leg vise vs the current design and given the option, would he work this into the design or leave it as is? The advantage from what I have read is the abilityto clam larger pieces and a greater variety of sizes.

Would be interested in Chris' thoughts on how short a roubo bench could be (practically) and still use the BenchCrafted (BC) Tail (wagon) Vise. The BC mini with offset legs (attached) won't work in my case. My space can handle about 6 feet.

Oh, also, how much overhang to right of Leg Vise is appropriate and why.

As others mentioned I'd be interested on his take of the spit vs monolithic top.

and

Full mortise and tenon vs barrel bolt hardware approach. In his book he did not think highly of the barrel bolt approach, but perhaps BC's massive offerings have more validity.

Top to Leg connections. Our BC/Guild approach or the double tenon (one dovetailed, other straight)?

Thanks, pops

post-357-0-59640300-1321810630_thumb.jpg

I need to roll my bench into the driveway each, non-raining day.

I plan to add a flip down wheel bar as shown on the LVL bench and seen at WIA. For this Roubo guild bench is this lunacy or workable given the size/weight?

thanks

Okay here's a few questions to consider for the interview.

What is your preferred choice of wood for the top and base?

If I'm using 10 inch wide 8/4 stock for the top and find that I could make the top thicker so as not to waste wood is a thicker top better and/or is there a reason for 4 inch top?

There's been some discussion on end cap Options for reflattening purposes what's your opinion on that?

And is there a way to make this bench mobile and still be solid to the floor?

Thanks

Jeff

This questions might reveal how shallow my experience pool is, but have having read the bulk of his book, I'd love to hear an answer to this from the both of you.

The wagon vise on the split top Roubo is perplexing me. It looks like the hardware is either identical of very similar to do a wagon vise or an slide L block tail vise. It seems, to my armature eye, that with a sliding block and dog holes in the right spot(s), I can do everything that the wagon vise can do plus more options for work holding on right end of the bench minus a little bit of support where the block sides out. The recurring theme that stand out in Chris's book is efficiency and economy of effort, so what's the downside of the sliding L block tail vise? What's a wagon vise do that an L block can't? Where's the gain?

What would Chris recommend to use in finishing a bench that uses curly maple for all show surfaces (legs, stretchers, front laminate, etc.)? I've been searching for something that would make the curly maple pop without darkening the bench too much and not making the bench too slick.

I've recently become a little obsessed with the Holtzapffel bench from Chris's Workbench Design book. Since he has experience working on both the Holtzapffel and Roubo bench designs, how would he compare the two?

I have heard that a bench is dependent upon not only the user but what kind of work they will be doing (hand tools vs power tools/routers). If you can only have one bench and the work you do is a balance of hand and power tools, how should this influence the bench height? Average between high (power tools) and low (hand tools)? Also could you reiterate the rule of thumb for ideal bench height.

Thanks

Does the added height of a Moxon Vice change the equation on bench height? Do he suggest setting a bench low enough for planing and use the Moxon to raise the material for dovetailing and/or power tool usage?

Will he ever allow Roy Underhill around another one of his benches???

And a related question...

Did he break Roy's axe in retaliation?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.