dodgeram99 Posted December 26, 2012 Report Posted December 26, 2012 Im looking to buy a drum sander. The one i have in mind is the G0458 from Grizzley. Has any one ever used this model? If so how well did it perform? Or is there a better brand for around the same price? Quote
Colorado Brian Posted December 26, 2012 Report Posted December 26, 2012 I'm usually a big fan of Grizzly but for my drum sander I went with the Jet 16-32. The jet has optional indeed/outfeed tables while a little on the pricey side but are definitely worth it. Just like a planer, if the work piece isn't supported you can get snipe in the last couple of inches of the board especially if you're being a little aggressive with your depth. The Jet performs well and the only tricky part is making sure you get the sandpaper on fairly tight and straight but once you get the hang of it the machine makes quick work of flattening panels. they are about $100 more in price than the Grizzly and the tables are about $137 Quote
Keggers Posted December 26, 2012 Report Posted December 26, 2012 I'm also in the market for a drum sander. All of my equipment is Grizzly, but this time I'm going with a different manufacturer. I've visited the Grizzly showroom in Springfield and wasn't real impressed with their drum sanders. I'm not sure what I'll buy, but this time, it won't be a Grizzly. Quote
estesbubba Posted December 26, 2012 Report Posted December 26, 2012 I own several pieces of Grizzly machinery and very happy with it but I went with a Jet 16-32 for my drum sander and love it. Once you run your first edge-glued panel through it, any hint of buyer's remorse you might have will instantly go away. I actually run most boards through it just to clean up the faces from the jointer and planer. Mine has the SandSmart feature and I generally run at full-speed and let it slow down the feed if needed. One thing is the manual said to adjust the open end slightly higher when boards are wide enough to require a double-pass. I found adjusting this to be a pain and keep my open end slightly high all the time. If it's critical that both edges are the same height then I make one pass, rotate 180º horizontally so same face is up, then send through again without adjusting drum height. I pretty much use 120 in mine all the time. I found it's a great for cleaning up edge-glued panels while not leaving deep scratches in the surface. Light passes are the key to great results (< 1/64") and don't try to use it for dimensioning. I buy the long rolls and cut them myself which is easy - just use the sample paper as a template. http://www.industrialabrasives.com/ Quote
Eric. Posted December 26, 2012 Report Posted December 26, 2012 I'm buying one this spring so I've been researching, too. The major problem with the Grizzly sanders is that most of them have a minimum board thickness of 1/8", which means if you want to sand home-resawn veneers thinner than that, you're SOL. That's unacceptable to me. So I've been drooling over this one and trying to talk myself out of it for a while. It's not working. Prepare for sticker shock... Quote
dcustoms Posted December 26, 2012 Report Posted December 26, 2012 I had that exact same grizzly drum sander for about two weeks. it's junk IMO. I would follow everyone else's recommendations and go with the jet. Quote
dodgeram99 Posted December 26, 2012 Author Report Posted December 26, 2012 I had that exact same grizzly drum sander for about two weeks. it's junk IMO. I would follow everyone else's recommendations and go with the jet. what makes it junk? Quote
dodgeram99 Posted December 26, 2012 Author Report Posted December 26, 2012 The jet 22-44 pro is way out of budget and would take up a lot of shop space. So its out of the question. Quote
Dave H Posted December 26, 2012 Report Posted December 26, 2012 Here's the jet 16-32 free shipping http://www.tools-plu...et-629004k.html I've been looking at this one myself, bought my unisaw from Tools Plus it was a free shipping deal they were good to work with, no problems. Quote
Eric. Posted December 26, 2012 Report Posted December 26, 2012 The jet 22-44 pro is way out of budget and would take up a lot of shop space. So its out of the question. Yeah, it's big and expensive. And badass. The minimum board thickness on the Grizzly is the deal breaker for me. I have a bunch of Grizzly machines and have been happy with them all. But their sanders...poorly designed, IMO, if you can't sand anything thinner than 1/8". Quote
dcustoms Posted December 26, 2012 Report Posted December 26, 2012 It didn't sand well no matter how much time you spent setting it up. I had it dialed in to perfection and it could not get through a board with out bogging down. The thrust bearings for the variable speed control stopped working and became stuck on their arbor. Everything with the machine was a struggle. It was made poorly. With that being said it is only what I observed. However I don't think I have ever used a grizzly machine that didn't give me trouble in some way or another. Again just my experience. I am sure there are Grizzly tools out there that work well and people enjoy using. I only have experience with the above mentioned drum sander, the 35inch dual drum sander, the 20 inch planer and several smaller machines. In my opinion I would not waste your money on this machine the jet machines are well known. Quote
Pwalter5110 Posted December 26, 2012 Report Posted December 26, 2012 I have a delta drum sander. With that being said...one thing to keep in mind is that you are raising and lowering the table, instead of the sanding head. So if you are running long stock you, every pass you will have to level your out feed support with the table. Just a thought. And one thing Im not happy about with the Delta. Quote
nateswoodworks Posted December 27, 2012 Report Posted December 27, 2012 I have had Jet16-32 for a few years now and love it. The common problem you hear of with the Delta is the fact that the conveyor raises and lowers and not the head, most people have issues with it going out of wack and the thickness from side to side changes. The place where I bought my Jet is a big distributor of woodworking machinery, after talking to them I found out they refused to even sell the Delta any more because of all the problems their customers have faced. I have several Delta tools and love them, but it seems they have dropped the ball on this one. As far as the minimum stock thickness, 1/8" is just fine. In order to run thin stock you're much better off using a substrate to hold you veneer flat and stable, then run the whole thing through. It will provide you a much better surface by eliminating any variances from telegraphing through and your conveyor belt will thank you as well. Quote
wjffineww Posted December 27, 2012 Report Posted December 27, 2012 I have the Jet 16-32 as well, and it works pretty good. My only real complaint with it is it's slow, and you really have to take light passes, but that is just the nature of that size machine, not necessarily that particular model. I would also say that it's more suited to smaller size workpieces. Not sure what type of work you do, but I wouldn't plan on running 4' x 32'' panels through a machine of this size all too often. Quote
dwacker Posted December 27, 2012 Report Posted December 27, 2012 Ive owned every jet /performax made since they came out and now powermatic. I would agree with everyone else the jet is probably the best for a home non production shop. I wouldnt buy any griz even the large closed end machines heard to many horror stories from production cab shops that took the chance at a griz. Don Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted December 28, 2012 Report Posted December 28, 2012 Just a thought... Any machine can sand thinner than 1/8", just attach the material to an MDF carrier with carpet tape or rubber cement. If you use tape, use it under an extra section of material that will be tossed, as the thickness of the tape will telegraph into thin material. You could also glue a consumable rear "pusher" fence to the carrier that will be sanded away as the material is sanded. I'm not familiar with the Grizz machine, but have been very happy with a Performax (Jet) for the last 5-6 years. Quote
Skunkeye Posted December 29, 2012 Report Posted December 29, 2012 I have a Delta, and don't like it. It seems to have two settings...bog down a little, and bog down a lot. I'll probably replace it someday if I need to sand a bunch of panels, because it is weak! Quote
Trip Posted December 30, 2012 Report Posted December 30, 2012 ==> Any machine can sand thinner than 1/8", just attach the material to an MDF carrier with carpet tape or rubber cement. +1 I have a small carrier (mdf with rubber mat) for inlay material. My WB can sand down to 3/32, but requires about 14" minimum, so a small carrier is needed for small parts. The only issue with carriers is length. I prefer a carrier for lengths up to 24" on inlay materials. For long lengths, carriers become a pain in the ass. I've used them to 48", but it becomes an issue beyond. For folks looking for thin stock beyond 48" (I would suspect very rare requirement), minimum thickness becomes a critical spec. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.