Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Sound Dampening

Featured Replies

I'm working on the basement shop. Right now, it seems like finding a solution to running a little 220 line for my saw is going to turn into furring out a few walls and creating a enclosed room for my furnace and whatnot.

 

My wife has always been a saint in regards to the noise going out of the shop, as directly above it is the living room. So, while I'm in upgrading the shop mode, I thought I could add some kind of sound dampening in the ceiling to keep my racket to a minimum.

 

What are some inexpensive solutions that I can apply between the joists to improve the situation?

 

My first thought is to roll some insulation and be done. However, everything I have been thought is that fiberglass insulation has little to no real effect, but I don't really know.

 

Also, a second layer of drywall is low on the reality list because the first layer is very low on the priority list.

 

Any ideas would be greatly appreciated.

Do a google search for a product called roxul.

Don't know if it fits your budget, but it's available at box stores.

A friend back in the day had a garage band the garage was in a populated area back in those days money was tight. We went to the local safeway they had the paper egg cartons they were for bulk eggs I guess they were about 18"x18" we stapled those all over the walls, and cieling of the garage it worked pretty good the cops seemed to leave them alone after that. Like these http://www.ebay.com/itm/120-Paper-chicken-egg-flats-cartons-hatching-eggs-NEW-/360483163436?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item53ee788d2c

I'm planning to do some sound dampening too in my basement shop eventually. My shop is under the kitchen/dining area, so it's not as critical. My approach is:

 

1. Seal off any air passages (helps with dust too) with firestop caulk or expanding foam. Sounds goes through air quite well.

 

2. Probably cover metal ducts running through the ceiling with duct insulation, as they can act like antennae for the sound.

 

3. Add 6" thick fiberglass insulation, although rockwool/Roxul is still a consideration. It's debateable whether it's enough of an improvement to justify the higher price.

 

4. Cover ceiling with 1/2" drywall, sealing any gaps carefully with firestop caulk/expanding foam.

 

5. Wall the shop off from the rest of the basement, using an exterior door.

try using the stuff they line houses with that are next to freeways.

Another thing that you might want to think about, while more expensive, is spray foam insulation. You can get multiple benefits from this option.    First you will get your desired sound proofing.  You add in insulation it you had a sealed off room that you wanted to isolate and control temperature.  It will also provide as a dust seal.  I dont know how much it would cost.  I do know that are some DIY kits, but I know nothing about them. 

 

I can say that I did just finish my basement and I did use batting and 5/8" drywall.  It worked surprisingly well.  There are areas that I did not do and you can most definitely tell the difference. I run a home theater system down there and it does s good job of suppressing that. Hope this helps.

Sac I checked into the DIY spray foam kit, and it was extremely cost prohibitive the home owner did an imediate 180, and we went with bat insulation, but it wasn't for sound deadening. This kit covers 8.7 cubic feet lets you were filling a 6" bay thats only about 17 sq.ft., and it's nearly $400 http://www.zorotools.com/g/00091855/k-G4301543?srccode=cii_10043468&cpncode=31-89473473-2&utm_source=channel_intelligence&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=shopzilla I have no idea what it would cost to have it blown in by a insulation contractor, but it would have to be alot less or no one could afford it.

AndyF

If you are looking for sound insulation value and are hanging drywall, you should look into investing in hat track designed for this kind of noise transfer situation. The drywall screwed directly to the framing actually promotes a lot of transfer and is self defeating.

This is a comment that in many homes is out of place but here goes...

Bang for buck, a suspended acoustical tile or drop ceiling provides a high level of sound insulation in connection with plain old fiberglass batting.

There's a product called "Green Glue" that you can use to glue up your drywall to the ceiling and it works really well.

A buddy of mine installs home theaters and uses this product all the time.
It's like glue but it never gets hard. I mean never... like never ever...

Sound is best absorbed by having to go through multiple layers of different density. If you fill in the voids with r-11 bats, apply hat channel across the joists and then cover with foam board and 1/2" particle board it will take care of most noise coming from your shop. Your wife may hear you if you pound on an anvil though.

+1 Troy and drop ceiling as well. Hang the drop ceiling with rubber cushions where the the hang wires meet the upstairs floor to prevent noise and vibration transfer.

  • Author

Wow...lots of great ideas. Going to have to do some more research and pricing. Thanks!

I saw a detail once where the guy put a foam backer rod between the wall and the drop ceiling to isolate the ceiling from the walls.

  • Popular Post

My basement shop of 18 years has a fiberglass insulated ceiling installed by the previous owner.  It works surprisingly well, most escaping noise travels up the staircase, not through the floors, as the staircase from the first to second floor is uninsulated solid wood.  I don't have any ducts, as my house has hydronic heating.  I'm sure ducts would transmit a ton of noise.   I'm sure insulating penetrations that go up inside walls helps sound transmission, too. 

 

In my experience, most basement wood shop noise is high enough in pitch not to rumble the floor, or transmit through the thick dimension of floor joists.  It's mostly the kind of stuff that loose fiberglass and soft surfaces eat up.  The exception is probably the cyclone.  Moving it around can find places that damp it's low frequency hum better than others, a similar idea to moving your stereo speakers around the room looking for the best sound.     

 

I think it also helps to locate certain things so they re not directly under where the other occupants spend the most time.  For example, I'm split in two, with machines at one end and benches / hand tools at the other.   The machine end is located below the end of the house that is normally used when we have visitors.   My cyclone is directly under the densest area, with a bathroom and two closets above it.   My bench area, the quiet end, is under the areas where my wife spends the most time when home alone downstairs.  I originally had a DC under the stairs, where it was clearly heard on the second floor, moving it 6 -8 feet made a substantial difference.

 

If you plan to install a drop ceiling, think about the height, and don't forget about clearances for ducts and pipes.  My ceiling is low enough that I'd rather plan to not use machines or my cyclone during sensitive times, than lose another six inches overhead.    Also, a flat ceiling, parallel to the floor, can actually amplify certain frequencies.  A broken surface, with soft surfaces, absorbs more noise.

 

Remember, even with the extra ceiling layer, staircases, metal flue pipes, drain and sewer pipes, HVAC ducts, etc...  will still transmit sound.  Certain ducts may even amplify certain frequencies, acting similar to an organ pipe or speaker port.    

 

I have to warn you though...  Not much helps a planer or a decent sized jointer.   Both are loud, all the time, when milling wood.  I've simply learned to plan my use of those machines to times where it's acceptable upstairs. 

  • Author

Barry--

 

Your description fits my circumstance fairly well. I actually have my shop set up that way, but I only realized it now that you have described yours. Not that it matters, but mine started as the the machines needed to go near the one wall with studs in the basement (the stairs). While it is away from the living space above, I am amplifying through the stairs. 

 

Thanks for sharing...You have made me completely rethink the situation, because I think that the most cost effective solution is to start to address the problem in a more pointed way rather than a blanket approach. 

 

Yes, this is a much smarter approach. I also think this allows me to combine some of the other suggestions in more focused locations. 

 

I'm very excited now!

The other option is be as loud as possible, at the worst times.  Then it's easier to sell management on the need of a large stand alone shop.....maybe???

The effectiveness of hat channel on the ceiling is questionable. Some sources say it doesn't contribute significantly to noise reduction because it is mounted more solidly than resilient channel on the wall, so it still transfers sound well.

For ceiling application I would use rubber roofing material between the hat and the joist and would use panhead screws with rubber washers.  The sheetrock is then screwed through the hat and not the framing.  This provides the best sound insulative value as vibration does not transmit efficiently through the rubber.  You could achieve the same with furring strips but the channel minimizes surface to surface contact.  A lot of builders do not install systems in a way that allows the system to do its job.  One of the most common mistakes is to use hat and then screw the sheet into the framing anyway.  I have seen this in a lot of demo work.  It is self defeating and would lead to inefficiency.

another thing I have heard is putting in carpet padding in the wall, it is great for sound dampening and is pretty cheap.

 

Leland

  • Author

The other option is be as loud as possible, at the worst times.  Then it's easier to sell management on the need of a large stand alone shop.....maybe???

 While I appreciate the strategic thinking here...I believe the long term result of this plan is to end up with a new stand alone shop and a wonderful alimony payment.

  • Author

another thing I have heard is putting in carpet padding in the wall, it is great for sound dampening and is pretty cheap.

 

Leland

 now that is an interesting trick.

I've seen photos of someone out there, but never caught any followup, where they used 2x6 or 2x8 studs, and wove the regular fiberglass back and forth through the studs to create a sound barrier.  The wall was just a little wider than usual, but the studs between the end plates (not remembering term right now) was your usual 2x4, just staggered by mounting every other one against that wall.  (Think slalom style.)  This allowed for the regular thickness of insulation to fit between the walls with only slight compression, but kept both heat and sound insulation levels.

 

What I don't remember was if they ran the insulation sideways so that there was one solid "sheet" of insulation, or if they ran these stagger-stepped studs horizontally...  Now I'm really regretting not following up...

Owens-Corning used to have an article on their site, showing the most effective ways to build an acoustical wall. I don't know if it's still there or not.

  • 2 weeks later...

I've got a new (to me) shop coming in the next month or so, and I've been doing some research into soundproofing.  Like the OP, the shop will be under living space so I've focused on the ceiling in particular.  A site that I found helpful was http://www.soundproofingcompany.com/soundproofing-solutions/soundproof-a-ceiling/.  This company sells Green Glue, so of course their solutions always feature that product.  But from all the reading I've done about other products, Green Glue seems to be the best bang-for-the-buck.  Homebrew remedies like egg cartons don't make me too comfortable, and other solutions like double walls, sound isolation clips, and double walls are too expensive and invasive.

 

For me, I'll likely seal every gap with caulk, then insulate the ceiling with standard pink fiberglass.  Finally I'll hang two layers of 5/8" drywall with Green Glue in between the layers.  I've seen multiple reports on home theater forums that this is the best results for the least effort and expense.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.