Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Router plane advice sought

Featured Replies

I'm looking at getting a router plane, for cleaning out dados and fine tuning tenons.  As usual, I am stuck in the "Veritas versus Lie Nielsen" debate.  When I first started looking, I'd say that they were on par with each other (and I know I'd be thrilled with either), except now it looks like there are a few differences that have caused me some pause:

- The Veritas large router plane has a wider selection of blades, without having to get a hokey blade adapter like he one required by LN to use the blades from their smaller plane.

- The Veritas plane has an available inlay cutter head.

- Lie Nielsen has the fence included, although one is available from Lee Valley.

 

To me, the fence is a 'wash' since it can be had for either plane.

 

For those of you with the Veritas plane: do you feel the availability of the additional blades has been a benefit?  Does anyone have (and use) the inlay cutter head?

 

For those of you with the Lie Nielsen plane: do you find that the 3/8" blade has been sufficient?  Have you bought the adapter and smaller blades, and actually used them?

 

 

I have the Veritas, and I did get the fence with it.  The big motivation for the Veritas over the Lie-Nielsen was the selection of blades, and not needing an adapter for the smaller sizes.  Admittedly, I still just have the 2 that came with it, but will buy the additional blades as needed.

I'm also looking at getting a router plane and came to the same conclusions with the addition of the differences in the knobs. The veritas looks like it would be more comfortable to use with the splayed knobs. Can anyone comment on that?

For those of you with the Lie Nielsen plane: do you find that the 3/8" blade has been sufficient?  Have you bought the adapter and smaller blades, and actually used them?

 

Yes, and no.

 

The typical tasks that I am using a router plane (Record, not Lie-Nielsen, but the blade is the same width) for are cleaning up the bottom of a groove or dado, which are larger than 3/8", so a smaller blade would be less advantageous for this task. For smaller grooves, I have a smaller router plane. Usually, a small groove is in a position that makes using the large router plane a bit difficult, so the small router is useful in more ways than just having a small blade.

 

The other task that would be more difficult with a router plane that would require a smaller blade is line inlay work. But I would argue that a router plane is not the best tool for that anyway. Better to have real inlay tools if you're doing a lot of that.

Hi John, I have the Lee Valley and like it. The different size blades come in handy. I also have the mini Router of which I haven't found much use for. Let me know if you want to try them out. I'm just accross town

I haven't got an LV or LN router plane but I do have an old Stanley. I find that I make most use of the 3/8" straight and the 1/2" pointed (double bevel) blades and the 1/4" stays in the box if that's any help :)

+1 On an old stanley or record (I have an old record). It's a real treat to have a LN or similar although it is a real simple tool. They used to be called "old woman's tooth" or "Grannies Tooth" by a few old boys I knew. Tells you something about the simple nature of the tool!  :)

..."Grannies Tooth" 

 

That's what I'm calling them from now on.  That sounds way more awesome than "router plane."

  • Author

I think if I told my wife I dropped some coin on an old used Grannies Tooth, she'd knock one of mine out for free :)

Don't forget, whatever version you get, you can add a shop-made base to close up the opening.

 

I have both sizes of the Veritas.    I normally use them for dado and groove cleanup, many times after a power tool, as well as hinge installation. 

 

I don't use them much for inlay, as I use a Dremel with a Stewart MacDonald base and Drill Technologies end mills for stringing, and a trim router for banding.   The inlay work mine do see is similar to hinge installations.   I have never used a fence with mine, even though I have one.

 

I've used mine, as well as borrowed LN's, Records, and Stanleys, and I think they're all perfectly usable.   These are very simple tools.  I chose the Veritas, because at the time I bought them, the LN only had the open throat version, and I wanted closed.  Since then, I've learned about sub-bases, and LN offers options, so I see them as all good.

 

I hadn't heard "Grannie's Tooth", but I know about "Old Woman's Tooth"...  :D

 

For those of you with the Veritas plane: do you feel the availability of the additional blades has been a benefit?  Does anyone have (and use) the inlay cutter head?

 

 

Yes and Yes.  I use both the 1/4" and 1/2" blades equally and on occasion the 3/32" is nice.  I have the inlay cutter too. I honestly haven't used the inlay head much yet mainly because a project hasn't come up where I wanted it, but its pretty cool.  It essentially scores two lines a set distance apart so that you can then go in and clean out with one of the regular blades.   It makes straight banding really easy and consistent.  Honestly I love my LV router plane...its probably my favorite tool.  The blade versatility (and low price of the additional blade sizes) is what really sold me on it, as well as the fact that fence has a wider range than the LN.  At the time LN also didn't make the closed throat router and that was important to me.   I never once second guessed my decision to get the LV version of the router plane, but of course there are just as many people who love their LN equally well.  You'll be happy with either, but if you can get your hands on one or the other it would be helpful. Some people really prefer the straight up handles of the LN and some prefer the canted handles of the LV.  Some prefer on depth stop on one or the other.  Even if the blade sizes don't matter those things might.  

 

 

  • Author

Derek, those are really nice!!  I will read your post in more detail later, but it looks to be thorough and clear. 

  • 3 weeks later...

I have an old Stanley and wouldn't want to live without it. For me I bounce between the 1/4" and 1/2"spear point and have never felt the need for other sizes. I do like the spear point but at times a flat bottom is nicer so a 1/2" straight is in my future. As for inlay I have a separate jig so I don't have any input on that. Mine is an open throat base but I made an auxiliary base that closes it off otherwise its problematic on narrower stock.

  • 1 month later...

I don't have either LN or Veritas, but the Stanley small and large routers are extremely useful not just for smoothing the bottoms of grooves, but also for squaring up the cheeks of tenons, and (but don't tell anyone) I've also used them as a marking gauge many times.

 

The spear point blade is a wonderous thing. It can smooth the edges of a groove so perfectly. Takes a bit of fiddling to sharpen, but is well worth the effort. Seems to be the one 'missing' in most ebay auctions though.

 

Sorry to be pedantic but I think Granny's tooth is correct, you can have two grannies, but as far as a single tooth is concerned...

Being a simple tool (though not so simple to sharpen) many were made in wood - though not quite as well as Derek's.

 

John

  • Author

I think Granny's tooth is correct,

Unless you're talking about the Stygian witches....but that would be "Grannies' tooth". But what can you do with their eye? :)

Didn't one of the Ozzies post a vid of a router plane and they called it a hags tooth? i might be mis remembering but they do like their funky names for things.

Unless you're talking about the Stygian witches....but that would be "Grannies' tooth". But what can you do with their eye? :)

How about teeth? ;)

I have used the veritas before, and I quite liked it. What was nice was that the straight blade can be sharpened with the mkII, or other honing guide, because the blade tip can be removed and placed in a simple jig.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.