Recommended Posts

Posted

I came to browsing eBay looking for a deal on a smoothing plane. I have been watching the Doucette and Wolfe videos for some time, and their use of the smoothing plane was what pushed me to look. I saw this as a multi use tool. I can put a final finish on wood with it, work wood larger than my jointer by running it through on the jointer and flattening the ridge with the plane. The less pieces I have to use in a glue up - the better.

 

However, the main reason I bought this plane may seem silly. The pins and tails of my dovetails were always proud by about 1/32" or more. This was on purpose because I would rather have them longer than shorter. I used my sander to sand these down. But because I have a soft pad on it, the wood always rounded over and became convex. Not good. I saw people cut dovetails and then finish them off with a few strokes of the plane. Seemed like a good reason to buy a new tool.

 

I was lucky enough to get tons and tons of help from Graham (G S Haydon). From what to look for, how to tune up, and how to use. I bid on items until one came around that I really liked. The blade had plenty of life in it, looked really clean, no pitting, no noticeable damage, and the price was right. Got myself a Stanley Bailey #4 for just over $40 including shipping.

 

I just bought myself a sharpening system for my chisels that I was pleased with, and was convinced I could make this plane usable. I did not set my expectations high so I would not be disappointed.

 

The plane arrived and it was game on. Closer inspection made me pleased for my purchase. The sole was DEAD flat, and the overall plane was in immaculate condition - for a used item. The blade edge was just terrible though. The edge was crooked by about 2-3 degrees, and the bevel was way off. This doesn't seem like much, but with my basic oil stone system it was A LOT of material to remove to get it close enough to put a secondary bevel on it that was straight and consistent across the edge. Took some time and elbow grease, but I got to spend some one on one time with my oil stone. We now know each other quite well.

 

When it came time to assemble the plane and test it on wood, I was excited to put it to use. I pictured those long shavings flowing through the wind just like in the videos. Full length. Full width. Perfect thickness. Here it comes!

 

CLUNK. CLUNK. CHATTER. CHATTER. $#!* Yeah, looks like I need to learn how to set the depth first. Rookie mistake.

 

So I remembered back to an old Rob Cosman video of him sighting down the plane, letting the blade poke out, using the lateral adjustment, then retracting the blade all the way out of sight. I slowly crept up on the wood until shavings started. It wasn't easy to plane, even on this pine. I thought to myself, if planing was this hard all the time...I'm going to need a stronger upper body. You hand tool enthusiasts must curl in the squat rack (I think Freddie might get that reference).

 

I looked into sharpening some more, and that was it. I made a jig to hold a 25 degree primary bevel, and 30 degree secondary bevel - as recommended by Graham. I also added the small camber on the blade by applying pressure to either side of the blade for a few strokes. That was the key!

 

Brought out every species of wood I had on hand and planed away. Cherry, Honduran Mahogany, Walnut, Red Oak, and Pine. The plane laughed at all of them, although some were harder than others - which I anticipated. The plane is sharp enough to edge joint a 3/4" piece of pine with little more than the weight of the plane pushing downward. I'm satisfied.

 

Here is a staged picture of my plane after use (cheesy, huh?)

D485948A-AF87-4A2D-A091-01BB12529904-685

  • Like 1
Posted

That looks like it's in great shape.  None of my planes are any newer than that, and their use covers part of what I do for a living.  For the restoration work I do, everything is finished with a plane.  Great job!

Posted

These planes are very capable of doing nice work. I have a #5 and #6 that are very similar.

 

Also, nice to see another Wisconsin person here! Small world indeed.

Posted

These planes are very capable of doing nice work. I have a #5 and #6 that are very similar.

Also, nice to see another Wisconsin person here! Small world indeed.

Where do you get your hardwood from? I usually shop the KM Hardwoods down by me in Milwaukee. I know there is another closer to you. Just curious if you shop them, too.
Posted

KM Hardwoods gets most of my business. Those guys are awesome!

Can't complain about their prices, either! Is that where you got those amazing pieces of mahogany?
Posted

So I ran myself a little test today. I grabbed a small piece of cherry I have (4" x 16"), and decided I would put some finish on it after planing just to see what the outcome would be.

 

I jointed a side flat on my power jointer. I could feel the machine marks left by my machine, and hit it with my smoother. A little more coarse at first to knock down the marks, then eventually backed away the blade until I eventually had shavings that crumbled to saw dust. Wiped off the piece, and went straight to finishing. I used my typical clear shellac that I have laying around. It went on flawless, and even after one coat it left a sheen I have yet to see. Seriously, I am blown away so far by this thing.

 

Took me about 2-3 minutes to "smooth" this piece. Not sure if that is slow or normal. But I am looking forward to making some nice projects now.

 

Oh, I forgot to mention, the blade is sharp enough to laugh at the end grain on this cherry, too. Felt as though I was planing a normal edge.

Posted

KM Hardwoods gets most of my business. Those guys are awesome!

I live about 10 minutes away from their North store (Hartford).  If you are in either location in the near future, look at the bubinga slab they just got in....so sexy!   Wish I had the $$ to pick it up.  But without a customer or need, it would be a very unpleasant conversation with management!

 

KM's go some good guys working the shops too, always willing to help.  They get all my domestic business, and most of my exotics as well. 

Posted

I live about 10 minutes away from their North store (Hartford).  If you are in either location in the near future, look at the bubinga slab they just got in....so sexy!   Wish I had the $$ to pick it up.  But without a customer or need, it would be a very unpleasant conversation with management!

 

KM's go some good guys working the shops too, always willing to help.  They get all my domestic business, and most of my exotics as well. 

Every time I go to the store by me (Racine), I look at all the slabs that they have. My fiance does not easily see the beauty in all the wood species and grains. But, ever her jaw drops and eyes open when I point out how nice of a table a 30" x 50" x 3" thick walnut slab would make.

 

Just my personal opinion, but the Northern unit is much more friendly and up beat. That's not saying the Southern unit is bad, because they are fantastic as well.

Posted

So I ran myself a little test today. I grabbed a small piece of cherry I have (4" x 16"), and decided I would put some finish on it after planing just to see what the outcome would be.

 

I jointed a side flat on my power jointer. I could feel the machine marks left by my machine, and hit it with my smoother. A little more coarse at first to knock down the marks, then eventually backed away the blade until I eventually had shavings that crumbled to saw dust. Wiped off the piece, and went straight to finishing. I used my typical clear shellac that I have laying around. It went on flawless, and even after one coat it left a sheen I have yet to see. Seriously, I am blown away so far by this thing.

 

Took me about 2-3 minutes to "smooth" this piece. Not sure if that is slow or normal. But I am looking forward to making some nice projects now.

 

Oh, I forgot to mention, the blade is sharp enough to laugh at the end grain on this cherry, too. Felt as though I was planing a normal edge.

 

Great work Sam. I'm delighted that blade came good in the end  :)

Posted

Oh, there is a piece of Bubinga there that taunts me from time to time. I want to make a bass (or three) with it.

 

There is also a very nice piece at Rockler for around a grand that is fantastic as well. 

Posted

There are a few things that I have come to learn about my plane as I get more time to work with it. It is evident how much you can learn with hands on experience as compared to reading or watching. I have read and learned all the basics about the plane. How it works, why it works, etc. I know the process to sharpen the blade, and I understand the reason to have a slight camber on the blade.

 

When I initially sharpened the blade, I left the camber out and just went for a straight blade. I wanted to get those shavings flying as soon as possible. Track marks galore! Not a problem, that blade still needed some work on the good old oil stone anyway. So I got back to it later and continued finessing that edge to get it closer to my goal. Now it was time to add the camber. Just did as I was told, and I added slight pressure to each side of the blade independently for a few strokes. At first it didn't look like I did anything, so I ground a bit more away. I thought I now had an acceptable camber on the blade, and now it was time to smooth that wood.

 

Of the 2" blade, only about 1" of shavings were coming out of the mouth. Uh oh, seems as though that camber was a bit too much. I should have stopped grinding a long time ago...

 

No worries. Hit that oil stone again and got enough of the camber out to grind a new one into it. Slight pressure, blah, blah, blah, but only few about 3-4 strokes this time each side. Bingo. Hit the nail on the head here. The shavings were now about 1.5" wide through the mouth, and extremely thin. The surface looked polished and perfect.

 

I had these glue up cherry boards that I ended up not using in a project. When they came out of the clamps I sanded them with the progression of 120-180-220 with a 6" ROS. That was fast, and seemed to leave a great surface. So I thought.

 

Took the smoothing plane to one and was just blown away by the amount of "dips" in the wood from uneven sanding pressure about. Took me about 7-8 minutes to fully flatten and smooth this 13x15" panel of cherry. Would have been less if there weren't so many dips. The plane really brought out some nice color in the wood, too.

 

Here is the comparison between sanded (left) and smoothed (right). Same pieces of wood, since this panel was actually cut in half.

1850FF5D-03ED-419D-82BA-F3B7F39B4543-799

Posted

Someones got the hand tool bug  :D. Great work Sam.

Wonder where he caught that bug? Graham, you'll go to hell for this, you know that don't you? B)

 

Sam - sometimes you have to roughen the surface a little with 240-320 grit sandpaper so that the finish will grip better - seriously.

 

John

Posted

Wonder where he caught that bug? Graham, you'll go to hell for this, you know that don't you? B)

 

Sam - sometimes you have to roughen the surface a little with 240-320 grit sandpaper so that the finish will grip better - seriously.

 

John

In that case, I save some time and not meticulously smooth as I did. There was a stage just before it turned all shiny that was still better than sand paper, but not as good as the final product I have now. Maybe I could stop at that for most cases?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.