daviddoria Posted August 12, 2013 Report Posted August 12, 2013 I just got my first card scraper and after trying to put a burr on it with every piece of metal I could find, I have given up and am going to order a burnishing rod. I was going to get this one: http://www.rockler.com/product.cfm?page=9949&site=ROCKLER&filter=burnishing%20rod but then I came across (the much cheaper): http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=32643&cat=1,310,41070&ap=1 Has anyone ever used a little stubby one like this? Would you recommend getting the longer one? Or for just the occasional use is the short one going to get me to the burr I need? Thanks, David Quote
G S Haydon Posted August 12, 2013 Report Posted August 12, 2013 Hello David, If you want to give it one more try take a look at this http://paulsellers.com/2013/08/poor-mans-burnisher/ Quote
AceHoleInOne Posted August 12, 2013 Report Posted August 12, 2013 I use the long edge of an old chisel. -Ace- Quote
daviddoria Posted August 12, 2013 Author Report Posted August 12, 2013 GSHaydon - I just tried using my center punch but just like my screwdrivers, etc., it did not seem to change the edge of the scraper (I don't feel any burr at all, and it doesn't even make dust when I try to scrape with it). Ace - I had tried the edge of a chisel, and I just tried it again, but it doesn't seem to change the edge of the scraper at all. Maybe these metals are just too soft (all of these tools were quite cheap)? Quote
Bombarde16 Posted August 12, 2013 Report Posted August 12, 2013 For a card scraper, you want the long one. Rolling the burr involves drawing the burnisher diagonally towards you, so the short one wouldn't be ideal. Purists will frown, but you can always use a scraper without a burr at all. Just swipe it over a file to get a square edge and go at it. (Hat tip: Clippinger) Quote
G S Haydon Posted August 13, 2013 Report Posted August 13, 2013 Nothing wrong going againts the purists. I have before just taken the blade out of my #4 and used it as a scrape with the bevel facing away from you and drawing the blade towards you. I like Rob's tip and I will give it a shot next time. Quote
TerryMcK Posted August 13, 2013 Report Posted August 13, 2013 Hi David, The long burnisher is the way to go. The short one is for curved scrapers and the other tools you've tried are simply not hard enough. Burnishers are cylindrical so you can get a really high pressure on the contact point of a cylinder and an edge. This physically deforms the metal of the scraper. A chisel will be hard enough but to get the high pressure you would have to use the very corner of the chisel. If you present the flat face of the chisel you end up just polishing the surface of the scraper. Have a look at Marc's video from William Ng showing how to sharpen a card scraper. The technique really does work. http://www.thewoodwhisperer.com/videos/scraper-sharpening-w-william-ng/ 1 Quote
Gary Posted August 13, 2013 Report Posted August 13, 2013 I agree that the long burnisher is the way to go. When turning a burr on my card scrapers, I like to clamp the card scraper in my vise at a consistent height. (with maybe 1" sticking out of the top of the vise) I will then allow the handle of the burnisher to run on the top of the bench as I am pulling a burr. This method helps me to keep a consistent angle when using the burnisher. Gary Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted August 13, 2013 Report Posted August 13, 2013 I own a famous name burnisher, but will point out that long chromed socket extensions work just as well. Quote
daviddoria Posted August 13, 2013 Author Report Posted August 13, 2013 Rob Horton - when I just have a square edge (and no burr) it just hardly makes dust. Do you get good shavings with it like that? SlingBlade - that is a good suggestion, thanks. CessnaPilotBarry - just like my screwdrivers, etc., that didn't work, doesn' it matter exactly what type of metal the socket extensions are made from? Quote
Tpt life Posted August 13, 2013 Report Posted August 13, 2013 How much do you play with the angle of the card? I can shave with a sharp square edge with no burr. It does not last as long making it less efficient and you have to hold it firmly at the angle that engages. Quote
daviddoria Posted August 13, 2013 Author Report Posted August 13, 2013 C Shaffer - I've tried it at as many angles as I could manage I guess I don't understand what it means to "engage" if there is no burr? Quote
Tpt life Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 I went and played around a little tonight and to not embarrass myself I'll PM you a link. I would tend to think after reflection that you potentially rolled too much material and deformed the edge so that there was more than a burr rolled. This makes more sense to me than a screw driver that is too soft. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 Rob Horton - when I just have a square edge (and no burr) it just hardly makes dust. Do you get good shavings with it like that? SlingBlade - that is a good suggestion, thanks. CessnaPilotBarry - just like my screwdrivers, etc., that didn't work, doesn' it matter exactly what type of metal the socket extensions are made from? No. It's the hard chrome plating that should make it work. Folks have used old engine pushrods, socket extensions, ratchet handles, carbide... Any metal harder than the scraper will work, but it has to be chromed if it's softer. Do you have some kind of super scraper? Quote
Bombarde16 Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 Rob Horton - when I just have a square edge (and no burr) it just hardly makes dust. Do you get good shavings with it like that? Sure do. Not as pronounced as the shavings from a scraper with a burr, but certainly more defined than the dust one gets from a dull scraper. What species of wood are you working? What was the last tool that touched the surface before the scraper? How did you prepare the edge prior to rolling the burr? After grinding things flat on a file, the face and edge of the scraper need to be polished on a high grit stone, otherwise the coarse striations will leave you a weak, serrated burr. Bear in mind also that, while gossamer scraping as a final step before finish certainly ranks high on the cool scale, it's not the only way to use a scraper. If all you get out of a card scraper is a good cleanup of a glue line, that's already a great thing. My personal favorite is not a card scraper (friction = heat = burned thumbs) but it's more brutish cousin, the overhand scraper. It's a massive time saver: In some species, you can go berzerk with a coarse belt sander, quickly scrape the surface with a cheap overhand scraper, and then skip straight to finish sanding. Quote
Byrdie Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 So after reading this for a couple days I think we're taking the wrong approach. Likely the problem is not the burnishing tool but the scrapper it's self. I think someone came close to the right suggestion. I think I missed who the scrapper is made by or the quality of the steel but I think either your scrapper is too soft or you've over done it to the point where you've gone beyond creating a burr to rolling the edge. I think you need to start over. Take your scrapper and lay it flat sides on the stone and flatten it on all edges. Think lapping the sole on a plane. Repeat on the other side. Lightly ... let me repeat that ... lightly square the edge that is to be used as your scraping edge and then get ready to burnish it. Here's the key - it doesn't take many passes to create a burr, maybe a couple firm strokes on each edge. Let us know how that turns out. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 My personal favorite is not a card scraper (friction = heat = burned thumbs) but it's more brutish cousin, the overhand scraper. It's a massive time saver: In some species, you can go berzerk with a coarse belt sander, quickly scrape the surface with a cheap overhand scraper, and then skip straight to finish sanding. If you mean something like this, I totally agree! Quote
mds2 Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 David, I use the sharpening method in this video: http://www.thewoodwhisperer.com/videos/scraper-sharpening-w-william-ng/ The thing I've found with sharpening scrapers, and just using them in general, is that it takes practice. The first day I bought one I spent about 2 hours rolling a burr, trying it out, flattening the burr, rolling another burr, repeat ad nauseum. I did this so I would learn how to do it and it was worth the time. When I sharpen now I do the 4 longest edges all at once, and very fast like Mr. Ng does. If I dont get all 4 perfect its ok. I usually get at least one good edge. When using scrapers resharpening often is the norm. Quote
daviddoria Posted August 21, 2013 Author Report Posted August 21, 2013 Ok folks, time for my follow up report. The problem seems to be that I was not filing enough. When I got more aggressive with the file (actually taking off visible shavings of steel), everything "just worked". I guess I am still glad I got the real burnisher though - I feel like it is easier to handle than the random assortment of other things I was trying. By the way Byrdie, it is a Bahco scraper. Thanks for all of the suggestions guys! David Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.