Recommended Posts

Posted

I've been trying to figure out how much grace/fudge factor/overage to give myself in roughing out components before hand killing them with planes.

How much extra do you give yourself in each direction (length, width, depth)?

Posted

This depends on the equipment you are using to do both rough and finish milling.  

 

Thickness: I typically leave 1/16 - 3/16 thickness when planing depending on how the boards are taking to the planer.  If I see some snipe I will leave extra thickness and finish by hand, but most of the time, I am snipe free so I take it to within 1/16 and then just do finish sanding.  

 

Length:  This again is machine specific, but I normally just leave about 1/2" in length for squaring up once I have jointed and planed.  

 

Width:  For width I try to take the minimum shave possible to get a clean edge.  I think will cut again leaving myself about 1/16" - 1/8"  larger than finished dimension at the TS and then take it to the jointer/planer to mill to final size.  By taking the minimum shave first, I then have squared, clean scraps left over.  I have found over time this is easier and safer to do up front, so I am not trying to mill up smaller scraps.  The machines just do better with larger stock.  

Posted

I usually leave very little in thickness. Somewhere about a heavy 1/16, assuming the surface is flat and stable. I would leave less, but I always seem to get some tear out that I need to fix if I try to leave less. Murphy's law, I suppose.

I always leave lots of extra length and width, but I typically use power tools to cut to final dimension. I clean up the surfaces with hand tools or sandpaper, but I don't consciously leave a lot of material because it only takes a pass or 2 with a smoother to clean up edges and a pass or 2 to clean up the end grain with a LA block.

Posted

I've been trying to figure out how much grace/fudge factor/overage to give myself in roughing out components before hand killing them with planes.

How much extra do you give yourself in each direction (length, width, depth)?

 

 

You should really watch Chris Schwarz's video, Coarse, Medium and Fine. He does a much better job of explaining this than I could. 

Posted

I don't leave any thickness as I rarely work with a set thickness.  Basically I just work til it is flat then gauge the thickest piece I can get.  This saves work.  Of course this changes when I specifically need thinner parts like drawers or case backs.  There is that pesky design proportion thing to consider too but regardless, I only want to mill it once and any additional surface planing I do is with a smoother and the amount that removes is negligible.

 

Width I saw no more than 1/16th from final dimension so I can true it up very quickly with a couple passes.

 

Length, I always add about 3-5" in length then cut whatever joinery I need, then trim to within 1/16 before shooting (if even needed).  Extra length will save you when chopping mortises near the end of a board.  You also can layout tenons and things an approximate distance from the end of the board and lay in a shoulder line.  That becomes your reference surface and you don't have to worry about exactly cutting the board length or shooting to get a flat and square reference face that will only get stuck in a mortise later. 

Posted

I think it's more a question of time than dimensions. Working by hand means than you can cheat quite a lot. So I may go close to thickness (for thick pieces), let it rest a while, and then decide. If the wood stayed still, fine I may not even try to go to 'thickness' because it's difficult to tell if one leg is 1/16" less/more thick than another.

 

Or if you're glueing up boards, they don't need to be exactly the same thickness, after all you'll need to plane the whole thing flat afterwards, so again a 1/16" (that's 1mm in real money) wouldn't worry me. Is the table top 1" or 15/16" or 1 1/16"? If you work by hand it may not really matter - I'd design the table to make sure it doesn't matter.

 

With machines you have to be more accurate, because each dimension is an element of the next machine operation. So 1/16" difference might become a nightmare.

 

I think generally that machines need precision, whereas handwork needs duplication. I certainly need all the legs the same length, but if I'm 1/16" or 1/8" off the specified dimension? Does it matter?

 

Length wise I tend to be more generous, say 1", especially if there are mortices to cut, since the extra 'horn' will stop potential splits.

 

Of course handwork can also be precise, perhaps even more precise than a machine, but it is up to us to decide when that precision is really necessary. With a machine you can get all the drawers identical, knowing that the space the drawers go into are identical. By hand you might fit each one to the space it goes into.

 

Then again, if I could build things better, I might not need all these little tricks  :rolleyes:

 

John

Posted

Tony, all good advice so far. 

 

If I had a project at hand and a pile of sawn lumber I would:

 

Layout my sizes on the wood trying to fit in all the short lengths on the most bowed wood. Cutting that down into short pieces means you reduce the bend.

 

I would allow 4" or so on the rough cut lengths to be accurately cut to length when planed up. This is not a hard and fast rule, its just about squeezing in your job on to the wood you have. I have gone down to 1/2" before, sometimes I leave extra over the 4". 

 

1/4" on the width should be just fine and is typical for machine work (I know your hand tool but we are still doing the same kinda jazz), perhaps once you get in tune with your planes you could go for less, especially on shorter components.

 

Pick the most bowed wood you have for a component group and straighten it all up and thickness it based on the minimum thicknessing required to get a clean face. All the other pieces withing that component group can then be set to this thickness. Part of Hand Tool work is embracing what you have rather than breaking your balls to get it to the mm shown in a book (IMO)

Posted

I used to cut right to final dimensions at the start.  Then I'd wonder why things weren't fitting after dealing with issues.

 

Now, it depends partly on how lazy I'm feeling, how productive I'm feeling, how much time I've got, and where the part goes.  Something on the inside or underneath, that won't get a lot of attention?  It's lucky I square up the ends.  Desktop?  Oi!  

 

If I leave it with extra meat on the bone, I'll only go about 1/8".  I don't mind a little hard work, but anything more than that and I'm swearing at my stupidity.  (then again, my hand tools aren't as well stocked, so I'm comfortable leaving an inch, because it's more room for my saw to get close and my two basic planes to square up.)

Posted

 I don't even have a rule of thumb on this.  It varies with so many factors to even start on a rule of thumb.  Only as close as you can get without going too far-might be a half inch or inch or 1/32". 

 

I was talking to a wood supplier this morning about stiles and rails for doors, and we decided on one board that is 1/16th over finished thickness, but flat, straight, and quarter sawn, and no others wide enough for those rails quarter sawn possible.  No power tool will touch it, since it's to have a hand planed finish anyway.

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.