Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dust Collection Questions

Featured Replies

So I am in the process of setting up my first real woodshop.  I have the lucky fortune to have plenty of space to work with thanks to my family farm.  I have put down a new floor, built a bunch of lumber drying racks (currently I have a good 1500 of board ft of Red Oak, White Oak, Walnut, Maple and Apple air drying).  I am working on electrical and dust collection now.  I have 2 2hp reliant dust collectors and 1 1hp grizzly dust collector.   My plan is to set them up on the floor below with switches to turn them on and off and blast gates to isolate the tool.

 

so here are the questions:

1- is going down the best option?  Most people go up, is that because its safer/better for them?  

 

2-Would it be worth raising the dust collectors up as close as possible to the ceiling to shorten the run?

 

3-PVC or Metal, Cost is a consideration.

 

4- is there a way to create one large bin for the sawdust collected between all 3?

 

Thanks in advance for the help.  I will post some pictures as I can.

 

Dave, 

 

 

In the one of my shops that has a framed floor, I went down through the floor.  I like it better and it will always be my first choice, especially if you have access to the ducts. 

 

I have always used metal HVAC ducting, which is dirt cheap from an HVAC supplier-not big box stores, and never had any trouble with it.

The reason most go up is ease of access.  If you get a blockage or need to reroute or add Ts or anything else of that nature, it's pretty tough to do in a crawl space or without ripping out the floor.  Don't think there's really any operational advantage to either one.

So I am in the process of setting up my first real woodshop.  I have the lucky fortune to have plenty of space to work with thanks to my family farm.  I have put down a new floor, built a bunch of lumber drying racks (currently I have a good 1500 of board ft of Red Oak, White Oak, Walnut, Maple and Apple air drying).  I am working on electrical and dust collection now.  I have 2 2hp reliant dust collectors and 1 1hp grizzly dust collector.   My plan is to set them up on the floor below with switches to turn them on and off and blast gates to isolate the tool.

 

so here are the questions:

1- is going down the best option?  Most people go up, is that because its safer/better for them?

 

If you're setting up shop on an upper floor and can run ducts through the joists into the floor below, fine and dandy.  Most folks run dust collection up and over because our shops (either basement or garage) have slab floors.  Though, I should hope that your barn has a crane in that case:  Dust moving down to the first floor implies that at some point heavy boards had to go up to the second floor.

 

 

2-Would it be worth raising the dust collectors up as close as possible to the ceiling to shorten the run?

 

If they're pulling from the floor above, sure.

 

 

3-PVC or Metal, Cost is a consideration.

 

I used thinwall, belled end PVC (from Lowe's next to the perforated irrigation pipe) for mine and it's worked fine.  Remember, the cost of a duct isn't the duct, it's the connections and fittings.  Good place to save money (and improve performance) would be to make your own blast gates.

 

 

4- is there a way to create one large bin for the sawdust collected between all 3? 

 

All things are possible, but not all things are good.  One large bin would get very heavy very quickly.

I will throw my $0.02 cents in for HVAC duct. I used it for about 10 years with my old 2hp collector and never had one problem. When I upgraded to my CV 5hp I did get one section to colapse with all the gates closed. I repaired that section and installed a safety that opens if the vacuum gets too high. Point the seams down stream to help prevent build up. I have micro switches on all my gates so the DC starts when I open the gate and stops when I close it. I find the delay between shutting off the equpment and closing the blast gate is enough delay to clear all the dust in the duct. More choices in fittings with HVAC vs PVC.

BRuce

  • Author

Thanks for all the replies, a new wrinkle is that I was just given a 2hp torit cyclone collector, and yes I have 3 phase for it. Now I need to rethink my plan a bit.

I am able to use the floor below because it's more like a basement then a first floor, so no stairs are required for lugging up and down.

You would have to move the starters. Or maybe just a switch to the coil. You need the protection they provide. You shouldn't have all of them connected. The pressure from one would enter the others without rotary air locks between them. And do not use "T" fittings. They are for hvac. You need a "Y" and a 45 to make a 90 T joint. Dust collection systems are not hvac. It will work so much better if you learn a little about proper design and duct sizing etc.

Steve

Is the "underneath" walk out or will you have to carry the dust upstairs? HVAC duct has wyes also. Not too hard to find or even have made.

BRuce

That Torit might crush hvac pipe. It certainly isn't made for negative pressure. Spiral pipe will hold up fine. PVC can spark dust explosions so ground it if you go that route.

Steve

HVAC Duct will only collapse if you run the DC with all the gates closed. DCs move material by moving large volumes of air, not suction. If you want to run HVAC let me know and I'll send you some pictures and help you make a device to protect the ducts so you can save some money. Thousands of people use PVC without problems. Spiral pipe is nice but not needed.

BRuce

  • Author

Thanks Bruce, I would love to see some pics, I want to do it as close to right the first time.

 

Yes the underneath is also a walk out.  but with the torit I may not be able to go down, the ceiling is only about 7 ft.  Now I am trying to plan to set it up outside so I can move full barrels with a fork truck.

 

thanks,

dave

PVC can spark dust explosions so ground it if you go that route.

 

A myth that has been debunked a hundred times over.  PVC pipe will not spark an explosion when used for dust collection.

 

Thanks Bruce, I would love to see some pics, I want to do it as close to right the first time.

 

Perhaps this is the biggest reason of all in favor of going overhead.  The only constant in setting up a woodworking shop is that no shop ever stays the same.  Your shop will evolve and things will move around over time.  Hanging DC lines from the ceiling isn't fun, but if you're running DC lines down through the joists then the shop floor will start to look like Swiss cheese.

  • Author

The original plan for running it through the floor was for two reasons, one to help with undersized dust collectors. Second the way the shop is set up is there is machinery around two posts that go up through the floor, so there would be one pipe coming up then wye-ing off to the different machines.

Now with the addition of the turit that may not be a problem, but I am still not sure which route to go

One of my most inspirational wood shop videos is layed out similarly to yours. One day i will have a tractor with forks and a loading bay!!!

Seriously, this might help reinforce your plan. Also, shoot him an email if you have any questions, he did all the work himself.

17 minutes of pure awesome wood shop.

http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Bif8FrBSeXk&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DBif8FrBSeXk

Andy also has many great videos on woodworking.

One of my most inspirational wood shop videos is layed out similarly to yours. One day i will have a tractor with forks and a loading bay!!!

Seriously, this might help reinforce your plan. Also, shoot him an email if you have any questions, he did all the work himself.

17 minutes of pure awesome wood shop.

http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Bif8FrBSeXk&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DBif8FrBSeXk

Andy also has many great videos on woodworking.

His lumber storage is awesome!
  • Author

So I went to the big box to check out pvc prices, and the solid drain bell end prices.  Then stopped by a local HVAC place to see about pricing there.  although I did not get prices I did get some info.  Normally they sell 30 gauge, but they can get 24 Gauge.  

 

I have been trying to get more info about the torit, the best I can find is that it is model #19CYC Cyclone dust collector, pulling 1200CFM.  

 

Thats a great video, I wish my shop looked like that... Maybe some day.

Heavydc2

 

Just as a point of reference I am paying $ .86 a ft for 26ga Sheet metal pipe and & .97 for 4” spiral.

Spiral is a good way to go.

 

As long as we are on the subject of Sheet metal and Cyclones, I am wondering .Is there  any interest in developing a sheet metal pattern for a cyclone 

It has been a few years, but I have been thinking about making one for my shop. 

The only HVAC dust that has ever collapsed on me was 30 gauge, so if you can get 24 I would go that route. As for underneath helping the undersized DC, it would not. What you would have is buildup on the horizontal sections. My shop is now about 15 years old and while I believe the layout works, I still have changes I want to make. The comment about flexibility are correct, the shop is rarely static, it evolves as you do.

Mar10, I believe there is a pattern on the internet somewhere and I know that Stumpy Nubs just built one from wood so you could adapt that one back to metal.

BRuce

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.