Recommended Posts

Posted

This project had disaster written on it since the day I brought the materials home. Luckily it is for my parents and it is going in a closet never to be seen by anyone else.

 

My father went with me to pick out the plywood and he chose the cheapest stuff (~$40 a sheet) even after I told him the perils of working with low grade plywood. I got the plywood home and it was already wanting to potato chip on me and I don't have anyplace to properly store it so it gets worse over time. 

 

I got the carcass built and then took my mom to pick out drawer slides. So what does she pick out? Just the full extension soft closing slides which cost more than the plywood. I should have know that it was not going to be a good combo. 

 

Then I made some rookie mistakes in construction which just made everything exponentially worse. The biggest mistake was not paying enough attention to the squareness of everything. The only clamp I have that was long enough to reach from corner to corner was a tool guide clamp which is apparently not strong enough to keep things square. Unfortunately I did not learn this until everything was glued up and I went to put it all together. However, only one drawer is really out of square everything else is close enough. 

 

The next rookie mistake was having too much glue squeeze out on one of the hardwood edge band strips on the side. Then it was either sand it away which would sand through the face veneer or sand as much as i dare and just deal with it looking like poo. At this point I all but gave up on the project and I know that I will be remaking this piece at some point. If it had been for a paying customer I would have lit it on fire and started over. 

 

So here it is. It doesn't look all that bad in the picture. If I work up the courage I'll post some of the mistakes I made.

post-7772-0-01803900-1398561319_thumb.jp

 

 

So what did I learn from this project?

1) I will never work with cheap plywood again

2) I hate working with drawer slides

3) Use right angle clamping blocks 

4) Don't use so much glue when attaching edge banding

 

 

 

Posted

Don't beat yourself up too bad! Everyone has to start somewhere!

It is very frustrating working without the proper tools to get the job done (you mentioned the lack of clamps). Call it practise and move on. Maybe try a smaller project for your next attempt, like a framed mirror or a clean book case.

We all make mistakes too. In fact, just today I was casing out a door in my home. I have done hundreds of door and window casings, but today I made a rookie mistake (cut a piece way too short) and need a new piece. I laughed at myself when I brought the piece over to the door and it was 12" too short. D'oh!

Posted

 If it had been for a paying customer I would have lit it on fire and started over. 

 

 

Yup.  My typical reaction to my projects, too.

Posted

That was not my first project which is why it was so frustrating. But it was the first where squareness was crucial. 

 

I will make sure that I have big enough clamps to do the job next time. The next project I am working on is one that I started last year but didn't get very far. 

 

post-7772-0-89388600-1398566852_thumb.jp

 

I've never done anything like it before so it will be a challenge for me. The best part is that it doesn't contain any plywood and it doesn't have drawer slides!!

Posted

That was not my first project which is why it was so frustrating. But it was the first where squareness was crucial. 

 

I will make sure that I have big enough clamps to do the job next time. The next project I am working on is one that I started last year but didn't get very far. 

 

attachicon.gifBookshelf Front Picture.jpg

 

I've never done anything like it before so it will be a challenge for me. The best part is that it doesn't contain any plywood and it doesn't have drawer slides!!

 

Looks like a version of marc's weekend wall shelf.  I made one myself.  Best part is if you cut your dados nice and square you don't really need any clamps to assemble!  

Posted

I can imagine doing a project for someone else can add some pressure, especially if it's on their dime. Have you considered ambitious projects for the shop?

I've muddled around with woodworking for years but this my first year of doing some projects that require serious skills. Since my garage needs organizing, I've started building a tool cabinet based on plans I saw in FWW. I figure if I make mistakes (and boy, have I!) it won't be on critical projects.

My latest mistake was yesterday when making a half dozen small drawers. I was rabbeting for the drawer bottoms so I gathered all of the side pieces and ran them through the saw.

It was only during assembly that I was puzzled by the drawers being out square that I realized the pieces were flipped upside down. **forehead slap**

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted

Like I said it was for my parents and they only paid for the materials not labor. I'm not a big fan of making elaborate things for the shop since it will inevitably get beat up. Eventually when I make a newer nicer dresser this old one will probably become shop furniture.

Posted

A construction question:  Did you insert dust/web frames between the drawers?  If you were fighting cheap plywood, a natural strategy would be to break up large expanses (i.e. the carcase sides) with some sort of bracing that makes it impossible to move.

Posted

Crappy plywood will curse any project.  I think we all have to go there once and learn that lesson ourselves.  I did it with some shop cabinets.  Disaster.  Every time I (try to) open or close the top drawer I'm reminded why I never use crappy plywood anymore.  Live and learn.

 

Have you heard anything from Wood Werks about the bandsaws yet?  I haven't.

  • Like 1
Posted

If that's your worst project, you have nothing to be ashamed of.  The only way to learn is by experimenting, which can seem like trying and failing.  I prefer to think of it as trying and learning.

 

As long as you learned something, it was successful.  And your parents got a custom made functional cabinet that exactly met their specs!  They specified crappy plywood, and that's what they got.  Sounds like a complete success all around!

 

And, maybe your father will learn something about crappy plywood, or listening to his son. ^_^

  • Like 1
Posted

I talked to woodwerks a couple weeks ago and they said they should be shipping at the end of the month but it already pretty close to the end of the month. I'm hoping to hear something this week.

Posted

If you don't want to work with cheap plywood again, then you'll source your ply from a professional dealer from now on, and plan to spend around $80-$100 for the cheaper stuff. It does make the difference though. Just remember, there is no such thing as a dead flat sheet of plywood. Your joinery, face frames, web frames, back panels are what will pull the project into square and straighten the panels out. 

Posted

I did get the plywood from my hardwood dealer but it already their cheapest stuff plus it was on sale. So they probably knew it was a bad batch and wanted to get rid of it. 

Posted

Freddie's right about the joinery, but sometimes it's just too bad to compensate for.  I know how to make dadoes square, straight and flat, but it didn't help with the cabinets I mentioned...the ply was just too warped.  I fiddled with the drawer slides for what was probably hours and finally got all but one working smoothly.  The last would require rebuilding the drawer.  Screw that.  It's a good reminder to always buck up for quality materials for every project, whether it's a "special" piece or a simple shop project.  Anything you build deserves to be done right, and that means both the building of the piece and the materials you use.  My time is too valuable to me to invest it in a project made of crap lumber or ply.  It's always worth the extra cost in the long run.  That Chinese birch ply will never be found in my shop again.  Never.

  • Like 2
Posted

All my crap projects have one thing in common: plywood. 

 

I know there is good plywood and that for some things, it is really the best alternative.  But since this is a hobby and not a job and I don't make cabinets for a living, I stick with solid wood.   I can joint it, plane it, sand it and repair it.  Not things you can do with ply.  I actually think turning out good plywood projects takes more skill and practice than turning good solid wood projects.  Even on the good ply, the veneers are microscopically thin and shrivel up and die the minute I plug in my ROS.   Plywood also offers the benefits of splinters, paper cuts, a sore back from heaving an 8X4 sheet on to the roof of my car.  Plywood is just not fun for me. 

Posted

Freddie's right about the joinery, but sometimes it's just too bad to compensate for.  I know how to make dadoes square, straight and flat, but it didn't help with the cabinets I mentioned...the ply was just too warped.  I fiddled with the drawer slides for what was probably hours and finally got all but one working smoothly.  The last would require rebuilding the drawer.  Screw that.  It's a good reminder to always buck up for quality materials for every project, whether it's a "special" piece or a simple shop project.  Anything you build deserves to be done right, and that means both the building of the piece and the materials you use.  My time is too valuable to me to invest it in a project made of crap lumber or ply.  It's always worth the extra cost in the long run.  That Chinese birch ply will never be found in my shop again.  Never.

 

I'm not saying I'm a big proponent of cheap plywood, but the Birch ply I get from my local Menards is actually quite good - for what it is. I don't expect it to be completely void free, or dead flat. But, I'll be honest, I rarely find a void that can't be filled with a slight dab of putty. Since I'm using this stuff for painted projects only, works for me. It stays relatively flat, and since I cut it up into smaller pieces anyway, it goes unnoticed.

 

However, I would never use this stuff for anything that required more precision. I can sneeze through the veneer on this stuff. But again, since it is painted, it is never seen that I sanded through a ply. The chips that come off the edge because the veneer wasn't glued on well enough, covered up with that thick and goopy paint that it put on. Blends right in.

 

It has a time and place, but anything where the wood is supposed to be itself, buck up for the expensive stuff. I have only purchased on "premium" sheet of plywood for a project. It is a WORLD of difference, even with just working with that one sheet alone. Veneer was thicker, although still paper thin. Did not chip at ALL when cutting, although I used my TS 55, perfect for this. Did not find one void, and entire sheet stayed dead flat with obvious precautions taken when storing for a week.

 

Don't be too hard on yourself about a project. Constructive criticism is good, and if you can learn from a mistake and improve on your next endeavor, it was a good mistake to make. Even with all that went wrong, and as frustrated as you became, it turned out nice and glad to see you stuck it out and finished it.

Posted

Thanks Sam. 

 

KiKi, I just got an e-mail say that the bandsaws will arrive at the Laguna Warehouse early next week and will ship shortly after that

Posted

I'll be ordering a Resaw King eventually but it's gonna go on my 17".  This new saw will be dedicated to curves so I'll be getting a 1/4" or maybe 3/16" for it and keep it there.  I'll probably just get a Timberwolf 3 TPI.  Good inexpensive blades.

 

What size RK did you buy?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 58 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined