Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Faking Walnut

Featured Replies

First, let's get this out of the way: no, it's never going to look exactly like walnut.

 

A client (and I use the word loosely) I've working with before has asked me to make a rank board for their dojo that's 27' long x 18" high. The basic design is this:

 

post-6112-0-57070200-1398796919_thumb.jp

 

Even though it's simple, at 27' long, it will get pricy, fast, using walnut (to match a torii I did for them earlier). So, I'm going to look into ways to reduce wood usage and maintain walnut as a primary wood, or using maple or white oak as a secondary wood (since they're about 2/3 the cost in my area).

 

As a worst-case-scenario, though, I might have to give up on matching the walnut entirely. This won't be in close proximity to the other piece I did for them, so the matching doesn't have to be exact... but I'm starting to look at wood/stain combinations that would provide a similar appearance. Thoughts?

Couple of years ago, I got a schedule from Charles Neil for Soft Maple and/or Poplar-->Walnut. This schedule gets you really close...

 

Sand Maple faces to 150/180 and edges to 320/400

Coat of blotch control

Second coat of blotch control on edges

Mohawk Medium Walnut Alcohol NGR

Let Dry

Mohawk Light Walnut Alcohol NGR

Let Dry

You may need a barrier coat depending on how your going topcoat it.

 

Poplar will be slightly red cast and Maple will be more brown.

 

The final result is very close to the real thing... From ten feet away, you can't tell...

 

Now if your existing Walnut finished with a pronounced red cast, use American Walnut NGR in place of the Light Walnut.

 

Do a test board or two in both Poplar and Soft Maple to see what's closer to that you've already done, sometimes two coats of Light Walnut may be closer than a Medium+Light. 

 

Good luck.

I would try poplar as a test first. It's cheap and comes in long wide clean planks. If you get several boards that are a similar color overall it will be easier to do the stain sequence .

Nope... More like http://www.mohawk-finishing.com/catalog_browse.asp?ictNbr=178

 

BTW: I'm "assuming" you are familiar with alcohol-based dyes... If not, you should do some reading... They are a different animal from other colerants... They are very powerful, penetrate more deeply and dry faster than any other kid on the block. Unlike stains, these will add color with each subsequent application... This means that drips/runs will place you directly in finishing hell -- no passing Go and no collecting $200... It is highly recommended that you spray dyes, but if you work fast and always keep a wet-edge, then you can hand-apply...

 

BTW, they are also the dye of choice to pop figure -- they penetrate Maple like nothing else...

  • Author

I'm only familiar in the general sense of "they're not forgiving." I don't have a spray setup, but for something this simple, I'm pretty confident in my ability to work fast. Drips though.... ugh. Hopefully I can get this into a more reasonable cost without relying on dying.

==>Drips though.... ugh

Yea, that's the downside... But there are simple techniques to manage drops/runs when hand-applying dyes. I'm reasonably sure that CN has a demo on his free site...

 

Essentially, you start from the ground and apply moving up the piece so any drip falls on an already wet surface. The key is to apply wet and keep the piece wet until you get it all colored, then wipe back from top to bottom...

 

Get yourself some dye and try it on maple, poplar, etc...

I made a blanket chest a few years ago entirely out of poplar and stained part of it with dark walnut stain. I know it won't fool a woodworker but, most people are just sure that it is walnut and maple.

 

FrontIMG_0760_zpsbfdb0d37.jpg

 

Anyway, I thought it looked fairly good.

 

Rog

BTW: Mohawk is only sold in 1gal or 5gal quanities. That's a bit much for practice... You can get Behlen's Solar Lux in quarts (maybe even pints) -- it's essentially the same product... Mohawk is sold primary into pro cabinet cabinet shops and Behlen into lutiers. BTW: if you've ever wondered how lutiers get such pronounced figure on guitars -- well, Behlen is part of the schedule... One other thing, a quart of dye is going to last you a long time -- while not as concentrated as Transtint, this stuff is still plenty powerful and many dilute it for use.

Butternut matches well for grain and figure if you can buy it cheap in your area.

Sent from my T-Mobile G2 using Tapatalk 2

I had a look at some doors made from poplar. Even I had a hard time telling them from walnut. They used a two step staining system. One step was watco Danish oil. The other I don't remember. For what it's worth.

Steve

 

 

A client (and I use the word loosely) I've working with before has asked me to make a rank board for their dojo that's 27' long x 18" high. The basic design is this:

 

OK, I've gotta ask. What is a rank board and a dojo :huh:

 

  • Author

Dojo - martial arts school.

Rank board - as people get a belt rank, their name goes on a wooden tag. These are sorted by rank. As your rank increases, you move up a slot. The highest slots are saved for the founder of the art, the current head of the art, the head of your organization, and your head instructor, etc. Some schools don't use them because they have too many students, or put too much emphasis on rank. The Japanese name is "nafudakake" (try typing that on your phone some time - you'll get GREAT autocorrect suggestions). They're also frequently used at temples in Japan to recognize people who donate money.

 

 

I have a couple examples on Pinterest

Kinda surprised no one said use walnut plywood. Edge banding is a lot less material and the resulting project will still be plenty strong.

  • Author

I thought about it, but it'd end up being a lot more work for me as I envision it. 

 

Assuming I can find a place that actually has walnut ply near me (I don't know of anywhere, believe it or not), it's certainly not cheap, and I'd have to do lamination to get enough thickness and then actually make the edge banding. What I'd save in materials cost I'd probably lose in time.

I thought about it, but it'd end up being a lot more work for me as I envision it. 

 

Assuming I can find a place that actually has walnut ply near me (I don't know of anywhere, believe it or not), it's certainly not cheap, and I'd have to do lamination to get enough thickness and then actually make the edge banding. What I'd save in materials cost I'd probably lose in time.

I see, I didn't realize that the thickness would be a problem from design standpoint. You can order walnut ply through HD pro desk - the brand is by columbia, PurBond or something like that. I have used the birch version when it first came out and despite the 5 ply design (there were hardly any voids and the plies were of poplar) it was really stable. The best part was the veneer was thick enough to plane a bit - about .02" More recently the veneer has been thinner, like everything else right...

My dealer has walnut combi-core for $140/sheet.  It's high quality and very nice, but honestly you can get the same square footage in 4/4 S3S for only a little bit more, and rough 4/4 for less than the cost of a sheet.  It's hardly worth it, IMO, unless a design needs ply for dimensional stability.

My dealer was shot last night for trying to push a load of Chinese Ply

My dealer was shot last night for trying to push a load of Chinese Ply

Will you be needing to change your handle to DB Cooper and disappear too? :P:D

  • 2 weeks later...

Walnut isn't a difficult color to fake and your pieces are narrow enough that they don't show a lot of grain and the focus will be on what is on the rack not the rack itself.  It's not like you're trying to fake a walnut armoire or something.  I think you're over thinking it.  Just get some walnut stain of your brand of choice on some poplar or soft maple and you're good to go.

  • Author

Heh. Krtwood, very true. I ordered a pint of the Behlens Walnut dye, and it looks just fine on poplar. Wipes on fairly easily too. Thanks for the advice, everyone. I'll be sure to take pictures of everything.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.