Recommended Posts

Posted

I just purchased my first hand plane on eBay (Stanley No. 4)...plane looks near mint.

 

My only concern (remember, this is my first hand plane) are the scratches on the sole. Since I have basically no hand plane experience, I don't know if this will affect the performance or if a little polishing will remove them.

 

Once shipping is factored in, I payed $115 CDN. This may seem like a lot to some, but considering where I live in Canada (Newfoundland), it's a fair price. I've seen Stanely's so rusted, you swear they were formerly boat anchors (everything in Newfoundland is rusted) go for $30-$50. But they are after all "antiques"...queue eye roll.

 

With the condition of the plane and where I live, I think I got a fair deal...I'm just wondering what some of you plane experts think.

 

http://www.ebay.ca/itm/281356755396?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1497.l2648

Posted

Personally, I think most over react to a few scratches in the sole of a plane.  For the most part, if the sole is reasonably flat and the scratches don't cause raised spots, unevenness or mar the work piece, I'd maybe lap it a few stokes, rub on some wax and go to town.  Make sure whatever you lap it on is dead flat.

 

As for the price paid, I don't think it was out of the ballpark.  I think it might've been fair value and/or close to full retail but I don't think it's something you should regret.

Posted

If it looks mint then you paid some extra to save yourself some time.  Nothing wrong with that!  I wouldn't worry about the scratches... I've scratches in all my vintage and new planes, some of it is just from using them on wood, no accidents involved.  Just think of them as a custom irregular corrugated model.

Posted

Sounds like a lot of money to me, but as you say, it varies much on where you live. For example here in Italy, when you bid on ebay in the UK, and add in the postage, you can end up only 25% under your purchase price. These days I advise people to try a Woodriver type plane, doesn't cost much more and you know what you're getting.

 

Is it me or have people 'wised up' on ebay as regards hand planes these days? My last three purchases had wire brushed soles, metric bolts wobbling around in Whitworth holes, broken cap levers, the works. My mistake of course, but you can only stare at a photo for so long...

 

As far as the scratches are concerned, they shouldn't be very deep, so don't bother trying to remove them. I've managed to scratch the soles of all my planes - no, no nails, just some tough gnarly hardwoods.

 

John

Posted

Scratches will probably come out when you lap the bottom.  I use a granite surface plate, and wet-or-dry sandpaper to flatten iron plane soles on anyway.  You can keep going finer in grit until it "shines like the top of the Chrysler building".

Posted

Since I'm a newb, I didn't know if scratches are "normal" or not. I'm glad a few minor imperfections don't matter.

 

I can honestly say I don't regret my buy...ie no buyers remorse. I also picked up a Stanley No. 5 in the same condition for $125...again, no buyers remorse.

 

The thing I like about the two planes I've purchased so far is they're in excellent shape. I'm just getting into woodworking and I don't want to spend hours and hours restoring tools before I can get to the wood. Down the road, yes I'll probably try my luck at tool restoration, but now I'm more concerned with tools that require little to no sweat equity. 

 

http://www.ebay.ca/itm/111378510674?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1439.l2649

 

Here's the question though...I'm paying roughly what a new Wood River plane would cost. How do old Stanley's compare to WR v3 planes?

Posted

I have the WoodRiver equivalent of the low angle block and low angle Jack (they come under different names in Europe). Both are excellent planes, and in my case came with multiple blades at different angles. I'd say the quality is slightly better than the vintage planes. Also there are no surprises, as can happen with vintage planes, no cracked handles or rust (sorry - I meant oxygen enhancement). I have no idea if they keep their value second hand, probably not to the same extent as the Veritas and Lie Nielsen planes.

 

John

Posted

I just purchased my first hand plane on eBay (Stanley No. 4)...plane looks near mint.

 

My only concern (remember, this is my first hand plane) are the scratches on the sole. Since I have basically no hand plane experience, I don't know if this will affect the performance or if a little polishing will remove them.

 

Once shipping is factored in, I payed $115 CDN. This may seem like a lot to some, but considering where I live in Canada (Newfoundland), it's a fair price. I've seen Stanely's so rusted, you swear they were formerly boat anchors (everything in Newfoundland is rusted) go for $30-$50. But they are after all "antiques"...queue eye roll.

 

With the condition of the plane and where I live, I think I got a fair deal...I'm just wondering what some of you plane experts think.

 

http://www.ebay.ca/itm/281356755396?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1497.l2648

 

Seems a little high to me.  Fifteen or twenty bucks maybe...

Posted

There's a guy near me, selling a #4 and #5 for a total of $40.  US... I have those so I don't need to get them.  I wish I'd known, I'd a picked them up and shipped them to you.

Posted

There's a guy near me, selling a #4 and #5 for a total of $40.  US... I have those so I don't need to get them.  I wish I'd known, I'd a picked them up and shipped them to you.

Hah...I've paid just a tad more than that. But as I've stated, living in NF things are different. I once saw someone ask $60 for a jack that I thought was almost beyond repair; "vintage plane".

 

Are the planes in the same shape as the ones I purchased off eBay?

 

Locally someone just posted a #4 for $60...Isn't that always the way? Would anyone else pay $60 for it? 

 

http://www.kijiji.ca/v-hand-tool/st-johns/antique-stanley-bailey-4-pat-1910-wood-plane-blade-perfect/603583451?enableSearchNavigationFlag=true

 

A "victor by Stanely"...never heard of it. I'm looking at it and I don't think it's worth $50.

 

http://www.kijiji.ca/v-hand-tool/st-johns/victor-by-stanley-large-measures-14-5-long/603583868

Posted

Look like fine planes to me.

 

If you use them regularly for the next 20 or 30 years, which you easily could, they would be no worse for wear and it would surely be money well spent.

 

Sure the market seems a bit inflated  for vintage tools. But I speculate that 10 years from now we'll all wish we had hit that buy button more often while we had the chance.

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.