Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dust Collector Suggestion

Featured Replies

I'm looking to set up my 2 car garage as a woodworking shop and trying to figure out what dust collector I should get. I'm in Sarnia, Ontario, Canada but this is a border town so access to the US is certainly a possibility.

I think I've read every possible forum topic about dust collection so this is what I THINK I need:

At least 1000 CFM

HEPA 0.3 micron filtering

At least 4" inlet

vortex/cyclone pre-filter

Remote on/off

.

Other than that, I'm looking suggestions. I will have either 120/240V available so that's not a concern. I'm hoping to spend less than $1,500 which will hopefully include some good flexible piping about 30' long (I'll up to SCMS, Table Saw, DW735 Planer, etc. as needed). I will install hard piping and blast gates, etc. eventually.

To me vortex/cyclone (for bulk waste) and the HEPA filtering (for clean air) are critical. It seems that everything I looked at had no better than 1 or 2 micron filtering. Am I being too picky?

Looking for specific brand/model suggestions. Available or at least supported in Canada would be nice.

Personally I find the micron ratings to be a marketing gimmick, since if you can't collect 100% at the source...which you can't on most machines because of poor DC engineering...you're still getting airborne particulates.  If you're that concerned about breathing dust, wear a respirator.  At all times.  Or do what I do and try not to think about it.  Ignorance is bliss.

 

Bigger is better.  Go for a 5HP unit if you're wanting good results.  2HP or 3HP will clean up the bulk of the mess but will leave a lot to be desired on certain machines, namely bandsaw and table saw.

Great topic Chris, I'm getting ready to build out mine as well.

 

Eric, Are you saying 5HP as a general rule or for the size/length of Chris' runs? I'm going to be in a small more confined space with the longest run being about 15'. Because I'm trying to get a new table saw/band saw/miter saw in my budget I was going to go smaller and have been looking at the Jet 1.5HP unit (and install an extractor on most tools as well). 

 

Thanks!

I'm saying bigger is better.  I have a 2HP ducted system in a two car garage.  It cleans up the bulk of the mess but it's far from Pentz-approved.  If you're concerned with health issues you have to get a way bigger unit than you probably think you need and you'll have to spend a ton of time modifying your machines to make them more efficient...a huge amount of CFM doesn't mean much if your port is a foot away from the source.  And you'll still need to wear a respirator.  If you're concerned only with picking up the bulk of the waste, you can save a lot of money and time wasted on worrying about it.  I started to run the Pentz gauntlet a long time ago...stopped mid-stride and said screw it...spent my money on tools instead of air movement and started building.

I am a go big kind of guy so I just bought a 5HP Oneida V-5000 for my 2 car garage/shop.  It does have a HEPA filter with 99.something something down to .3 micron.  My rational is that I'll have lots of airflow to catch more of the dust as it is generated.  I also plan to leave it running for extended periods so it will act to clean the air of what dust initially escapes.  Larger motors shouldn't have short start/stop cycles so this will be better for the motor.

 

Because the collector will be running in between using the machinery I don't want good noise control so I don't have to wear the ear muffs all the time.  I've just about finished a sound proof room where the collector & compressor will reside.  When I get it all done & the machinery installed I'll report back with sound level results.

 

The cost difference between a 5 hp & 2 or 3 hp really isn't that much.

 

If your looking for 1000 CFM at the machine, I'm pretty sure your going to need something with a lot more than a 4" inlet. Probably 6 - 8".

 

Frank

I side with Eric on this one. Dust collection will eat your hobby budget for lunch. Different thing entirely in a commercial shop. Use a respirator for the fine stuff, and a small DC or shop vac for the bulk clean up. Lot's of folks claim good service from the 2hp model sold at Harbor Freight, and it is very reasonably priced.

Use a respirator for the fine stuff, and a small DC or shop vac for the bulk clean up. Lot's of folks claim good service from the 2hp model sold at Harbor Freight, and it is very reasonably priced.

+1 in a hobby shop

Ken (K Cooper) likes his HF dust collector - he may chime in with his views too.

The advice presented so far is spot-on… DC starts at the tool… Unfortunately, some tools are inherently harder to collect fine dust than others… Further, some mfgs pay more attention to DC in their designs than others… I view DC as a purchasing criterion when evaluating brands/models…

 

If you have the funds, I’d get a decent DC… As strong as the respirator argument is, I’ve met few hobby woodworkers with the discipline to wear a respirator day-in-day-out… Don’t get me wrong, certainly some do, but human nature says it’s the minority... The other argument is that a good DC setup will last decades and as tools come/go, new acquisitions can be made with DC in mind… So even though you might not be collecting the fines on day one, over time the percentage of pickup will increase with smart purchasing…

 

The issue of HP mentioned above in mostly true…  But you’ve got to be careful about HP – some use HP as a marketing spec and one mfg’s 3HP system may outperform another’s 5HP setup… Unfortunately, some have gotten very creative with HP specs… Not all motors are the same… Same goes for HEPA, CFM, SP, etc… To be blunt: some mfgs claim totally bogus specs developed with truly creative test methodologies… For the small shop, a 7” inlet 3HP system is AOK – assuming you are actually getting a valid 3HP setup…

 

For some time, CV had the edge for small shops limited to 4” inlet tools operating one at a time on a tight budget. Today, I’d get the new polycarbonate V-System from Oneida over anything from Clear-Vue:  http://www.oneida-air.com/inventory.asp?CatId={883C6AA7-4C85-49FD-9EEA-C51D09DC8B19}... The new V-system is the Clear-Vue killer: trusted specs, HEPA out of the box, factory assembled/balanced motor/impellor/housing, etc at the same price-point as a CV unit. Side Note: I suspect CV’s next restructuring will be their last… Penn State makes a good unit… I’ve never used the Grizzly 3HP, but it looks solid – but their specs are a bit suspect…

 

The real key to successful shop DC is the ductwork… You can purchase a great cyclone, but poorly designed/installed ductwork will reduce performance dramatically… Personally, I’d pay the $200 for a ductwork design… Why? I’ve seen WTO members get themselves a very nice cyclone setup, and then kill any ability to collect fine dust with poor ductwork decisions… The shop may look clean, but they have no hope of collecting fines, so they have to wear a respirator… Personally, I’m not that disciplined… If you are, great… But I do think it's a bit wasteful to spend $2K to keep the shop clean and not protect your health... Always remember, it’s the dust you can’t see that’s the issue…

 

Anyway, good luck…

You could have a 20 horse torit and teflon coated duct work and if your using machines with 4" ports your going to have the same issues as a smaller collector. Common sense need to play a bigger part than all this spec hype.

The duct work will most likely cost more than the collector, if you go spiral it most certainly will, I am no pro wood worker but I am a professional craftsman and dust is part of it, I use several dedicated shop vacs under problem tools, the lathe is just a mess no matter what. If I were going to spend that much money on dust collect I would vent the particulate matter outside the shop instead of trying to filter down that small.

My manual was pretty decent at helping with design, SP loss, and CFM. I'm sure a professional designer would have did some things differently. My worst run has 9 SP loss which about 1100 CFM on my curve. 4" flex hose has 6X more SP loss than 6" steel pipe which adds up quickly. 

 

http://cdn0.grizzly.com/manuals/g0441_m.pdf

 

Here my thread on my ductwork. Down the road I might change to 8" from cyclone to first wye and add bigger ports on some of the machines. Don't if I'll visually see a difference, but like hhh said, my lungs might notice it. 

 

The duct work will most likely cost more than the collector, if you go spiral it most certainly will, I am no pro wood worker but I am a professional craftsman and dust is part of it, I use several dedicated shop vacs under problem tools, the lathe is just a mess no matter what. If I were going to spend that much money on dust collect I would vent the particulate matter outside the shop instead of trying to filter down that small.

I got all my spiral pipe and fittings locally and spent under $500 which was a lot cheaper than anyone on the Internet. 

 

post-8178-142094496604.jpg

==>using machines with 4" ports your going to have the same issues as a smaller collector

Unfortunately, too true...

 

It's kind of crazy to see small ports on big tools... Like I said, if you care about DC, then it starts with purchasing tools with DC designed-in... All my Euro kit has 6" ports, but if you look at comparable Asian-sourced, you get 4" -- just crazy... The EU’s been pushing DC far longer than on this side of the pond… As more consumers start caring about DC, the venders will respond... Look at FT -- they use DC as a Marketing advantage... And it works...

 

 

==>Common sense need to play a bigger part than all this spec hype.
Very true... You can simply over-provision and get a mongo 5HP+ unit... That’ll probably get you past the mfg’s manipulation of CFM/SP in a small shop, but you still have to deal with filtering (unless you vent outside)... Many venders simply publish bogus filtering performance because a HEPA filter is about $600 and a spun-poly “sounds like HEPA, but not actually HEPA” filter is about $200… Guess which venders actually spend the $600 for HEPA filtering (hint: not CV)... Why does this matter? Because hobbyists are increasingly adding stationary sanders to their workflow…  And if the “sounds like HEPA” filter isn’t HEPA, then wearing a respirator might not actually matter -- the sub 0.5u fines are recirculated long after the sander is shut down and the mask comes off…

 

Speaking of HEPA filters: some mfg’s will ‘upgrade’ your unit with a HEPA filter – now pay attention to the fine print: notice they say the filter's HEPA, but still don’t state that the system's HEPA compliant… Why? You can’t slap a HEPA filter on a system not designed for HEPA and suddenly the system becomes HEPA-compliant… Why? Because the filter media adds back-pressure to the cyclone setup (it doesn’t quite work like that because I’m simplifying things a bit)… That’s why certain cyclone mfg’s have such rosy specs --- running the system without filter media adds around 1-2in/H2O WC SP or so to the performance curve… HEPA media is a bit more – I think mine is just around 2"-3”WC give/take.

 

Every inch WC is important… The difference between a typical 2HP and 3HP setup is right around 3”WC give/take… The difference between a 3HP and 5HP is also around 2”-3"WC give/take (varability with impellor)… So substituting PTFE HEPA media for the factory spun-poly non-HEPA media on a 5HP cyclone is just about the same as substituting a 3HP motor for the 5HP motor give/take (now before the Engineers in our studio audience point-out that it doesn’t quite work that way – yea, I know but its close enough and the result’s the same)…

 

Further (and for the sake of transparency), I don’t buy the respirator argument… If you take a poll of the 10K+ WTO members, what percentage actually wears a respirator when milling stock? Sanding and finishing, yes – but milling? What percent would it be? One percent? Less? And how many remove their respirator after the operation is complete – all while the fines are freely recirculated for the next twenty minutes? In all fairness, if a hobbyist is really a one-project/year dust maker, then he/she probably won’t be exposed to enough dust to matter… But more and more are using man-made materials (MDF, laminates, etc) and that’s a big dust load in a short time interval… Of course, the simple solution is to vent outside… External venting cures many DC problems :)

I got all my spiral pipe and fittings locally and spent under $500 which was a lot cheaper than anyone on the Internet. 

 

post-8178-142094496604.jpg

That is a very good deal, I ran spiral duct exposed in the upstairs loft area in the house it was designed by a local Supplier and it took six weeks to receive it but after reviewing the cost I realize that the majority of the cost was in the custom made brushed aluminum registers for the round duck.

I'm looking to set up my 2 car garage as a woodworking shop and trying to figure out what dust collector I should get. I'm in Sarnia, Ontario, Canada but this is a border town so access to the US is certainly a possibility.

I think I've read every possible forum topic about dust collection so this is what I THINK I need:

At least 1000 CFM

HEPA 0.3 micron filtering

At least 4" inlet

vortex/cyclone pre-filter

Remote on/off

.

Other than that, I'm looking suggestions. I will have either 120/240V available so that's not a concern. I'm hoping to spend less than $1,500 which will hopefully include some good flexible piping about 30' long (I'll up to SCMS, Table Saw, DW735 Planer, etc. as needed). I will install hard piping and blast gates, etc. eventually.

To me vortex/cyclone (for bulk waste) and the HEPA filtering (for clean air) are critical. It seems that everything I looked at had no better than 1 or 2 micron filtering. Am I being too picky?

Looking for specific brand/model suggestions. Available or at least supported in Canada would be nice.

Hi Chris,

 

I would check out Welbeck Sawmill. They are in Ontario and have great prices and service. They sell the Oneida line of collectors there and most Oneida systems will fit your requirements except the budget part....

 

I am in Montreal and just received a v3000 from them yesterday and installed it. Great quality machine and is PLENTY of power for a one man shop. 

 

If you want to give them a call ask for Mike. Great guy, great service. 519 369 2144

 

Shane

Don't have my receipt but here are rough prices on my components.

6" x 10' spiral pipe $16

6 6 6 custom made wyes $33

6" blast gates $16

I notice that Mike's system looks very well designed and efficient, using two 45's in place of a 90 degree elbow to connect to most machines.  The drum sander/planer drop is a 90, but it looks like a large radius.  He uses blast gates on every port and has a minimum of flex hose to make connections.  Those kinds of things are every bit as important as CFM, SP, etc. when trying to get the most out of a DC system.

I have the harbor freight 2hp dust collector with a wynn filter. Cost was a little over $300. I only hook up one machine at a time, so that slows me down. But the collector works fine for me. The Wynn filter is fantastic.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.