Recommended Posts

Posted

I realize this may be a borderline religious debate, but I need to try.

 

The important part is I need to know what will be the better choice for me and the tools I have.  I need to cut some 3/4" and 1/2" dados.  I have a choice betweek:

 

  • Rigid 4510 Table Saw
  • Ryobi R161 1-1/2 HP 1/4" Router

 

I have no bits for the router, and no dado blade for the saw.  For the same money (> $100) would I be better off getting something like the Oshun or Freud 6" dado set (and I need to somehow come up with a dado plate), or get something like the MLCS 15-piece set and cut the dados with that?

 

This is for the project where the wife will start to see some results, so I need to get in on a budget and hopefully expand my capabilities a little more.  If she's happy, I get to spend more next time.  :rolleyes:  :D 

 

At first blush it seems like I may get more utility out of the router bit set, but I may be missing something.

Posted

Ultimately, you need to be able to do both.

 

Given the option between your TS and a hand held router, the TS would be the better option for accuracy.  If you were talking about your TS and a Router Table, well, then that would be a different story and I'd have a lot more questions.

 

You can build an insert for your TS so, you don't have something else you need to purchase.

Posted

That router seems under powered, you may need more than one pass per cut. Dado cuts are demanding.

 

To make those dado cuts with a router, you will also need a router table and fence. If those cuts are really close to the edge of the wood, you could use an edge guide for the router instead of a router table.

 

If you don't have those accessories (router table and fence or edge guide) you'd be better off with a dado set for the table saw. Make sure your TS supports 3/4 inch dado sets or even 1/2.

Posted

When I'm making that decision the biggest factor is the size of the piece I'm running the dado in.

If it's a small piece that is easily handled, I typically opt for the router table. On bigger pieces, where it would be hard to manage it on the smaller surface of the router table, I may go for the table saw. On really big pieces, I'll use a straight edge and a handheld router or use an edge guide attached to the router.

The quality of the cutter is important, and I'm guessing that you will be able to buy a nice white side bit for far less than getting a comparable quality dado set. So not having the tooling in place already, I'd go with a router and get a good quality bit.

It's a good idea to practice on scrap, and don't try to hog the whole dado in one pass. Especially if you are working with hard wood or are making a big/deep dado.

Also remember, 3/4 plywood often isn't exactly 3/4, so if you use a typical 3/4 bit you will have a loose fitting dado. They make special plywood dado bits that are the correct thickness to get a tight joint.

Good luck.

  • Like 1
Posted

Also remember, 3/4 plywood often isn't exactly 3/4, so if you use a typical 3/4 bit you will have a loose fitting dado. They make special plywood dado bits that are the correct thickness to get a tight joint.

 

 

That also applies to router bits. Undersized plywood bit sets are available from Freud, CMT, etc.

Posted

Also as that is a portable table saw it isn't ideal for use with a dado stack.  I think making up an exact width dado jig and getting a pattern making bit for the router would be the best option.   At least for ones that are long.

 

Neither of those is exactly what someone would be wanting to choose as the tool for the job.

Posted

Technique and Workflow are driven by what you're trying to accomplish, experience and available toolset...

 

Let's get the what out of the way before we jump on the how...

 

What are you making?

Do you have a drawing?

Can you post it?

How long are the dados?

How deep?

In what material(s)?

Can you gang-cut them?

et al...

 

What you do depends on what you make... For example, my last big dado job was four garage storage units: Laid two 4x8 3/4 BB on the garage floor side-by-side, clamped a straight-edge and routed six dados and two rabbits using a plunge router and 1/2 spiral bit across both sheets at the same time... Used a circ saw to rip each sheet into four strips, then routed a 1/4" rabbit in the sides of three more sheets (to fit in 1/2" dado) and ripped the shelves and a couple of sheets of 1/2 BB for the backs... Add a pneumatic stapler and some TBIII -- done... No tablesaw, no router table, no special bits... A good straight edge was the key...

Posted

 

A good straight edge was the key...

 

Yeah but making matching dados with a straight edge can be very frustrating, since a new setup is required for each individual cut. Not for beginners IMO. Most beginners do not know how to take accurate measurements, make and use spacers, etc.

Posted

Thanks for the comments so far.  To answer some important points that were brought up:

 

  • What I will be doing is primarily along the length of a piece of plywood.  Not trying to be vague, my plans are all over the place. :)  Let's say 3/4" nominal (for plywood so they will be smaller) and 3/8" deep.  
  • Wood will be baltic birch or something close to it.
  • I will be making/cobbling together a router table FIRST, I do not intend to do any of this freehand.
  • While I am new at this sort of woodworking, I'm not entirely new to the equipment.  My skill level was "new house trim" level.  By this I mean I'm pretty olay with process, layout, use of spacers, measurements, jigs, etc..

 

I know if the router were slightly beefier it would be an easier choice.

Posted

I would not make a router table around a 1 1/2 HP router, but that's just my opinion.

 

Maybe I'm missing something, but you don't generally build a router table that can only be used with one router, do you?  I may have to change the plate but I can put an upgraded router in there when I get one, right?

Posted

Maybe I'm missing something, but you don't generally build a router table that can only be used with one router, do you?  I may have to change the plate but I can put an upgraded router in there when I get one, right?

 

If you add a lift, they are not typically universal.

Posted

Another thing to take into consideration is wether or not your project calls for stopped dadoes. If so, you definitely want to use a router table or router free hand. Safer that way. Not impossible on the ts just easier as a beginner to use a router.

Edit: by freehand i mean with some form of straight edge or jig. No table involved...

Posted

If you add a lift, they are not typically universal.

 

Gotcha.  Understood, at the least the "clamp" would need to be changed.  I've been noodling that.

 

Another thing to take into consideration is wether or not your project calls for stopped dadoes. If so, you definitely want to use a router table or router free hand. Safer that way. Not impossible on the ts just easier as a beginner to use a router.

Edit: by freehand i mean with some form of straight edge or jig. No table involved...

 

Current project has stopped dados.  I guess that may actually make my decision for me, huh?

Posted

Gotcha. Understood, at the least the "clamp" would need to be changed. I've been noodling that.

Current project has stopped dados. I guess that may actually make my decision for me, huh?

I would say so. Please dont start your first project doing stopped dadoes with a dadoe blade, especially if its stopped at both ends!
  • Like 1
Posted

Gotcha.  Understood, at the least the "clamp" would need to be changed.  I've been noodling that.

 

 

Current project has stopped dados.  I guess that may actually make my decision for me, huh?

 

Pretty much..  Best done with a router and chisels.

  • Like 1
Posted

==>matching dados with a straight edge can be very frustrating, since a new setup is required for each individual cut

Point taken...

 

Now that I think about it... I've seen numerous articles and videos on these router-dado jigs... Didn't Marc have one? Don't remember if it was an article or video and don't remember if it was on his free site... If not there, then FWW, PoP-W, YouTube, et al -- just search for router dado jig... Takes a lot of the guess work out of the setup -- most are 1/2 bit + 5/8 bushing setups...

 

Agree with the above: router + chisel is the way to go...

 

@OP... You can build a table around a lift/plate. Most of the better lifts can be ordered with diferent motor mounts....

Posted

Thanks for the discussion everyone. It's really helping me work all this out in my head.

Maybe I should keep an eye out for a close out or refurb 2.5 HP router first. This one is perfectly good but as we've covered it may be under powered for what I want, and it's a large frame making it a bad choice for a small trim router.

Oh, decisions.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted

I'm gonna estimate that I do roughly 90% of my dadoes with the router.  They're so frequently stopped that it eliminates a bunch of them right there.  I'd never do a stopped dado with the TS...not because it's dangerous, but because it would take more time cleaning the "ramp" with a chisel than it would be worth.  And most of the time I'm only doing one or two or four dadoes for a one-off piece, and setting up a router is faster than installing the dado stack...so that eliminates a bunch more.

 

The only times I use the dado stack is when I'm doing through dadoes and doing a bunch of them, which doesn't happen often.  Also the router gives you more consistent dadoes...you almost always need to clean a stack-cut dado with a router plane.  Often a dado with the router is good enough as-is.  Always good to check, but the physics make it more possible to get a consistent flat bottom right off the bit.

Posted

That also applies to router bits. Undersized plywood bit sets are available from Freud, CMT, etc.

 

Yea, that was confusing how I wrote it.  I meant the router bits, but typed it as "dado bit".

Posted

Thanks for the comments so far.  To answer some important points that were brought up:

 

  • What I will be doing is primarily along the length of a piece of plywood.  Not trying to be vague, my plans are all over the place. :)  Let's say 3/4" nominal (for plywood so they will be smaller) and 3/8" deep.  
  • Wood will be baltic birch or something close to it.
  • I will be making/cobbling together a router table FIRST, I do not intend to do any of this freehand.
  • While I am new at this sort of woodworking, I'm not entirely new to the equipment.  My skill level was "new house trim" level.  By this I mean I'm pretty olay with process, layout, use of spacers, measurements, jigs, etc..

 

I know if the router were slightly beefier it would be an easier choice.

 

By "along the length of a piece of plywood" do you mean along the 8' length, the 4' length, both?  And how big will the entire piece of plywood be that you are routing?

 

Main reason I ask is because, if you are doing this on a pretty large piece of ply, a router table is going to be much more difficult than using a router hand held.  Its hard to maneuver large pieces of ply over a large surface like a table saw and much moreso over a smaller router table surface.  Then factor in that your ply will possibly (and could even say likely) not be completely flat.  That means you'd have to be moving around a large piece of ply, and at the same time making sure that the part around the router bit is completely pressed down against the table surface.  If it's not, you are going to get an inconsistent depth dado which will screw stuff up.

 

With larger pieces of ply, its almost always easier and safer to take the tool to the wood as opposed to bringing the wood to the tool. 

 

Edit:  While your router size/HP is not ideal for this task, it can do it.  Just dont try to do the cut all at once.  Do it in two or three passes, getting a bit deeper with each pass and you should be fine.

Posted

By "along the length of a piece of plywood" do you mean along the 8' length, the 4' length, both?  And how big will the entire piece of plywood be

Sorry that was pretty ambiguous. Let's say I cut a 2' x 1' piece. I have through dados the long way and stop dados the short way. Sort of like a box.

Edit:  While your router size/HP is not ideal for this task, it can do it.  Just dont try to do the cut all at once.  Do it in two or three passes, getting a bit deeper with each pass and you should be fine.

Thanks, appreciate the level check. :).
Posted

I have cut plenty of 3/4" dados with a Porter-Cable 690, so your router will work fine. There are a number of videos on making exact fit router guides for dados, so, it just needs a little searching. By the way, if you are cutting dados in 3/4" ply, 3/8 is fairly deep. 1/4" deep will give significant holding capability and won't unduly weaken the support piece. In the book shelves I have built, 1/4" dados support heavy loads - the limiting factor is the strength of the shelf, not the depth of the dado.

Posted

I agree on 1/4" deep dados being plenty. I got undersized plywood bits at Rockler, they work well, just keep them clean. As you see resin build up on bits the time spent cleaning is well worth it.

If your router will accept ring bushings you can build a jig that makes routing dados much easier. My version is shown in my Mahogany Library stair Project Journal.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 42 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined