Recommended Posts

Posted

Has anyone used a tankless before!

Getting ready to remodel the bathroom and would like to get the big water heater out of the room. But with very limited space available we are looking at a tankless. any experiences and/or opinions would be greatly appreciated!

Posted

I have..  Tankless is awesome as long as you can keep it relatively close to your shower.  Otherwise, you're paying extra to heat a lot of water before it ever gets there.

Posted
20 minutes ago, TIODS said:

I have..  Tankless is awesome as long as you can keep it relatively close to your shower.  Otherwise, you're paying extra to heat a lot of water before it ever gets there.

We put in a tankless that's about 80 - 100 feet away from out shower. We had them install a circulating pump with a timer on it. We also had them increase the diameter of the mixing valve in that bathroom. System works great! It also supplies hot water to our radiant floor heating system. I can hop in the shower within 5 seconds of turning it on.

  • Like 1
Posted
3 minutes ago, micks said:

We put in a tankless that's about 80 - 100 feet away from out shower. We had them install a circulating pump with a timer on it. We also had them increase the diameter of the mixing valve in that bathroom. System works great! It also supplies hot water to our radiant floor heating system. I can hop in the shower within 5 seconds of turning it on.

I do wish I'd of made those exact changes when I had mine installed.  Had mine in for about 8 years tho..  Live and learn!

Posted
1 minute ago, TIODS said:

I do wish I'd of made those exact changes when I had mine installed.  Had mine in for about 8 years tho..  Live and learn!

It took a few trips for them to figure out about the larger mixing valve, but once it was installed - instant hot water for the shower.

Posted

We got a tankless  heater about six years ago.

When we switched, they had to put in a larger gas line and mount it on an out side wall at the front of the basement so we have about 40' to the furthest bathroom. A water softener is required for our area but, we already had that before anyway.

I love it! With just two of us we don't use all that much hot water normally but when the kids come to visit,  we NEVER run out of hot water! A shower can be running at the same time as the dishwasher or laundry washer and every body is happy. Some times when you have six people waiting to shower and only two showers the old heater would have a time catching up (40 gal.) but not any longer.

When we are gone, the hot water doesn't have to keep turning on and off to maintain a constant temp. and using gas unnecessarily.  I'm sure we are saving money on the gas bill and still have the advantage of never running out of hot water.

My vote is YES it is worth while, as well as saving money over the long haul, even though it was three times the cost of just replacing a tank style every 5 or 6 years because of leaks and corrosion.

Posted

I don't have one, but want it badly. The only one designed and manufactured in the USA is made right here in my hometown. I met with the owners a few months ago and almost went to work for them. They had a ton of cool ideas. They are looking at the tankless water heater as just the start of the "Internet of Things" for them. Pretty cool stuff. Their features rock. 

Intellihot is their name. 

Posted
9 minutes ago, wtnhighlander said:

My MIL moved into a new apartment complex after my FIL passed away. All the units have the tankless heaters, mounted on an exterior wall. Hers froze during the first winter.

Nobody mounts anything outdoors here except an AC unit!

Posted

Not outside, just an an exterior wall. Of course, we also discovered that at least one receptacle circuit, and the water supply to one bathroom sink, originate from another unit in the building. And this is West TN, where the winter temps spend very little time below the freezing point of water.

Posted
30 minutes ago, wtnhighlander said:

Not outside, just an an exterior wall. Of course, we also discovered that at least one receptacle circuit, and the water supply to one bathroom sink, originate from another unit in the building. And this is West TN, where the winter temps spend very little time below the freezing point of water.

Even plumbing supply lines are run on interior walls here, in best practice.  At the very least, the plumbers run them on the "warm side" of the insulation or it would be a guaranteed pipe break at some point in a very cold winter.

My Tank less HWH is an unfinished basement, and the installer had to build a mini stud wall (like 16" wide) to mount it so that it wouldn't be on the inside of an exterior wall.

Posted

In 2009 I inquired about a tankless heater for my house in the chicago area.  The plumbing contractor claimed that our tap water is too cold in the winter for them to work effectively.   The tap water can be as low as 40 degrees in the winter, especially close to lake where I lived (i was about a mile from lake michigan, so our tap water traveled a very short distance from the pumping station).   He said they have a difficult time keeping a steady supply of shower-hot temperatures.   Considering the installation (at the time) for a tankless unit was way more $$$ than a 50 gallon tank I took his word for it.    He also said they computer controls were unreliable and needed frequent rebooting.  "Do you really want to head to the basement at 5am to reboot your water heater?" was his question to me.   Again that was 2009 so things could be better now.  

Posted
17 hours ago, wtnhighlander said:

My MIL moved into a new apartment complex after my FIL passed away. All the units have the tankless heaters, mounted on an exterior wall. Hers froze during the first winter.

I really can't figure that out because I live in Kansas and the current temp (@ 2: 23 PM ) is 28* f and there is no water except in the pipes and tubing to freeze. After six years and temps anywhere from 109 f down to -12 f we have never had a problem with freezing.

The reason for mounting on an exterior wall if for the exhaust heat and gasses. We were told to just not let snow, leaves or ice build up over the exhaust port.

Buy the way our water heater is in the basement and exposed to semi heated air from the furnace but there is no real heat registers or direct heating down there. It is somewhat cooler than the living quarters in the basement and all the water pipes are down there and haven't frozen in over 40 years!

Posted
3 hours ago, Mike. said:

In 2009 I inquired about a tankless heater for my house in the chicago area.  The plumbing contractor claimed that our tap water is too cold in the winter for them to work effectively.   The tap water can be as low as 40 degrees in the winter, especially close to lake where I lived (i was about a mile from lake michigan, so our tap water traveled a very short distance from the pumping station).   He said they have a difficult time keeping a steady supply of shower-hot temperatures.   Considering the installation (at the time) for a tankless unit was way more $$$ than a 50 gallon tank I took his word for it.    He also said they computer controls were unreliable and needed frequent rebooting.  "Do you really want to head to the basement at 5am to reboot your water heater?" was his question to me.   Again that was 2009 so things could be better now.  

Sounds like your contractor was afraid of new technology. This is the standard argument - it's newer than the 100 year old tank technology so it's inherently bad... Not everything newer is better but in this case tankless is excellent.

I've use tankless HW for past 6 years and it's great as long as you get a unit with enough capacity.  I can run 2 shower heads and washing machine and dishwasher all at some time if I want - with minimal loss of water pressure and no loss of temperature.

  • Like 2
Posted
3 hours ago, Mike. said:

In 2009 I inquired about a tankless heater for my house in the chicago area.  The plumbing contractor claimed that our tap water is too cold in the winter for them to work effectively.   The tap water can be as low as 40 degrees in the winter, especially close to lake where I lived (i was about a mile from lake michigan, so our tap water traveled a very short distance from the pumping station).   He said they have a difficult time keeping a steady supply of shower-hot temperatures.   Considering the installation (at the time) for a tankless unit was way more $$$ than a 50 gallon tank I took his word for it.    He also said they computer controls were unreliable and needed frequent rebooting.  "Do you really want to head to the basement at 5am to reboot your water heater?" was his question to me.   Again that was 2009 so things could be better now.  

When I first decided to go with a tankless water heater because to old one was going out, I called around to various plumbers to ask about them. Of the five I contacted, three were older plumbers and said "Yes we can install one but, we don't recommended them.". Two were younger guys that thought that that was the only way to go and did try to sell me on the idea. The person we went with came over and showed me a list of about five hundred other people and businesses' that he had sold tankless hot water heaters to in our area and had had good luck with them. He did admit that one restaurant owner did not follow his instructions about how hot to set the thermostat and suffered a melt down and another person just happened to get a lemon heater.

According to our plumber the older guys depend on replacing a "tank" heater about every 5 to 7 years and that means future business for them down the road.

I don't understand what the temp of the water in the pipe has to do with it. It has to get hot one way or another from the pipe to the shower head. Does it really mater if it warms up traveling through the tubing in the tankless or if it sits in a 50 gallon tank and warms up slowly?

The tankless is a lot more expensive to have installed and the initial cost is about 3 times more expensive than a standard heater but, if it lasts 5 times longer and you have the advantage of endless hot water during that time.... You do your own math.

I'm not sure about the "rebooting" thing, I've never had to do it and I'm not sure where the computer controls are on our heater anyway.

Your guy sounds like one of the old guys.

Posted
1 hour ago, Rapid Roger said:

I really can't figure that out because I live in Kansas and the current temp (@ 2: 23 PM ) is 28* f and there is no water except in the pipes and tubing to freeze. After six years and temps anywhere from 109 f down to -12 f we have never had a problem with freezing.

The reason for mounting on an exterior wall if for the exhaust heat and gasses. We were told to just not let snow, leaves or ice build up over the exhaust port.

Buy the way our water heater is in the basement and exposed to semi heated air from the furnace but there is no real heat registers or direct heating down there. It is somewhat cooler than the living quarters in the basement and all the water pipes are down there and haven't frozen in over 40 years!

Never under value the benefit of that basement. Practice gas changed around here in the last two years.  Code required 48" footing, but we just had our second year in a row with frost deeper. This has led better builders to re-evaluate and change practice with regard to water line depth. I had to move some lines over a slab and redesign the insulation plan because pipes in my house froze for the first time since the house was built in the 50s. This could be a similar struggle and not a tankless caused situation at all. 

Posted

This Old House and Mike Holmes uses them - to me that is all the selling I need. 

I  know the company here in my home town that makes them are creating apps to control the heaters from your phone. They also are intelligent in that they know when you take a shower everyday and are prepped and ready. Smarter tech is great stuff.

Posted
59 minutes ago, woodbutcher74 said:

Cliff, you should take into consideration that TOH and most of the DIY shows have advertising considerations from vendors and contractors. Not saying tankless WHs aren't any good. 

Oh agreed completely but those two groups of guys are very reputable. I don't believe they'd use bad products. And at least in the case of This Old House - their remodels have stood the test of time. 

I mean, if I saw something on say.. Property Brothers - I'd put zero faith in it. 

Posted

Well, as a onetime builder I will say Holmes makes me cringe, Property Bros are flippers and do not depend on long term service or perform it, and the least safe and craziest things I have seen of the three were on TOH. Having said this, I'd let them work on my house, but I would do my homework and not blindly trust. 

Posted
7 minutes ago, C Shaffer said:

Well, as a onetime builder I will say Holmes makes me cringe, Property Bros are flippers and do not depend on long term service or perform it, and the least safe and craziest things I have seen of the three were on TOH. Having said this, I'd let them work on my house, but I would do my homework and not blindly trust. 

What makes you cringe on Holmes? 

I do see Tommy Silva use the circular saw very unsafely. But if he wants to cut his body parts off to build my house, I'll let him.

Posted
22 minutes ago, Cliff said:

What makes you cringe on Holmes? 

I do see Tommy Silva use the circular saw very unsafely. But if he wants to cut his body parts off to build my house, I'll let him.

Holmes jumped on a few band wagons early. He has a history of homes with catastrophic failure of improperly mixed spray foams tied to his endorsement. He also got caught up in the hurry up game and had some foam houses with toxic off gassing due to improper spraying of "lifts." This may have not been him as I know there are two presentations of TMac. In a nutshell, I have had a few conversations with people who thought they had a better grasp of things than their builder because of endorsements made by Holmes. I don't think he is a bad guy. I think he got connected with some things through the sponsorship game. 

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 45 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32k
    Total Topics
    437.5k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Lenny2
    Newest Member
    Lenny2
    Joined