Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Cherry Piano Bench (AKA Domino Crash Course)

Featured Replies

  • Popular Post

I always figured a finger tip would be my first casualty due to this hobby, but I just gave an arm and a leg to the guys at my local Woodcraft store.

Domino.jpg

I can quit anytime I want, right @shaneymack?

My son loves his piano and the bench is falling apart. I can attempt yet another re-glue or I can use this as a chance for a crash course in how to use the Domino. I have one more small household project to get finished before Christmas and then I have a couple of gaming tables on-deck after the holidays. I'd like to use the Domino for these but I need to get familiar with it, and this seems like a good excuse.

Inspired by @TIODS "desk in a day" build, I'm hoping to knock this thing out this weekend (sans finishing time). It's a simple bench, using some cherry I have leftover and whatever I can find to fit the bottom of the storage area. Really not much to journal about except learning to use the Domino.

Bench v1 small.jpg

Same dimensions and style as the current bench, but hopefully a bit more sturdy.

-E

PS - If I fail miserably, watch this thread for a Domino fire sale :)

Looks awesome!  You might consider some lower rails on 3 sides like I did on the desk for extra lateral support.

Love the tapered legs!  

Congrats on the new toy!

  • Author
  • Popular Post

A bit late on posting the pics and update, but it went mostly well. The Domino learning curve is not very steep and it works well, but there are some things on the 700/XL that I didn't realize the 500 was missing.

I didn't get it wrapped up in one weekend as planned, but I had to spend a few hours on a big ladder hanging Christmas lights on Saturday and then Sunday we went out to get the Christmas tree.

Christmas Lights II.jpg

The top of the eaves are 35' up, and that extension ladder is a bear to move. Additional lights and yard decorations weren't up when this pic was taken.

The Domino really does make short work of assembly. On Saturday I was able to mill the stock down, cut the parts, apply a roundover to the edges, sand everything to 150, cut the mortises, and glue up the short sides of the bench; all in less than 3 hours of work (not including time spent RTFM and testing the Domino). I had very little time on Sunday but I was able to cut the bottom deck of the storage area, glue up the bench frame, and also glue up the panel that will be the top of the bench.

I setup a video camera for the stock preparation, but I don't have time to edit right now. I did snap a couple of pics for the highlight reel. The day didn't start well when I fired up the bandsaw and the white tire on the top wheel shredded itself before I could make a cut.

Bandsaw Tire Blowout.jpg

It's not my shop and not my saw, so I called the owner and used the table saw to rip the 8/4 cherry for the legs. After the last rip, I noticed some metal on the INSIDE of the wood. Probably a nail or something similar. But this was not on the outside edge. This was in the tree and the tree grew around it. Absorbing it like a female anglerfish on a date.  I opted to keep the 8/4 extra long before milling and that decision saved me later on. Had I cut off the bulk of the waste earlier, the nail would have been sent through the planer and become part of the bench.

I used some small plywood scraps to built a sled/jig to cut the taper on the legs with the table saw since the bandsaw was out of commission. This is in the video, but no pics. It's nothing fancy, something most of you have done a dozen times before.

When it came time to use the Domino, I used some cutoffs to make sure I had everything dialed in. I want the apron sides to have a reveal, rather than to be flush with the legs. On my test cuts, once I had the settings dialed in, I wrote them down on the sample board to ensure I don't screw them up later. Oh hey, look, it's a nail.

Domino Test - Notes and Nail.jpg

I realized that I needed to keep track of board orientation at all times. The Domino has built in guides that reference off one edge, but as you cut the mortise on the opposing stock, you have to flip everything 180 degrees to reference the same edge on the opposite side of the Domino. I marked the Top edge of each piece to ensure that I was always referencing the correct edge. I also figured I should mark the Outside edge of the legs so I didn't put a mortise on the wrong face. The legs are tapered so there are 2 inside faces and 2 outside faces. I made it more idiot proof by writing the word Outside so that it would be visible through the sight-glass of the Domino and even drawing a little mortise to make sure I didn't screw up.

Domino Test - Notes.jpg

Domino Test - Window Notes.jpg

My new rule: If you don't see the word Outside through the window, don't cut the mortise. I learned a long time ago to make things as idiot proof as possible. I'm an idiot and odds are I will continue to be an idiot. Best to make adjustments for it early in the planning stages.

The first gotcha I encountered with the Domino is that you can't put more than 1 mortise in a board less than ~4.5" wide, that is, assuming you follow the guidelines in the manual for spacing. I wasn't aware of this limitation so the apron on the bench won't have 2 dominos in each end. To account for the loss of the 2nd tenon, I decided to use a 3/4" cabinet ply for the bottom of the storage area. This will be anchored to all 4 apron sides and should hold everything together just fine.

Domino Test - Stock Width.jpg

In the future, I need to avoid boards smaller than 4.5" wide.

My biggest complaint is that the Domino XL 700 has 6 reference pins on the face of the tool. You can uses these pins to reference the edge of a board and also to help with spacing between mortises. The Domino 500 does not have these, it only has 2 tabs used to reference the edge of a board. The combo kit includes some accessories that you can use to reference off of the previous mortise, but that accessory hangs off the side of the tool.

Domino Test - Min Stock Width.jpg

If you want to use the included accessory to chain mortises together, the minimum board width is ~7". Everything I read about the 500 vs 700 was that the main difference was that the 700 can use the thicker Dominos. Not having the reference pins on the 500 was a bit frustrating. Yes, you can use pencil marks and manually position the Domino. But the Domino is incredibly accurate when you use the stops on the tool. If I want to use pencil marks and align things by hand, I have a biscuit joiner or a doweling jig for that. Not being able to use those stops on the 500 is, in my opinion, a little ridiculous considering the hefty price tag. Unfortunately, I budgeted for the 500 combo kit and the 2nd systainer with tenon stock and cutters. Adding $500 more wasn't possible.

Dry Fit - Panel Edge II.jpg

The Domino is incredibly accurate when you reference off the edge using the stops on the tool. The pic above is a dry fit of the top panel for the bench. You can see the hairline on the end but you can't feel it at all with your hand. I was very impressed. Also, I need a jointer.

Another benefit of the Domino is that you can dry fit everything and it will (mostly) hold itself together. Here is the new bench (before roundover and sanding) next to the current one.

Dry Fit - Old and New.jpg

Final glue up of everything:

Glue Up - Frame.jpg

Glue Up - Panel.jpg

The only thing left for this weekend is to cut the top panel down to final dimensions, route the ogee around the edge, and then apply ARS.

-E

 

Coming from a 500 owner that uses the tool 99% of the time by lining up the sights, do you need to calibrate the cross stops at all? I think you need to calibrate the pins on either side of the 500, but im wondering if the cross stops can ever differ from left to right? Plan on using them more often in the future, which is why i ask. 

4 hours ago, Elroy Skimms said:

with the Domino is that you can't put more than 1 mortise in a board less than ~4.5" wide

This is the dumbest thing I've ever heard. Is it possible you have misunderstood what you read? I have a feeling that they mean using the end stops you cannot get two dominos in 4.5" without them over lapping. The only rule of thumb is that you need to leave atleast double the thickness of the domino being used between each domino. So in the case of  6mm dominos you'd basically leave a 1/2"(12 mm) between the two.   I would never have a situation like that with a 4.5" apron and only have one domino. Please double check that in the instructions and report back. The df700 instructions say nothing like that and neither does the supplemental manual for either machine.

 

4 hours ago, Elroy Skimms said:

My biggest complaint is that the Domino XL 700 has 6 reference pins on the face of the tool. You can uses these pins to reference the edge of a board and also to help with spacing between mortises. The Domino 500 does not have these

Totally agree. The domino would not be as awesome without the pins on the 700. This is another reason as to why it is better to get the DF700 with the seneca adapters and not buy a df500. The DF700 also has two depth stops for when you are switching back and forth between depths which the df5oo does not have. 

 

The project is looking great! I wish you would have posted your question before you only put one domino in those aprons as I would have convinced you to add another domino :)

 

  • Author
33 minutes ago, shaneymack said:

This is the dumbest thing I've ever heard. Is it possible you have misunderstood what you read? I have a feeling that they mean using the end stops you cannot get two dominos in 4.5" without them over lapping. The only rule of thumb is that you need to leave atleast double the thickness of the domino being used between each domino. So in the case of  6mm dominos you'd basically leave a 1/2"(12 mm) between the two.   I would never have a situation like that with a 4.5" apron and only have one domino. Please double check that in the instructions and report back. The df700 instructions say nothing like that and neither does the supplemental manual for either machine.

Totally agree. The domino would not be as awesome without the pins on the 700. This is another reason as to why it is better to get the DF700 with the seneca adapters and not buy a df500. The DF700 also has two depth stops for when you are switching back and forth between depths which the df5oo does not have. 

The project is looking great! I wish you would have posted your question before you only put one domino in those aprons as I would have convinced you to add another domino :)

I don't have the instructions in front of me, but I think you have the gist of it. If I want to use the end stop on each edge, the board width works out to be ~4.5", depending on the cutter diameter. From the edge, you have ~1.25" before you hit the first mortise, then you have the mortise which is <1", then you have a 2x diameter gap (depending on material) call that 5/8", the last mortise is <1" wide, and then the final ~1.25" space from mortise to edge. Using only the stops on the face of the tool, and keeping within the spacing guidelines, that's where it leaves you. Yes, you can mark 2 lines and space them yourself, but you lose the accuracy and repeatability of the end stops.

I have some brass setup gauges that I could use in the future to help close the gap between the edge of the board and the stop on the tool. But they aren't green and I didn't know if the Domino would short-circuit if it came into contact with something not the proper shade of green :)

I considered posting the question after doing my first test. But in reality, I didn't need to wait a couple of hours to know what the answer would be. If I had to have perfect edge stops, I would need a wider board. Or I could manually place the mortises and deal with the inaccuracy. Or I could beef up the bottom of the storage area so the apron will be attached firmly to the bottom deck. I figured if I wanted to learn to use the Domino, I should first learn to play within the guidelines. So I opted to beef up the bottom deck and make note for future designs.

 

2 hours ago, Pwk5017 said:

Coming from a 500 owner that uses the tool 99% of the time by lining up the sights, do you need to calibrate the cross stops at all? I think you need to calibrate the pins on either side of the 500, but im wondering if the cross stops can ever differ from left to right? Plan on using them more often in the future, which is why i ask. 

I didn't do any kind of calibration on the cross stops. My understanding is that they are geared more toward panel glue ups, where you need spacing of 6"+. They are notched to give a positive stop every 1mm of adjustment and I didn't have any issues with them on my panel.

-E

4 minutes ago, Elroy Skimms said:

Yes, you can mark 2 lines and space them yourself, but you lose the accuracy and repeatability of the end stops.

True but you could just use two lines and then use the tight setting on the apron end and the middle setting on the leg side. That way you could adjust the apron flush to leg top on glue up. The strength comes from the cheek to cheek glue bond so there is no loss in strength. 

Btw , you are still within the Festool 30 day return policy. If you really like to work with the end stops you'd be much better off with the 700. Send that puppy back. The upgrade to the 700 could be your Christmas gift ;)

How is it that difficult to understand how to use the thing?

If you're using layout marks, you don't need the end stops. The thing has a cursor in the window, line it up and plunge... It could not be any simpler.

As for not paying attention to which face is your reference, this goes with all types of joinery. 

2 minutes ago, Llama said:

How is it that difficult to understand how to use the thing?

He is not saying its difficult, he is saying he likes the accuracy when using the end stops. 

  • Author
Just now, shaneymack said:

True but you could just use two lines and then use the tight setting on the apron end and the middle setting on the leg side. That way you could adjust the apron flush to leg top on glue up. The strength comes from the cheek to cheek glue bond so there is no loss in strength. 

Btw , you are still within the Festool 30 day return policy. If you really like to work with the end stops you'd be much better off with the 700. Send that puppy back. The upgrade to the 700 could be your Christmas gift ;)

Except the df500 was my Christmas gift. And anniversary. And birthday. Believe me, if I could come up with the $500 for the upgrade, I would do it in a flash. I literally stood there at the counter at Woodcraft for several minutes doing all sorts of math in my head about what my options were to fund the upgrade. Sell a kidney? Sell bodily fluids? Sell some of the kids? It's amazing what goes through your mind when you want to buy a Festool!

-E

Just now, shaneymack said:

He is not saying its difficult, he is saying he like the accuracy when using the end stops. 

And I'm saying both ways are just as accurate. Many people take the stops out and simply use layout marks.

Difficult meaning, there is a heck of a lot of conversation on such a simple operation.

  • Author
3 minutes ago, Llama said:

As for not paying attention to which face is your reference, this goes with all types of joinery. 

Absolutely true. This is not a complaint about the Domino at all. The Domino makes the joinery so quick and easy that it lends itself to people like me making stupid mistakes. It's like a doctor removing the wrong limb. You'd have to be really dumb to screw it up. I'm really dumb. So I make allowances in my process for that :)

-E

And I'm saying both ways are just as accurate. Many people take the stops out and simply use layout marks.

Difficult meaning, there is a heck of a lot of conversation on such a simple operation.

If you want to just use the tight setting then you need to use the end stops. Its very hard to get everything perfectly aligned with just pencil marks. Thats where the loose setting comes in. Thats what I recommended he use.

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

Just now, shaneymack said:

Thats what I recommended he use.

There are many ways to skin a cat. 

There are many ways to skin a cat. 

For sure but not so many ways to use the domino in this instance.

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

You can certainly use the domino on the tight setting with layout marks. Which would be fine for this. Adding gauge blocks to use the stops will lead to errors. Which is why the layout marks are the best. 

6 minutes ago, Mike. said:

I use the domino on tight setting and layout lines all the time.  In fact I have never used the stops.   I don't even know how to put them on.   

Same here.  never taken them out of the sys.

Same here.  never taken them out of the sys.

They are attached to the domino.

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

You can certainly use the domino on the tight setting with layout marks. Which would be fine for this. Adding gauge blocks to use the stops will lead to errors. Which is why the layout marks are the best. 

You would change your mind about layout lines if you ever get a 700. I almost never use a pencil line. Your better than me if you can line up multiple dominos on the tight setting with pencil lines.

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

I use the domino on tight setting and layout lines all the time.  In fact I have never used the stops.   I don't even know how to put them on.   

We are referring to the end stop attached to the domino

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

I use the accessory ones all the time, I've never had a problem. From my first plunge to the last. Maybe I am just really lucky and happen to do things the right way the first time. I would go insane if I had to dissect every single motion I had to take to make something. 

Project is looking good. Sorry for the speed bumps, but I'm glad you are getting the hang of the tool.  I too wish the 500 had he same stops as the 700, but also wasn't willing to sell a kidney or child. Gotta adapt. Keep the pictures coming, good work.

4 hours ago, Mike. said:

I use the domino on tight setting and layout lines all the time.  In fact I have never used the stops.   I don't even know how to put them on.   

I think they're talking about the two flappers on the body of the D.  I use layout lines and the tight setting 99% of the time.  That is, there is almost always two dominos per joint...one will be done with the tight and one with the loose.

  • Author

Saturday turned into a comedy of errors.

Bench Lid - Post Sand.jpg

Put the bench lid through the drum sander and then realized I never finished my crosscut sled from a couple of months back. Just about everything that could possibly go wrong went wrong and it took me several hours to get the sled finished. Mostly rookie mistakes or issues with changing the sled design on the fly and not thinking through all of the consequences. But it's done.

Cross Cut Sled.jpg

And with that, I cut the bench lid to size.

Cross Cut Sled - Bench Top.jpg

Several hours in the shop and all I really did was make 2 cuts on the bench lid. Feels like a wasted day, but I know the sled will be useful in the future.

Need to route the bench lid, finish sand everything, and find a warm place to apply the ARS. Lows in the mid 20's at night, so that's not going to work.

-E

  • 3 weeks later...
  • Author
On ‎12‎/‎8‎/‎2016 at 5:03 PM, shaneymack said:

Btw , you are still within the Festool 30 day return policy. If you really like to work with the end stops you'd be much better off with the 700. Send that puppy back. The upgrade to the 700 could be your Christmas gift ;)

So my Christmas bonus rolled in, and I am still within my 30 day return period. Do I upgrade to the XL 700 or add a TS 55? I'm leaning toward the TS 55 as I find manhandling sheet goods by myself gets tedious. I think the TS 55 will be more of a "quality of life" improvement over the XL 700. If I can use the sights on 500 for smaller parts without worry, seems like the TS 55 would be a better choice. But having used neither, it's nothing but idle speculation on my part. Thoughts?

Also, warmer weather rolled in and I was finally able to put some ARS on the bench and lid. Two coats down. Just need a quick 600 grit wipe and possibly a thinned 3rd coat to wrap it up. Routing the edge of the lid exposed a defect in one of the long edges. Not the end of the world. This project was more about the domino and learning how to use it. I make too many mistakes to worry about finding the perfect piece of material for every part (for now).

The color in the pic looks a little wonky, the bright spot in the center of the lid is reflected light. In better light, it's fairly evenly toned, similar to the left corner of the lid in the pic.

Bench Lid - ARS First Coat.jpg

Bench Frame - ARS First Coat.jpg

-E

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.