Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Is my design structurally sound?

Featured Replies

This is a question I often ask myself, "Is my design structurally sound?" What typically follows is a piece of shop/home furniture which is heavy, chunky, and overbuilt. As I gain more experience I will learn from my failures, but I was wondering how do you all go about designing something which is structurally sound with the minimal amount of lumber, joints, and if needed. . . fasteners?

My next shop project is a cantilevered freestanding frame enclosure for the motor, blower, cyclone, and bin for my Clearvue CV1800. I know the cantilevered design is unnecessary, but it will make the structure feel much smaller in my small shop, and that is important to me. I have attached a highly technical drawing from my iPhone Notes app. :D Main construction features are:

  • Approximate Dimensions: Height: 96" / Width: 26" / Depth: 26" (The base portion may require additional length to remain stable)
  • Frame: The frame will be built using 2x4 framing lumber. I will potentially need to glue up multiple 2x4s for the main supports of the enclosure around the blower/motor.
  • Enclosure: The enclosure will surround the blower housing and only a portion of the motor and cyclone body. The motor will stick out the top of the enclosure to provide cooling, and the cyclone body to watch the dust swirl (design choice). The enclosure panels will be set into rabbets and secured utilizing wing nuts screwed into threaded inserts epoxied into the rabbet.. This will allow me to remove all the panels for maintenance. The panels will be constructed as follows: 3/4" MDF / Green Glue / 3/4" MDF / 2" Roxul Acoustical Fire Batt (AFB) insulation.
  • Additional Considerations: The freestanding frame will need to support about 80lbs (motor, blower, cyclone). The filters will be attached remotely by a 8" insulated duct. The filter enclosure is almost completed.

Thoughts? Thanks for all of the help!

Picture1.jpg

2x4's will be plenty strong enough without gluing up multiples.  I'd raise that diagonal brace location up enough to cross the lower horizontal part of the upper panel, so that it effectively widens the weak spot-not necessary for strength, but it would look more substantial to me. 

Also, you don't need to epoxy threaded inserts.  If the panels are removable, it's no need to make them so heavy, especially since removable panels shouldn't be counted into structural strength.

I don't think you'll gain a lot by building such an acoustically elaborate enclosure around the blower. Most of the noise comes from the outlet (filters) & some from the motor fan, but the blower housing itself doesn't emit that much noise. At least that seems to be the case with my V-5000.

All those efforts would be better used to build a good baffled, free-flowing enclosure around the filters.

I rely on sagulator a bit for deflection etc. if the question exists. Typically convention follows. Knowing how beefy a piece needs to be leads to a schedule of joints or fasteners that are common across several platforms. 

19 hours ago, Derek_PNW said:

This is a question I often ask myself, "Is my design structurally sound?" What typically follows is a piece of shop/home furniture which is heavy, chunky, and overbuilt. As I gain more experience I will learn from my failures, but I was wondering how do you all go about designing something which is structurally sound with the minimal amount of lumber, joints, and if needed. . . fasteners?

I can't offer much advise on your project, but the questions you raise are good. 

If it had been up to me we never would have had the Federal Style which I admire so much.  It just would not have occured to me that such long spindly legs could support the piece and stand up to use.

When I built the tree house (avitar) I designed everything meticulously on graph paper, drawing say a 2 x 6 to scale.  Then I would go to the lumber yard, look at the 2 x 6's, scratch my head and come home with 2 x 8's.  In the end it was heavily over built.

56 minutes ago, Mark J said:

If it had been up to me we never would have had the Federal Style which I admire so much.  It just would not have occured to me that such long spindly legs could support the piece and stand up to use.

I know what you mean.  It still blows my mind that the cabriole legs on a highboy don't snap at the ankle supporting that massive high chest.  Even if you nerd out and draw out the force diagrams it seems like basically any lateral force should make the legs fail.  There's magic in there somewhere.

  • Author

Thank you everyone. It is honestly just tough and with limited weekend shop time, there are some things I would like to not engineer through multiple failures. :)

@Tom King thank you for the help! I appreciate the confidence in your answer. I originally was thinking about using 4x4 lumber again.

I was making the panels so heavy since I was trying to aid in sound dampening. Green Glue comes in a 6 or 12 packs and I opted for the 12. . . so I am feeling ambitious to make it as quiet as I can now with the leftover Green Glue from my filter enclosure. I blame this on @drzaius :D He sparked an interest in me to make this thing as quiet as I can. All I can say is the filter enclosure weighs a ton. . . 3/4" MDF / Green Glue / 3/4" MDF / 2" Roxul AFB. . . it is a tank. This is why I am trying to minimize the amount of the cyclone I am covering.

@C Shaffer I will see if I can make the Sagulator work for my application. Thanks.

Derek, this may be old info, but back in my teen years, building speaker cabinets was a big thing. The recommendation at the time was to build with particle board for the best sound dampening then veneer with solid wood. I don't know how much difference there might be between PB and MDF.

How new is your cyclone? The newer cyclones, like the Oneida I own, don't generate a lot of noise. I believe mine is around 70 - 75 decibels. Since that is below the threshold where hearing protection is required, I didn't worry about enclosing it for sound. Even with an older Oneida cyclone, which probably generated noise in the 90 decibel range, the enclosure I made from plywood on 3 sides didn't lower the notes output enough to make a real difference.

As for strength, I'm sure you know that most of the weight is on top where the motor is. If your cyclone is made of steel, then that adds significantly more weight. I'd move the angled piece from below and angle it so that it helps support the top section. While I suspect that 2 X 4's and sheets used to enclose it would be sufficient the way you designed it, I would use that angled piece to support the top or just run it straight up from the bottom on the front side and not really worry about the sides for sound deadening.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.