Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Identifying rough wood species

Featured Replies

I suck at it.  I'm rough milling hard maple for two kitchen helper/learning towers.  I've now milled two or three full boards only to notice open pores when they come off the planer.  Ash I guess?  Now I need to find use for a bunch of 4-6" wide 20" long shorts. 

Anyone else have the same problem?

  • Author
1 minute ago, Ronn W said:

Would a cabinet scraper help in ths situation?

Most likely.  I probably could have even taken a block plane to it to clean it up a bit...I just didn't think about it til it was too late.  

The bark is also a good indication of the specie. No planing required !

Maple (regular maple here) :
maple_bark_ii_by_pc_stock-d63e4ip.jpg

Ash :

fram1290063.jpg

Sorry, I'm a slug, but those look eactly the same to me.

  • Author

Lol, if I've learned anything about identifying species of standing trees, it's that I no longer feel dumb for not being able to identify species of standing trees.

1 hour ago, Mark J said:

Sorry, I'm a slug, but those look exactly the same to me.

Hmm. The scale of the texture is different and there are other noticeable differences. On picture it's probably less obvious than in front of the real stuff. Bark is as unique as a fingertip. Sometimes the figure in the wood may be confusing between two species, but bark never lies. The maple have red brown areas on top. Under the chips you reveal dark gray areas. Horizontal cracks are irregular. The ash is mostly medium gray overall. Horizontal cracks are larger and are pretty regular.

Sometimes close species are hard to differentiate, like Pine and Douglas. Hopefully, the bark allows to know who is who.

Pine :
Study-suggests-pine-bark-extract-contrib

Douglas :
DouglasBark.jpg

Wood is not just about grain or working with planks. If you're interested by wood, it's good to recognize wood by its leaf or its bark too.
Wood is a natural material. The tree can teach a lot about how to use it, how to work it, how the finish it.

That's why I buy slabs, and why I use sometimes several slabs when I could cut all my parts out of a single one.
Some areas are not good for a leg or a top, or simply not good for the shape of my finished part.
Sometimes I save a part of a slab for specific uses, because I know that chunk is made for it.
When I was a young woodworker, I did not understood that, and some pieces did not grow old as expected, from shape to look.
You want to work with the nature of the wood, not against it. This way you avoid a lot of issues.
Learning this take time but don't worry, if you love wood, you will learn it anyways.

48 minutes ago, Jean [Fr] said:

Hmm. The scale of the texture is different and there are other noticeable differences. On picture it's probably less obvious than in front of the real stuff. Bark is as unique as a fingertip. Sometimes the figure in the wood may be confusing between two species, but bark never lies. The maple have red brown areas on top. 

This is very overconfident and does not allow for any environmental factors that trees face. Confident guesses are possible, but none of my forestry service family will swear by a bark ID with no leaf or other evidence. (A few obvious caveats do exist) 

39 minutes ago, Jean [Fr] said:

.... Bark is as unique as a fingertip.... 

Wood is not just about grain or working with planks. If you're interested by wood, it's good to recognize wood by its leaf or its bark too.


Wood is a natural material. The tree can teach a lot about how to use it, how to work it, how the finish it.

 

That may explain why I never got that job with the FBI ☺.

It is worth learning, no doubt, from leaves to bark to grain.  But it is certainly an endeavor that will take some time and effort.

At this point I can tell deciduous from evergreen.  --- At least in the winter months. ☺

I'm really good at identifying the trees here in the midwest, but take me to another region and I'm lost.  Fortunately we grow walnut, cherry, maple and white oak...and I can't think of another one worth knowing anyway. :) ...until I find that Cuban mahogany plantation I KNOW is somewhere near my house.

6 hours ago, C Shaffer said:

This is very overconfident and does not allow for any environmental factors that trees face. Confident guesses are possible, but none of my forestry service family will swear by a bark ID with no leaf or other evidence. (A few obvious caveats do exist) 

Overconfident is a very strong word in French. I'll take it kindly anyways. Your answer troubled me. I first thought overseas tree's barks may all look the same, but as I can see on US websites, this is just like here. Eric. is right, we only know the species of our region. I'm not as confident with imported wood. Your maple is pretty different from ours (we call yours sycamore) and we don't have red oak, for example. But we are pretty lucky in France to have forests sheltering diversified species, and different forests like Mediterranean or Alps are not far at all. Here, in western France I can find maybe 20 species you can use for cabinet making.

Believe me or not, but I learned how to distinguish a specie from its leaf, bark or overall shape before to be able to read wood grain. I learned my childs too, and they were able to recognize any specie before to reach the age of 8. It's probably simpler than you think. Some species also have their own sound or smell. The poplar is the first tree to catch the wind and the sound of its foliage is very characteristic. I can understand this is not as obvious for someone who did not learn with an ancestor.

56 minutes ago, Jean [Fr] said:

Overconfident is a very strong word in French. I'll take it kindly anyways. Your answer troubled me. I first thought overseas tree's barks may all look the same, but as I can see on US websites, this is just like here. Eric. is right, we only know the species of our region. I'm not as confident with imported wood. Your maple is pretty different from ours (we call yours sycamore) and we don't have red oak, for example. But we are pretty lucky in France to have forests sheltering diversified species, and different forests like Mediterranean or Alps are not far at all. Here, in western France I can find maybe 20 species you can use for cabinet making.

Believe me or not, but I learned how to distinguish a specie from its leaf, bark or overall shape before to be able to read wood grain. I learned my childs too, and they were able to recognize any specie before to reach the age of 8. It's probably simpler than you think. Some species also have their own sound or smell. The poplar is the first tree to catch the wind and the sound of its foliage is very characteristic. I can understand this is not as obvious for someone who did not learn with an ancestor.

This is not designed to be argumentative, but bark is a single factor that is weak in many ways. Drought affects it, minerals or deficiencies also affect it. Knowing where the tree stood matters when taking bark into account. This is hard with a felled log. That said, this is all off topic for the guy milling purchased lumber with no bark. 

I have a lot of trouble with trees. I think I can identify oak, but not if it's white/red/black. I can get maple because of the leaves, but not sugar/soft/hard/silver. I think I got walnut down pretty well. Cherry, I only know it based on Cremona's vids where he explained what it should look like. Pine - I know the DAMN needles that drop all over my back yard. 

When it comes to rough, I think walnut is by far the easiest wood for me to identify. Because I see it all the time. The rest I have to take a plane to, and even then I've got a long way to go. It's fun learning though. 

5 hours ago, Jean [Fr] said:

Overconfident is a very strong word in French. I'll take it kindly anyways. Your answer troubled me. I first thought overseas tree's barks may all look the same, but as I can see on US websites, this is just like here. Eric. is right, we only know the species of our region. I'm not as confident with imported wood. Your maple is pretty different from ours (we call yours sycamore) and we don't have red oak, for example. But we are pretty lucky in France to have forests sheltering diversified species, and different forests like Mediterranean or Alps are not far at all. Here, in western France I can find maybe 20 species you can use for cabinet making.

Believe me or not, but I learned how to distinguish a specie from its leaf, bark or overall shape before to be able to read wood grain. I learned my childs too, and they were able to recognize any specie before to reach the age of 8. It's probably simpler than you think. Some species also have their own sound or smell. The poplar is the first tree to catch the wind and the sound of its foliage is very characteristic. I can understand this is not as obvious for someone who did not learn with an ancestor.

Or grow up in a forest.   It was the same for me, growing up surrounded by woods.  I knew trees by their bark, and leaves way before I ever paid any attention to the wood that they produced.  I know every tree that grows anywhere around where I grew up, from the time saplings spring out of the ground, but would be completely ignorant anywhere else.   I had no idea about the first two pictures you posted here.

Working at the lumberyard has been a huge advantage for my ID skills.  I've worked with almost every species we carry by now, but there's nothing like handling and inspecting thousands and thousands of boards to hone your eye.  I also worked for a tree service for a few years when I was a youngster so that taught me a lot of tree ID...not that that has any benefit to my woodworking per se, since I don't harvest my own lumber...but it's still something I enjoy knowing...makes me feel even more familiar with the wood somehow.  I like trees, and I like the material they yield.  Package deal.  I enjoy planting and caring for them almost as much as I enjoy mangling them. :D

8 hours ago, C Shaffer said:

This is not designed to be argumentative, but bark is a single factor that is weak in many ways. Drought affects it, minerals or deficiencies also affect it. Knowing where the tree stood matters when taking bark into account. This is hard with a felled log.

You don't subscribe to my point of view because you feel not confident to identify wood by its bark. It's ok. Please understand some people knows how to do it. To me, whatever the external factor, nothing can turn a specie into another.

4 hours ago, Jean [Fr] said:

You don't subscribe to my point of view because you feel not confident to identify wood by its bark. It's ok. Please understand some people knows how to do it. To me, whatever the external factor, nothing can turn a specie into another.

Read back Tom's post, then Cliff's. I know the trees here. The ash no longer grow in traditional fashion. The emerald ash borer has infected and affected the trees so that  many are cut with no bark, or bark that is not from healthy growth. I can often get you to a type of tree, but I am there at shape, texture of branch growth, topographic placement and other factors. I am not saying that bark is useless. I just think I could fool you with Catalpa bark, or Norway maple bark based on what you have posted here. Carry on. We all like trees. 

So this geology student on a field trip finds an intereting specimen, shows it to the professor and asks, "Professore, what is this?"  He replied, " It's a rock."

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.