Recommended Posts

Posted

I've made this thread to discuss my purchase of a Jointer - I'm more than likely going with the PC bench top...

Here's my situation...

I currently use my TS for edging and sander(s) to try and make my junk boards "flatter". I haven't tried using my TS for all sides yet, but just made another jig to try that.

At my level of proficiency (which is still very basic), getting everything perfect is not a priority. I've yet to make anything "perfect" - every thing I make has mistakes of some kind or another

My wallet is not fat enough to buy top end machines - hence my recent purchase of the skil 9" band saw.

It was cheap, lets me work with a machine I've never used before deciding if I need/want a better more expensive band saw - which I may in the future.

For right now, being able to get the edges smooth with my TS works good enough for me, but getting the flat of the boards smooth is a real PITA with a sander!

Having the 6" PC jointer solves 3 problems for me:

  1. I get to work with another machine I have no idea how to work that is within my budget
  2. I can get my boards "smooth" with a lot less effort.
  3. It's a bench top so I can put it away or make another rolling cart for it

I have no room for a large jointer. If I need longer feeds, I can make another miter cart with wings for the jointer

I understand there is no parallel using the jointer, but you have to remember I don't work with good wood like the rest of you!

I don't use hand tools, since I really don't know how - except a hammer and a hack saw LOL

I've gotten very good at destruction!

Heck, I just learned how to rabbet, still can't figure out how to get dadoes done correctly on more than 1 board for shelf units and cabinets and just learned how to join more than 1 board to make wider boards!

Perfection/even thickness/parallel is about the last thing on my mind right now LOL

I work a lot with ply, sometimes Pine and now more with pallet wood. Ply and pine I don't need to joint, only the Pallet.

If I ever get good enough to use good wood, then I might look into getting a planer as well since hopefully by then I'll have enough funds to do so and I'll know why I need one LOL.

Thoughts?

Thanks as always in advance...

Posted
25 minutes ago, Wimayo said:

I've posted this before and not everyone agrees. My recommendation for someone with limited space and funds is to buy a planer before a jointer. Then, build a planer sled for it. These are used to flatten one side of a board with the planer. You can find plans on the net for sleds from simple to more sophisticated. The advantages are that you can do the work of two machines with one, plane all your project pieces to a consistent thickness, and you can flatten wider boards at lower equipment cost. You can continue to straighten and square up edges with your table saw and get a jointer later if you need/want one.

Can't I do the same thing with  jointer? I've read a few articles stating I can edge and flatten boards with a jointer.

I don't know much about planers yet, but aren't they mostly for raw boards? 

I don't buy that type of wood.which is why I ask

Posted
5 minutes ago, new2woodwrk said:

Can't I do the same thing with  jointer? I've read a few articles stating I can edge and flatten boards with a jointer.

I don't know much about planers yet, but aren't they mostly for raw boards? 

I don't buy that type of wood.which is why I ask

You can edge and flatten, but you can't get parallel flats.  You can get parallel edges on the TS.

  • Like 1
Posted

I work without a jointer, but you'd have to pry my planer away from me... Think of it this way. Getting one side of a board roughly flat with a hand plane, without worrying about how good the surface is, is pretty easy. It gives you a bit of a work out, but it's very doable and only takes a few minutes (at worst). It doesn't need to be perfect, just good enough that the boards will be flat on the opposite face after going through the planer. Getting both faces parallel with a smooth surface finish by hand? That would be WAY more work (4-5x), and is what you're signing up for without a planer.

 

A lot of the opinions you see on this question are hypothetical, from people that have and use both machines. I don't really miss having a jointer, but you do need a jack or fore plane and a work bench that won't move on you. As you're doing now, edge jointing with a table saw, router, or track saw will work. It'll work better if you run a plane over the surface afterwards.

  • Like 1
Posted

The answer is both yes and no. Most planers are from 11 1/2" wide and wider and sell for maybe $250 and up. You can get 12" jointers, but they are very costly and take up lots of space. A jointer can flatten one face, but it is very difficult to use to make the opposite face flat and parallel. A planer with a sled can flatten one face and then, using the flattened face as a reference plane, flatten the opposite face and make it parallel. At the same time, you can plane the board to whatever thickness you need.

A planer works by having a flat surface at the bottom over which a board slides. There are rollers and spinning knives above that are adjusted up and down. You feed a board into it and the knives plane the top of the board smooth. However, if the bottom of the board is not straight, the board will ride up and down on the dips and twists and the knives will plane the top surface accordingly. A sled provides and auxiliary reference plane on which you secure the crooked board. You pass them through the planer together in order to get a straight and true surface on the first side so that you can then remove the board from the sled and flip it over and use the newly planed surface as a reference plane for the second side.

No. Planers are not just for "raw" boards. First, most all projects are much improved by having joining components the same thickness. Plus, it is rare for any purchased or salvaged lumber to be perfectly straight. The planer and sled will allow you to get your wood straight, smooth, and ready for cutting and assembly.

 

Hope this helps.

  • Like 1
Posted
5 hours ago, new2woodwrk said:

and now more with pallet wood.

There is one thing that always concerns me when I see that someone is working in pallet wood.  Most people don't realize it but a lot of pallets are treated with different types of chemicals and there is no way of knowing which pallets are treated.  Depending on what they were originally used for it can be things like fungicides and pesticides and then it can be other chemicals because things are shipped from overseas on them.  So it always scares me when thinking about some not only breathing the sawdust fines that you dust collector doesn't get but also the potential chemicals that are in the dust.

You just really need to be on top of your dust game when it comes to using this type of wood for your projects.  I know it can be cheap project material but at what cost.

  • Like 1
Posted
30 minutes ago, Chet said:

There is one thing that always concerns me when I see that someone is working in pallet wood.  Most people don't realize it but a lot of pallets are treated with different types of chemicals and there is no way of knowing which pallets are treated.  Depending on what they were originally used for it can be things like fungicides and pesticides and then it can be other chemicals because things are shipped from overseas on them.  So it always scares me when thinking about some not only breathing the sawdust fines that you dust collector doesn't get but also the potential chemicals that are in the dust.

You just really need to be on top of your dust game when it comes to using this type of wood for your projects.  I know it can be cheap project material but at what cost.

Very good point.

Posted

@wimayo i can get on board with the planer only but the big benefit of the jointer is really the nice clean edges and making larger things like legs square. That being said i made a lot of what i call nice furniture with out a jointer and only a planer.

Posted
3 hours ago, Chestnut said:

@wimayo i can get on board with the planer only but the big benefit of the jointer is really the nice clean edges and making larger things like legs square. That being said i made a lot of what i call nice furniture with out a jointer and only a planer.

I certainly don't mean to suggest that a jointer is not useful. I have one, but use it mostly for edge jointing. However, if one must choose for financial or space reasons, I would choose the planer with a sled.

Posted
10 hours ago, Chet said:

There is one thing that always concerns me when I see that someone is working in pallet wood.  Most people don't realize it but a lot of pallets are treated with different types of chemicals and there is no way of knowing which pallets are treated.  Depending on what they were originally used for it can be things like fungicides and pesticides and then it can be other chemicals because things are shipped from overseas on them.  So it always scares me when thinking about some not only breathing the sawdust fines that you dust collector doesn't get but also the potential chemicals that are in the dust.

You just really need to be on top of your dust game when it comes to using this type of wood for your projects.  I know it can be cheap project material but at what cost.

Thanks @Chet

I have a chart I use to identify which pallets I work with and always use a P100 filter when cutting the wood. Pallets are labeled by how they are made - HT /MB etc.

I do understand that you never know where a pallet has been since it may be used over and over and recycled etc. however, I don't use stained pallets, and only use pallets labeled as HT.

Some pallets you can "smell" the treatment - these I use for cleats after cleaning them up

So far so good - I'm not dead yet  - I know it's not a funny subject, but it does save me a lot of money

pallet-stamp.jpg

  • Thanks 1
Posted
9 hours ago, Wimayo said:

I certainly don't mean to suggest that a jointer is not useful. I have one, but use it mostly for edge jointing. However, if one must choose for financial or space reasons, I would choose the planer with a sled.

Agreed.

@new2woodwrk Eventually there will be a time and a place to graduate to hardwood from a lumber yard. There are some days that i feel investment in good lumber is a better investment than in good machines. I have a decent stack of reclaimed lumber in my basement right now though as well and really appreciate that it hasn't cost me any money. Some of it is actually pretty nice looking.

  • Like 1
Posted
17 minutes ago, Chestnut said:

...There are some days that i feel investment in good lumber is a better investment than in good machines...

I agree this certainly affects the final piece. I have a coffee table build that I have been trying to make the wood i have work but decided it just won't do so I will use some for the base and the rest for future projects, for the top I will be buying new.

Posted
2 hours ago, Chestnut said:

 There are some days that i feel investment in good lumber is a better investment than in good machines. I have a decent stack of reclaimed lumber in my basement right now though as well and really appreciate that it hasn't cost me any money. Some of it is actually pretty nice looking.

I certainly identify with that. Conversely, I can empathize with new2woodwrk. I have saved a lot of warped, twisted, bowed, rough lumber with my planer and sled. Some years ago, I purchased perhaps a thousand BF of really cheap cherry and got what I paid for.:D In the end, I probably saved 75% of it and was able to build some nice pieces of furniture for our home. Fortunately, I'm not doing production work. Some of the planks had beautiful (to me) pitch patterns. I ended up resawing these and using the veneer for drawer fronts.

im001683.thumb.jpg.d90ba9d3dd1170500bb5f5c2166a16a3.jpg

To new2woodwrk: Keep doing what you are doing and continue to strive for improved skills, equipment, and materials. I still dream of perfection in all those areas.

One last admonition: Keep in mind that pallet lumber has got a lot of ground in dirt and grit that will quickly chip and dull planer and jointer knives. Clean it as thoroughly as you can before running it through any machine. IMO, A high pressure washer can't hurt and may help save your knives.

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 29 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined