Recommended Posts

Posted

I am currently working on a refinishing project in which I have been doing ALOT of sanding, I have a cheapo Black and Decker palm sander and it does an okay job, but at the end when I stained one of the drawers I noticed sanding marks! They looked like little tiny squgily lines all the way across the drawer front. Now honestly I do not think most people will notice, but I sure did and I am fairly new to the wood working as it pertains to furniture (which is what I want to do more of). I have heard alot about random orbit sanders and think maybe this is the way to go, however I am looking for value too, not harbor freight and not Festool, but something in the middle that is good and people would reccommend. So any advice would be great!

Thanks,

Andy

Posted

My local Menards recently had the Porter Cable ROS without the case for $39.99.

I bought it, and it's really a great value.

My previous ROS died after a long life (it was an old craftsman.) I was going to spring for the Festool, but I was in Menards and said "Damn, can't beat that."

I think the deal is that my Menards was going to start carrying the Porter Cable with the case and a couple extra things for like 80 or 90 bucks, so they were clearing out all of the Porter Cables which just came in the cardboard box. It works well, it accepts velcro style paper, and you can hook your shop vac to it if you want.

  • Like 1
Posted

I have a Bosch 5" ROS. After maybe 15 years, I finally wore out the velco pad and had to replace it a few weeks ago. It is not a variable speed model, nor have ever had a ROS with variable speed so I don't know how necessary it is. When I was researching whether to replace the pad or buy a new sander, the price is around the $60 range (pad was only $20). The variable speed version was in the $80 range. So, it is very affordable and a great sander.

Tim

Posted

Thanks for all of the advice, I will have to post my refinishing project in the refinished section too. I think I am going to chew on it for a little bit (mainly cause the $$$ is not there) and then go out and get one!

Posted

i bought the dewalt ROS from lowes as well, but looking back, i wish i would have checked the Ridgid ROS from home depot. i believe it's variable speed and of course, it comes with the Ridgid lifetime power tool warranty. can't really go wrong with that guy. let us know how you decide to proceed.

Posted

i bought the dewalt ROS from lowes as well, but looking back, i wish i would have checked the Ridgid ROS from home depot. i believe it's variable speed and of course, it comes with the Ridgid lifetime power tool warranty. can't really go wrong with that guy. let us know how you decide to proceed.

I've actually been fairly disappointed with the rigid model. I'm an occasional user (preferring hand planes on straight grains) and already the spin is not all there anymore. It still orbits fine however without the spin it's no longer a ROS, rather it's just an OS.

  • Like 1
Posted

I a few of these and the best one for the money is from a box store called Canadian tire paid $20 for it on sale and it is 6 yrs old. It has been abused and dropped and gotten wet in the rain and it still works just fine. I also have a newer makita and had to change the pad on it once already. I figure it was a lemon pad because it did not last a full day before there were troubles with it the new one has been on it for a while and no probs. The makita was around $80 I plan on getting another cheap one next time I get one.

Posted

I have the Dewalt which we have put tons of hours on it doing restoration on exterior and interior of our old house. It hooks up to my shop vac which does a great job with reducing the dust. Just recently used it to refinish oak staircase and it did a great job. Spent around $80.00 on it a year ago or so.

  • 5 years later...
Posted

I am aware i am reviving an old thread, but i am in need in professional palm and orbit sanders for my company which is about 5 peaces each. I dont want to waste my money, so guys can you please recommend some of the brands.

Festool or Mirka

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

Posted
I know they're expensive but, Shaney is correct..

Yup pretty expensive but he says they are for his business.

I would go with the Festool Ets Ec 150

https://www.festool.com/Products/Pages/Product-Detail.aspx?name=Eccentric-sander-ETS-EC-150-5-EQ-Plus&pid=571882

Or the Mirka Deros

http://www.mirka.com/en-CA/mirka-deros/

If warranty is important to you go with the Festool. I have first hand experience with their great service. I do not have experience with Mirkas service but I've only read terrible things about it.

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

Posted
36 minutes ago, shaneymack said:

 

 

Festool or Mirka

 

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

How does Festool compare to Dewalt in terms of noise and vibration? I have a Dewalt sander, it's not bad at sanding but it's a PITA to use.

Posted

To me, noise and vibration are slightly better.  It's the dust collection that really make them shine.  Your paper lasts longer and you get fewer of those swirl marks because of it.

  • Like 1
Posted
30 minutes ago, Immortan D said:

How does Festool compare to Dewalt in terms of noise and vibration? I have a Dewalt sander, it's not bad at sanding but it's a PITA to use.

I don't know how old your dewalt is but i have a new one and it's MUCH better then the old ones for noise and vibration. I've owned a 125/3 ets and the current dewalt is close in vibration to the ets then the older dewalts. The ets got returned because it didn't perform to the cost and the dewalt stayed.

I will never suggest dewalt for a pro application i don't think they'd hold up to the abuse. @MaximuSR5 I'd go Mirak Deros, it will be my next sander when i step up to a pro level finish sander.

  • Like 1
Posted
4 hours ago, Chestnut said:

I don't know how old your dewalt is but i have a new one and it's MUCH better then the old ones for noise and vibration. I've owned a 125/3 ets and the current dewalt is close in vibration to the ets then the older dewalts. The ets got returned because it didn't perform to the cost and the dewalt stayed.

I will never suggest dewalt for a pro application i don't think they'd hold up to the abuse. @MaximuSR5 I'd go Mirak Deros, it will be my next sander when i step up to a pro level finish sander.

You cant compare the ETS sanders with the deros. The sander that is comparable in the Festool line up is the ETS EC models. If it was between the deros and the ETS EC I would go with the Festool for warranty reasons. From what I have read from people that have both, they are pretty similar sanders. 

 

If you would have bought an ETS EC model, im sure you would have not returned it. But it is very expensive. 

Posted
4 minutes ago, shaneymack said:

You cant compare the ETS sanders with the deros. The sander that is comparable in the Festool line up is the ETS EC models. If it was between the deros and the ETS EC I would go with the Festool for warranty reasons. From what I have read from people that have both, they are pretty similar sanders. 

That sander didn't exist 2 years ago when i was trying out sanders. If it had existed and i bought it all previous and following comments may never have been uttered. I still swear i got a lemon with the ETS that i had but it put a bad taste in my mouth for the green koolaide, the broken parts out of the box on my domino didn't help either.

Posted
That sander didn't exist 2 years ago when i was trying out sanders. If it had existed and i bought it all previous and following comments may never have been uttered. I still swear i got a lemon with the ETS that i had but it put a bad taste in my mouth for the green koolaide, the broken parts out of the box on my domino didn't help either.

Ya i hear you man, that sucks. I just wanted to make sure the op knew there was a distinction between the two models and that the newer one is a whole other animal.

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

Posted
Chestnut - did you buy the domino brand new? 

I think Makita and Bosch are the two best "sub festool" brands.  Makita might have a consumer (aka contractor) and professional line, not sure.  I see white Makita stuff in to box stores and don't trust it.  Bosch is pretty good all around.  The more I see a brand in the box stores, the less I trust it.  

Most importantly, get a 6" sander!  I don't understand why 5" sanders have come to dominate the market.  You will save so much time with a 6" sander.  

Agree 100%. Most tools i have that aren't Festool are Bosch or Makita. Milwaukee looks like they have some nice stuff now but I've never used any of it.

Also agree with the 6" sander comment. Its a big difference in size compared to the 5" !

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 63 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined