Ron Swanson Jr. Posted September 8 Report Posted September 8 Here's something I've been struggling with, and thought I'd solicit opinions or insight from the group. It's a little sensitive subject for me and I'm not sure what to do. My dad has a brand new SawStop Contractor series. It probably has less than 2h of use on it. He has Alzheimer's and is unfortunately deteriorating very rapidly, which is the main reason I've got almost nothing done this year. He offered the saw to me. I can't keep them both so one would need to be sold. I have a 10 year old 3hp PCS that looks 10 years old, but it's dialed in and works perfectly. I'm not sure if I want to step down in power, but I honestly don't know if I need all that juice anymore. I do my initial ripping on the bandsaw and then use the table saw to take off about 1/16", so I'm not really ever taxing the motor all that much. I almost never see stock thicker than 8/4 anyway. So I guess my only real question is to any one who has the contractor saw: How is the power and the dust collection on it? Any regrets or issues with it? Thanks 1 Quote
Popular Post wtnhighlander Posted September 8 Popular Post Report Posted September 8 There is more to a cabinet saw than horsepower. While the SS contractor series is undoubtedly a very good machine, there is no way it can rival your PCS in accuracy and cut quality. Mass matters. 3 1 Quote
Popular Post Von Posted September 8 Popular Post Report Posted September 8 I'm sorry to hear about your father. I would sell the newer saw and use the funds to buy something I needed/wanted. I would endeavor to show my appreciation of the generosity even though it was transformed. 3 1 Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted September 8 Report Posted September 8 I have the contractor, and I agree with Von. Keep the PCS and do something appropriate and meaningful with your father's contractor saw. 1 1 Quote
Ron Swanson Jr. Posted September 8 Author Report Posted September 8 Thanks fellas, I appreciate this group. 1 Quote
Popular Post gee-dub Posted September 8 Popular Post Report Posted September 8 I would never give up a cab saw (even a hybrid) for a contractor saw. The contractor format has many design flaws when it comes to doing anything very accurate. Keep the PCS. Sell the contractor and buy more wood. 2 1 Quote
Popular Post Chestnut Posted September 8 Popular Post Report Posted September 8 I'm sorry to hear about your father. I hope you get to enjoy your remaining time together. I hope its a long while. I neef to take my own advice. I butt heads with my father too often about the dumbest things as well. 3 1 Quote
legenddc Posted September 8 Report Posted September 8 Seems like you have a decision already. Sorry about your father. Alzheimer's is awful. I hope you get to enjoy the good moments as they come. 1 Quote
Popular Post Ron Swanson Jr. Posted September 8 Author Popular Post Report Posted September 8 On 9/8/2026 at 7:42 AM, legenddc said: Seems like you have a decision already. Sorry about your father. Alzheimer's is awful. I hope you get to enjoy the good moments as they come. Thanks. It really is awful. There's no treatment. All you can do is helplessly watch as they slip further and further away. I'm trying to get over there every weekend. Some are better than others. Last weekend was a good one, so I'm grateful for that! 3 1 Quote
Popular Post gee-dub Posted September 8 Popular Post Report Posted September 8 Good on you. Back in college I would visit my grandmother once a week. Each visit I would be setting there talking to her for about 10 minutes and all of the sudden her eyes would go wide, she would smile, and say with surprise "Oh, it's Glenn!". 3 1 Quote
Immortan D Posted September 8 Report Posted September 8 I'm sorry to hear about your father. I have a Bosch contractor saw but I only use it as a last resort. Like you, I use my bandsaw for rip cuts whenever possible. The fence on the Bosch sometimes locks slightly out of square, so I don't trust it. 1 Quote
Popular Post Ron Swanson Jr. Posted September 8 Author Popular Post Report Posted September 8 Thanks to all who have weighed in. That's why I like this forum so much, when I'm about to start down a bad path,I can count on you folks to show me why that's a bad idea. I'll be keeping my PCS. I'll take Von's suggestion and put the funds from Pop's saw to something else. Probably to Mr Tom Lie Nielsen. I was thinking an engraved plane or 2 would be a great replacement, and easier to pass down when the day comes that I have to hang up my spurs as well. Anyway, thanks again All. 7 Quote
pkinneb Posted September 9 Report Posted September 9 On 9/8/2026 at 10:47 AM, Ron Swanson Jr. said: I'll be keeping my PCS. Late to the game but good choice 1 Quote
Popular Post Beechwood Chip Posted September 10 Popular Post Report Posted September 10 On 9/8/2026 at 11:33 AM, Immortan D said: I have a Bosch contractor saw but I only use it as a last resort. I had a Bosch 4100 and sold it to buy my Sawstop contractor saw. I wouldn't call them both "contractor saws". My Sawstop is all metal, has cast iron top and wings, 52" fence, and is just all around solid and reliable. Definitely not portable. I'd call the Bosch a "jobsite saw". 4 Quote
Immortan D Posted September 11 Report Posted September 11 On 9/10/2026 at 12:04 PM, Beechwood Chip said: I had a Bosch 4100 and sold it to buy my Sawstop contractor saw. I wouldn't call them both "contractor saws". My Sawstop is all metal, has cast iron top and wings, 52" fence, and is just all around solid and reliable. Definitely not portable. I'd call the Bosch a "jobsite saw". I have the Bosch 10j. Definitely a jobsite saw. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.