Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Contrasting Woods

Featured Replies

I am planning on building a shelving unit similar to Marc's Weekend Wall Shelf except mine will be a freestanding unit. 

 

The picture below is a basic SketchUp model a did real quick. 

 

post-7772-0-92778400-1365966011_thumb.jp

 

I want to make it from solid wood. 12/4 for the back vertical support and then 8/4 for the top 4 shelves. For the bottom shelf is thicker because I plan on making it from 4/4 stock so I can build it around two 12x12x2" concrete pavers  to give it some heft on the base to make it more stable. 

 

I would like to make this piece with contrasting woods. I know that I can get 12/4 hard maple for the vertical support and I was thinking about using walnut for the shelves. I think that would look good what do you guys think? 

 

I also like that walnut is cheaper than some other rich colored woods. 

 

I tried looking for some projects that used these two woods together but I had some trouble finding good examples. 

 

Also what are some of your favorite wood contrasting wood combinations?

 

I have made tea light holders with maple outside strips and a walnut center strip. It looked nice and the gift recipients seemed to have liked them.

RJ

 

Walnut and maple sound just fine and the design seems fine too. Just make sure there is a good fixing if it's wall mounted. I think you US guys are lucky to have such a good availability of home grown species.  

Maple and walnut is a great combo. South American walnut is a real deep dark chocolate color if you are looking for a major contrast.

Air dried walnut shows better variations in grain and color, kiln dried walnut is steamed to make the sapwood pick up color from the heartwood.

Ambrosia maple and walnut with some sapwood showing is a nice combo as well. My hardwood lumber mill sells Ambrosia maple cheap because it is a degraded material . If your source has a premium on Ambrosia maple you are buying retail.

I think all of the combinations above look fine. My rule as a web/graphic designer has always been, if something has to contrast, MAKE IT CONTRAST. If you go halfway (say, maple and white oak), there's contrast in the grain patterns and colors, but it's so slight it will look like a mistake, or that you ran out of wood and made do with what you had in stock. 

Walnut and maple look great together if you use a neutral finish like lacquer or acrylic poly. Oil based finishes yellow the maple too much and it doesn't jive with the cool brown of walnut.

  • 3 weeks later...

I like to use contrasting (or as I call them, "complementing") woods. Used H Mahogany and hickory/pecan recently on several projects to nice effect (display stand). In exotics I've used bubinga and padauk (attached hall table). When looking at woods keep in mind how they age. Padauk is bright orange when first cut, matures quite quickly to a chocolate with purple cast rather quickly. 

 

Never used purpleheart, but assume it darkens fairly quickly as well. So be careful about falling in love with the fresh color. As McQ says, be aware of the effect finish has on the color. Oil-based varnish-based finish tends to enhance most woods to my eye, but maple is a different story. 

 

On small projects bubinga and zebrawood are nice together. As are bubinga and wenge. 

 

I'm looking at my corner cabinet of mostly cherry but door panels, back panels, shelf and top are padauk. I like TheFatBaron's advice on contrast in general, but subtle can work at times. Re: the corner cabinet. In time the cherry darkens and the padauk does its thing this contrast is on the subtle side, but you can also have contrast in grain, texture and other characteristics. Color is not the only attribute working for (or against) you.

 

Word on South American walnut. I've only used a few boards of it. Good quality was that once the finish (oil-based) hits it the wood becomes a very deep, dark brown. Great for backdrop base. However, the wood itself (that I have) is not particularly fun. Pretty crumbly and dusty feeling even though it milled fine. Not at all like N American black walnut in appearance or feel. In my limited experience.

 

Have fun.

post-357-0-78098700-1367496284_thumb.jpg

post-357-0-10870600-1367496286_thumb.jpg

I think Maple and Walnut is a great look.

 

As for which part is which, depending on where it's going I'd consider making the back piece out of the darker wood and the shelves from the lighter color wood - I think that would give it an overall "lighter" feel.

I'm a big fan of cherry and walnut. Natural maple is a bit too light for my taste.

Maple/walnut (unfinished)

photo_zpse9ed8099.jpg

Cherry/walnut (salad bowl finish)

photo2-13.jpg

  • 2 weeks later...
  • Author

Ok I'm confident it will look good.

I am having trouble locating 12/4 stock in both Maple and Walnut. I was thinking about buying thinner stock and just laminating pieces together to get the thickness I am looking for.

Then I got to thinking about grain continuity and thought that it woul be hard to get a good enough match on all the pieces. So then the saying "if you can hide it, accentuate it" came to mind.

So my idea now is to get 6/4 walnut and then put a layer of maple in between. So the shelves will be like a Maple sandwich with the Walnut as the bread and visa versa for the back support.

I think this could look pretty awesome but I have not seen anything done like this. Is there a reason why? Anything I should be concerned about?

Thanks

That sounds like a good idea rj, laminate that bitch with a nice maple stripe in the middle, will look hot! Post pictures when you start building

  • Author

The more I think about it, the better I like the idea. I might even take it a step or two further. In the Sketchup model I posted the vertical post in is completely straight but I am thinking about adding a taper to it. The taper will make the bottom about 12 inches wide and finding a single board that wide will be pretty tough so I am thinking about running a vertical strip of walnut down the middle of the support (kinda like a racing stripe). Not only would it prevent me from having to grain match it will also accentuate the taper of the support. 

 

Along the lines of the stripe, I was thinking that maybe I would make the center 5" of the vertical support out of the Maple then attaching walnut to the sides and cut the taper in the walnut. I would leave about 1" of walnut at the top then it would expand to 3.5" at the bottom. 

 

I need to get on sketchup and draw some of this stuff out. I'll pics of the ideas.

  • Author

Here is what I've come up with really quick. Warning the colors aren't that close to what they would actually be it's just a quick representation.

 

post-7772-0-56407000-1368554911_thumb.jp

 

This is with the stripe of walnut and the tapered back support. 

  • Author

Yea it kinda looks like it belongs in a 1950's bowling alley

Marc made a whatnot shelf similar to that and I copied it for a woodworking contest that I was in.

The problem with the contest was that you could only use ONE 2 x 4 x 86" long! So it took some planning on my part.

I'm sure that yours will look much much better. :)

 

 

ItsfinishedIMG_0819.jpg

 

 

My granddaughter now owns my whatnot shelf. 

 

Rog

Yep I made one too, for my baby boy's room when we were expecting him.  It's a fast and easy project...think I knocked mine out in one day, minus finish.  Terrible pic, but the mahogany is singing now!

 

dscn0898m.jpg

  • Author

Mine is going to be scaled up some compared to the one's that Marc and you guys built. I am wondering if the half lap joint will be enough by itself to hold the shelves in the long run. I am considering putting in a couple bolts like Marc did on the platform bed to give it that extra strength. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.