baok Posted May 22, 2013 Report Posted May 22, 2013 I have an old Stanley #7 that I use for edge jointing since I got rid of my powered jointer. Generally things go well but I often seem to end up with it slightly out of square - usually sloped away from me. This happens even when I make sure the iron is square in the plane. I suppose I could lay it on the bench, elevate the stock slightly, and run the plane along the bench shooting-board style. Or attend a hand tool class. But is there some obvious change in stance I could work on? Must be some ergonomic issue going on. Quote
G S Haydon Posted May 22, 2013 Report Posted May 22, 2013 Hi Greg, You could try a fence, home made or an off the shelf version . These would help you get a feel for dead square. Doing two boards at the same time can also help support the plane and make it easier to plane. Quote
RJsumthn Posted May 22, 2013 Report Posted May 22, 2013 I have the same issue when I am edge jointing. I have to really focus and keep the plane square to the board because to me it feels like it will slope toward me even though it is square. I'm sure with practice I could make it feel comfortable to me. I think that I worry too much about putting downward pressure and since i'm right handed I favor that side and that is why I get the slope. If you get on Shannon's good side and you take a quick video of you edge jointing, I'm sure he could diagnose the issue Quote
RenaissanceWW Posted May 22, 2013 Report Posted May 22, 2013 Most of us have a tendency to lean one way or another. Identifying this is half the battle. Once you know that direction I find if you skew the tail of the plane off the opposite side you will correct that lean. Consciously putting weight on the off side will do wonders too. There are lots of other "tricks" as well. Putting a curve on your blade will allow you to center the deepest part of the curve over the high side thus taking more wood off there. Or use the lateral adjuster to skew the iron so it takes a heavier cut on your high side. Whatever you do, you want to keep the plane sole firmly on the wood's surface. Don't try to tilt the plane to correct the angle. This is too iffy to be repeatable. Usually once you have brought the edge back into square, a couple of passes right down the middle with firm pressure down on the edge will finish it off. I also find that not holding the knob but instead wrapping your thumb around the base of the knob and trailing your remaining fingers off the edge of the plane and around to the sole allows you to use your fingers as a fence to gauge square. It also lowers the center of gravity making it easier to feel the pressure of the plane on the board and any deviation from the angle you want. This works just as well when jointing bevels into a board. There is another option you might try too that I like to call my "Square Edge Trick". 1 Quote
ChrisG Posted May 22, 2013 Report Posted May 22, 2013 Edge jointing is not about having the ability to hold a plane perfectly square (though some folks can do that). It is about paying attention to how close to square you are and removing material where necessary. You should be checking the squareness of the edge before during and at the end of edge jointing. There are a few way to remove material just on one side of the edge or the other, the easiest is probably to use a somewhat cambered blade to take a thicker shaving on the high side (put the center of the blade on where more material need to be removed because that's where a cambered blade takes the thickest shaving.) I would suggest Googling something along the lines of "squaring an edge with a plane" or "squaring an edge with a cambered blade". I'm pretty sure Bob Rozieski (misspelled, sorry bob), Shannon Rogers and Chris Schwarz all have video's out there demonstrating this. There are easy ways to do this with a straight not cambered blade as well but they are harder to explain and I'm not going to try. However, a few internet search will give you at least one or two solutions. It's also important to distinguish between squaring an edge and jointing edges for glue up. When jointing edges for glue-up it is best to clamp together and "match plane" the two pieces being glued together. That way any amount you plane out of square will be cancelled out when you put the edges together for gluing. I would suggest doing an internet search about this too...again there are videos readily available online that show it better than I can explain it. EDIT: Ha. Well looks like Shannon was posting at the same time as me and beat me to the punch. Quote
baok Posted May 22, 2013 Author Report Posted May 22, 2013 Excellent advice - and video too. I will try to put these techniques into practice soon. Quote
wilburpan Posted May 23, 2013 Report Posted May 23, 2013 One other possibility to check is that when you have your board in your vise for edge planing, your board might not be perfectly vertical or plumb. That's an easy thing to check with a level. I had the same issue for a while when edge planing with edges being consistently out of square in the same direction. As it turned out, the front edge of my workbench and the leg of my leg vise were a little out of plumb, which led to boards that I was edge planing being not perfectly vertical. Fixing the front edge of my workbench and the face of the leg fixed all those issues. I think that we are much better at determining level and plumb than we think we are. If your board is set up so that it's not quite plumb, you'll wind up edge planing an edge that is level to the ground, which results in an out of square edge. Quote
Rick_J Posted May 24, 2013 Report Posted May 24, 2013 One technique I always use, especially on long edges, is to use a shooting board. I made a simple one about 6 ft. long out of two pieces of melamine. Using a shooting board pretty much guarantees that your plane will always be 90 degrees to the board edge. As long as you alternate the top and bottom sides when you mount your pieces on the shooting board, any difference in the angle of your iron from 90 degrees will cancel out when you joint the adjoining edges. 1 Quote
ChrisG Posted May 24, 2013 Report Posted May 24, 2013 I just watched the video Shannon. That's a great technique. Funny enough I've been doing something very similar and have been using straight edges in my jointer more and more. Slight difference in what I do. Instead of using the block still use the jointer to initially bring that high edge down, but I move the jointer so its centered (or even past centered) on the high edge so that the metal edge of the plane around the mouth is riding on the low edge. This lets me bring the high side down a couple shaving w/o bringing down the low side. The final step is to take those full width passes like you did, but bias pressure toward that side that was just brought down. This essentially tilts the plane in the wanted direction a miniscule amount, w/o one having to try and hold it at an angle. Like with your block plane technique when the shaving is full width you're done. The technique is a little bit more try and check than yours and yours seems like it might be a bit more precise, but its been working well for me. Just another easy way to square an edge with a straight iron... (P.S. What I've been doing is a slight modification a technique I learned from Deneb at the LN booth at Hearne's open house last year. I was suprised I didn't run into you there . Though I did get to meet your buddy Chuck Bender, that was cool! ) Quote
RenaissanceWW Posted May 29, 2013 Report Posted May 29, 2013 Chris, I have been to a few of the LN events at Hearne but I usually go on Friday and turn it into a business trip since Hearne is one of my customers. Quote
baok Posted June 3, 2013 Author Report Posted June 3, 2013 FWIW, I got to try this out yesterday during several hours of woodworking and I ended up with some nice square edges. I'm pretty happy with both my edges and my newfound knowledge. Quote
woodbloke Posted June 12, 2013 Report Posted June 12, 2013 Most of us have a tendency to lean one way or another. Identifying this is half the battle. Once you know that direction I find if you skew the tail of the plane off the opposite side you will correct that lean. Consciously putting weight on the off side will do wonders too. There are lots of other "tricks" as well. Putting a curve on your blade will allow you to center the deepest part of the curve over the high side thus taking more wood off there. Or use the lateral adjuster to skew the iron so it takes a heavier cut on your high side. Whatever you do, you want to keep the plane sole firmly on the wood's surface. Don't try to tilt the plane to correct the angle. This is too iffy to be repeatable. Usually once you have brought the edge back into square, a couple of passes right down the middle with firm pressure down on the edge will finish it off. I also find that not holding the knob but instead wrapping your thumb around the base of the knob and trailing your remaining fingers off the edge of the plane and around to the sole allows you to use your fingers as a fence to gauge square. It also lowers the center of gravity making it easier to feel the pressure of the plane on the board and any deviation from the angle you want. This works just as well when jointing bevels into a board. There is another option you might try too that I like to call my "Square Edge Trick". Pretty much correct. In addition, what helps enormously is to have your bench flat and level in both horizontal planes...easy to check with spirit level and then chock the appropriate legs. If you use the vice, make sure as well that the front apron is also true and square to the top - Rob Quote
TerryMcK Posted June 12, 2013 Report Posted June 12, 2013 Hi Greg, You could try a fence, home made or an off the shelf version . These would help you get a feel for dead square. Doing two boards at the same time can also help support the plane and make it easier to plane. The off the shelf "training wheels" or "cheating mode" is what I do. I have the magnetic Veritas fence that I attach to the Veritas low angle jointer I have and it works for me. I no longer stress about getting edges square now. I can concentrate on not applying to much force to the leading edge and forming a curve at the end of the cut. Quote
duncumb.fc Posted June 17, 2013 Report Posted June 17, 2013 When I joint fronts and backs, I use two different methods. (The Viola da Gamba has a carved top and a flat back) Backs are normally glued when around 4-5mm thick (and then the final thicknessing is done). We do this on a shooting board, which makes it easy to get square! Fronts are another matter. The wedges are often 30mm wide on the gluing edge, and the joint must be perfect. I personally have practised without a fence, and as previously said, when you identify the problem you can then start to work out how to sort it! Personally, I just check often with a square, and then often just thinking about planing it back the other way is enough, subconsciously our bodies can work it out! However, another method that works is to clamp the two boards to be jointed together in the vice, and plane them as one surface. Get them flat, not in wind etc. When they're perfect they'll fit together, whether square or not! This is because if there's an angle on one, there's the opposite angle on the other. Fraser 1 Quote
Tom King Posted June 20, 2013 Report Posted June 20, 2013 Shannon's block plane trick is close what I do. I don't worry about keeping the edge of the iron inside the face of the board edge though. I just knock the high side down enough for the jointer to seat like it should. I keep a 60-1/2 in my tool belt, in it's own pocket. It gets called on for all sorts of things. I keep a straight bladed iron in a #8, and an ever so slightly cambered one in a #7. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.