Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Farmhous table & am I woodworking snob?

Featured Replies

Okay, this has me wondering if I'm a woodworking snob.

A good friend asked me to build a farmhouse table for her. (I already have too many projects to complete in a lifetime, but that's not the point of this post.) She has 4 kids, all boys, ages from 3 to 11 years old. They are all very nice kids, but certainly not easy on the furniture.

 

She gave me this post as a reference: http://ana-white.com/2012/11/plans/farmhouse-table-updated-pocket-hole-plans?page=1

 

I'm want to build this for her, but I don't know if I should tell her that I don't think this method of construction is acceptable.

 

Here's my issues:

1 - I don't think that breadboard end will ever survive her children leaning on it (sitting, standing, jumping etc.) It is only held on with pocket screws into construction grade lumber.

2 - The stretchers are only held on with pocket screws

 

3 - I don't think gluing end grain to long grain creates a strong joint.

 

4 - Construction grade lumber isn't a great "long-term" furniture solution. As it dries I'd expect it to twist, cup or bow.

 

5 - I worry that this table will look shoddy in 5 years. For the above mentioned reason. (I know it "supposed" to look distressed, but in my mind I see joints separating.)

 

My plan is to build her a farmhouse table, but to use drier wood (looks like Walnut right now) and pegged mortises and tennons, with a proper connection between the table top and the base which would allow for expansion of the wood. I will let her and her boys distress it if they would like, as I think the boys would love that part.

 

But my question is, as I look at this post from Ana White, who seems very nice btw, all I see are reasons why I wouldn't build my table that way. So, have I become a woodworking snob?

 

I don't think "snob" is the correct word for what you are, I would use "educated".  Have fun with the project and build it to last.

I'm pretty sure she's looking at the tables appearance and, not at all the construction methodology so you do the proper joinery to achieve the desired look(no pocket screws, or butt joints)than when you have your plan in place show her how your proposed construction method would give her a family heirloom instead of a table that won't last through a moving process. I do like the rustic furniture look.

I don't think any one of your concerns makes you a snob.  Those are all legitimate concerns about making a piece of furniture that your friend will be able to enjoy for a long time.  If she just likes the look of the table in the picture, then you should be able to come up with a "counterproposal" that still looks great but addresses your concerns over build quality and sturdiness.

Chet, your'e no snob your simply a very good woodworker ( I know this to be true because I have seen Seymour and Roubo). I would agree with all of your points if your'e building quality furniture. And if Ana's stuff's not for you it's not for you.

 

I personally think Ana White is a legend. All the content on the site is free and accessible most of the builds are cheap quick confidence builders that provide serviceable furniture that although simple does the job better than most Ikea type stuff. It also get people picking up tools and trying stuff, and we all know where that leads...........And it appeals to a completely new demographic who might soon be making their own Seymour or Roubo.

  • Author

Hey guys,

Good feedback. I agree I'm sure my friend is looking at the table for its appearance not its construction. I hadn't thought about the last until it's no longer trendy thing, but that's a good point.

Graham, I don't know if Ana is a legend, but she seems very nice and certainly has a lot to share.

You're the snobbiest snob I've ever seen!

 

No, basically that design is good for the do it your self type person. I see that design and instructions great for someone with a circular saw, drill, and pocket hole jig. Building something to work, not to last. Not intending to ruffle some feathers there.

 

Most of us here have a bit more experience and access to more than just those tools and joinery methods.

 

You have used better joinery methods that are tried and true. I think letting her know that your methods will be better in the long run, she will respect your decisions.

I agree with the comment that your client is probably more concerned with the look of the piece than the construction technique.  I also take no issue with a desire to use good technique as opposed to what I consider (this will probably get me in trouble) lazy techniques or the kinds of short cuts used by an uneducated woodworker.

  • Popular Post

I think a compromise is in order. What about using better joinery techniques with southern yellow pine? It's pretty hard and tough, might move a bit but the design is sort of rustic. It would lower the material costs and given the abuse from the boys it should survive quite well. At some future date it could be used in another room for crafts or one of the kids first apartment. A quick Danish oil finish is easy to apply and repair.

+1 on "Not a snob." My wife has shown interest in this table and the first thing I pointed out is that the breadboard ends would create problems with movement. (I'm a novice woodworker, but even in wood flooring we recognize when cross-grain movement will present a problem.)

I don't disdain pocket-screw joinery by any means (several plywood bookshelves and tv console so far), but for this dining table I've managed to convince my wife that real hardwood (read: stair treads) and more traditional joinery are in order.

With regard to Ana White, I agree with the positive points raised here. I especially appreciate the fact that she's opening up the craft beyond the sort of gender norms we've grown much too accustomed to.

Thanks for your post,

Ryan

I don't think you're being a snob, but as others have said, I think the 'fashion' aspect of some furniture has to be considered. Much of what Ana builds are knock-offs of trendy furniture from Pottery Barn, etc. For much of the trendy stuff, it really only needs to last 5 years or so, and I think this would do that. If I asked my wife if she wanted some trendy piece on Ana's site, and told her that I could build it for a fraction of what it was available for at Pottery Barn, but would only last 5 years, she'd jump all over that because she'd likely tire of the PB piece after 5 years anyway.

 

I also think that woodworkers underestimate how long furniture should last based on how it's built or used. I have a set of barrister box bookshelves in my office at home that belonged to my wife's father. They're over 30 years old. If I told you I was considering building them, and showed you the actual joinery as my plan for how to build them, you'd certainly tell me that they wouldn't last 3 years. And when I look at them, I can't see how they did. They should have fallen apart years ago, but they trudge along.

I think a compromise is in order. What about using better joinery techniques with southern yellow pine? It's pretty hard and tough, might move a bit but the design is sort of rustic. It would lower the material costs and given the abuse from the boys it should survive quite well. At some future date it could be used in another room for crafts or one of the kids first apartment. A quick Danish oil finish is easy to apply and repair.

I have to agree. I have done a few projects in pine and there are ways to stain pine without blotching and make it look like mahogany. You can give her all that she is requesting, while still not lowering your obviously good standards. There is no snobbery in this like others have mentioned, just better understanding of furniture than the lay person. If your BORG has SYP, which is fairly hard, not quite as hard as poplar, you can generally get 2x16 and smaller dimensional lumber, let it acclimate in your shop for a few weeks, mill it up and good to go.

 

As for Anna, she is certainly becoming a bit of a legend in her own way. Not really a woodworker in my opinion, more of a designer/DIY'er. I have used one of her designs for a step stool. She does make the craft easily accessible to many. I just hope folks do more research and pay attention to safety. I saw her using a table saw on youtube and felt uncomfortable for her safety.... Don't know if it was just because she is a female or because of how she was handling herself/material, just a visceral feeling....

Customer education is important.

 

You could work up a design that looks exactly like the request, including tenons to engage the ends and frame, using proper lumber, and present a price.   When, not if, she questions the price, concisely explain why you're doing what you're doing, in other words, looking out for her interests and long term satisfaction.

 

At that point, of you can't come to an agreement, respectfully move on.

 

On a side note, I do respect Ana's contributions to appreciation of hand made stuff.  I just wish she were in an area where quality materials were easier to obtain so she didn't build everything out of construction lumber. 

Another thing to consider is your values as a woodworker and an artisan (how is that for a snobby word).  The first time those butt joints fail, your name is associated with the piece.

 

Here's another piece of snobbery, what about the environment - I mean that lumber comes from somewhere.  I know it's only construction grade lumber but how much do we waste as a society in sub-standard construction that ends up on the curb after 3-5 years.

 

I like what Peter Follansbee said of his joint stools - "It should last for the first 400 years, after that my warranties no good."

Treat othres like you want to be treated. As others said before, your friend likes how the table looks. Now you have to help her understand that if longevity is an issue, there are construction techniques that will help her and her family to enjoy this table for many years.

Once she understands this concept and why this will help her, then you make the changes.

As per the wood ... Depends on the finish you want to achieve, there are many options.

Good luck.

  • Author

I wanted to say thanks for all the input into this post.

I also wanted to give you all an update.

My friend has decided that she would like to go with solid Walnut, and puts a high degree of faith in my advice for the construction technique.

 

So, we are going forward with the project, including all of my recommendations.

I think I'll start another thread in the project journal section so that you all can follow the construction if you so desire.

 

Thanks again for everyone's input.

  • 2 months later...
  • Author

post-2771-0-87908900-1387313096_thumb.jppost-2771-0-06159100-1387313094_thumb.jppost-2771-0-16735000-1387313095_thumb.jppost-2771-0-07651300-1387313096_thumb.jppost-2771-0-38560200-1387313120_thumb.jpOkay, I thought you all might like an update on this thread.

I've completed the Farmhouse Table.

I went with solid air-dried walnut, breadboard ends, pegged to the table.

Drawbore peg construction. Everything was designed to allow for wood movement. Even though the walnut was air-dried indoors for almost 15 years. I know how dry our house gets in the winter and how humid Iowa summers can be. With solid wood construction, I made sure to allow for movement. My guess is this table will only last 2 or 3 hundred years.

I left a lot of it somewhat rough, because that was the desired look.

My friend asked me to strike a balance between farmhouse rough, and finished elegance.  

I'm not even sure exactly what that means, but she is thrilled with the way it all came out. (She asked me to add a bench and I actually like the bench better than the table.)

 

I'd love to hear everyone's thoughts, comments or criticism.

 

Sweet looking table and bench!  What finish did you use?

Looks good to me Chet, with the brief of "farmhouse rough and finished elegance" you came up trumps. Not sure I can see the rough you mentioned? Stop chamfers add a bit of detail which is cool. 300 years, yeah, sounds about right. I also do like that bench, it does an even better job of being "farmhose elegant".

  • Author

Looks good to me Chet, with the brief of "farmhouse rough and finished elegance" you came up trumps. Not sure I can see the rough you mentioned? Stop chamfers add a bit of detail which is cool. 300 years, yeah, sounds about right. I also do like that bench, it does an even better job of being "farmhose elegant".

 

Thanks Graham,

The stop chamfers got rave reviews from the my friend. My initial thought was that they may help lesson the amount of dinged knees, as she has 4 boys between the ages of 3 and 11. However, I have to admit I really like the look as well.

I really like the splayed legs of the bench.  Its an interesting touch I don't see much on these types of dining benches. 

The table looks great too.   I bought the lumber for a similar style table about 9 months ago, still haven't built it.  You getting this done so quickly is giving me some motivation.  

 

Curious why you decided to stain?  Stain is always conterversial amongst a bunch of woodworkers!  Were you trying to even out sapwood or just alter the color a bit? 

  • Author

I really like the splayed legs of the bench.  Its an interesting touch I don't see much on these types of dining benches. 

The table looks great too.   I bought the lumber for a similar style table about 9 months ago, still haven't built it.  You getting this done so quickly is giving me some motivation.  

 

Curious why you decided to stain?  Stain is always conterversial amongst a bunch of woodworkers!  Were you trying to even out sapwood or just alter the color a bit? 

 

The legs are splayed at 4 degrees. This is so that the bottom of the bench is a 1/2 inch wider than the top. As I mentioned my friend has 4 young boys in the house and I thought this would make the bench more stable. In addition I made the bench 2 inches wider than what is normal for a bench of that type and size. This too, was to add to the stability of the bench.

The stain was done to match other pieces in their house. I think the walnut would have been beautiful without it, but in needed to be a bit darker to match the other pieces, including a hutch that's been in their family for literally like 150 years. I did a few sample pieces to see what matched best and this is what I came up with. I must admit I wasn't jazzed about the stain, but I ended up really liking the result.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.