Tony Wilkins Posted June 2, 2014 Report Posted June 2, 2014 As you may remember, a while back I bought, had a horrible time with, and returned an LN #5. I really wanted to love that plane. I settled down with a few LV planes and then got an LN LA jack. As an early Father’s Day Gift I got myself (In my boy’s name of course) a bronze LN #4. I’m in love. Put a microbevel on it and started taking wispy shavings - I can see how that’s addictive. I had a little piece of mahogany that I’m going to use for a simple shelf for my wife in the bathroom. Got it out and went to work - first with an LV 5 1/4 to take out the twist, then the LN LA Jack as a jointer, and then glorious mahogany shavings from the LN. I always wanted to love LN planes as they are so beautifully crafted and now I have found one I can settle down with Quote
G S Haydon Posted June 2, 2014 Report Posted June 2, 2014 Interesting progress Tony, glad you're pleased with it. Do you find you have a preference for BD vs BU now? Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted June 2, 2014 Author Report Posted June 2, 2014 Interesting progress Tony, glad you're pleased with it. Do you find you have a preference for BD vs BU now? I'm leaning toward the bevel down but I still find times where that low angle jack is useful. Quote
Shane Jimerfield Posted June 3, 2014 Report Posted June 3, 2014 I just got one of these in the mail today as well. It was from that cat who was unloading all the hand tools last week. Well now I know what all the fuss is about - amazing, i love it. best plane I have ever used. now I have to figure out where to get enough money to replace all my hand planes from LV...yikes. Quote
brooklyngohardwood Posted June 3, 2014 Report Posted June 3, 2014 Nice! I lust after the bronze Lie-Nielsons, although after trying them at a show I found the #4½ fits my hand better than the #4 which means no bronze for me . I've been saving up for one but am still a little torn between a LN #4½ and the LV Bevel Up Smoother. The LN is what my heart wants, and many people I respect seem to prefer the bevel down smoothing planes (Shannon, Chris Schwarz, et al). But there's something about the simplicity and adjustability of the LV BU planes that also appeals. I love my LV Low Angle Jack and how easy it is to clear the mouth and then get right back to the preset mouth opening. I worry that the LV will actually be more user-friendly in practice? Arg! Choices! Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted June 3, 2014 Author Report Posted June 3, 2014 From what I've seen from many asking that question, myself included, it really comes down how you 'feel' interacting with the tool. As much as I like my bevel up planes, I find the bevel down planes easier to adjust. That said, when I get my LV planes just so they work fantastically but lately I've had trouble getting them that way (and I'm not sure why). Quote
Llama Posted June 3, 2014 Report Posted June 3, 2014 Nice! I lust after the bronze Lie-Nielsons, although after trying them at a show I found the #4½ fits my hand better than the #4 which means no bronze for me . ! There is a limited edition bronze 4 1/2 Quote
brooklyngohardwood Posted June 3, 2014 Report Posted June 3, 2014 From what I've seen from many asking that question, myself included, it really comes down how you 'feel' interacting with the tool. As much as I like my bevel up planes, I find the bevel down planes easier to adjust. That said, when I get my LV planes just so they work fantastically but lately I've had trouble getting them that way (and I'm not sure why). Yeah, that's Chris Schwarz biggest complaint about bevel down it seems. But I actually don't have that much trouble adjusting cut depth while planing with my LAJ—yes you have to move your hand down a bit, but it's not like you need to completely stop using the tool @Fretless — yes, I've heard of that mythical beast. I'm afraid it would be way out of my price range on the secondary market. Also I have to imagine it's a heavy beast. 1 Quote
jmaichel Posted June 3, 2014 Report Posted June 3, 2014 Congrats on the new plane Tony! I dream of one day owning a bronze LN # 4 myself. I have owned both LV and LN planes. I don't like the totes on the LV planes I just don't think they are as comfortable as the LN planes. I am sure several of us could make a good case for having a LA angle jack and regular BD jack. The LA BU jack plane works very well for all regular planing tasks but I really like how well it planes end grain. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.