Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Hard maple question

Featured Replies

I am going to go look at some hard maple today, and possible buy some. This will be for a new work bench top. Split top style roubo.

My question is what most people pay per BF for hard maple?

I know price will very based on area and what not. I am just looking for a ruff  estimate . 

The stuff I am going to look at is 8/4 thick, and 5-6" wide. Shortest boards being 7' long. 

I also have a few sites up on the phone for  identifying between hard and soft maple. I will be using the visual way, as not making the color test not able to weight it. 

Also any advice anyone has on buying hard maple for a bench would be great. I know to stay away from defects and all, but what else?

Close to me my hardwood dealer sells 8/4 & 6/4 hard maple for 4.95 a board foot.............

$3.75/bf would be a pretty good price...

But there is no such thing as a free lunch... You've got to consider grade as well... Sometimes you get a good price because it's a lower grade... And it could be rough or surfaced... Etc...

Around here, 8/4 S&B Rough A.Saccharum is around $4.75/bf

 

$2.40 4/4 $3.50 8/4 for me, cheaper at another mill I go to but don't know their prices off hand, I'm in KY though, we have a lot of trees.

I paid $1.90/BF, but it was only 4/4, rough & it had lots of streaking in it. Almost no knots though.

8/4 Hard Maple, KD, FAS quality, selected for color (all white, no brown streaks), S2S is $7.58 bd ft from the retail lumberyard

8/4 Hard Maple, KD, Select and Better, Rough Sawn, selected for color is $4.40 bd ft from a local mill.  

8/4 Hard Maple, KD, Select and Better, Rough Sawn, not selected for color is $2.95 bd ft from a local mill.

Personally I like maple with brown streaks, only problem is it can be less stable.  You tend to see more checks and shakes near the brown heart wood.

 

  • Author

Total spent $160.....over 60 BF.    Not nots or issues, but all rough cut. Oh and 2.6 about thick. And 8.2-9.3" wide.

Plus two book matched spoted red oak boards for free. He saw I liked them and will make shelves or something. They 4/4

image.jpeg

So about $2.66 bd ft.  I am pretty sure I see two big knots on that top board.  I'd say that is somewhat consistent with the grade.   Trimming around those two knots you are probably select or #1c grade.

http://www.woodworkerssource.com/shop/grad.html

  • Author

Bench top will be 3" thick, knots will be cut off, no part of it. 

Any little ones going to fill in with epoxy. So should be fine. But did my best picking.

Just now, rmartuszewski said:

Bench top will be 3" thick, knots will be cut off, no part of it. 

Understood, I was just making a comment that the price is consistent with the grade.   Given the width and thickness of the boards, you have a lot to work with.  

  • Author

Yeah, I think it will be a lot of work. But a better choice than building it out of 2x4 from HD as I was planing. Didn't want to but no hard maple anywhere near me till now, jumped on it. 

You did well.

Another source to consider: I bought my hard maple from Shannon Rogers (of WoodTalk and Renaissnace Woodworker fame).  It was not cheap but I have to say that the quality is amazing.

At 8-9"wide,  you should be getting two boards from each,  which will leave you about 30% waste. I definately do see some knots.  Two in the top,  a big one on the left side of the second board down. 

How long are they? Getting 96" boards for the top was a pain in the butt part for me.

  • Author
39 minutes ago, Brendon_t said:

At 8-9"wide,  you should be getting two boards from each,  which will leave you about 30% waste. I definately do see some knots.  Two in the top,  a big one on the left side of the second board down. 

How long are they? Getting 96" boards for the top was a pain in the butt part for me.

The shorest one is 103".  

Just left wood craft orlando. Bought two more pieces of wood for lathe handles.

marblewood, padauk

image.jpeg

If it were me and I could save some waste, I wouldn't cut out the knots, I would just put them on the bottom of the slab and fill them with epoxy.  It's a workbench and no one will ever see.

14 minutes ago, Dknapp34 said:

If it were me and I could save some waste, I wouldn't cut out the knots, I would just put them on the bottom of the slab and fill them with epoxy.  It's a workbench and no one will ever see.

I'm doing this right now in the "Roubo from scratch" thread. The issues I see is once you run two saw blade kerf and edge joint even one edge, the thickest board at 9.3" wouldn't yield 3 3"thick pieces 

  • Author

Yeah, going squeeze as much as I can out of them. Were the straitest out of all of them. He had some nicer ones with no knots, but had so much live edge they wouldn't have yelded one lol.

 

Going to buy some new stone for the plane blades. And make a track saw. And get a  Japanese saw for doing the tennons and such. Then will go through the boards and start planing the cuts.

I will rewarch all the youtube videos again (tons), and try and talk the wife into the guild buying of the project videos and such. I have a few books also I will pull off the shelf. 

The legs and such are going to be big box store wood, and buy the dryest, straightest, least knots I can find. Have a HD and Lowes close. The other side idk yet. Would love to do HM but the stuff I left is not worthy. 

This will be a split roubo, and outfees table, and  assembly table all in one. Plus still have to buy a tail vise or a wagon vise. And want to make a front leg vise. 

Buying the wood today was cart before horse, but could pass on the deal. Now have to get back on track and do this right lol. 

  • Popular Post

Buying the guild videos will save you at least $100 in mistakes and frustration. 

1 hour ago, Dknapp34 said:

If it were me and I could save some waste, I wouldn't cut out the knots, I would just put them on the bottom of the slab and fill them with epoxy.  It's a workbench and no one will ever see.

pretty sure he will be laminating the boards so that the edge grain is facing up (which ia typical of a roubo build). . You really don't want a knot where the dog holes will be, because your hold fast might not hold if the knot breaks loose.   Personally I would cut out the knots rather than risk an unstable lamination.   Filling large knots with epoxy is time consuming and expensive. 

  • Author
3 minutes ago, Mike. said:

pretty sure he will be laminating the boards so that the edge grain is facing up (which ia typical of a roubo build). . You really don't want a knot where the dog holes will be, because your hold fast might not hold if the knot breaks loose.   Personally I would cut out the knots rather than risk an unstable lamination.   Filling large knots with epoxy is time consuming and expensive. 

Yes it is, did it on the black walnut TV stand I am finishing up this week. Took two weeks of fill, dey, flip, fill, dry, etc.  slab, legs, etc

4 hours ago, Mike. said:

pretty sure he will be laminating the boards so that the edge grain is facing up (which ia typical of a roubo build). . You really don't want a knot where the dog holes will be, because your hold fast might not hold if the knot breaks loose.   Personally I would cut out the knots rather than risk an unstable lamination.   Filling large knots with epoxy is time consuming and expensive. 

Good point about the dogholes.  When I did my Roubo, I had some small knots that I put on the underside of the back slab, so they were out of the way.  I did end up with a few on the top too, but they were very small and I was using some pretty janky $1 bd ft hickory, so I couldn't really avoid it.  I would think that the knots would have to be pretty darn big to make a lamination that large unstable, but it probably isn't worth risking for anything larger than a small knot, as long as you have the extra stock to spare. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.