Recommended Posts

Posted

So we are thinking about getting my son a gaming console for Christmas, but I know nothing about the latest and greatest.  So I have a a bunch of questions for anybody that plays games or uses for streaming Netflix or similar.  So know for the questions I have.

1)  what system is better, PlayStation 4 or Xbox 1?

2) what size system in GB is the minimum to make it worthwhile?

3) what internet speeds are needed to make either system work well?

4) do both systems allow you to download games, what are the typical cost, download size and time?

5) how well do these units do at streaming tv or movies?

6) do you need to buy extra things to maximize the console and its features?

7) can you actually cut the cord from cable or satellite tv with these consoles?

Ok that is probably enough to get me started on determining what to buy.

Thanks 

Posted
25 minutes ago, Woodenskye said:

So we are thinking about getting my son a gaming console for Christmas, but I know nothing about the latest and greatest.  So I have a a bunch of questions for anybody that plays games or uses for streaming Netflix or similar.  So know for the questions I have.

1)  what system is better, PlayStation 4 or Xbox 1?

2) what size system in GB is the minimum to make it worthwhile?

3) what internet speeds are needed to make either system work well?

4) do both systems allow you to download games, what are the typical cost, download size and time?

5) how well do these units do at streaming tv or movies?

6) do you need to buy extra things to maximize the console and its features?

7) can you actually cut the cord from cable or satellite tv with these consoles?

Ok that is probably enough to get me started on determining what to buy.

Thanks 

 

1. Depends on what you like. I got friends that swear by both. I'm an xbox guy, I don't like playstation controllers. PS4 is the first to have a VR experience though. 

2. minimum.. 500gb is what I got. I really would like at least 2x more. You have to install every game, not just the ones you download for xbox. I find myself deleting games that I may have to reinstall later.

3. Whatever the lowest broadband is. I only run maybe 5-10mb here cause I just don't see why I'd need faster. It's fine. Most places have that level of speed. 

4. Yeah both do. $60 is the norm, download or physical media. Download size depends on number of updates and downloadable content the game maker offers. It usually takes 2-3 hours to download a game for me. there are other factors like what I may be doing on my connection besides downloading games. This list may be useful: https://www.finder.com/xbox-one-install-sizes

5. Pretty excellent. I stream mostly from my harddrive using the plex app, it's pretty flawless. Netflix works just fine. though i personally prefer a Roku for dedicated streaming.

6. Not really. A nice headset comes in handy. I haven't bought anything for my Xbox One. 

7. Depends. Only true 100% cord cutting that can be done is piracy or buying every thing you want to watch when it comes on dvd or in a store for download. But netflix will provide a lot of tv shows. Hulu helps fill the gap. Check into Playstation Vue for a much cheaper solution than cable (requires ps4, or roku, pretty sure there is no xbox app) or Sling (far inferior in my opinion.) there are other solutions as well. Searching cord cutting will get you lots of good info. Particularly reddit. 

 

  • Like 2
Posted
1 minute ago, Eric. said:

Get him a baseball glove instead and go have a catch.  No one will ever convince me that video games are good for kids.  Or adults.  Or humans of any kind.  Waste of life, sorry.

Agree 100%

  • Like 1
Posted
1 hour ago, Woodenskye said:

So we are thinking about getting my son a gaming console for Christmas, but I know nothing about the latest and greatest.  So I have a a bunch of questions for anybody that plays games or uses for streaming Netflix or similar.  So know for the questions I have.

1)  what system is better, PlayStation 4 or Xbox 1?

2) what size system in GB is the minimum to make it worthwhile?

3) what internet speeds are needed to make either system work well?

4) do both systems allow you to download games, what are the typical cost, download size and time?

5) how well do these units do at streaming tv or movies?

6) do you need to buy extra things to maximize the console and its features?

7) can you actually cut the cord from cable or satellite tv with these consoles?

Ok that is probably enough to get me started on determining what to buy.

Thanks 

I think Cliff's answer is mostly good stuff as far as consoles go... 

The only thing I will add is that PC gaming tends to be better in general, and I would guess Cliff will agree...although a good gaming PC will cost more than a console, it will last a lot longer, serve additional purposes (schoolwork, etc), and you tend to have more options for games that are actually intellectual games, instead of just shooters. Most of the time I spent playing console games was largely a waste shooting friends in multiplayer games until 2am (Goldeneye, Halo, etc).  But I spent some time playing computer games like Age of Empires, SimCity, Starcraft, etc, and I think those actually were good exercises in strategic thinking and planning. Not trying to argue it is better than doing something in the real world, but it's far better than just playing a shooter. Just my 2 cents.

  • Like 2
Posted
8 hours ago, Eric. said:

Get him a baseball glove instead and go have a catch.  No one will ever convince me that video games are good for kids.  Or adults.  Or humans of any kind.  Waste of life, sorry.

I agree with this, my son plays hockey and is on the ice 5 or 6 times a week, which drops in the spring when it is lacrosse season.  Right now he needs to earn the 30 minutes of tv or tablet time he gets a day.  

As for everyone else, thanks for the replies.

  • Like 2
Posted
10 hours ago, JosephThomas said:

I think Cliff's answer is mostly good stuff as far as consoles go... 

The only thing I will add is that PC gaming tends to be better in general, and I would guess Cliff will agree...although a good gaming PC will cost more than a console, it will last a lot longer, serve additional purposes (schoolwork, etc), and you tend to have more options for games that are actually intellectual games, instead of just shooters. Most of the time I spent playing console games was largely a waste shooting friends in multiplayer games until 2am (Goldeneye, Halo, etc).  But I spent some time playing computer games like Age of Empires, SimCity, Starcraft, etc, and I think those actually were good exercises in strategic thinking and planning. Not trying to argue it is better than doing something in the real world, but it's far better than just playing a shooter. Just my 2 cents.

Ya PC gaming is much better. I play Starcraft 2 often. Playing WoW right now. Great way to hang out with my friends and game since they are not local.

 

7 hours ago, bleedinblue said:

Get him whatever his friends have, so that if they play online they can play together.  PS/Xbox aren't compatible in any way, so if his friends all play a certain game in one platform, he wouldn't be able to play with them if he had the other.

But seriously, Eric is right.

He's not right at all. Nothing is a waste of time. No hobby is more important than any other. This elitism is useless.

Posted

As long as your kid is active, doing well in school, etc, there is nothing wrong with some screen time.  Anyone who has kids these days knows that technology and video games are the social currency of the playground.  If your kid is the only one that doesn't play Minecraft, for example, then in my opinion you're doing them a disservice by not giving them something to which every other kid at school can relate to.  

And not all games are created equal.  Again, using Minecraft as an example, it is basically electronic Lego.  It encourages creativity and imagination, as do some others out there.

  • Like 1
Posted

It's like everything else, it's OK in moderation.  I'd be OK with my kid having one when she's old enough as long as she has some self control and does other activities.  I do have a PS3 that I play for about an hour a year, and s Wii that gets turned on about every three years ;)  Video games just provide little to no benefit.

Posted
15 minutes ago, Art said:

As long as your kid is active, doing well in school, etc, there is nothing wrong with some screen time.  Anyone who has kids these days knows that technology and video games are the social currency of the playground.  If your kid is the only one that doesn't play Minecraft, for example, then in my opinion you're doing them a disservice by not giving them something to which every other kid at school can relate to.  

And not all games are created equal.  Again, using Minecraft as an example, it is basically electronic Lego.  It encourages creativity and imagination, as do some others out there.

Fair point.  But then why not just get them Lego's?

Posted

I'm truly in a struggle as we go 1:1 with Chromebooks as a school district. I find it important to have some protected off-screen time. The way things are going, having a child be great at gaming could set them up to be drone pilots or the like for USAF or Amazon. I was warned about burnout when I chose music. A wise old man said "beware when your recreation is your livelihood." I'll butt out now as I cannot help the OP. I grew up with books about 60' off the ground in a tree. 

  • Like 1
Posted
29 minutes ago, Eric. said:

 One yields something of value that can be appreciated by more than one person for generations to come.  The other yields nothing but a flabby ass and bad eyes.

 I would never enable my kids to become sedentary video game turd piles

 

Who knows? A viewpoint that messing with computers is a waste of time is probably an out-moded mind set. Twenty or thirty years down the road things may be completely different. Your kids may benefit from the screen time of their youth. We just don't know what kids will use later in life.

Forty years ago I got thrown out of typing class for being disruptive. The teacher told me to go away and not come back, and he would overlook my truancy. I thought that was a good deal. After all, I figured, who on Earth would ever need to be able to type proficiently?

I wish I had stuck around and learned how to type. It would help a lot today.

 

Posted
35 minutes ago, Eric. said:

Fair point.  But then why not just get them Lego's?

Ahh have you seen the prices of Lego's ?! Minecraft is cheap ($4.99 I think for IPad, if you don't already have an ipad or PC, you may have a point).

This forum is kind of like a video game...

 

Posted
40 minutes ago, Eric. said:

Fair point.  But then why not just get them Lego's?

My daughter has enough lego to build a full sized house :)  She has actually built some of her Lego stuff in her Minecraft world.

  • Like 1
Posted
39 minutes ago, davewyo said:

Who knows? A viewpoint that messing with computers is a waste of time is probably an out-moded mind set. Twenty or thirty years down the road things may be completely different. Your kids may benefit from the screen time of their youth. We just don't know what kids will use later in life.

Forty years ago I got thrown out of typing class for being disruptive. The teacher told me to go away and not come back, and he would overlook my truancy. I thought that was a good deal. After all, I figured, who on Earth would ever need to be able to type proficiently?

I wish I had stuck around and learned how to type. It would help a lot today.

 

 

But typing is a form of communication, essential for human interaction.  Video games are not essential.  You just stare at a screen and drool on yourself.

I'm not making some ridiculous argument that technology in general is bad.  I'm saying video games turn kids into turd piles, generally.  I think it's tough to argue with that.

 

8 minutes ago, Isaac Gaetz said:

Ahh have you seen the prices of Lego's ?! Minecraft is cheap ($4.99 I think for IPad, if you don't already have an ipad or PC, you may have a point).

This forum is kind of like a video game...

 

 

Everything is better when it's real.  Even if it costs ya extra. ;)

Posted

Regarding the question the OP generated:

I would echo the thought that the most important console to get will be the one that your son's friends have. Your son will want to play with his friends online. If you have any contact with his friends parents you can call them up and ask them what they have for their kids. Seriously this is by far the absolute MOST important factor for your son. Nothing else matters even half as much.

Whether you can cut the cord on cable depends entirely on how often you watch cable. If you like to watch movies and tv once or twice a day then sorry you will not be happy with the streaming offerings. If you watch tv once or twice a week then you probably can do away with it since Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon Prime will likely cover almost all of your needs.

 

Now addressing the issue of whether video game playing is a good idea in general. Two points. The first is reality, video games are a part of life and general socialization for children now. The presence of video game consoles or pc in homes is extremely pervasive, specifically 91% of children play video games now (source). When kids get together they talk about video games, they socialize now through video games. Its the equivalent of socializing through TV and phones 30 years ago. Additionally skills learned through pc gaming (ie building a computer and maintaining one) dramatically help with computer literacy later in life. So in short any idea of ignoring or bypassing video games is frankly not realistic, they are here and here to stay.

Second point, any reference to video games not being physically active or somehow detrimental to socialization or development can be equally applied to watching tv, reading, talking on the phone, or listening to music. And in fact all of these arguments have been made regarding those hobbies at various times. Everything should be done in moderation including video games, but video games are no worse or better then any other non-physical hobby. There are video games that require you to talk to your friends constantly, video games that teach you strategy, and video games that tell an amazing and emotionally gripping story. Just as there are books that are devoid of any real intellectual value, or music that is frankly just bad. So in summation video games are just like anything else and singling them out for ridicule is not logical.

  • Like 1
Posted
2 minutes ago, minorhero said:

Second point, any reference to video games not being physically active or somehow detrimental to socialization or development can be equally applied to watching tv, reading, talking on the phone, or listening to music. And in fact all of these arguments have been made regarding those hobbies at various times. Everything should be done in moderation including video games, but video games are no worse or better then any other non-physical hobby. Their are video games that require you to talk to your friends constantly, video games that teach you strategy, and video games that tell an amazing and emotionally gripping story. Just as there are books that are devoid of any real intellectual value, or music that is frankly just bad. So in summation video games are just like anything else and singling them out for ridicule is not logical.

In general, I'd argue that age appropriate video games are better than TV and Movies. At least the video game is active and the child is engaged in doing something, instead of simply being a passive observer.

Posted

I'd still rather take my kids hiking or canoeing or fishing or get them out in my shop.  Minorhero makes good arguments but the fact remains...video games make kids fat and weak, pasty, lazy, disconnected from reality.  Ain't gonna happen to mine, regardless of the "social" consequences.  When I was a kid I could never participate in the conversations about the current music because I didn't listen to any of that crap...and I turned out fine.  Got a wife and kids and a job and a house and everything.  Normal guy.

Two rules in my house that I will never budge on...no dogs, no video games.  Ever.  At least books teach you things.  AND you read them once and move on with your life.  You don't read chapter six over and over and over and over and over again until you beat it.

Posted
7 minutes ago, Eric. said:

 

But typing is a form of communication, essential for human interaction.  Video games are not essential.  You just stare at a screen and drool on yourself.

I'm not making some ridiculous argument that technology in general is bad.  I'm saying video games turn kids into turd piles, generally.  I think it's tough to argue with that.

 

 

 

 Do you have no room for nuance in your views?  I don't think anyone here is advocating letting their kids sit transfixed in front of a screen for days on end.  The last thing I want for my daughter is for her to spend all night playing a shooter, smoking dope, eating Doritos and letting life slowly waste away.  I'm arguing that in today's environment, moderation in electronics is needed.  It's a different world from the one most of us grew up in. 

I grew up just as home video games were coming on the market, and while we played some, my days were spent outside playing hockey in the winter and baseball in the summer, and running through the woods all year round.  I have a very healthy respect for being outdoors, and we are instilling that in my daughter, as I hope most parents are as well.  I don't see being a healthy, active kid and playing video games as being mutually exclusive.  It definately takes discipline, and setting rules in the house, but it can be done.  It also very important now to allow your kids to slowly become adept and safe while online, and that can start by playing online with friends, and instilling in them simple rules about interacting/chatting online. 

  • Like 1
Posted
13 hours ago, Eric. said:

Get him a baseball glove instead and go have a catch.  No one will ever convince me that video games are good for kids.  Or adults.  Or humans of any kind.  Waste of life, sorry.

How about a hockey stick and pair of skates? ;)

Posted
11 minutes ago, Art said:

 Do you have no room for nuance in your views?

Of course I do, and I'm not naive enough to think electronics can or should be eliminated from a modern human's life.  I'm not anti-technology.  Here I am typing at my computer, chatting with people, working, researching.  It's great.

My point is that after a full day of interacting with the ipad, the phone, the computers at school, coming home and watching some TV while having a snack...the last thing they need is more screen time with video games.  And I think it's hard to deny that the overwhelming majority of young kids with gaming systems in their homes spend FAR too much time playing them.  If you're truly that regimented that you can restrict the hours effectively, then good on ya, you're a far more structured parent than I am.  But here in my house off the military base, I can only govern in a more casual way because I'm a casual guy...it's much easier to simply eliminate bad habits before they're formed.  If my kids get bored they have a million other activities to engage with that I feel are more stimulating than staring at a screen.

This argument is nearly akin to politics or religion since it's one that can't be won.  So I think I'll quit now while we're all ahead.  My initial post in this thread was only a reminder that physical activities are better than sedentary ones, and if there's one thing mushy Americans need these days, it's physical activity.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 30 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32k
    Total Topics
    437.5k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,007
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    FurniCore
    Newest Member
    FurniCore
    Joined