Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey there everyone,

I'm just starting out in woodworking - I used to do a bunch of stuff in my dad's garage and have always had a soft spot in my heart for wood projects.  The only piece of equipment I own is a DeWalt miter saw that I had to buy for a few small home projects.

I've been doing some research and I'm wanted to get some opinions on whether to bother going in for something like Festool and Powermatic equipment or if I should just go for cheaper brands, like DeWalt.  Obviously, price is a factor, so can I afford it?  Yeah I could afford a few Festool items ( I'd probably start with the router and a ROS ), and probably a P1000 table saw ( although I have 220 available - so I could maybe go higher )

But again, I'm new to woodworking - so can I justify going for the high end stuff? Is it worth it as this is just a hobby, not my source of income? Would it be better to go lower end and get more tools, like a band saw, jointer, planer, etc?  Obviously my choice of Festool/Powermatic is influenced by Mark - but any similar price/quality hardware would apply.  Is there really a middle-ground to aim for, like Jet?

I plan on getting a membership to a local Makerspace that has a bunch of tools as well to really start getting into.

Any advice appreciated!

Posted

Ultimately it depends on if you will actually stick with the hobby or not.  As a rule of thumb, assuming you're going to stick with it, buy the best that you can afford.  Buy once, cry once.  If you buy a "starter" piece of gear and stick with the hobby, it won't be long before you outgrow it and have to spend for an upgrade.  

Do your homework!  There's lots of good threads in the archives here that as a lot of the questions that you have so, that's a good place to start!

Best of luck!  I look forward to seeing your progress!

  • Like 1
Posted

I'd take a different tack and look at the range of tools used most commonly. For the big stationary tools this is the tablesaw, jointer, planer, dust collector, bandsaw, drill press and router table (I consider a mitre saw optional but it is moot as you already have one). Then your core hand power tools - ROS, router, jigsaw. Next factor in the core hand tools for joinery and finessing - set of chisels, low-angle jack plane, block plane, combination square, handsaw, shoulder plane, ruler(s) and marking gauges. Finally there is all the ancillary stuff - dust extractor, table and band saw blades, workbench, sharpening system, drill bits, router bits and so on. 

Now, make a budget and buy the best you can afford. When I've made a mistake buying a 'cheap' tool, the mistake was usually buying one without enough capacity - e.g. 6" instead of 8" jointer, 14" instead of 18" bandsaw. I find the brands of tools to be a lot less important than buying one with the right capacity and is well reviewed. I'd take an 8" Grizzly jointer over a 6" Powermatic anyday.

Welcome to the hobby and best of luck.

Posted
1 hour ago, TIODS said:

Ultimately it depends on if you will actually stick with the hobby or not.

This is true and maybe you should start out using your makerspace membership to find out whether you thick you will stick with it.  If you find that it is something for the long run then use your experience at the makerspace to determine what tools to buy first and what tools to buy for your work flow, no sense buying a tool that you don't or won't use.  But like Kev said once you start putting your shop together try to buy once cry once get the best you can afford at the time don't get hung up on a color, all your power tools don't need to match.

  • Like 2
Posted

I'm in a similar position as you.  I am just starting out, in the sense that I've always wanted to get serious about woodworking, but up to now I haven't physically had the space.  Now that I do have the space (a 2 car garage), I am going all in.  After poring over many threads, watching many videos, and planning things out, I decided to take the "buy the best that you can afford" route.  I'm lucky in that I can afford pretty good stuff, and I don't have to justify the cost.  Like you I had a mitre saw that I used for home stuff, but in the last six months have bought stuff as I needed it - a Sawstop table saw, a Hammer combo jointer/planer, a Bosch router (I still can't justify a Festool router), a Festool ROS and track saw and one of their vacuums , as well a bunch of hand tools and a decent dust collector.  I still don't have a drill press or band saw, but will pick them up when I need them.  I've been happy with this approach, and I realize that the actual stuff I've bought is likely way overkill for my actual use, but at the end of the day, it's a rewarding hobby for me, and the cost has been well worth it for me.

  • Like 2
Posted

I think you buy the best tool you can justify. You'll enjoy using it more due to quality and ease of use.  A good quality, well-tuned tool is fun to use; one you have to spend a lot of time fiddling with trying to get it to work right is frustrating.  If you use it a while then decide to get out of the hobby, the resale value is higher. If you do like it, then you're already working with a good tool and time will tell if you need to upgrade and if so you'll have a better idea of what you really want in tool x.  

Just my .02

  • Like 2
Posted

Also consider wood turning.Its very rewarding because projects can be done in a weekend.

You will learn a lot about woodworking how a sharp tool cuts,grain direction.

Sanding finish.

I think Woodturning is over looked by amateurs.Just starting out.

Aj

 

Posted

In my opinion, if you have money to spend on a good tablesaw, planer, jointer, and maybe a router, go for the best you can get. If it doesn't turn out to be your thing, you can recoup a much greater percentage reselling quality machines vs. "homeowner grade" stuff.

AJ3 has a good point, too. If you don't have immediate plans to build specific furniture projects, the rabbit hole of wood turning might be a good place to start. Or even consider going with hand tools for a while. They can get expensive as well, but don't have to to get good quality.

Whatever route you choose, remember that sharp tools are the only tools worth working with. In the machine world, that means you should expect to shell out some coin for good blades & bits & abrasives, even if your machines aren't premium. In the realm of meat power, pick one of the gazillion sharpening systems / techniques available, and learn to do it WELL.

  • Like 2
Posted
12 minutes ago, wtnhighlander said:

Whatever route you choose, remember that sharp tools are the only tools worth working with. In the machine world, that means you should expect to shell out some coin for good blades & bits & abrasives, even if your machines aren't premium. In the realm of meat power, pick one of the gazillion sharpening systems / techniques available, and learn to do it WELL.

This is sage advice right here.

  • Like 1
Posted

Thanks for the advice everyone.  I'm very much in the 'buy the best you can afford', but I've tempered that a bit with how many hobbies I have - it's definitely why I plan on trying out the maker space first to at least to get a feel of what I like/don't like about a tool.

As far as projects go, I want to try and tackle the guild Game Table, as my other huge hobby is board games ( I have over 450 of them.. ) and we are also in need of a dining table, so it seemed to be the perfect idea.

My budget ( for tools ), is about $5k, and I like the point about buying the tools you need to finish the project, so I'll probably go that route.

Regarding Festool - since I'm new and don't have a lot of equipment - is it worth it to buy into their system?  I've seen a lot of people say no, but that seems to come from people who already have a lot of tools and don't want to rebuy, sorta like a Nikon camera user switching to Canon.

Thanks again

  • Like 1
Posted

It's worth noting along the "buy the best you can afford line" - if you do that with used equipment, the risk of falling out of love with the craft is greatly reduced.  If you buy it used and then later sell because you ultimately don't enjoy woodworking, you'll be able to get most of your money back when selling it.  (Or maybe more, in some cases, if you have cleaned it up and taken care of it.)

I'm not sure that diving into expensive new stuff is a great idea, because if it doesn't work out for you, you'll lose a lot when you sell it used.  (Festool stuff is a bit of an exception.  Rarely available used, and when it is, it often sells at 80% of new, or more.)

Posted

I'm all for the buy-the-best tool strategy, but not everyone has an infinite budget. I've taken the buying the best (or near it) for some things like a jointer, bandsaw, and hand tools but for some items I have gone cheaper.

What I have done for items on the 'upgrade it eventually path' is buy tools that are both good enough for what I need out of them now, and those that hold their value well. My reasoning is that when I want to upgrade to that 20" planer with the spiral cutterhead, offloading my Dewalt 735 planer will be relatively easy and I can sell if for $100 less than retail quickly and put that towards the next one. Same with my table saw (Ridgid) and dust collector (mobile one tool at a time unit). Something like an entry level tablesaw seems to move quicker on craigslist then the mid range ones, and also easier to move into a truck. Those tools do what I need for them now and as I build the skillset I can better plan for future purchases.

Also realize that for some tools spending 50% of the price to get 90% of the capability (see Bosch jigsaw vs Festool jigsaw or Bosch gliding miter saw vs Festool miter saw) may just make more sense. These strategies have allowed me to get started without worrying about how to flatten a board without a planer.

One other thing that bites into the budget is the accessories. Saw blades, router bits, miter gauges, etc. But the nice thing about those is that when you upgrade your table saw or router, you get to keep the accessories :D

  • Like 2
Posted
To the "buy the best you can afford" rule, I'd add, "Don't buy it until you need it to finish a project." This does a couple things for you: 1) Lets you stretch out your buying dollars over time, 2) lets you experience that new-toy feeling each time you add some cool tool to the shop. I mean, why blow that feeling all at once? Make it last!

There's something to be said for "buy it when you don't need it", in that possible time pressures to finish a project might lead one to make a hasty purchasing decision. Also, not having the immediate need, one can keep an eye out for good deals.

______________________________________

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

  • Like 1
Posted

To temper Shane's Fes-thusiasm, keep in mind that although they are well-engineered and well-manufactured, their target market seems to be people like Shane, who travel from site to site as they work. So, they may not make as much sense in a stationary shop. It also seems apparent that the interconnectivity / interactivity of the Festool line means you won't get the full value if you mix them in with other brands.

I'm not knocking them, just pointing out some things to consider, given the Festool prices.

In the interest of full disclosure, I must inform you that I own exactly ZERO Festool products. I have no real idea what I'm talking about!

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 66 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined