Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Woods used in traditional Southern furniture?

Featured Replies

Been away from here for a while... got lots to update on my projects but I have a question relating to a new project I'm getting ready to start as a gift.

My FIL is a huge Civil War buff and is a member of the Sons of Confederate Veterans. His grandfather fought for the South in the Civil War. Yes, you read that right... my FIL's GRANDFATHER. He comes from a long line of VERY old men marrying VERY young women (His dad fought in WWI, too).

That all being said, I've acquired a book on some period-accurate woodworking projects for Civil War replica furniture, boxes, etc. His birthday is coming up near the end of next month and I'm thinking of making one of the projects for him. If I'm not able to get it finished by that time, it will end up being a Father's Day gift so one way or another it will get made. 

The book mentions lots of oak being used so I'm looking at some quarter-sawn white oak for the project but I'm wondering what other types of wood are native to the South and would also make for good furniture? I'd rather have some options to choose from before I start this and I figured that the Southern folks here might be able to give me some insight.

  • Author

If I could get my hands on some historic wood from the South I'd be all over that for this project but I don't think that would fit in my budget... I heard there's a pond down in Georgia somewhere that still has timbers stored in it from Civil War era ship-building but can't find any info on if it's possible to purchase any. I'm sure the shipping from there to Idaho would be insane, though.

  • Popular Post

Red oak, White Oak, Ash, Walnut, Cherry, Sassafras, Box Elder Several pines.  That should just about cover what you need.... There are a few others, like Cypress and Locust and Elm.  It sorta depends on how far South you want to go.

  • Author

Very cool... so the options are actually as broad as I had thought. I had googled it and came up with a list similar to @RichardA's there, along with a bunch more. I wondered if there were ones that were of particular use but I think @Eric. answered that nicely, as well.

I think I'm going to price out some QS White Oak and Cherry... would love to do more walnut but prices are rising quite sharply here on that. I assume that is due to the issues they are having with disease in walnut trees in other parts of the US but who knows.

1 minute ago, MisterDrow said:

Dassalottawalnut O_O

Ugly too. I love walnut, but these big walls of narrow rotary-cut panels really look tacky. Reminds me of old dark-wood paneling.

If they stop using ply on such ugly wall panels and start using solid wood, then we all will be in trouble, fighting for a piece of pine or poplar for our lil projects. So long life to plywood.

18 minutes ago, Mike. said:

They did the same thing in my last building, which was about the same age.  The lobby is a city block long and 1/2 city block wide - nearly 40,000 sq ft.  They removed the solid granite floors and replaced with white limestone.  Guess what we get in the winter here?  That is right, snow.  Guess how they keep the sidewalks safe?  That is right, salt.  Guess what happens to limestone when it gets in contact with salt?  That's right, it etches.  So they replaced a 30 year old slab granite floor that was in perfect condition with limestone that lasted exactly one winter before it was destroyed.  These designers will go to stupid lengths to make everything a shade of white.  It is my new pet peeve.  

I feel ya. Some of the other owners of apartments in my building are always proposing to remove the solid white oak panels from the walls of the hall and also the granite floors, and replace them with something more "modern"... idiots, they make me attend every single meeting we have just to prevent things like that from being decided.

  • Author
15 minutes ago, Mike. said:

 OP - sorry for the threadjack :)

 

LOL no worries. Still interesting discussion.

On researching Thousand Canker Disease, it seems that it's been spreading for several years now. It does kill the walnut tree but the bugs and fungus that make up the whole of the disease really only affect the bark and the outer parts of the sapwood. It does not damage the wood in terms of lumber usage so it seems the increase in price could simply be in anticipation of more trees dying, too.

that all being said, a good friend of ours has a VERY old Walnut tree in her backyard that has Thousand Canker and she's finally going to have to cut it down this Summer. She's already said that she is going to have her tree guy cut the trunk (which is about 3.5 feet in diameter and doesn't break until about 12 feet up) into slabs and she'll give me whatever I want from it as long as I make her something big with it. Guess I need to get some racks to dry these things on all set up.

Red oak, White Oak, Ash, Walnut, Cherry, Sassafras, Box Elder Several pines.  That should just about cover what you need.... There are a few others, like Cypress and Locust and Elm.  It sorta depends on how far South you want to go.

 

Spot on Rick.

 

 

Poplar is very common in carcasses and drawer work in South especially VA and NC. I have a line on old growth dredge cypress already dimensioned if need be. Maple is pretty common where I live so I work with it alot.

 

But I would avoid locust because most are going to be very skinny pieces left over from people making fence posts. Plus locust smells terrible when it is being cut and milled.

 

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

 

 

May be going back further than you are looking but I do know a thing or two about the Revolutionary era having spent way to much time in classrooms.  The South was divided into more of a class structure.  The wealthy would have better wood, possibly imported, while the less fortunate would have used whatever was on their land to make whatever they needed, if they even bothered.  It was also common to paint cheaper wood to look like more expensive wood.  You can see this in a lot of the homes you can tour today in both the North and South.  http://www.newsadvance.com/new_era_progress/news/local/research-confirms-poplar-forest-doors-are-jefferson-era-originals/article_6fd92f64-f87c-5d99-8214-40fc5f4b3c6f.html This article shows that Jefferson made his doors out of Walnut and finished in varnish and shellac.  Not to much has changed in good furniture. 

1 hour ago, MisterDrow said:

On researching Thousand Canker Disease, it seems that it's been spreading for several years now. It does kill the walnut tree but the bugs and fungus that make up the whole of the disease really only affect the bark and the outer parts of the sapwood. It does not damage the wood in terms of lumber usage so it seems the increase in price could simply be in anticipation of more trees dying, too.

Mike already fingered why walnut is expensive...it has nothing to do with cankers or other STDs.  Walnut is super trendy in the US right now, and China knows it.  They send their buyers over to the American mills and snatch up all the best logs before we can even crack them open, they slice them into veneers, then build garbage furniture and paneling and sell it back to us.  Lumber is a global commodity and supply and demand drive the price just like any other commodity.  And no, there's nothing Trump can do even though it's Gina and he's yooge and everything is great again.

  • Author

My FIL used to do a lot of re-enactments with a local historical club and LOVES period-accurate furniture, especially items that were used by the armies on the battlefield camps. I recently acquired this book: https://www.amazon.com/Civil-War-Woodworking-Woodworkers-Reenactors/dp/1933502282/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1490044242&sr=1-1&keywords=civil+war+woodworking and was planning on making a couple of the sling-back officer's chairs from the included projects. The plan suggested oak but said that other woods would be equally acceptable. I know the South used a LOT of white oak for ship building and furniture making but was curious what else was native to the area.

I can get 8/4 QS white oak from my local supplier for $5.44/bdft which isn't bad at all compared to other places around here. I can also get cherry for about $3.20/bdft but I may reserve that for a different project from the book. I think after the discussion here, I'll stick with the QS white oak for this but I'm excited to delve into the other projects in the book. Many of them are very simple but could easily be dressed up to be a more fancy piece as well while still maintaining the spirit of the design.

And thanks for the clarification, Eric. I fully understand the demand aspect with regard to pricing of goods/materials. I think it was Marc on the Wood Talk podcast recently who first talked about how prices could be going up due to the Thousand Canker junk. I had asked our supplier about it and the sales guy I spoke with didn't know why the prices had gone up recently (went up from $5.75/bdft to almost $7 in a few months). Still a good price, though. Maybe I just haven't been a part of the hobby long enough to see how widely prices can fluctuation in short periods of time, though.

9 minutes ago, Eric. said:

And no, there's nothing Trump can do even though it's Gina and he's yooge and everything is great again.

So wait... Are you telling me those fellas are gonna get those walnut logs over the wall? 

53 minutes ago, Llama said:

So wait... Are you telling me those fellas are gonna get those walnut logs over the wall? 

 

 

 

White pine and poplar were common secondary woods. Dogwood if you are a masochist !

 

Hey now.... I'm more of sadist personally.

 

That being said I've used some Dogwood limbs to make some little display pieces like a candle holder and picture stand. It planes super smooth, paper white wood, and will accept just about any stain. Maybe the heartwood is crazy to deal with but I haven't seemed to have that problem.

 

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

 

 

  • Popular Post

Dogwood heartwood is one of the hardest I have ever tried to saw. 2150 Janka hardness. It dulls cutting edges pretty quick too.

  • Popular Post

I dunno how things were in the 1860s, but these days, woods like walnut and cherry aren't doing so well in my part of the South. Oak (red & white), poplar, and pine all grow like weeds, though. And then there is 'aromatic' eastern red cedar / juniper. That stuff really is a weed.

  • Popular Post

If you get some sinker Cypress, it may have actually been there when the South was still fighting.

52 minutes ago, Brendon_t said:

when the South was still fighting

They stopped?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.