Popular Post krtwood Posted November 14, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted November 14, 2017 I had a Grizzly 6" x 80" edge sander for many years and it's been an indispensable tool. The thing is when you have a tool that does a particular thing well you start designing around the limits of that tool. I have a 14" band saw with a riser that can at least theoretically cut 12" deep curves but since my edge sander only does 6" I tend to not use the band saw beyond that, at least for curves. So I longed for an edge sander with more capacity. The trouble is beyond 6" there's one realistic option, a Powermatic 9" x 138" 800 lb behemoth that costs $5500. That doesn't even get me the full depth and if I could afford it I couldn't fit it my shop and if I could fit it in my shop I would die trying to get it into the basement. Beyond the Powermatic you are looking at industrial "drawer sanders" with 10 HP motors so if you've stolen a sheet of MDF from the box store and the police are pounding on the door you can turn it into sawdust before they can break it down to get rid of the evidence. But really how often do you need to do that? So my point being that this capacity machine just doesn't exist in the market so it became clear that if I wanted it I was going to have to build it myself. Besides the vertical capacity there was another function that I really wanted. When you sand a convex curve you can get great results against the straight platen on the sander. However when you sand a concave curve the closer the radius of the sander matches the curve of the part the better the results you get. I think anyone who has tried to use a spindle sander to sand a shallow curve on a rail or something like that is familiar with what I'm talking about. It's really hard to get a perfect surface and you end up having to spend a fair bit of time having to finesse it by hand. So I wanted one of the rollers to be as large as practical. The side effect of this is that it creates a space inside of the sanding belt where the motor can go, rather than hanging underneath the drive roller. This in turn frees up the space under the machine for belt storage. With my Grizzly I built a rack to hang the belts off the side of it which greatly increased the footprint of the machine. Another side effect is that there's enough room over that roller to have a decently large table so you can continue the drive shaft up through and have a spindle sander. Unfortunately because you have to lower the rpms of that shaft to get the proper belt speed the spindle sander is running much slower than it should be. But you get this basically for free so why not? So this is where the name comes from - Edge Spindle Curve. Also the table support on the Grizzly was a joke. On paper it looks like it's easy to move the table up and down but in practice it's a pain so I never did that. So it was a priority to make the table easy to raise and lower. The table has to wrap around both ends to make it possible to use the large drive roller, which really complicated the dust collection. Despite the pretty massive table, the machine actually takes up about the same footprint as the Grizzly when you include the belt storage I added to it. I used a 1.5 hp motor because my shop doesn't have 220V (except the DC). It's a bit under-powered, considering the Grizzly was also 1.5 hp, but it's done everything I have asked it to do. When you're sanding a curve there isn't very much of the part in contact with the belt at any one time regardless of how thick it is. This is not the tool for flattening end grain cutting boards, even though it looks like it should be able to do it. So here is the short, edited version. There's a long build series on my second channel that this video links to if you want all the details. If you ignore the dust collection it's a pretty simple build. 4 2 Quote
Mark J Posted November 14, 2017 Report Posted November 14, 2017 Very cool. As impressed as I am with the design and execution I am even more impressed that you were able to figure out in advance every part you would need exactly and cut them out with the CNC. At least it looked that way--tell me you had to go back and cut some of them a second time. Quote
krtwood Posted November 14, 2017 Author Report Posted November 14, 2017 The only parts I cut on the cnc were the circles for the rollers. Quote
Chet Posted November 14, 2017 Report Posted November 14, 2017 That looks like a great solution to all that you wanted it to do. I don't know when you built this but if you have been using it for a while is there anything that you would do different if you were to do it over? Quote
krtwood Posted November 15, 2017 Author Report Posted November 15, 2017 8 hours ago, Chet said: That looks like a great solution to all that you wanted it to do. I don't know when you built this but if you have been using it for a while is there anything that you would do different if you were to do it over? I finished it a few months ago. The main issue I really have with it at this point is that the belt tracking is still iffy. But I don't have any better ideas on how to do it differently. It would also be nice if the dust collection didn't become completely useless when sanding on the drive roller end. I think the DC could attach with sort of a bayonet mount and be repositioned at the back of the machine. Quote
Tom King Posted November 15, 2017 Report Posted November 15, 2017 Awesome! I want one, and don't even do any sanding to amount to anything. Quote
Coop Posted November 15, 2017 Report Posted November 15, 2017 I’m still trying to get over the video. Brilliant job on both! Quote
kyokahn Posted November 16, 2017 Report Posted November 16, 2017 That's a great machine! Would you be able to swap out the motor for something bigger if needed in the future? Sanding full faces is probably too much at that size for 1.5hp. I read somewhere that adding a strip or two (or quite a few in your case) of tape in the middle of your drums could help the tracking quite a bit, maybe you can experiment a bit with that? Anyway, thanks for sharing! That was pretty cool. Quote
wdwerker Posted November 17, 2017 Report Posted November 17, 2017 Sanders with undersized motors just need less pressure and more patience! Trust me if you put too much pressure on a underpowered sander the breaker blows pretty soon. But with a little patience you can pull off some incredible results. Worn abrasives and undersized motors aren't a good combo either. But newer abrasives are far cheaper than a bigger circuit and a bigger motor ! And 12" x 89" belts aren't cheap ! Quote
krtwood Posted November 17, 2017 Author Report Posted November 17, 2017 11 hours ago, kyokahn said: That's a great machine! Would you be able to swap out the motor for something bigger if needed in the future? Sanding full faces is probably too much at that size for 1.5hp. I read somewhere that adding a strip or two (or quite a few in your case) of tape in the middle of your drums could help the tracking quite a bit, maybe you can experiment a bit with that? Anyway, thanks for sharing! That was pretty cool. That motor is in there snug as a bug but it's certainly not the smallest 1.5 hp I've ever seen. It would also be potentially possible to relocate the capacitor(s) on a larger motor since it's one of the caps that's almost touching the belt with this one. There's already more crown on the drive roller than the belt will conform to. It doesn't touch the roller at the edges. So one potential remedy is to reduce the crown. Matthias thinks it's because the two rollers aren't parallel to each other in the axis opposite to the one that rotates for the tracking. I can adjust that but it's already dead on square as close as I can see so I would just be guessing at shimming it. Haven't got around to trying it as it's the busy season now. 1 Quote
kyokahn Posted November 17, 2017 Report Posted November 17, 2017 1 hour ago, krtwood said: It doesn't touch the roller at the edges. So one potential remedy is to reduce the crown Yes, if it's more crown than the belt can wrap around it gives a little more room to go off its track. I think other than referencing to the surface and making sure they're at the same angle from the base in all directions, any efforts to shim it could make it worse. Do you have one of those digital angle meter thingies? Going around both rollers with one of those should give you the same reading all around, if they are, it's just a matter of raising or lowering without changing the angle and trial and error from there. *image for comedic purposes, mostly* Quote
krtwood Posted November 18, 2017 Author Report Posted November 18, 2017 The way the idle roller bracket is made is with a dovetail that is just held by one screw and no glue. So it's easy to add a shim to experiment with it, and if it doesn't work it will go right back where it was before. Getting to the one on top is easy. The lower one is much harder to get to which is why I haven't tried it yet. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.