Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

The Robots are Stealing our Jobs!!

Featured Replies

Not really. 

Mods, if this is in the wrong place please move it. 

I heard about this story yesterday and thought it was cool so I'm posting it here. It's about automation coming to the shop. The article plugs it was a safety device since the robot cuts the wood not a person. Looks kinda of clunky now but I'm sure a production machine will have all the kinks worked out. For me, if it can cut straighter lines than I can I'm all in. 

https://www.theverge.com/2018/2/28/17058532/robot-carpentry-automated-mit-assisted-furniture

What, precisely, are they trying to achieve?  Hacking a Roomba with a jigsaw to cut a circle?  I suppose the only advantage over a CNC router is that you could cut right into an inside corner with that.

The only potentially novel idea I saw was Ms. Schulz's idea to have scale-able parameters in the design of a table, allowing for the best of both worlds:  automated production speed plus custom specs which are tested for stress in real time.

Supposedly one of these students trained originally as a carpenter and we're given a vision of a future in which carpenters will "go to their jobsite, punch in some numbers, and have robots bring them a cut piece."  Perhaps some builders on the forum could give us a sense: How much do you see of homes being framed stick-by-stick on site versus how much do you see of panelized homes being framed offsite and delivered to the jobsite?

Beyond that, I choked a bit on the pull quote:  "Wood is not a futuristic material--but it does have a future."  Cute, these students certainly are.

Context as a builder. I see almost no panelized homes. I see 75% stick built and maybe as much as 15% factory built “trailer” homes. Know this, I am speaking from a massive “trailer home” hub. They get shipped out all over, but the saturation rate still goes to the stick builders. Panelized homes here are in the 10% that exists with log homes or ICF homes. Obviously this might vary by region, but consider a thing or two. Precut studs were designed to do this very kind of thing. If you automate the cutting to give yourself the right length on the vast majority of wall studs, then you increase efficiency. Bringing the robot to the job requires hardiness. I think that might be where you where going? Automation truly shines where you control the atmosphere in the shop. Trouble shooting on the road in the rain is no fun. 

Working for  a state university system I see the NSF supply grants for a lot of stuff that seems odd to me.  The research and sometimes fabrication being done is exploring a scientific model.  The results get applied to things that often bear little resemblance to the research effort. 

That being said, we have certainly seen robots doing much more complex things, on a larger scale and in a more refined manner.  I don't think the hammer-swingers have much to worry about for a while yet.  When an autonomous android costs about what a mid-size car costs . .. then things will get interesting ;-) 

I recall back in the 70s where there were houses built in sections and assembled on site.  Don't see that anymore.  Scottish Inns were the same- the rooms were lined up and stacked like kid's blocks.  Stayed in one once.  The floor sagged in the middle.  Start at one corner, walk downhill and then back uphill as you got closer to the opposite diagonal corner.

Edit:  I recall an engineer telling of visiting an aluminum foundry in Japan in the mid 70s.  It was totally automated with only a handful of people working the foundry.  He said it was rather spooky looking out of the control room and there were only a couple of people on the foundry floor.

A lot of university engineering research is "proof of concept".  The concept is interesting, but the researchers just implement the bare minimum to prove that it's possible. And then some reporter videos the roomba with a jigsaw duct taped on top.

The big deal here is not that a robot can cut a circle, but that a customer can go to a website, select a cabinet, and then adjust the width from 48" to 42" and the height up to 50" and press submit.  The order goes to a program which pumps out the new design, and the CNC factory pumps it out without missing a beat.

Think kitchen cabinets, where you're happy with a design picked from a catalog or showroom, but want custom dimensions.  The same thing could be applied to a table or a dresser, for example.  "I like this dining room table, but my dining room is (bigger/smaller), so I want to change the dimensions."

The core of this is that a person needs to design the cabinet, design the CNC work flow to make it, and then make the whole thing "parameterized".  Instead of cutting the back 48x40, the back is cut WxH, depending on the width and height specified.  The doors which were 23.5" at 48 inches are now (W/2)-0.5, because the reveal is fixed and doesn't scale.  And the hinge position is fixed regardless of the dimensions.  You end up with a design for a cabinet that will work for any dimensions within specified limits (you can't use it to make a 10" x 8" cabinet, because at that size you need a completely different selection of molding, hardware, reveals, etc).  Artificial intelligence might, in the future, be able to take a design and program the factory to make it, but you still need a person to do the design.

I assume that Ikea and other large volume furniture manufacturers are already totally automated for fixed designs, so those jobs are already lost. This research just suggests a way to make semi-custom furniture with the same sort of mass production as non-custom.

38 minutes ago, Bankstick said:

I recall back in the 70s where there were houses built in sections and assembled on site.  Don't see that anymore.  Scottish Inns were the same- the rooms were lined up and stacked like kid's blocks.  Stayed in one once.  The floor sagged in the middle.  Start at one corner, walk downhill and then back uphill as you got closer to the opposite diagonal corner.

Edit:  I recall an engineer telling of visiting an aluminum foundry in Japan in the mid 70s.  It was totally automated with only a handful of people working the foundry.  He said it was rather spooky looking out of the control room and there were only a couple of people on the foundry floor.

Actually they still do this. A forum member had his shop build this way. Also there were some apartment builds i saw built in western ND that were brought in section son semis and then lifted and set into place.

They built a motel near me out of trucked in modules. They built those in factories under controlled conditions and use nail guns, overhead lifts and an assembly line approach. I don't think robots are involved.  Entire walls are built, sheathed, flipped and the interior applied while it's laying flat then lifted and installed on the module. No weather delays, bulk buying and repeated layouts are some of the big advantages.

I saw a show about an entire neighborhood that was built in a temporary steel building onsite a few houses at a time. Complete 2-3 story houses roof and all then moved to an awaiting foundation. When the neighborhood was done they took the steel building down and moved it to the next project . 

Like I said, I haven't seen that in years but seems to still be active in other parts of the country.  I have seen homes similar to this on manufactured home lots (not called house trailers anymore due to some regulations) that were two story.  Delivered in  pieces and put together on site.

If it's delivered and installed on suitable piers & strapped down. Then the wheels taken off, that's called " Manufactured Housing" 

If it's just got corner jack posts and you can hook it to a truck to drive off it's a " Mobile Home " or House Trailer.  I think some of the distinction is for how they qualify for financing. If you can move it easily how are they gonna repo it if you quit making payments. Thus the reputation of " Trailer Trash " 

It's also related to zoning, I think - at least around here.  

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.