Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Grinder Dust Collection

Featured Replies

Looking for some dust collection solutions at the grinder.

I have a grinder with CBN wheels and sharpening produces a good bit of particulate steel debris.  I was starting to ponder how to do DC, but was thinking maybe this problem has already been solved.  

My set up has two CBN wheels with the guards removed.  I was thinking about a hose clamp to position either the shop vac hose or 4" DC hose near the bottom of the wheel.

Yeah this screams fire risk to me. I think the best way to deal with it is let the stuff cool and vacuum it up after the fact. Or build a housing around it if possible to contain the mess.

I put a wet paper towel under the wheel, and it catches a lot of it.  I think most of us that use CBN wheels have the guards removed, mainly because the wheels don't fit in the typical grinder guard.  I'm sure it's still nowhere near the detritus created with a friable wheel though.

Even so, I'm going to go back to wet grinding, as soon as I see enough positive reviews of the Tormek diamond wheels.  I can't dry grind in the houses I work on, so the grinder has to be kept outside.   I'll never go back to friable wheels though, for woodworking edges. 

  • Author
1 hour ago, Chestnut said:

Yeah this screams fire risk to me. I think the best way to deal with it is let the stuff cool and vacuum it up after the fact. Or build a housing around it if possible to contain the mess.

Oh yeah, there's that.  Glad I asked.  CBN's don't make much sparks, but there's some.  So on to plan B, then.

Damp paper towel is easy.  Would there be such a thing as sticky paper?  I am thinking of a smaller version of the sticky foot mats you see at construction sites.

I was also thinking of a tray under the wheel, removable and easy to dump, could have a bit of water in the bottom.

What about one of those strong magnets?  I could put it in a small Ziplock and leave it under the wheel.  Then periodically peel off the bag to discard the fillings.

@Tom Kingthey do make a CBN wheel for the Tormek (e.g. Woodturning Wonders), but it is  supposed to be used dry.  Can the diamond wheels be immersed?

Mouse trap pads?

I wonder if a pan with grease would just end up making a mess inadvertently? Might catch better than water long term because it wn't evaporate but bump it and instant mess.

Maybe one or two of those big Rockler silicone glue mats would contain it all and be able to be cleaned up whenever necessary?

  • Author

Well here's what I've come up with so far.  I decided to pursue the sticky door mat idea.  I bought "Step N Peel" from Menards.  It's $20 for 30 sheets. The sheets are 24 x 30 inches so that can be cut into 6 smaller pads (the material cuts easily).  The product comes with 30 numbered tabs on one corner that have no adhesive, so you have a  place to grab the expended sheet when pulling it off.  

Thing is it's impossible to pull off just one sheet without the tab.  So,before cutting them out, I laboriously peeled back the edges of each sheet to put my own paper tabs in the corners of my smaller pads.  Well, I dd 15 sheets before I got tired of it and decided to just try what I had.  After all it might not work.   Here's a couple of pictures showing the pads in place. 

 SAM_1312.thumb.JPG.c6c75b2d024fd73d02ed31575249f57d.JPG

SAM_1313.thumb.JPG.c67dcb4f45fbffcc11a7e8f48aec723d.JPG

I have to say it worked pretty well.  Here's an after use picture.  You can see the faint haze of metal particles.  

SAM_1314.thumb.JPG.0c7fc66e8a4c369ae1cbb1b599a15b4f.JPG

The metal particles appear well adhered to the pad, but after one use I think the pad may be saturated.  There's not much stickiness left right under the wheel.  And some particles fly out beyond the pad, so there's still that mess.  Overall it's very much better than nothing, but the damp paper towel may be just a simpler solution.  I'll keep goofing with this idea and see where it goes.  

One idea that crosses my mind is to just use the whole floor mat pad.  Put the pad on a board, then place the grinder on the pad.  The pad should be big enough to collect most of the debris.  You would have to pick up the grinder every time you changed sheets, though.  

How much space do you need under the wheel could you make a chute that goes back to a container and then just empty that? I know it's complicated to build but ..... it might be worth it? OR even get one of the  slow and narrow DC shrouds and have it dump on a blast gate then just open the gate to empty it into a container?

Now that I see a picture it's making a lot more sense.

  • Author

Don't need much space under the wheels or below the tool rest bar.

I want to contain the dust and keep it from contaminanting my work area.  The idea is to keep the sharpening station near the lathe for frequent tool sharpening, but the grinder is a lot more messy than I had given it credit for.

After I go through these adhesive sheets I may try fashioning  collection trays from aluminum pie pans.  That would require eating some pies, but some sacrafices have to be made in the interest of woodworking science.  

Maybe I'm missing something, but why not just put a box around the grinder, since this looks like a permanent setup? You could leave the front open, and enclose the sides, back, and top, leaving maybe 1" clearance from the wheels. I'm assuming you really only need access to the front portion of the wheel. If you're worried about fire risk, make it from sheet metal or just line the lower part of the inside with sheet metal. It would keep it all contained, and you could just vacuum it out periodically. It's probably not all that much work to build (you could try it with cardboard to see if it works) and it wouldn't require any ongoing effort.

  • Author

I like the idea of building walls around the grinder.  That could be easily done with cardboard and I don't see any real fire risk with CBN's.  

But it's looking like the magnet idea might have some merit.  All I had in the way of rare earth magnets were 3 quarter size magnets.  But I had to touch up one of my tools today so I put them into so some zip lock bags and replaced the sticky mat with the magnets.  

Here's a picture after sharpening the tool.  Wasn't that much metal taken off, but you can see the dust sticking to the front and bag magnets.  The side one didn't do much.

SAM_1380.thumb.JPG.07722b336a3470e0d2b9ea9744dc88e7.JPG

There was surprisingly little dust in between the bags, but this was easy to sweep up with the magnets.  Took them over to the garbage can and removed them easily from their bags whereupon the metal dust fell into the can.  Re-used the bags.  

I am going to goof with this some more and see where it goes.  Next time I may put all three magnets under to wheel.  I will look for a 2 inch long bar.  I would suggest freezer weight ziplocks, too.  The magnets stick to each other and other things like the metal base of the grinder (fortunately the  wheel is aluminum) and it takes a lot of pulling to get them apart.  

  • Author

After a little research I decided to stick with the little magnets I have.  The pulling force of these things seems to go as the volume.  The little bars I saw had like ten pounds of pull which seemed like a lot for this application.  

Today I did try using a collection tray as well as one of the magnets.

20181028_153008.thumb.jpg.65af9ff22f17e56aa5558d331806f874.jpg

You might want to use something less valuable than this hand formed aluminum vessel with vintage patina, but the idea worked well.  It gives better reach out in front of the wheel.

Harbor Freight has the magnetic thingies for free with a purchase. I have one and got one for my son. Handy as a pocket on a tee shirt!

  • 10 months later...
  • Author
  • Popular Post

I'm returning to this thread because there's been some further evolution.  

First the magnets in an aluminum pan idea worked well as long as I was using the Tormek jigs which left plenty of space under the open CBN wheels.  They collected almost all, but not 100%, of the metal dust.  Clean up is a little bit of a nuisance and really needs to done after each session.  

Can't remember if I explained this before, but the ziploc bag is essential.  To clean the magnets open the bag over the trash.  Dip a screwdriver in to retrieve the magnet.  With your fingers pinched above the magnet squeege off the metal bits as you move the magnet up past your fingers.  Then drop the magnet back in the bag.  

Like I said, works well.  But whenever I sought help with sharpening lathe tools I realized the rest of world all have the Wolverine system so I decided I needed one, too.  And turners are always one tool away from greatness.  

The Wolverine takes up most of the space under the wheels.  I tried to work around this for a while, but the dust collection was definitely not as good.  

Then enter last month's American Woodturner Magazine.  There's an article in the tips section where one of the members (Mitchell Friedman, to give him credit) had put together an attachment to collect dust at his grinder with PVC pipe.  The Editor's note indicated the the procedure should be safe if the vacuum was dedicated to the task and did not contain wood dust, etc.  The Editors also recommend grounding the PVC pipe.  

20190915_203356_Burst01.thumb.jpg.778eef2e8819a8a96b03cb75193fa06f.jpg

20190915_203446.thumb.jpg.41d5ee2200dee887a25476a7c3422052.jpg

20190915_203323.thumb.jpg.447ba9b2aaa6f1bdc6fcea80eeaee3bc.jpg

I have a clean dedicated vac, but am not planning to ground the PVC as I don't see what a static spark could ignite (and I'm not sure how to do it).

It's 1 1/2" pipe.  Two 60's, two 90's two 1' sections, a T and a plug as well as an adaptor to the vac pipe.  Friction fit and held in place with gravity.  

I have used it to shape two new gouges, which is a lot of grinding, and refresh one gouge, as well.  I looked into the vac and found quite a bit of metal in there, so I think it works at least as well as the magnets.  Very good, but like 95%.  Also after the test I decided to install a clean, new filter bag.  I really don't believe it's a fire hazzard, but I can see that cleaning out the vacuum could get ugly.  And by the way I figure to empty the bag when it's at 5%.  No way am I going to be able handle 14 gallons of steel dust.  

 

 

I wonder if an ash vacuum would be better/easier to empty. I imagine it will take you a while to fill up 14 gallons of steel dust.

I just vacuum with a round nozzle after the particles have cooled...usually an hour or more when I do the whole shop. I don't vacuum right away after sharpening.

I'm giving up on dry grinding, and going back to a wet grinder, for this type of grinding.  One like I want is not made, so I'm planning to cobble one together myself.  I don't want to give up on the non-diameter changing advantage of the CBN wheels, so the plan is to go with wet diamond wheels.  I had given up thinking about it for a while, but this weekend I saw (new to me) reversing servo motors for commercial sewing machines, which solves the previously very expensive variable speed reversing motor problem.  The sewing machine servo motors are less than a couple of hundred dollars for a nice motor, and controls.  There will have to be a belt drive to a spindle holding a couple of wheels.  My sharpening sink is 92" long, so it can sit on that drainboard.

Beings that we are having grinder discussions. Low speed grinders show up a lot for sharpening tools. Is there a point to have a high speed grinder around if I'm never going to do metal work? Could i use the low speed grinder for other grinding tasks like sharpening my mower blade or taking a 1/4" off of a screw?

  • Author

My answer is yes.  In fact I'm not sure what a high speed grinder would be for.  The 1750 RPM of a "low" speed is already fast and more than aggressive enough.  

Tom, I don't blame you one bit.  It's the best dust containment system, and it's great to be able to flush the debris away. 

But wet grinding when I have to reshape a heavy metal tool just exceeds my patience.  And faucet and sink are some distance away for me.  

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.