Popular Post Tom King Posted January 22, 2019 Popular Post Report Posted January 22, 2019 I got the call to redo a professionally done large format floor, that didn't suit the homeowner. I've installed a lot of tile over the years, but this was my first time with large format. If anyone is planning to install some yourself, I've learned some things that will probably be useful to you that you won't find on youtube. If no one really can use the info, I won't bother. 3 Quote
Isaac Posted January 22, 2019 Report Posted January 22, 2019 How large were the tile and what were the issues? Excessive lippage? Were they some of the long slender plank ones, or the real beast squares? I've generally only seen the big square ones in commercial spaces over concrete slabs or occasionally in residential basements. Quote
Tom King Posted January 22, 2019 Author Report Posted January 22, 2019 These were just 12 x 24. The problem was lippage, in a room that will be occupied by people of all ages, barefoot out of the lake many times. On concrete, in a daylight basement room, but really badly out of level. 1 Quote
Isaac Posted January 22, 2019 Report Posted January 22, 2019 12 x 24 is already pretty darn big! They probably weigh 10 lbs a piece, right? Glad you were able to straighten it out for them. I am curious to hear what you were learned, but don't want you going too much trouble just for me. Quote
Popular Post Chestnut Posted January 22, 2019 Popular Post Report Posted January 22, 2019 I'm curious but i'm not sure i want Tom to show me all the stuff i did wrong on the large format tile job i did. Then again i sold that house.... 3 Quote
Tpt life Posted January 22, 2019 Report Posted January 22, 2019 I’d be surprised you have anything Sal Diblasio has not covered on YouTube. That said, I started his vids because I have a job in my future. I am all ears Quote
drzaius Posted January 22, 2019 Report Posted January 22, 2019 I have a bit of a tile fetish & love doing it. I've done 1 kitchen with a less than level subfloor in 12 x 24 & it certainly had its challenges. Please do share any tricks, tips or pitfalls that you encounter. Years ago I got a Dewalt D24000 tile saw, & for light use, it is very good. It won't match the brute force of the big commercial saws, but it's so much nicer to move, store, and use than those guys. It really is a sweet tool & I highly recommend it. Quote
Popular Post Tom King Posted January 22, 2019 Author Popular Post Report Posted January 22, 2019 I had never used the leveling systems before, never having laid large format before. I bought the T-loc, that seems to me the most popular, and the RTC screw type. https://www.amazon.com/Spin-Doctor-Leveling-System-100pc/dp/B01IACPX9M/ref=sr_1_8?hvadid=177788134688&hvdev=c&hvlocphy=9009793&hvnetw=g&hvpos=1t1&hvqmt=b&hvrand=4018255558700068644&hvtargid=aud-589036435099%3Akwd-205661006409&ie=UTF8&keywords=spin+doctor+tile+leveling+system&qid=1548199603&sr=8-8&tag=googhydr-20 The T-loc system uses the wedges, and special pliers. The wedges have grooves on the top, which I felt was unnecessary, and aggravating. The screw down type are more infinitely adjustable. The trouble with the screw type is that you have to have strong fingers, so don't get the mechanical advantage of the pliers. I ended up not using the pliers for the T-locs, but sent the pliers back after the first day, and decided not to use that system anyway. One thing that I haven't seen discussed is that you can't depend on the leveling system to pull a tile up. They can push one down easily, or at least on normal consistency thinset. We had to use the minimum amount of water, since the thickness was so uneven on the floor. Do some experimenting to start with, measuring the water, to make sure you can repeat it exactly like you want it, but still in the range stated on the back of the bag. This is not really that important on a normal job, but this was nothing like normal, so the recipe for water to thinset was critical. We spent the first couple of hours getting the ratio down perfectly. The owners had a moisture problem in this 2 million dollar, fairly new house, and didn't want all the water used on a floor leveling pour introduced into the house air, so we had to find some other way. By the time we got to the second row, having started in the high corner of the room, the thinset was about an inch in the middle of the room, and back to 5/8" at the other end. We let that row set the first day. It was not stable enough to help with any pulling of the next row. After that, I decided to get the floor into a much better level using various combinations of 1/2" and 1/4" backer board. That made it go along much better, and 1 ounce more water in the thinset mix made a noticeable difference in workability. One trouble the previous installers had was getting the grout joints even. They had depended on the stems of the leveling system to set the grout joint spacing. I found out real quick that wasn't going to work. If the tiles were perfectly all the same size, and the thinset bed consistant thickness, they might have. Desired grout joint was 3/16. After using those the first day, I ordered some 1/8" stems. After the thinner stems came, we went back to work on it. I used regular tile spacers. I like the Tavy ones, and by eye in some places because the tiles were not exactly the same width. Another thing the thinner stem spacers let you do, which is much like, but not quite as good as laying tile without them, is to lay the tile hard in the corner, get it down very close to final height, and then slide it sideways. This keeps the grout joint clean, so you don't have to fiddle around with a sponge, and tool to get squeezeout off, and out of the joints. Full thickness spacers on the stems leave no margin for error, and you can't tighten up any joint just a little bit. The screw levelers were just used to pull the tile being laid down, and one of the screw caps used as a lippage feeler. I have always used a Tavy puck for feeling lippage, but the RTC screw caps are more critical than the puck, and they needed to be close at hand anyway. The tiles were not perfectly flat, so almost every tile had to be compromised here, and there. The owners liked the results, and I explained that they could not be laid to be exactly, perfectly even all over. As an example, if you leveled both ends exactly with its adjoining tile there might be an objectionable lippage in the middle of that tile. That would have had even less lippage if the directions on the tile boxes were followed to only offset the tiles less than 1/3, but the owners wanted half offset, so this is the way it was. You can walk on them, and not feel the lippage, unless you really try, and that is before grouting. My tile saw doesn't have a 24" length of cut, if you use the push fence on the tray, but I just let the tiles ride over that until the back of the tile was ahead of the push bar ( much like pushing a board though the table saw), and then finished the long cuts normally. The long tiles would also hit the water pump, so we hung a bucket over the side, and dropped the water pump in the bucket. Mike kept the bucket filled with a hose, while I ran the tiles. I actually liked this setup, because it kept pumping clean water over the saw blade, rather than recirculating the muddy water. I would have to do this every day to invest in another tile saw, but I am absolutely not going to do that anyway. The pros also had not back buttered the tiles, and some of them had come up, so I was told. The owners had it demoed before they came begging to me. Their house is right down the road from our house. Fortunately, the owners had bought a whole pallet of these tiles, which was much more than this job needed. We laid out enough tiles, at the end of each day, for the next day, plus some extras. I used a straightedge to pick the flattest ones, but every day when we came back, some of the tiles we had laid out were not as flat as they were the day before. I don't know where these tiles came from, but they had the sprayed on pattern of glazing on the top. The pattern never repeated, so they probably weren't quite as cheap as the ones you buy in the box stores, with the repeating pattern. All I know is that they came from Maryland. I won't do a job like this again without making sure the floor is perfectly level to start with again. The first day, we only laid 12 tiles. We improved it a lot with the backer board, but it was nearly impossible to get it perfectly flat with the thick thinset method. I ended up buying a couple of extra 1/2 x 1/2 trowels, and grinding the slots out deeper on two of them. That helped, but with the slots taller than deep, they didn't work as good as symmetrical slots to allow you to seat the tile fully. Some things you might already know, and it especially applied on this job, that amplified every possible error, is to make your final pull with the trowel only in straight lines. If you don't, it can trap air pockets under the tile. With straight rows, when you wiggle it sideways to the ridges, they lay down nicely. When we first started, I had to eyeball the proper height of the ridges, and that was almost impossible without multiple tries, which meant a tile had to be taken up, and tried again on the stiff thinset. Fortunately, there is a thinset especially for large format tiles that can withstand being laid thick, but it's not as easy to work with as the normal stuff. We still have a couple of days left to finish up this job. I don't know if any of this was clear, or if I left anything out. Laying tile is normally a simple job, but this was anything but. The youtube videos of large format tile laying make it look easy, which I'm sure it is on a level floor. This was anything but. I actually won't mind doing it again on a level floor, but don't want to anytime soon. Every little error is accentuated with large format tile that doesn't flex. Some of the really large ones do flex some, so the levelers work easily on those. With tiles like these, they just help you find the best compromise. I'd estimate the worst here to be .010 (at the most), but if that was doubled without finding the compromise, it is very noticeable. The grout should make it even out better, so it won't hurt bare feet. I walked on it barefoot, sliding my feet, and it's going to be okay, but right now it's not comfortable without grout in the joints. I think the original installers must have just laid it on the floor like you would for 12 x 12's, which are way more forgiving, even on an unlevel floor. If you have never laid floor tile before, I'd strongly advise not to start with anything larger than 12x12. I have laid a lot of that over the years, and never even thought about using any kind of leveling system, so had some feel for it before starting this. 5 Quote
pkinneb Posted January 23, 2019 Report Posted January 23, 2019 Thanks for the info Tom!! I might have to rethink the tile for my basement... Quote
Tom King Posted January 23, 2019 Author Report Posted January 23, 2019 It wouldn't be so bad if you went with a 12 x 12 . Quote
drzaius Posted January 23, 2019 Report Posted January 23, 2019 Boy, I wish I'd have known about the levelling systems when I did an 18" x 18" tile job. Would have made the job so much easier. @Tom King, do those 12 x 24 tiles have a curvature to them? The ones I used in that kitchen had the middle bowed up about 1/16" higher than the ends. That made it much easier to get things more acceptably flat on the uneven floor cause it kept the corners from sticking up proud. Quote
Tom King Posted January 23, 2019 Author Report Posted January 23, 2019 There is no consistency in the curvature. They mostly have a curvature down in the middle. Coming right out of a box, on the pallet stack, they are pretty flat. Left overnight, like we do with wood for it to acclimate, the curvature shows up the next day. Fortunately, it's nothing like as much as 1/16", but what makes it worse is they have pretty pointed corners on the edges, with no taper at all. Poorly designed overall, but the owners didn't want to change tiles now. Some better shopping for tile would have made it so much easier to do a good job. I expect the weight in the cube on the pallet flattens them out, but they must have some stress in them. Laid normally, on a thin bed of thinset, it probably wouldn't matter as much, but when laid on a thick bed, the stress has time to come out before the mortar can set hard enough to hold them. Quote
drzaius Posted January 23, 2019 Report Posted January 23, 2019 The curvature on the tiles was actually a good thing. We set them in a running bond, so the corners of the tile were always just a little lower than the edge of the next tile. That was especially helpful where there was hump (one joist was high) that ran across the width of the room. It may not have been as much as 1/16", but it was enough to help keep those corners from being proud, while not being obviously curved. It was pretty consistent from tile to tile. It was for my daughter's kitchen & I'm just glad they didn't want 12 x 48 tiles. I think I'd have declined. Quote
Chestnut Posted January 23, 2019 Report Posted January 23, 2019 47 minutes ago, drzaius said: The curvature on the tiles was actually a good thing. We set them in a running bond, so the corners of the tile were always just a little lower than the edge of the next tile. That was especially helpful where there was hump (one joist was high) that ran across the width of the room. It may not have been as much as 1/16", but it was enough to help keep those corners from being proud, while not being obviously curved. It was pretty consistent from tile to tile. It was for my daughter's kitchen & I'm just glad they didn't want 12 x 48 tiles. I think I'd have declined. Did you have to back butter the tiles then? I'd be concerned about not getting enough thin set in the middle. Quote
Brendon_t Posted January 24, 2019 Report Posted January 24, 2019 On 1/22/2019 at 11:31 AM, Chestnut said: I'm curious but i'm not sure i want Tom to show me all the stuff i did wrong on the large format tile job i did. Then again i sold that house.... Same.. 12x24s in the bathroom and shower Quote
Chestnut Posted January 24, 2019 Report Posted January 24, 2019 At first go i thought you got a call back on your own job. I was about to say something to the effect of that home owner must have been really really picky. I think you solution to build up in the low areas rather than try and fill with thin set was the right way to go about it. It does make me wonder if there is an "approved" way of doing that. I leveled the sub floor in my old house using shingles and multiple thicknesses of plywood. it worked great but it'd have never held up under tile. I think from the high point in that room to the low point it was off by over an inch. for a 12 x 14 room it seemed like a lot but the house was 95 years old. The large format tile work i did was the walls in a bathroom and shower. I defiantly did have some awful lippage there but it wasn't the floor. I did do the floor with 12" natural slate tile. I also got some lipage there but it was mostly because the tiles were cheap and varied in thickness. I really liked the look of it but it had it's down falls. I just chalked it up to being a natural product and didn't think much of it. Doing walls with 12 x 24 tiles was nerve racking. I was worried they were going to fall off the wall constantly. Quote
Tom King Posted January 24, 2019 Author Report Posted January 24, 2019 On a flat surface, it wouldn't be so bad. Thinset, if not mixed too thin, is really sticky. My first try at leveling was with a stepped screed to ride on the previous, and set up row of tile. That didn't work because of the stickiness of the thinset. You could probably put 12x24's on a ceiling. The way we're doing it, the notched trowel still can't be bottomed out, so it's a bit more of a balancing, guessing act, and the thinset has to be mixed thick enough that it's hard to squeeze down if you put too much under it. I've even had to stand on some tiles to get them down close enough for the levelers to take over. I'll find a video of floor leveling. There are special products for that purpose, but this house had a mold problem, and the owners didn't want all the extra moisture put in the air from the leveling liquid. Here's the first youtube video that came up. I didn't take time to look through them to pick a good one, but this should show you how it works. It would have made this job many times easier. Cost was not any kind of issue, but these folks are just a little particular, and peculiar. Those are the kinds I get along with fine. 1 Quote
Tom King Posted January 26, 2019 Author Report Posted January 26, 2019 These folks won't be back until Easter, so we'll just work on this job on rainy, or really cold days. For those of you doing tile work, if you haven't seen one of these, you need one if you're going to do the thinset mixing inside. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B077H5BN15/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o07__o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1 1 Quote
Tom King Posted January 28, 2019 Author Report Posted January 28, 2019 Some friends, and I were talking about tile work tonight. I remembered that I left out a lot here for some of you that are figuring on doing it yourselves, and maybe haven't done it before. One tool you absolutely need is at least one margin trowel. You need to keep your hands out of the mortar as much as possible, so I like this one that hangs on the lip of the bucket, and keeps the handle clean. https://www.homedepot.com/p/Bon-Tool-5-in-x-2-in-Pro-Carbon-Steel-Bucket-Margin-Trowel-Wood-Handle-14-456/305903928 Our HD doesn't stock those, so check yours online first. You will probably want two margin trowels. They come in different lengths. You can get more covered in less time with an 8" one, but you need to have arms used to working. Make your second one a Marshalltown with the red rubberish handle. Home Depot does stock those. Rose Brothers is normally my favorite brand of trowel, but for tile work, it makes no sense in using a leather handle in tile work, and your hands will be tender from the lime in the wash water, so the soft handles are nice. I'd like it better if Bon Tool made that bucket trowel with a soft handle. Quote
Tom King Posted January 31, 2019 Author Report Posted January 31, 2019 We worked on this job today, since it was a job we didn't have to heat up after we arrived. I've figured out a better way to use the levelers. Before, I had only used 4 levelers per tile, as seen on youtube videos. The trouble with the levelers is that they won't push the tile being laid down below the level of its mate. Like this, if there was some variation in the middle of the long side, there was not much you could do about it. Using the screw caps as feelers, with four on the long side, the "clicks" can be split between the middle and the end. It's better to have a light click on both the middle, and end, than to have one larger click in the middle. The lippage is still not bad. The Tavy puck https://www.amazon.com/Tavy-Marble-Level-Lippage-Detector/dp/B002FYE1LS won't click anywhere on the floor, but anything out of perfect is noticeable to me with these tiles. There is no getting this kind of tile perfect though. The red screw caps are more particular "feelers" than the larger Tavy puck that I have used for so long. The Tavy puck works fine on non perfectly flat topped tile with hard edges. When shopping for whatever floor tile, get the kind that has some sort of turned down top edges. These try to look like the high ends ones, that can be laid perfectly flat, but to me, are much worse than the old type of floor tile that had the edges that gave you some leeway. 1 Quote
Tpt life Posted January 31, 2019 Report Posted January 31, 2019 They recommend overlaps per tile manufacturers specs based on the curve they expect. In other words, almost all tiles recommend no more than 25-30% overlap in the running bond. This keeps low corners from lining up in the center most portion of a neighboring tile. Showing your 50% overlap running bond immediately tells me why you say your lippage still exists. Quote
Tom King Posted January 31, 2019 Author Report Posted January 31, 2019 I know that recommended overlap, and so did the owners. It's even on the boxes of tile. They didn't want it any other way than this, and I have to agree that it looks a bit odd to me to have the smaller overlap. If the normal, ordinary, or recommended way would have been what they wanted, they probably never would have come to me. I've never worked for this couple before, but their house is just a couple of doors over from the one that I put the standing seam roof on, and that guy sent them to me. The lippage we have is negligible, but it does take a bit more effort to minimize it. It's not even as much as the thickness of a sheet of paper, like this, and that not in many places. I'm not convinced that this tile would have been any better installed the recommended way. Some are nice and flat, some are concave, and some convex. I recommended, soon after we started, that they switch to some other tile, but they didn't want to have to think about it any more. I'm sure they'll be satisfied with it, and I will know a lot more about what large tile to use in the future. Quote
drzaius Posted January 31, 2019 Report Posted January 31, 2019 At the T intersection it doesn't matter so much if the straight 'through' tile edge is a tiny bit high, but if the corners are even a hair high it gets much more uncomfortable. Quote
Tom King Posted January 31, 2019 Author Report Posted January 31, 2019 I agree. Since some are convex, and some concave, we're alternating rows after sorting through them. The four levelers in that layout, as in the picture, lets me drop the corners a hair, and still keep the corners on the already laid tile a hair below. I could still level the corners with only two on the long side, but the long edge may have been noticeably high. If needed, I can push down with the middle ones, which will lower the corner that otherwise couldn't be lowered. It's still no fun though. Maybe one out of five tiles, I'll have to take it up, and find a better candidate. I'll be glad when it's done, and will know better next time what to take on to start with. If the floor had been flat, and level, it wouldn't have been so bad. The Tavy puck says there is no lippage anywhere. I'll try to remember to get a picture of the bottom of it, with a straight edge, today. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.