Von Posted January 29, 2025 Report Posted January 29, 2025 Sorry if this has been hashed through already, but it seems nearly everyone at one time or another replies to a very old thread not realizing how old it is. On some other forums I believe the forum will warn you when you are posting to an old thread. I don't suppose we have a similar option we can turn on? BTW, I'm happy to research this if helpful. Looks like we're running on the https://invisioncommunity.com/forums/ software (a version number would help if someone knows it). TIA Quote
Popular Post gee-dub Posted January 29, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted January 29, 2025 Older threads still have value. The original conversation, even if years old, still contains opinions, tips, and info that someone who has not read the thread can find useful. I do share your opinion on threads where someone replies with a helpful tid-bit of info without realizing that the problem was solved 3 years ago . I have not participated in a forum that has that feature but totally agree it would be useful. Some sort of floating "originally posted" date field or a warning pop-up if you are replying to a thread that is over a year old . . or whatever criteria makes sense. I know I have responded to help someone only to realize later that they may be dead for all I know the thread is so old. 5 Quote
Popular Post woodwhisperer Posted January 29, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted January 29, 2025 Just did a quick bit of searching and it doesn't appear to be a stock forum feature. In past versions, 3rd party plugins would do this but I'm not sure there is anything we can use that would work with the current software. If anyone finds anything promising and it isn't too involved or sketchy, I'm happy to take a look. 3 1 Quote
Von Posted January 29, 2025 Author Report Posted January 29, 2025 On 1/29/2025 at 1:10 PM, thewoodwhisperer said: Just did a quick bit of searching and it doesn't appear to be a stock forum feature. In past versions, 3rd party plugins would do this but I'm not sure there is anything we can use that would work with the current software. If anyone finds anything promising and it isn't too involved or sketchy, I'm happy to take a look. If I know what I'm talking about, there is a "Dead Topic Protection" plugin that was updated in November of 2024: https://www.sosinvision.com.br/index.php?/forums/topic/3013-dead-topic-protection/ It does cost $18 up front and $10/year, which seems a little pricey given this is a minor annoyance at most. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted January 30, 2025 Report Posted January 30, 2025 The posting date / time is displayed just below the username on each post. Maybe a small adjustment to the forum theme could make it more obvious? 1 Quote
Popular Post h3nry Posted January 30, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted January 30, 2025 On both this and other forums, when a zombie thread appears ... it's often a new poster and the text reads a lot like an AI bot. I don't call them out just in case it is a real human. I don't think the robots will care if any measures are put in place, they'll still come here to push whatever agenda robots have these days. 3 Quote
Coop Posted January 30, 2025 Report Posted January 30, 2025 I find that most of these are one timers, never to be heard from again. 2 Quote
Mark J Posted January 30, 2025 Report Posted January 30, 2025 11 hours ago, h3nry said: On both this and other forums, when a zombie thread appears ... it's often a new poster and the text reads a lot like an AI bot. I don't call them out just in case it is a real human. I don't think the robots will care if any measures are put in place, they'll still come here to push whatever agenda robots have these days. I just wish there was a way to weed out the AI bots and the spammers. It doesn't bother me so much if a real person re-opens an old thread. 1 Quote
Popular Post wtnhighlander Posted January 31, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted January 31, 2025 Well, pre-emptive blocking would be awesome, but you guys do a great job of pointing out the weeds as soon as they sprout, so keeping them cleaned out isn't too difficult! 2 1 1 Quote
Von Posted January 31, 2025 Author Report Posted January 31, 2025 On 1/29/2025 at 7:42 PM, wtnhighlander said: The posting date / time is displayed just below the username on each post. Maybe a small adjustment to the forum theme could make it more obvious? Your question is a good one, but well past my understanding of the Invision Community software to answer. My conclusion is there isn't obviously a cure for this issue that is better than the disease. I thank everyone, especially Marc, for their thoughtfulness on my question. If you are reading this ten years from now, your thoughts on this thread are welcome. 2 Quote
Chestnut Posted February 3, 2025 Report Posted February 3, 2025 There isn't a lot of technological advancement in woodworking zombie threads are usually relevant still. The bots or spammers are the true problem and i don't think there is much more we can really do there. Honestly i sometimes wish zombie threads got resurrected more often. A good portion of the questions we see have been answered before, but sometimes could maybe benefit from more detail or further explanation. 2 Quote
Popular Post Coop Posted February 6, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted February 6, 2025 Old threads coming back alive can be a good thing sometimes. It allows you to remember some of the great folks that are no longer participating on the forum and maybe not above ground any longer. 4 Quote
Mark J Posted February 7, 2025 Report Posted February 7, 2025 On 1/30/2025 at 6:41 PM, wtnhighlander said: Well, pre-emptive blocking would be awesome, but you guys do a great job of pointing out the weeds as soon as they sprout, so keeping them cleaned out isn't too difficult! I seem to recall that if two spam reports are made on a post, the post is deleted (temporarily?). Do I understand correctly? Quote
wtnhighlander Posted February 7, 2025 Report Posted February 7, 2025 @Mark J, there are 'moderation points' applied to a post / poster when reports are logged, and they do accumulate. I don't know about the post being hidden, all I've seen is that further posts from the reported user may require approval from a moderator. I think at least 2 or 3 separate reports must be logged for this to trigger. 2 Quote
woodwhisperer Posted March 5, 2025 Report Posted March 5, 2025 One potential solution to the old thread problem is implementing an archive. We can archive old content based on date. This forum is old enough and activity has decreased enough in recent years that if we were to archive any content older than 10 years, that would archive 50% of the forum's content. So what would happen if we did archive content? Those threads would then be locked so no one can post to them, though they are still fully readable. They will also be taken out of the search so that when you do a search, you end up getting more recent content. The insane number of pages in catch-all sections like General Woodworking Talk would be drastically reduced. And it also puts the posts into a separate table in the database, which I imagine might speed things up a bit. I'll leave this up to you guys. If the majority are in favor of it, I'll implement it. 2 Quote
Mark J Posted March 5, 2025 Report Posted March 5, 2025 Would there be some way to do a search of the archive itself? Quote
Popular Post Beechwood Chip Posted March 5, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted March 5, 2025 I don't see replies to old threads as a problem, as long as they aren't spam or off topic. Some new posters come in after finding an old post in a search, and if they contribute and become members, that's good, right? 3 Quote
fcschoenthal Posted March 5, 2025 Report Posted March 5, 2025 On 3/5/2025 at 10:01 AM, Beechwood Chip said: I don't see replies to old threads as a problem, as long as they aren't spam or off topic. Agree, and I don't really see that much of it happening. I also like the option of searching old posts and at least referencing them when answering "new" questions that have been answered many times in the past. This should probably be a collective Moderator decision, as they are the ones impacted the most. Quote
Von Posted March 5, 2025 Author Report Posted March 5, 2025 When I brought this to I was really hoping there was was something that could be easily enabled. I don't think this is a problem with anyone spending significant effort on. I appreciate the thinking about this and as the person who originally asked about this, I'm fine with us collectively moving on. Thanks! 1 Quote
Popular Post Chestnut Posted March 6, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted March 6, 2025 I just zombied a 12 year old thread on another form and got great feedback. I like the old threads and would rather they stay active. Honestly I might have a thread that gets that age that I'd post again. A 10 year review of my poor choices could be a learning experience. 6 1 Quote
Popular Post Coop Posted March 7, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted March 7, 2025 Again, a chance to revisit the past and old friends. 4 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.