Beechwood Chip Posted October 21 Report Posted October 21 If I'm working with kiln dried dimensional Douglas fir, at what stage do I let the wood acclimate? I figure I should assemble the project as soon after milling as possible. I'm planning to rough cut blanks before milling. Do I sticker the boards and let them acclimate, then do the rough cuts, mill and assemble? Or, buy the boards and cut them into rough blanks, let them acclimate, then mill and assemble? I figure that the rough cut blanks will have more surface area to lose moisture. But I've always heard you should sticker the boards with weights to let them acclimate. I don't have the patience to let them acclimate twice. (I suspect that I'm over thinking this and it doesn't really matter.) 1 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted October 21 Report Posted October 21 I'm betting that your last assumption is true 1 Quote
Ron Swanson Jr. Posted October 21 Report Posted October 21 I usually buy my stock ahead of the project and let it sit in my shop for a few days. Mill it about halfway and let it sit again for a few days, and then mill to the final dimensions. 1 Quote
gee-dub Posted October 21 Report Posted October 21 I live in an area that has a pretty stable climate. I still make the occasional lumber run but most of my stock has been in the racks for years. Still, stress release when cutting can give you unexpected results. Pecan and mahogany have given me the most extreme reactions when ripping thin (1-1/2" to 2-1/2") strips for frame parts. Like Ron, my usual is to cut blanks to an oversize dimension. This is relational; small parts I cut with an extra 1/4" or so, larger parts get more extra. Nothing specific. This does a couple of things for me. First it allows for any bow or curve that may result from stress release. Second it makes the piece of material smaller so that the following milling steps are dealing with less variation if present. That is, a 1/4" of bow over 4 feet becomes much less if the piece is cut into a pair of 2 foot pieces; if that makes sense. Wood is a natural product and will try to do what it wants to do. Still I do clamp oversize and finished size parts to a reference surface until I assemble them. In my mind I know this probably isn't "controlling" anything but it makes me feel better 2 Quote
Von Posted October 21 Report Posted October 21 What I figured out from going through the process of air drying wood for my workbench is wood dries very slowly (I know, Captain Obvious, bear with me...). What this means is that all that is going to happen in most acclimation times of a few days to a week is the loss of a little surface moisture. If it's rough lumber and you are just going to mill the surface away, I don't see the benefit of acclimation - it's just not going to dry the wood deeply enough to matter. What I found worked for me was to not mill and cut the final joinery all in one day. It will move after you work it and expose the wetter interior wood. Mill it close to final (or rough cut the mortise or tenon or whatever joinery you are doing) and then pause and let it dry before going to final dimensions. It will shrink or move on you at that point, and then do your final cuts. HTH 1 1 Quote
Popular Post pkinneb Posted October 21 Popular Post Report Posted October 21 Like others I buy the material in advance and let it sit in the shop for at least a week or two, then I rough mill it and let it sit for at least another few days stickered (longer if I am splitting say an 8/4 board into 3/4 pieces), then I final mill, cut joinery, and try to assemble with in a day or so. 4 Quote
Popular Post curlyoak Posted October 21 Popular Post Report Posted October 21 Because I want to make sure I have all the material required for the project, the wood gets a lot of shop time weather it needs it or not. If it is properly done, I would not worry about moisture. Hickory that I tried was kiln dried and moved a lot. It never happened again because I am done with hickory. I oversize most everything as I start from the rough. I get more yield in thickness with shorter pieces. Cutting larger is a function of the dressing process. Not moisture. I am thinking that what I do is somewhat different because I live in high humidity and that enters in to the equation somehow... 3 Quote
Popular Post wtnhighlander Posted October 22 Popular Post Report Posted October 22 In my experience, the amount of movement caused by moisture gain or loss is directly related to the ratio of "width" to "thickness" of the part. I've had wide, thin panels literally go from flat to Pringles-shaped, overnight. Conversely, sticks of equal, or near equal, width & thickness tend to remain pretty straight, even through high humidity swings. Grain orientation has an influence, of course. Internal stress, like in wood from a branch or leaning tree, seem to appear during rip cuts, but as far as I can tell, don't affect moisture-related movement so much. My practice is to not worry about acclimation. I break lumber down to parts in a couple of stages, but mostly to minimize the waste from milling rough stock, and to allow 'second chances' at getting the final dimensions correct. And my 'work' schedule is generally so broken up that the process stops wherever it stops. I try to not leave (thin) panels lying flat on the bench, to avoid uneven moisture wicking, but that's about it . No stickers, no clamps. 3 Quote
krtwood Posted October 22 Report Posted October 22 "kiln dried dimensional Douglas fir" is not 8% kiln dried hardwood and a few days acclimating isn't going to do anything for you either way. Leave it in a rack until Spring or do whatever you want and hope for the best. 2 Quote
Popular Post gee-dub Posted October 22 Popular Post Report Posted October 22 Just some more random input. . . I followed someone's advice 25-odd years ago and bought wide kiln dried dimensional lumber to build a workbench base. The idea was to save some dough. I let it acclimate for two months and then ripped it down to rough dimensions. I let it set for two more weeks and then ripped to width. Long story short; once the base was completed it continued to move for months until I finally had to abandon it. The net result is that I could have bought properly processed poplar and the cost would have been about half. We are many times penny wise and pound foolish. Lesson learned and never repeated. 6 Quote
Popular Post Beechwood Chip Posted October 23 Author Popular Post Report Posted October 23 On 10/22/2026 at 3:24 PM, gee-dub said: once the base was completed it continued to move for months until I finally had to abandon it. OK, you've convinced me. I'm going with wood from a real lumber yard. Red oak for the top and poplar for the base. I'm basing my design on Rex Krueger's minimum lumber workbench, and I'm using even less lumber than that. Still, the cost is making me blink twice. But, "buy once, cry once!" 5 Quote
Popular Post Ron Swanson Jr. Posted October 23 Popular Post Report Posted October 23 On 10/23/2026 at 2:53 PM, Beechwood Chip said: OK, you've convinced me. I'm going with wood from a real lumber yard. Red oak for the top and poplar for the base. I'm basing my design on Rex Krueger's minimum lumber workbench, and I'm using even less lumber than that. Still, the cost is making me blink twice. But, "buy once, cry once!" If you think of the years of service you'll get out of it, it helps to soften the blow a little. But as a pretty frugal guy myself, I understand. 3 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted October 24 Report Posted October 24 @Beechwood Chip, are you going to build the 'english' face vise, too? Quote
Popular Post Beechwood Chip Posted October 24 Author Popular Post Report Posted October 24 On 10/23/2026 at 9:05 PM, wtnhighlander said: @Beechwood Chip, are you going to build the 'english' face vise, too? No, it will really be more of a heavy duty assembly table than a traditional workbench. No vises, but MatchFit slots all over the top. And the top, legs, aprons, and stretchers all flush for clamping. 3 1 Quote
Popular Post Mark J Posted October 24 Popular Post Report Posted October 24 16 hours ago, Beechwood Chip said: I'm basing my design on Rex Krueger's minimum lumber workbench, and I'm using even less lumber than that. A journal would be nice . 4 Quote
Popular Post Von Posted October 24 Popular Post Report Posted October 24 21 minutes ago, Mark J said: A journal would be nice . Nah, journals suck :-) 3 Quote
Popular Post Beechwood Chip Posted October 24 Author Popular Post Report Posted October 24 On 10/24/2026 at 8:35 AM, Mark J said: A journal would be nice . After Von's magnum opus, I'd feel foolish posting my little project. I'm keeping this very simple, no fancy joinery. I just want something that I can actually accomplish. But if you guys want one, I'll see what I can do. 5 Quote
Popular Post Mark J Posted October 24 Popular Post Report Posted October 24 Simple is instructional, too. 3 Quote
Popular Post Ron Swanson Jr. Posted October 24 Popular Post Report Posted October 24 On 10/24/2026 at 8:44 AM, Beechwood Chip said: After Von's magnum opus, I'd feel foolish posting my little project. I'm keeping this very simple, no fancy joinery. I just want something that I can actually accomplish. But if you guys want one, I'll see what I can do. @Beechwood Chip One kind of unexpected benefit of doing a project journal is that it helps to keep you motivated and moving forward with the project. I'd love to follow you on this one, no matter how simple it is! I always walk away from watching your guys' projects with *something* I didn't have before. 5 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted October 24 Report Posted October 24 1 hour ago, Mark J said: Simple is instructional, too. Amen! 2 Quote
Von Posted October 24 Report Posted October 24 3 hours ago, Beechwood Chip said: But if you guys want one, I'll see what I can do. Absolutely! Quote
dwilliam Posted October 27 Report Posted October 27 I’d rough-cut the boards slightly oversized first, then sticker and weight the blanks in your workshop until they acclimate. Afterward, mill them to final dimensions and assemble promptly to minimize movement and reduce the risk of warping. 2 Quote
Popular Post gee-dub Posted October 27 Popular Post Report Posted October 27 On 10/23/2026 at 1:34 PM, Ron Swanson Jr. said: If you think of the years of service you'll get out of it, it helps to soften the blow a little. But as a pretty frugal guy myself, I understand. I can talk myself into (or out of) almost anything. If I use my workbench 3 times a week for 10 years I just divide the cost by 1,560 and there is my actual "cost". So if I spend $1,560 on my workbench it actually only costs me a dollar per use-day. This pseudo-science does not apply to Starbucks coffee though. How do people spend $5 for a cup of coffee!?! 3 1 Quote
Popular Post Ron Swanson Jr. Posted October 27 Popular Post Report Posted October 27 On 10/27/2026 at 5:58 AM, gee-dub said: I can talk myself into (or out of) almost anything. If I use my workbench 3 times a week for 10 years I just divide the cost by 1,560 and there is my actual "cost". So if I spend $1,560 on my workbench it actually only costs me a dollar per use-day. This pseudo-science does not apply to Starbucks coffee though. How do people spend $5 for a cup of coffee!?! I was in a Starbucks last week, not to buy coffee, but because I use their reusable cups. I noticed the price of their fancy drinks are now now like $7-$8. Which seems insane to me. But then again, took the wife out for dinner last weekend and she had a martini that was $16 and a glass of wine that was $12, so I guess it's kind of relative. 3 Quote
Popular Post gee-dub Posted October 27 Popular Post Report Posted October 27 On 10/27/2026 at 5:37 AM, Ron Swanson Jr. said: I was in a Starbucks last week, not to buy coffee, but because I use their reusable cups. I noticed the price of their fancy drinks are now now like $7-$8. Which seems insane to me. But then again, took the wife out for dinner last weekend and she had a martini that was $16 and a glass of wine that was $12, so I guess it's kind of relative. Wandering off topic to the original thread and I apologize BUT, when I am taking LOML out on date night . . . all bets are off! 1 2 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.