matthew-s Posted December 4, 2012 Report Posted December 4, 2012 Hi. Nice forum you have here. I'm a fairly new to woodworking, and I'm looking to get my first real router & router table for some projects I have in mind. I'm interested in this groups recommendations. I recognize recommendations will depend on my criteria - so here are a few requirements: 1. I have very limited space (no dedicated shop area). I need something that I can put away - so a benchtop model, or something that folds up, would be nice 2. Projects will be "medium sized" I guess. I'd like to build a "Gerstner-like" toolbox, bookshelves for kids room, flower (window) boxes, etc for starters. 3. Price matters, but I do *hate* buying twice, so I'm willing to spend a bit more up front to circumvent that. I consider myself a beginner. I've done basic home DIY work (crown molding, wallboard, etc) and build a woodshed, but those are more in line with general carpentry than what I describe above, which I think is closer to cabinetry. I'm meticulous and good at following directions - this gives me hope that I can make the transition! Here are my more specific questions and musings: A. I've been thinking about getting a Festool 1400 to build my kit around, but its not clear to me if it will fit in a non-Festool router table. Will it? Should I look elsewhere? B. I like the idea of the CMS table (supposed quality and portability - I love how it folds up), but the price is eye-watering, especially when you throw in the router too. What else can I look at? Any feedback on the Bench-Dog Contractor's table, which is one I've been looking at in particular? C. I have a Bosch 4100 table saw (It folds up and rolls away!). I like the idea of mounting a router table on one side of the 4100, but its not clear to me that the table-saw options are intended to fit in the wing of a jobsite saw. Is there one that fits this bill? Should I go this route? D. I will entertain options that have me building a portion of the router table, but my hobby time is limited, so I'd rather get on with my "real" projects, than spend a few weekends building a router table (despite the learning opportunity it provides). E. I assume a lift is not mandatory, and can be added later if need be, correct? F. I don't have a Dust Collection solution (heck, I did not even know I needed one until I found this site). That may or may not factor, given the Festool offerings here. I suspect I should solve the dust collection problem before getting too crazy on a table, no? I've searched the forums a bit on this, but I did not see anyone else with identical requirements. Apologies in advance if I missed something relevant. Thanks! Matt Quote
Eric. Posted December 4, 2012 Report Posted December 4, 2012 For a handheld router, Festool 1400. If you're putting it in a table, PC7518. Putting the Festool in a table is a waste of a Festool, IMO. Quote
rodger. Posted December 4, 2012 Report Posted December 4, 2012 Dust collection is a must with a router table. The amount of dust and chips it can make is astounding. How small and portable do you need? You can get a nice Freud router table and router combo from HD that can be put on casters to move about. You can even add a shelf to the bottom portion for extra storage space. If you combine the fence dust port with under the table collection (hood included), your dust issue is solved. I run the big freud router in my table (springs removed). I connect my DC to the fence port, and shop vac/Dust Deputy to the underside. I edge routed profiles on a bunch of maple last night and didn't even see a speck of dust on the table. If you plan on the router being versatile, make sure it has variable speed (I think it would be hard to buy a router without VS these days, however). http://www.freud.ca/...es/PKG0025.html They also have a portable option: http://www.freud.ca/...es/PKG0028.html I would spring for the bigger unit, as with table mounted routers bigger usually means better . If budget doesn't matter too much, take a look at festool for sure. Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted December 4, 2012 Report Posted December 4, 2012 I'd start with a piece of 3/4" plywood over a pair of saw horses, Run a 2x4 through your Bosch to get it smooth and straight and clamp that to the table as a fence. Cut a hole for the router bit and screw something like this to the bottom to hold the router. Use that for a while and you'll have a better idea of what features you want in a router table, whether you want to build or buy, etc. Or, maybe you'll decide that it's good enough and you want to put the money towards something else. Quote
duckkisser Posted December 4, 2012 Report Posted December 4, 2012 might want to decide if you going to do small stuff or inlays if that's the case you might want to think about getting a small hand router that you can do shallow or small cuts with. the big boys can be a bit of a pain when it comes time to remove a inch of material so you can drop in a wood inlay. also plan your router table area so that you can save patterns for future projects then you don't have to make a new pattern like an egg shape that I just recently used. Quote
tim0625 Posted December 4, 2012 Report Posted December 4, 2012 First of all and most importantly.......WELCOME to Spagnuolo's Wide World of Woodworking! It's a good place to hang out. I have a Makita 1101 as my main work horse. Medium HP, moderately priced, soft start, variable speed and it will work well as a handheld or in a table. Beechwood had a good idea on the acrylic base plate. I'd buy it from my local glass shop for $2 and drill it myself but the concept is spot on. Plywood for the table. I went to a local mobile home dealer-they also have a repair division. Brian always has a piece of laminate 36x36. I'm not choosy on the color/style so when he offered to give me a piece, I took it, a little glue and made my own table. I have a wire welder so I used some flat bar and built a square to accommodate a router base plate. You don't have to do that though. You can rabbet a recess in the plywood. If you didn't want to go with Beech's acrylic, universal base plates are pretty cheap. (No lift needed but it is really nice to have!) Buy a base platethat's 9 1/4 x 11 3/4 and when you get a lift, it will match the hole as you upgrade things. If you make your own table, for portability, you could mount it to another table/bench with a hinge to swing down and be vertical when not in use. I have yet to own any Festool product. Everyone says it's good stuff - seems over priced. IDK at this point. Dust collection - yes it's a must. Franklin Pug is spot on. A router creates a lot of chips and dust. Anything in your lungs besides the 'air' you breath is not good. When you get to exotic woods (Padauk, Purpleheart, etc) they have natural toxins that cause serious lung damage to some people. Craigs List is the best. You can spend $100-$200 and find a nice portable dust collection unit until you can decide how large of one you will really need. From Craig's list, buy a 1 1/2-3HP. Be aware names like Jet and Portamatic - they are good units but you pay for the name too. Delta and Grizzly are good units and will serve you well and sometimes are a little better priced. Rule is pay no more than 1/2 of the new price. No warranty and wear and tear is the reason. Be wary of stuff coming from "production shops" - heavy use. Electricity - if you don't know how to wire something, find a friend but you'll eventually want and need 220V. If you know the basics of wiring, running a 220V line is easy and if you don't, watch the 'friend' and ask questions and you'll wonder what all the hoopla was about. Gotta go to work...stay in touch! 1 Quote
Dave F Posted December 4, 2012 Report Posted December 4, 2012 One space saving option... do you have a table saw? If so and you have extension wings for your fence, you can usually build in a router table as an addition to the saw table. Just a space saving suggestion for you to consider. 1 Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted December 4, 2012 Report Posted December 4, 2012 For a handheld router, Festool 1400. If you're putting it in a table, PC7518. Putting the Festool in a table is a waste of a Festool, IMO. Eric is dead on here. I've used a dozen router tables over my woodworking life. I've built 3, bought 4 so far. In my opinion get the Porter Cable 7518, it fits everything and there are litterally zillions of aftermarket things that it will fit. I have one and I have a Freud 3-1/4 HP. I love the Freud for under the table, but it simply doesn't fit everywhere, but the Porter Cable will fit everywhere. Every aftermarket router product out there seems to be first designed for Porter Cable and then adds others from there. Having said that, my advice is build a very simple bench-top router table. There are tons of plans out there. Some so simple that the entire thing can be build from 1/2 sheet of plywood. Building it will be good experience and if you are anything like me this won't be your last router table anyway, so keep it simple and inexpensive. Use it for a while until you figure out what you like, then you can look at up-grading. I can remember needing an additional router table to get a particular job done and simply drillng a hole in a 2'x2' sheet of plywood, reinforcing it will 2 strips of wood and putting on a pair of saw-horses. It worked fine. Start simple. While you are using it keep track of features you wish you had. You will then have a much better idea of what to get when you decide to either build or buy your next (last?) router table. Quote
jmaichel Posted December 4, 2012 Report Posted December 4, 2012 I don't currently own a router but am going to buy one in the next few months or so. I plan on getting the Festool Of1010, which from what I have seen is a very capable router. One of my main reasons for leaning toward the OF1010 vs the 1400 is that I can use 8mm bits and Lee Valley offers a bunch of different 8mm bits and they are well priced. I know a lot of woodworkers love their OF1400 but I think if one had several different sized routers the OF1400 would get the least amount of use but if i was only planning on having one router I would get the OF1400. Eventually I would like to add the OF2200. Router table, I have no interest in the CMS, I think there are too many other better router table options and not needing the portability of the CMS makes is overpriced IMHO. I am leaning toward and nice router table setup from Jessem or Bench Dog and putting a PC7518. I like the idea of going big once on a router table and not having to worry about it again. I am also considering a Shaper with a router bit adapter. Grizzly sells some nice Shaper's for about half the price of a full router table setup. This is just my approach to buying a router and router table and by not currently owning a router or a bunch of 1/2" bits I don't feel constrained when shopping for a router. Good Luck, let us know what you decide. Quote
joelav Posted December 4, 2012 Report Posted December 4, 2012 I have the 7518 in my router table for all the reasons mentioned above. I had and returned the OF1400 router. For me, it just wasn't worth the premium over something like the Bosch 1617. It's a nice router, but not twice as nice as the Bosch, although it is over twice the price. If you google a bit, you will find some people that have made router table inserts for your Bosch 4100. Quote
Chris H Posted December 4, 2012 Report Posted December 4, 2012 3. Price matters, but I do *hate* buying twice, so I'm willing to spend a bit more up front to circumvent that. Hi Matt! There is one tool that you may not regret buying twice, and that is a router. When you first start into woodworking, I don't reccomend a high end router. Go for a larger, variable speed router at a reasonable price (This will likely end up as your "table router") Most wood workers realize shortly after a furniture/cabinet build, that the ideal setup will involve at least 2 routers. After a few projects of, "on the table", "off the table", "on the table", "off the table"....it becomes evident that a second hand held router would be a very nice thing! So, I don't reccomend going crazy high end for a first router. I don't reccomend a generic chinese brand either though. I would target dewalt, porter cable, rigid, bosch as good brands to start with. They are economical, but also have good performance. I love amazon reviews. They have the volume to support a good market opinion without having a lot of brand reputation to protect (aka reason to tamper with reviews). I have a Rigid that I love, and I would love to get my hands on a mid-grade "Speed Router" for trim work on cabinets and stuff, so the Rigid could stay under the table, where it belongs. Also, I could buy 3-4 of them for the price of a festool. Festool stuff is awesome, but it's a bit like buying a Mercedes for your first car. Yes, that would be awesome, and it is a better machine than, say a Civic. But, the Civic is reliable and will get you from one point to the next just fine. Quote
Dlhunter Posted December 5, 2012 Report Posted December 5, 2012 Just buy one and if you don't like it buy another. And another, and another... Routers are like clamps. You can never have too many. Quote
matthew-s Posted December 5, 2012 Author Report Posted December 5, 2012 Wow! I'm overwhelmed with the response. Thanks to all that posted. I've picked a few to follow up on. I'm warming up to the build your own route, but I don't yet know how I'd deal with the fence - I'd assume get a commercial fence - rather than trying to DIY that particular part. For a handheld router, Festool 1400. If you're putting it in a table, PC7518. Putting the Festool in a table is a waste of a Festool, IMO. In this case - I'm expecting this router to do double duty - I don't envision it being dedicated to a table. I recognize the PC7518 is super popular, but would I not need to have a plunge capability if I have only one router? I don't think the 7518 can plunge, can it? How small and portable do you need? a look at festool for sure. Well, the smaller the better! I don't have a lot of excess floor space in our detached garage. It's not heated or insulated either, so it would be even better to have something I could move down to the basement for storage if possible, but that is not a firm requirement (That said, if I need to keep it in the garage better be fairly robust to deal with the seasons. It will at least stay dry). Oh, and I love your avatar. We had two pugs up until a few weeks ago. Now we are down to just one might want to decide if you going to do small stuff or inlays if that's the case you might want to think about getting a small hand router that you can do shallow or small cuts with. I forgot to mention that I have a small Ridgid "palm" router. So I guess I have this covered! One space saving option... do you have a table saw? If so and you have extension wings for your fence, you can usually build in a router table as an addition to the saw table. Just a space saving suggestion for you to consider. Yes - a Bosch 4100 (which sort of started me down this slippery slope). I'd love to drop something into the "hole" created when I slide the extension on the right all the way out. I have not found one that I'm confident would fit. I'm open to all leads here. One of my main reasons for leaning toward the OF1010 vs the 1400 is that I can use 8mm bits and Lee Valley offers a bunch of different 8mm bits and they are well priced. Interesting. One reason why I was looking at the 1400 was because I thought it did both 1/4 and 1/2" bits. The other reasons were the claims on amazing dust management, and what seems to be a nice plunge setup, and the general following these tools seem to have. I have the 7518 in my router table for all the reasons mentioned above. I had and returned the OF1400 router. For me, it just wasn't worth the premium over something like the Bosch 1617. It's a nice router, but not twice as nice as the Bosch, although it is over twice the price. If you google a bit, you will find some people that have made router table inserts for your Bosch 4100. Thanks for the thoughts on the Festool and alternatives. As noted, I'm interested in a way to drop a router top into the Bosch. So far, I've only found this (photos, no plan). http://juliantracy.com/Bosch%20Tablesaw/index.htm If you happen to see a good example, send it my way! Quote
Trip Posted December 5, 2012 Report Posted December 5, 2012 pc7518 has been THE router table router for about 2 decades. you can get just the motor for $145-$199 and a lift and save by not getting the base and kit... Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted December 5, 2012 Report Posted December 5, 2012 Just to answer one of your questions, you can get the porter cable with a plunge base, I did. You can get it with a fixed base, a plunge base, a D-handle base, as well as a special dust collection base, among other base options. You can also get nearly any combination there of, sold as a kit. Quote
KMoura Posted December 5, 2012 Report Posted December 5, 2012 You cannot go wrong with a Festool 1400. I use that router for damn near everything. You can use it with 8mm, 1/4" and 1/2" shank router bits. I also have a Porter Cable Laminate Trimmer Kit and that palm router in it comes in real handy. I have a PC 7518 motor in my router lift that is in my New Yankee Workshop style router table. I use a Smart Digital Lift that I bought at Rocklers on sale, and over the last 5 or 6 years I have yet to use the digital readout for anything. If you decide to go the Festool route make sure you get one of there dust extractor/vacuums. I have the CT33 and CT22 and they work great. I am not sure how well a plunge router works in a router table set-up, but I suppose you could modify a router plate to fit a 1400. Quote
matthew-s Posted December 5, 2012 Author Report Posted December 5, 2012 If you decide to go the Festool route make sure you get one of there dust extractor/vacuums. I have the CT33 and CT22 and they work great. I am not sure how well a plunge router works in a router table set-up, but I suppose you could modify a router plate to fit a 1400. Yes - I'm starting to see how using the plunge router with a table may not make sense. I presumed it was "normal" to do so given that it works in the CMS, but I guess that is a one-off affair. One could go ahead and use a Festool CT dust collector with non-festool tools fairly easily, no? Say another router brand, or my jobsite table saw? Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted December 6, 2012 Report Posted December 6, 2012 A plunge router actually works fine in a router table. I've had my 3-1/4 Freud mounted at some time or another into all of the tables I've own. No problem. 1 Quote
Trip Posted December 6, 2012 Report Posted December 6, 2012 ==> I'm starting to see how using the plunge router with a table may not make sense exactly, you only need a motor and a decent lift. The actual base gets tossed. You can save about $100-$150 getting the motor as a bare tool. Many around here recommend the woodpeckers lift. Don't know that you need all that digital nonsense in today's offerings, but who knows -- it may save time. Note: if you get a router motor with variable speed (recommended), make sure your DC in the motor area is solid -- the smalls get sucked through the motor body along with the cooling and clog-up the variable-speed switch (an expensive repair). Quote
rodger. Posted December 6, 2012 Report Posted December 6, 2012 A plunge router actually works fine in a router table. I've had my 3-1/4 Freud mounted at some time or another into all of the tables I've own. No problem. Me too. I removed the springs so I wouldn't have to fight against them. There are detailed instructions on the freud website on how to do this. Quote
pghmyn Posted December 6, 2012 Report Posted December 6, 2012 If you are ambitious, you can even build your own router lift to save some money. Check out Matthias Wandel's version. Quote
dcustoms Posted December 6, 2012 Report Posted December 6, 2012 A few things... First IMO the best all around router for the shop is a PC 690 series there are several bases that you can interchange with the same motor to go from fixed to plunge to D handle. As far as the router table goes Triton makes a decent plunge router that is 2 1/4 HP that has an integrated lift that come with a crank for through the table adjustments. That is a good place to start and for that matter you could make that your one and only router. The PC 690 would do you just fine in a table or for kicking around the shop. If you are just starting out I would not recommend spending a ton of money on a router but getting a good one that will last you a long time then in the future upgrade to a dedicated router table router. I bough a 690 years ago as my first router and for a long time my only router I now have several other 690's and PC 7500 for a table and the above mentioned triton plunge. Hope this helps! Dustin Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.