Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

8" Jointer - Why would I pay twice as much for a Powermatic?

Featured Replies

I'm looking at 8" parallelogram jointers and am leaning towards the Grizzly P0490. I've also looked at the Powermatic PJ882 but it's twice the price with a smaller motor and no mobile base. The only apparent advantage over the Grizzly is a slightly longer bed. What else am I getting with the Powermatic that would make it worth the price?

 

The truth is my right brain is telling me the Powermatic is a whole lot sexier but it needs a little help trying to convince my left brain to go along for the ride.

 

http://www.grizzly.com/products/8-Jointer-with-Parallelogram-Beds/G0490

 

http://www.amazon.com/Powermatic-1610079-Horsepower-Parallelogram-230-Volt/dp/B0007DHHEM/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1374279912&sr=8-1&keywords=pj882

 

 

 

I bought the grizzly G0495x, the top of the line 8 inch jointer. I traded in my 490 as fast as it came to my house because it was a complete lemon. To be honest, the machine you choose is solely based on what you feel more comfortable spending, not anyone else's decision. Don't get washed away by the online reviews like most of us do. Grizzly gets a lot of heat online but then again a lot of successful furniture, cabinet, and instrument makers are making a living with grizzly machines in their shops. 

What else am I getting with the Powermatic that would make it worth the price?

 

 

Pretty gold paint and a cool name like "Powermatic."  Others will argue that there's a big difference.  I personally don't buy it.  My Grizzly is fine for my one man casual hobby-shop.  If you're going into production, you might think on it longer.  Otherwise...

Short and sweet.

 

Powermatic, from what I have seen and heard, comes out of the box pretty well tuned and/or easy to tune right to perfection. Grizzly, on the other hand, requires some elbow grease to get to where you like it, and you may have to settle for an imperfection here and there. For myself, a hobbyist, the 8" G0656P jointer was a bargain! All parts were there, and no damage. Took some time to get everything together, and lined up. The tables are a few thousands out of coplanar, but they are close enough for now. They can be fixed, but I don't have the time for it now. The absolute precision is not needed at the moment.

 

I can see where Grizzly "cheaped" out on some components. Doesn't bother me.

 

What are you going to be doing? Can you spend a few more hours/days in calibrating to your specifications?

 

Also, customer support of Grizzly tools is TOP NOTCH.

I own a few Grizzly tools since I have a local store.  Each of them requires a little elbow grease to get them tuned up.  Once there, I rarely have issues with them.

 

With that said, I've had more issues with their 6" jointer than any of the other tools.

I have the grizzly GO490 myself. I absolutely love that jointer. But I can also say that I have never owned anything powermatic...

  • Popular Post

Basic difference is Powermatic has a much higher standard of quality control. They accept only parts that meet or exceed the standards. Anything below that is rejected. Some of the Tiawanese factories make the same machine under several labels. The Powermatic parts are probably the top 20% they make, the rejects get used for other brands.

Same basic castings can be machined to several levels of quality, different qualities of motors, switches and accessories finish out the build of the tool.

This reminds me of the saying, "you can swear once when you write the check, or you can swear everytime you have to use the tool."

 

I started out buying a few of the lesser (but still decent) quality tools.  More often times than not I was spending time fine tuning, adjusting, etc before the cuts were made; and even still they just weren't to my standards...  Rips weren't accurate for glue-ups, angles were inconsistent on repetitive cuts even though nothing on the machine itself was changed, etc.. 

 

Depending on the tool and it's function there is a certain amount of play to factor in when looking for accuracy..  IMO when a build consists of using a few different tools and there's variance in many of the cuts that were made, they add up and compound to the eventual finished product resulting in a piece that can still be good, but not what you were working for. 

 

I'm not suggesting that you buy the "best" of the best, but more of try to get the highest quality that you budget affords; in the long run it will actually save money and frustration.  For personal projects I turn to woodworking for relaxation and peace of mind.  The last thing I want is to monkey around with tuning and adjusting the tool every couple of times I have to use it.  I want to work the wood; not the tool..  Yes there's a joke in there somewhere, but I'm not going there :P !

 

Ultimately what it boils down to is how much do you think you'll be using a particular tool.  If it's fairly often then the extra money is worth it IMO.  If it's an occasional use item then maybe the extra attention to detail may be more justified.. 

 

So, in this particular situation I guess it boils down to how much you'll be starting your projects with rough lumber and having to mill it.  If you're mostly working with pre-milled lumber then the cost difference may be difficult to justify.  If you will be doing the milling yourself then this would be a tool to spend a little more on.

 

Another thing to keep in mind for the long run is that pre-milled lumber is more expensive than rough.  Over the course of a few years that added expense adds up.

 

I have no experience with Grizzly so can't comment on their quality; mostly delta (which I was NOT happy with) and Powermatic (which I have really come to appreciate).  For my own personal use, I'll be sticking with Powermatic until some major changes in quality happen. 

 

Forget "sexy", their equipment really is a pleasure to use!

 

Hope this helps :)

See what I mean? ^^^  :D

 

My Grizzly jointer always turns on when I press the green button, and it makes boards flat when I pass them over its cutterhead.  I'm pretty sure that's what a jointer is supposed to do.  :)   I have a number of Grizzly tools, and they've all met my standards.  And I'm very anal when it comes to precision and accuracy in my work.  Very anal.

  • Author

 

What are you going to be doing? Can you spend a few more hours/days in calibrating to your specifications?

 

 

I'm just a hobbyist making mostly furniture for myself and family/friends. I have a 6" general international now and the main reason I'm upgrading is because almost every project I've done has required more than the 6" capacity. The other reason is that before every project I need to re-shim the ways because everything is out of whack again. I probably have the time I just don't like doing it.

 

 

So, in this particular situation I guess it boils down to how much you'll be starting your projects with rough lumber and having to mill it.  If you're mostly working with pre-milled lumber then the cost difference may be difficult to justify.  If you will be doing the milling yourself then this would be a tool to spend a little more on.

 

Another thing to keep in mind for the long run is that pre-milled lumber is more expensive than rough.  Over the course of a few years that added expense adds up.

 

Forget "sexy", their equipment really is a pleasure to use!

 

Hope this helps :)

 

I always buy rough lumber.

 

Not to get all metaphysical but isn't "sexy" more pleasurable than "ugly"?

Well i guess that changes the game. If it was a girl you were choosing between, do you want the grizzly girl or the powermatic girl!

It's sort of funny how folks get defensive over brands. The grizzly folks are worse than the festool nut jobs. I have over $30,000 worth of Powermatic machines and can honestly say the gold color is ugly. :)

Go out and put your hands on some machines. Do your own comparisons and see if the machine is the right fit for you. Many are happy with griz just like any other tool. Hell a black and decker screw driver will drive a screw. Does anyone really need to spend more on better brands? A $30 skill saw will do the job of a festool tracksaw, are the folks that buy festool idiots or do they just have higher standards?

My delta is only 6 inch, and it does a nice job. I find that it is too small for some of my work, so I flatten one face by hand with a jack plane and jointer plane. Then I run it through the power planer to clean up the other side.

It doesn't take very long to flatten an 8 inch board that is 4, 5 or even 6 feet long with good hand planes and some practise. Then the planer can handle dimensioning the second side. Alternate a few passes and viola, you have a perfect workpiece bigger than your jointer can handle.

The veritas jointer plane with fence, and VM steel blade is about 400 here in Canada (after tax). Then you can flatten any size board you like, as long as your planer can handle the width for the second side.

That being said, I do use my power jointer on any board less than 6 1/8 inches 95% of the time.

In my opinion, all of these machines (Grizzly, Jet, Powermatic, Delta, General)are roughly the same. They are all geared towards hobbyists, or part time professionals. Some come with better fit and finish than others, but most of that is just make-up. Some come more tuned out of the box than others, but you will have to tune them all at some point. 

 

The best thing you can do is wade through all the marketing hype, and brand loyalty euphoria and pick the machine that you feel best suits your needs.

 

 

Personally, if i had the money to buy the Powermatic, I'd get a Grizzly G0609 (12" Parallelogram), and then start saving for a Byrd head for it. If i didn't want the weight of a bigger machine, I'd get the 490 and buy a Byrd head for it and it would still be cheaper than the Powermatic.

Go out and put your hands on some machines. Do your own comparisons and see if the machine is the right fit for you.

 

 

Great advice...

 

I've made several visits to the Williamsport, PA Grizz showroom, and highly recommend anyone who can visit one of the showrooms.     I'm lucky in the respect that I can fly there in an hour, and there's a $2 bus between the airport and mall.

 

My experiences, in short:

  - Does Grizzly make decent tools?

      In some cases, Yes!   BUT!   In my experience, the closer comparisons are closer in price.   The versions that are 1/2 the price of major brand tools were obvious that they were 1/2 the price of major brand tools.   I've seen lots of nice tools in Williamsport, but the apples to apples comparisons were closer in price than lots of folks who haven't touched the various versions might guess.  Some of the lower end Grizzly stuff is closer to Harbor Freight, while the top end is closer to major brand, excepting the motor, but priced a lot closer to the branded machine.

  - Will the 1/2 price versions work for me?   Maybe!  See for your yourself....  This is especially true if having a tool down for repair, or having to futz with it longer doesn't cost you money.  You could be a hobbyist, or you could be a pro looking at tools that are functionally duplicated in your shop.

  - Should I compare tools one at a time, vs. overall brands?   YES!   Nobody makes the best of anything, and while Grizzly has a few jewels, the big brands also have a klunker here or there...

  - Don't underestimate motors...  Marathon and Baldor really do make better motors than most Chinese examples.   They cost more, too...

  - Get as much hands-on time on various machines as you can.   This is where taking a class can pay huge dividends.  Learn what "good enough" means to you.  

 

Here's the interesting part...  After several trips to the Grizzly showroom, and having all the major brands represented locally by Tools-Plus, Coastal, and Woodcraft, I've never actually purchased a Grizzly machine.   I think Grizzly has some decent machines, but on the tools I compared head to head, at the time I compared them, the apples to apples comparisons never ended up being as much of a slam dunk as I expected.

I have to agree on needing an apples to apples comparison. I have a Grizzly DC and bandsaw (g0555). Friends with higher end brands comment on the quality of my bandsaw compared to theirs. My DC is better than twice the price brands. However, I've tried a few grizzly table saws and was not impressed.

Adam

for those who want to no what professional grade equipment costs, take a look at Northfield. their smallest jointer is an 8" and it starts at $12,590.  :o

Out of curiosity, I just did a search on ebay for "8" jointer", and there are a lot of good buys of old iron there.

 

http://www.ebay.com/itm/NORTHFIELD-JOINTER-8-INCH-/400515385298?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item5d4093c7d2

 

My '60s Delta has served me well for over 35 years, and it was used when I bought it.  I've never needed a "better" one.  It's quick and easy to change the knives on.

 

This is one I'd consider if I was in the market for one, and that Norhfield was too far away:   http://www.ebay.com/itm/Delta-8-Professional-Jointer-with-Mobil-Base-and-Extra-Knives-/200944749036?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item2ec93d89ec

Dealer premium and warranty differences are reflected in the price, so that's at least part of the equation. 

==>  take a look at Northfield. their smallest jointer is an 8" and it starts at $12,590.

 

yea, cost/quality is all relative...  

 

Once you get to Oliver, Northfield, et al. you are in pattern making territory...  There was a pattern maker in our town, but he's now closed (of course -- they all are).  I used to stop-in every once in a while to use his kit and pick-up tips (occasionally needed to pass some glue-ups over his large planer -- a full 30" -- it weighed over 5000lbs).

 

There's a full-service gunsmith in the area that still has pattern kit  -- you could outfit an entire hobby shop for the cost of any one of his stationary machines...  But again, these guys are slowly closing...

 

If you want true quality on the cheap, then look at used pattern tools.  You could pick-up an Oliver 12" jointer built in the late '40s for anything from $500 to $1500 (depending on condition) and it would be far superior to just about anything you could get today...  With a little work you could get it up to snuff (there are entire websites dedicated to restoring classic Oliver kit).  If you remember David Mark's show WoodWorks, he acquired a 16" pattern maker's jointer circa the 30's (AWWM?) to surface his band-sawed veneers -- he liked to highlight the beast during the show with the 'standing nickle test' ... Many pattern shops got started during the war (obviously) and a great deal of top-shelf pattern equipment is available on the used market...  The real issue is not cost, but weight and 3ph power.  Most hobbyists would have a hard time dealing with 1500lb bandsaws, 1700lb jointers, 3000lb planers, etc...  Try getting one of those bad boys into your basement...

 

it's all relative...

for those who want to no what professional grade equipment costs, take a look at Northfield. their smallest jointer is an 8" and it starts at $12,590. :o

There is a difference between professional and industrial. What you describe is industrial and its outdated industrial at that. I learned woodworking in an industrial shop. We had 100,000 sq ft cabinet shop with many Northfied machines. Today all that has been recycled into Ford and Toyotas to make room for Even larger faster CNC equipment. Today that same company only produces doors in the 950,000 sq ft facility all Cnc. They still have a small 25,000 custom area, every machine in that area is Powermatic with exception of the chain mortiser and wide belt.

==> and its outdated industrial at that

 

Think they prefer the term, 'old school'...  or perhaps, 'classic'... 

Ask yourself what your tolerance level is.  I started with the lower priced jointer you are referring to.  Each time they delivered another one my tolerance level became less and less.  The fifth jointer in my shop over 2 months was a Powermatic PJ882, fresh out of the crate no issues, still running perfect.  Cuts better than the other 4 machines.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.