Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

8" Jointer - Why would I pay twice as much for a Powermatic?

Featured Replies

I own both mfg's. The grizzly works fine and so does the powermatic. I own the grizzly in the joiner. In powermatic I have there sanders. I thought at the time they were a little ahead in quality and might in this area. Buy the Grizzly, if you do not like it sell it. It will not loose that much in value.

Okay, I think I can roll down to MO and visit Grizzly's showroom to test drive their machines. Is there such a place to test drive Powermatic?

I guess it depends on your local store (if there's one), but my local Woodcraft is pretty liberal about letting you turn on the machines and testing / demoing them. I did so for a JET planer, but they had Powermatic jointers in the area as well.

Okay, I think I can roll down to MO and visit Grizzly's showroom to test drive their machines. Is there such a place to test drive Powermatic?

 

I doubt anyone is going to let you test drive a machine. Some woodcraft stores have a class shop, they might let you in for a quick look. With Griz the best thing is to see if they have the machine you want on site. Take your straight edge along to check out the machine so you dont have to send it back if there is an issue. 

I have an old Delta 8", and a Woodtek Taiwanese 6" for a portable jointer.  Either will turn out a good straight board with a clean cut.   I'd like to have a 16", but not bad enough to pay for one, and I do have room for it.  The Woodtek may even be a cheaper machine than the Grizzly, but I've used it a lot in the 6 years I've owned it, and never done anything to it but change the knives.  A jointer is a pretty simple machine.  The Delta has handwheels, and the Woodtek levers.  I actually like the handwheels better for control of fine adjustments.  I don't really "need" anything better than either of these.

 

The only thing I like better than either of the ones I have was an old one I saw once that had a direct drive motor.  The motor was mounted on the end of the cutterhead.  It was the smoothest running woodworking machine I've ever seen. You could hear it running, but there was absolutely no vibration.  If I ever get a big one, it'll be a direct drive.

This chart holds true for just about any purchase, not just tools.

 

The more premium a product, typically the less you get per $ spent.  That isn't to say the value isn't there, or that it is not worth it, but you need to decide where on the chart you fall, and how much certain features are worth.  

 

 

post-7224-0-28659000-1375360874_thumb.pn

  • Popular Post

This chart holds true for just about any purchase, not just tools.

 

The more premium a product, typically the less you get per $ spent.  That isn't to say the value isn't there, or that it is not worth it, but you need to decide where on the chart you fall, and how much certain features are worth.  

 

That chart is to subjective. But just looking at face value Griz would be economy, PM Value and Felder or the like premium making Griz bottom of the barrel which it is not. Their value is in the mind of the owner not some chart that can be changed easily by bias. If we change it up a bit making PM economy, Minimax value and Felder premium this would make the pm bottom of the barrel. We can bias the scale any direction we want in our own minds with just about any product making it worthless.

 

When making a tool purchase it doesnt matter the only thing that matters is that the tool meets your expectations. If it does not then it does not have the expected value. Some are fine with griz and other think they are boat anchors. Any way you look at it as long as a guy is happy with his purchase that is value.

 

 

When making a tool purchase it doesnt matter the only thing that matters is that the tool meets your expectations. If it does not then it does not have the expected value. Some are fine with griz and other think they are boat anchors. Any way you look at it as long as a guy is happy with his purchase that is value.

 

Hit the nail on the head.

PB, I totally agree with you.  The biggest point I am making is that there is an arc, and not a flat line in the price to performance/feature curve regardless where you effectively start and stop your evaluation/scope.  In a perfect world every tool belongs on the chart from HF up to Felder or whatever uber machines are above them on the price scale, however typically budget will define the scope any buyer realistically should review.  Where that arc falls is different in every purchase, but it is important to find out what those additional features are and decide if you are paying the right price for them.  

 

The chart doesn't list value as an axis because it is subjective (probably a poor choice for a category name in hind sight).

Chris, I don't mean to dog pile on your chart, but it doesn't make sense for a lot of products.
I'm not an economist but according to the chart we should buy the most expensive everything. At that point in the chart we are getting the most value because the biggest increases in performance can be had for the smallest increases in cost. That's not the way the most products are marketed.

 

In many cases the line is the exact opposite. The slope of the line would be lower at the bottom of the curve and have a greater slope at the top of the curve. Think about televisions, breakfast cereals, toothbrushes, blue jeans. The curve you show here would apply to products across the same name brand. For example if you compared one grizzly bandsaw to another grizzly bandsaw or one PM jointer to another PM jointer then I think your curve is relevant. This curve makes no account for name brand meaning anything. It also doesn't allow anyone to command a premium for innovation. If this chart were accurate in all cases Bose or Festool could not command the prices they do. Because according to this chart those top end innovations would come at only a minor increase in cost.

 

I don't want to hijack this thread but I'm curious in what context did you find this chart?

The chart needs an overlay for "sledgehammer to crack a nut ratio". I have never heard of most of these brands until woodtalk, however I see minimax (SCM) getting a mention and you view it better than Powermatic? 

I can only speak as I find but we bought a Minimax bandsaw once, and for the money, it was a pile. It was factored into the project and we still use it now, but wow it's crap.

That said I am blessed with some rather nice industrial machines. For a custom Joinery shop like ours the older "classic" machines such as Wadkin, Robinson and Stenner still have very good resale value even though they are on occasions 60yrs old. But not quite this old.....

6948e2e856b4843b7a013f67a502e5a5.jpg

 

Does anyone take a look at industrial suppliers http://catalog.firstchoiceind.net/FIRSTCHOICEIND/myinventory.asp?mc=33&P=52105&S=191&PubID=4979 . Is the 3 phase and issue? Inverters?

==> I have never heard of most of these brands until woodtalk, however I see minimax (SCM) getting a mention and you view it better than Powermatic? 

 

==> we bought a Minimax bandsaw once, and for the money, it was a pile. 

 

It helps to understand how these companies are organized to see why you can get a top-shelf tablesaw and a dud bandsaw from the same company… Usually there is a sales/marketing, service and finance entity combined with one or more manufacturing arms.  Some of the equipment might be manufactured directly by the entity, contract manufactured by a third-party or simply OEM labeling of another entity’s kit (this happens more often than you might think -- you can get exactly the same kit from several mfgs).  Combining several mfg sources allows the entity to offer a ‘full line-up’ without the significant CAPX investment in mfg plants…  Most of the brand names you could mention operate along these lines – some kit is directly made and some is sourced externally…    As for SCM Group – in general, they have a reputation as a middle-to-upper-middle Euro tool supplier and considered a step up from PM, but a step below Griggio/Felder, et al.  However, the same can be said for Powermatic – depending on the tool and/or time-frame, the kit could be supplied from various sources and at different quality levels… So making blanket assessments that one company is always ‘better’ may not hold for their entire line-up…

Chris, I don't mean to dog pile on your chart, but it doesn't make sense for a lot of products.

I'm not an economist but according to the chart we should buy the most expensive everything. At that point in the chart we are getting the most value because the biggest increases in performance can be had for the smallest increases in cost. That's not the way the most products are marketed.

 

 

You are absolutely correct....I had a brain fart!  The axis are mis-labeled.  The Performance should be on the Y-Axis, and Price on the X.  I was quickly re-creating from memory, and did so poorly.  The point is that as you get to the upper level, you are paying a lot more for much less in the way of feature.  

 

Sorry.

I don't see any comments or comparison on General International machines. Any reason?

You are absolutely correct....I had a brain fart!  The axis are mis-labeled.  The Performance should be on the Y-Axis, and Price on the X.  I was quickly re-creating from memory, and did so poorly.  The point is that as you get to the upper level, you are paying a lot more for much less in the way of feature.  

 

Sorry.

OHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.........  In that case, I agree with you.

Now it makes sense to me.

I like this thread.

I have the same trepidation.

Right now I am considering a new bandsaw. I often look at the 18 inch Powermatic and imagine how nice that would be in my shop. Then I discover I can buy 3 of the 19" Grizzly's for the same money. (or 4 or even 5 of the 17 inch Grizzly's.)

 

I've read a ton of reviews on both and their seem to be the same number of positive and negative reviews.

 

What I really need is to be able to go test each of them, but I'm struggling with how to get that done.

 

This is my line of thinking I paid 3 times the cost of a comparable Grizzly table saw for my table saw and I would do it again tomorrow. Every time I run my table saw I smile from ear to ear. (I don't even worry about getting dust in my teeth the dust collection is so good on it.) I want that same feeling when I run my Band Saw.

 

Up until now I use a crappy old craftsman which truth be told has served me well. BUT I don't smile from ear to ear when running it. Do I have to buy the PowerMatic to get that feeling? Can I get that feeling from Grizzly? (The wood magazines always rate it higher than most of its higher priced competitors.) Should I get some other model? I NEED TEST DRIVES, MAN!

I have been saving for a bigger planer for a while. I'm am getting the planer I will never need or want to replace. My plan is to get a powermatic, unsure which size yet. I still have a lot of Nickles to save before I get there.

Chet, you should also take a look at the 18" Rikon bandsaw.  I got one when Highland had them on sale for ~$1,000, and I've been very happy with it.  Solidly built, rips straight without "drifting", and that's with the stock blade.

I don't see any comments or comparison on General International machines. Any reason?

 

I though the same many brands to check GI, Hammer(Felder), Jet, Shop Fox W1705, Sunhill CT-240L, ("Canadian" brand like King, Craftex),  Bridgewood BW8J, Woodtek 907064, Delta.

 

Of course it's also about availability in your area.

  • 10 months later...

I just had the biggest hassle of my life when I got the grizzly 8 inch spiral head dovetail jointer. It took me about three months before I actually got a chance to unpackaged my purchase and then it took me another three days to get all the Schmutz cleaned off of it from the being sent from overseas. I thought to myself boy this is going to be awesome 8 inch helical cutterhead for less than half of the price of a powermatic. Once I finally got the machine set up I put a straight edge on it outfeed table to touching the blade to the infeed table and I ran my long straight edge all the way to one end or the other it was 3/32 inch out of being coplanar. Also my fence was warped on the outfeed side the top left-hand corner was out and on infeed side the bottom right hand corner was out so if I fixed one issue the other one actually got worse. Grizzlies customer service was actually pretty good, they want me to take pictures of my issues and send it to them, they decided that my issues were not acceptable or fixable and they authorized the return for me to ship it back and that's where things went downhill. They told me to send it back the best I could so I put the machine on a pallet wrapped it with three layers of thick foam and tape and took pictures and that was part of my saving grace. After I ratchet strapped the machine to the pallets I gave it to UPS and took pictures after they loaded it a few weeks later I got an email telling me that they had received my machine and I had returned it in horrible condition. They proceeded to tell me all of the things that I had broke and was bad and that they had set the machine back up and fix the parts and that it was very much within their acceptable tolerances. I sent them the pictures that I took and told them that I was not the person who broke any of that stuff, UPS the carrier was to blame I was very upset and mad that they blamed the customer for all the broken stuff and didnt even think to ask UPS if they had dropped it in shipment. Needless to say after they saw my photos they agreed that UPS was to blame for the damage, by that time after hearing that their engineers thought that the things that I found were bull and that the problems that were caused by me and things that were broken were my fault I got totally turned off to precision grizzly equipment. With that said I own many things from grizzly a dust collector, a sander, a grinder, and a small lathe, but please note that all of those things are not precision instruments much like Harbor freight there certain things you buy there and certain things you don't and I think grizzly is the same way stay away from precision equipment. IMHO.

I too own a lot of Grizz stuff and always check them before bringing them home. That's the benefit of having one local.

 

I recently had an issue with them on a backorder item.  Originally, the item was a couple weeks out and then went to a few months.  When I told them this was not acceptable, they managed to find one and have it sent overnight to me. I've had awesome luck with their customer service.

 

It sucks that you've had bad luck and these stories should be shared.  Hope you have better luck getting everything taken care of!

What I don't understand is why you had to return the machine.  The only complaint you had that was actually a manufacturing problem was the warped fence.  Why not just return the fence?  The tables out of coplanar are inconvenient but adjustable, and I'm scratching my head about it taking 3 days to wipe the cosmoline off your cast iron...seems kind of a silly thing to complain about.  Would you have preferred they sent it to you with unprotected metal all covered in rust?  It takes me all of 15 minutes to wipe down a new machine and get it all cleaned up and waxed.  How long does it take you to brush your teeth?

 

Grizzly is a budget-friendly alternative to more expensive units.  Why are they more budget friendly?  Because they have lower quality control tolerances, which means it costs them less to manufacture.  If they raised their QC standards, they would have to raise their prices, and we would no longer have a budget-friendly alternative.  Ordering a Grizzly machine and expecting Felder-quality to arrive is unreasonable.  You have to consider the risk of having some issues when you pay nearly half the price of a comparable higher-end unit.  You get what you pay for.

 

I have several Grizzly machines, and I've had my issues with a few of them.  None were deal breakers.  I had to send back a bandsaw table three times and a jointer fence with the same issue you had.  A minor issue with the drive belt on my planer, and a garbage fence that came with my table saw.  I dealt with the problems, got everything fixed with or without the help of Grizzly customer service, and now everything is smooth sailing.  I feel like I still came out way ahead compared to paying the outrageously inflated prices for a similar machine with a fancier placard and paint job.  Yeah it was irritating, and I expected to be somewhat irritated when I made the purchases.  It comes with the bargain price.

 

Not to lay all the blame on you...if the fence was warped beyond their stated acceptable tolerances, then that's a problem and they're responsible for that.  But it seems like a pretty big overreaction to send back the entire jointer because of a warped fence and a coating of cosmoline that comes with every crated piece of cast iron machinery in the history of cast iron machinery.

 But it seems like a pretty big overreaction to send back the entire jointer because of a warped fence and a coating of cosmoline that comes with every crated piece of cast iron machinery in the history of cast iron machinery.

 

I have to agree, One of the many reasons Grizzly is cheaper, is because they aren't paying for a small army of people to de-grease the machines once they get them off the boat.

....Why are they more budget friendly?  Because they have lower quality control tolerances, which means it costs them less to manufacture.  ...

 

The primary reason Grizzly is less expensive is that they don't pay dealer markup, and only offer a 1 year warranty.  I'm not trying defend them, but comments about their quality control tolerances and number of personnel are speculative.....it's not information that's readily available to the public, so it'd have to come from inside Grizzly.  Grizzly sells more machines than PM, Jet, and Laguna combined, so it's logical that they'd have more defects, but not necessarily a higher defect rate.

 

I agree with having the fence replaced, as opposed to sending back the entire machine. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.