mkirby Posted May 3, 2014 Report Posted May 3, 2014 Decided it would be great fun to try and flatten my bench top. It was fine along the length but tapered across the width. 9 hours later and i have given up. Im seriously contemplating just burning the damn thing and starting from scratch. Off to have a bath and forget about it until the morning. I new i should have left it well alone. Sigh Quote
Eric. Posted May 3, 2014 Report Posted May 3, 2014 I caught you lurking over at the Hand Tool School...Shannon couldn't straighten you out? You take baths? Quote
Llama Posted May 3, 2014 Report Posted May 3, 2014 Kiki, how is that hand tool school? I've been thinking about it, mainly because I'm sure I'd learn something... Yeah, who takes baths? Quote
duckkisser Posted May 3, 2014 Report Posted May 3, 2014 When you take a bath how do you keep all the sawdust and chips from floating away? 1 Quote
G S Haydon Posted May 3, 2014 Report Posted May 3, 2014 You're most likely to hard on yourself Marc, I'm sure it's not that bad. You've got a Rou so loads of stock thickness to straighten it out. Quote
jhl.verona Posted May 3, 2014 Report Posted May 3, 2014 For bad you take a shower. For very bad, only a bath will do. Put a couple of wedges under the legs on the low side, we won't tell anyone. John Quote
Llama Posted May 4, 2014 Report Posted May 4, 2014 Shim it. It'll be good. If you really want to, flatten it again. But that should come later after the frustration of the Roubo wedge edition dissipates. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted May 4, 2014 Report Posted May 4, 2014 Anyone who thinks it is "fun" to flatten a workbench top with only hand planes doesn't need a bath. They need an ice-cold shower to shock them back to reality!!! Quote
PaulMarcel Posted May 4, 2014 Report Posted May 4, 2014 Yeah, unbolt the top, lug it to a cabinet shop, have them run it through some wide planer or drum sander. Don't tell a soul. 2 Quote
derekcohen Posted May 4, 2014 Report Posted May 4, 2014 Decided it would be great fun to try and flatten my bench top. It was fine along the length but tapered across the width. 9 hours later and i have given up. Im seriously contemplating just burning the damn thing and starting from scratch. Off to have a bath and forget about it until the morning. I new i should have left it well alone. Sigh What did you attempt, how, and what was the outcome? Perhaps some will learn from this, and you may have advice on how to correct the situation (whatever that is). Regards from Perth Derek Quote
Popular Post Trip Posted May 4, 2014 Popular Post Report Posted May 4, 2014 ==>lug it to a cabinet shop, have them run it through some wide planer or drum sander. +1. Before I had an oscillating wide-belt sander and a wide planer, I used to lug things to Frank Klausz's shop for just this purpose. Couple of suggestions: 1.Call ahead and ask for a window when the shop is not busy... I typically had to wait between ten days and two weeks. 2. Explain the problem clearly and accurately up-front and reinforce you're in a jam, would appreciate a favor and could use some experienced help. 3.Offer to pay shop-rate up-front. Frank never took my $$, but I always made a donation to what I called the 'sharpening fund' when using his wide planer or the 'sandpaper fund' when using his wide-belt or stroke sander. 4. Make sure the slab is ready to go so there's no futzing-around when you arrive at the shop. He had his apprentices work with me so their time costs him $$. Don't squander their time. Be ready to go when you hit the parking lot... 5. Watch how they process the slab (or anything else going on). I learned quite a bit from watching a Master working with his Apprentices. After a while, I developed a relationship with several shop's in the area. I asked where they got wood, supplies, etc. After a while, two shops allowed me to add stock to their orders to leverage volume-discount. They also let me pick-over his scrap pile -- what one shop called 'scrap' was what I called 'gold'. ==>Don't tell a soul. +2 Good luck. 3 Quote
CStanford Posted May 4, 2014 Report Posted May 4, 2014 Decided it would be great fun to try and flatten my bench top. It was fine along the length but tapered across the width. 9 hours later and i have given up. Im seriously contemplating just burning the damn thing and starting from scratch. Off to have a bath and forget about it until the morning. I new i should have left it well alone. Sigh 1) Pick first face to flatten (this side will be the side you register to the frame of the workbench). 2) Test for, and remove twist. Check at the very ends of the top and at a couple more spots in from the ends as you work very carefully making sure to remove material only where needed. Don't make one plane pass that you don't know the purpose of. Not one. 3) Once twist is gone, evaluate face for cup and general flatness from end-to-end. 4) Remove cup (or hump) whatever the case may be. 5) Finally, flatten from end to end using the longest plane you have; check for cup and twist while you do this to make sure you aren't planing defects back into this face. 6) Once one face is flat, USE YOUR MARKING GAUGE TO MARK THE OTHER SIDE TO DESIRED FINISHED THICKNESS. 7) Plane to the marks but continually check for cup and twist and flatness from end to end. If the first side is really flat and out of twist the gauged marks on side two should result in it being very close to perfect but because of the size of the workpiece (a benchtop) it bears constant checking anyway. 8) Once done, get a finish on both sides of the top as quickly as you can and store the unmounted top so that air can circulate around both sides. Quote
mkirby Posted May 4, 2014 Author Report Posted May 4, 2014 All fixed smooth as ice now. Not perfect but good enough. Basically i had a taper across the width and i was fed up with my marking gauges rolling off (it was that steep). Tried to plane the taper out with the jointer 1st instead of following proper flattening procedure. Once i broke the scrub plane out and found a long enough straight edge it was fairly easy todo. Just a tad monotonous as there was so much wood to remove. Its good enough that a 2' known flat board registers fine on most parts of the top. Even got whispy shavings off of my BU jointer, don't have a smoother yet, for fun. Mortice and tenons tomorrow i need a day of some light work my arms are killing me. 2 Quote
mikem Posted May 5, 2014 Report Posted May 5, 2014 I think you hit upon the best way to solve a problem like that. Walk away from it for the day, and look at again with fresh eyes in the morning. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.