estesbubba Posted June 2, 2014 Report Posted June 2, 2014 I have the major power tools - table saw, band saw, jointer, planer, and drum sander - and looking to compliment those with hand tools. I'm not looking to replace those and looking for hand tools that will help with my efficiency. I have a decent set of chisels plus a set I can beat up so I'm good there. I have the Veritas MK.II honing guide and stones which work good for me. I think flat and round spokeshaves would be useful so they are on my list. I also can see a lot of uses for a router plane and that's on my list. One thing I would like to cut down is sanding time and being able to start with a higher grit. I use my drum sander with 120 for a lot of my boards and usually have to start with 80 on my Festool ETS 150/5. Depending on the grain it can take some work with 80 then after that the next grits go quickly. I have a Veritas card scraper holder and sharpening kit but haven't used it much lately. Would that be good for cleaning up planer and drum sander marks or would I be sharpening too often? Would a cabinet scraper be better for the task and keep an edge longer? Or what about a low-angle jack plane? http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=49708&cat=1,41182,41186,49708 On the plane subject, I have a Leigh FMT I use for mortise and tenons and don't see a shoulder plane being useful right now. If a tenon is a hair thick a router plane could do the trick. I do want a block plane and was thinking about the Veritas Skew block plane. It looks like it could do the work of a block plane and rabbeting block plane. What do you think? http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=65373&cat=1,230,41182,48942 Would the Veritas skew block plane and low-angle jack planes be good initial purchases for getting into planes? I'm not looking at getting a huge plane collection but do want tools that I will use. One additional item is sometimes boards are too big to wrestle into my drum sander and occasional I have to clean up glue lines with a ROS. So if an item above would help that with great. So my list right now is: Router plane (yes) Round spokeshave (yes) Flat spokeshave (yes) Cabinet scraper (maybe) Veritas skew block plane (maybe) Veritias low-angle jack plane (maybe) Thanks for any advice. Quote
TerryMcK Posted June 2, 2014 Report Posted June 2, 2014 Would the Veritas skew block plane and low-angle jack planes be good initial purchases for getting into planes? I'm not looking at getting a huge plane collection but do want tools that I will use. HI Mike, yes indeed the planes you have quoted would be a great initial purchase. I personally would just get a regular block plane though. You will use that more than the skew. The jack is an excellent choice too. Cabinet scrapers (are you thinking card scrapers?) are cheap and great to use too and will remove milling marks easily. 1 Quote
Eric. Posted June 2, 2014 Report Posted June 2, 2014 The LAJ is a very versatile plane, but you'll need to get an extra blade. Use the stock blade for end grain and grind a high angle on the second one for everything else. If I were to have only one block plane it would be the rabbeting block. I use my cabinet scraper way more often that my card scrapers...but card scrapers are cheap so grab a couple of those, too. I usually prefer my cabinet scraper to my smoother for removing mill/sanding marks. If I worked with softer domestics more often that might be different, but I use a lot of exotics and I find the scraper usually gives me better (and more predictable) results than a hand plane on the harder and more figured stock. I'd add a flush trim saw, dovetail saw and a small crosscut saw to that list. I use them pretty often even on non-hand tool projects. Router plane is very handy A couple high quality hand-stitched rasps from Auriou or Liogier 2 Quote
estesbubba Posted June 2, 2014 Author Report Posted June 2, 2014 I have a bunch of card scrapers but not a cabinet scraper. A cabinet scraper just looks like it would be easier to use with its handles. The Veritas skew plane looks to be a rabbeting block plane with a skewed blade. Maybe it tries to do too many things but none of them very well? I'll have to see if I can find any reviews for it. I have a flush trim saw and use it all the time. I have a dovetail saw and never use it because. I have a Leigh D4. I do also want to get some rasps sometime. Thanks for the tips and keep them coming! Quote
Gilgaron Posted June 2, 2014 Report Posted June 2, 2014 A nice compliment to a flush cut saw is a chisel plane. Lee Valley calls theirs a cabinet maker's trimming plane. I like my Veritas tools but went with the Woodriver equivalent in this instance, since it is less than half as much. It doesn't have adjustments to speak of like the LV does but I'm not sure that the adjustments are all that necessary for flushing plugs and glue lines. Quote
wdwerker Posted June 2, 2014 Report Posted June 2, 2014 I routinely sand to 150 on my drum sander before going to the ETS 150 with 120 grit. Proceed from there as you have. Quote
brooklyngohardwood Posted June 3, 2014 Report Posted June 3, 2014 Consider the LN Rabbiting Block instead of the Veritas Skew Block. Although I don't have one yet, lots of research has convinced me it will be more versatile (works better as a regular block plane) and is a bit cheaper. Quote
derekcohen Posted June 3, 2014 Report Posted June 3, 2014 So my list right now is: Router plane (yes) Round spokeshave (yes) Flat spokeshave (yes) Cabinet scraper (maybe) Veritas skew block plane (maybe) Veritias low-angle jack plane (maybe) Thanks for any advice. Hi Mike My advice is to buy one or two on your list, use them slowly and integrate them into your powertool-orientated methods, learn what they can do, and only then move on to the next tool. The problem I see is that you have compiled a list of tools off fora, and these are popular, not necessarily helpful to a novice. For example, I would not buy the skewed block plane just yet, nor the rabbet block plane. They are more specialist tools. Just get a basic block plane, either LN or LV. You would love the LN #102 or the LV Apron. Similarly, since all the boards you will work are machined flat, a longer, all-round plane like the LV LA Jack would be useful - use it to traverse and smooth panels, and on a shooting board. A tool that you reject is the dovetail saw. Get one. Even if you are not sawing dovetails, get the feel for joinery by sawing offcuts. Using handtools is all about acquiring muscle memory, recognising the feedback they give you, and enjoying the control that you can achieve. Handtools will take you to places that machines cannot go. Begin the journey now. Start slow. Regards from Perth Derek 1 Quote
PaulMarcel Posted June 4, 2014 Report Posted June 4, 2014 Definitely get the spokeshaves and throw offcuts in a vise and start shaping them. Won't be long before curves are appearing in new places in your projects. Rasps are nice, too, but I think you could get a long way with the spokeshaves first to see how you like that type of shaping. Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted June 4, 2014 Report Posted June 4, 2014 Derek's advice is very sound (as usual). A spoke shave is a very handy tool to shape as Paul-Marcel mentions. When the urge to get a rasp strikes, visit with Noel Liogier as he's very approachable and hand makes very fine rasps over in France. 1 Quote
PaulMarcel Posted June 4, 2014 Report Posted June 4, 2014 Love the Liogiers and Iwasaki plane files. Did a cove on the inside of a leg with just the Iwasaki files and it came out needing a light sanding at P180. Quote
jmaichel Posted June 7, 2014 Report Posted June 7, 2014 I think the best way to approach adding hand tools is to think about what tools you would get the most use of. Off the top of my head the first two that make the most sense is a router plane and the LAJ or even a regular Jack Plane. I only have one blade for my LN LA Jack Plane and don't have any problems using it on end grain. Granted I tend to only use soft woods or softer hard woods. I have used it Purple Heart and a couple of other figured woods and did not have great success. If I was using exotics and figured wood on a regular basis then I would definitely recommend two separate blades. I did break the corners of the blade but still get some plane tracks when smoothing, not a big deal though. I can clean up the plane tracks with a card scraper or sanding block. I would also take a good look at a rabbet block plane; I have one and use it all the time, they are great for trimming tenon cheeks but I have found it very useful for creating rabbets. In the interest of full disclosure, this is not what I did the first time I added hand tools but that is a different story. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.