networkspeedy Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 I'd like to start putting together a good arsenal of planes. A bench plane, and a jack plane first. I read reviews of the higher-end stanleys and there's a holy war about whether or not they are up to snuff. Are they? Do they get the job done and do it well? Or do I truly need a lie nielsen plane for that? I can accept that I'll have to pony up more cash per plane if lie nielsen is the must-have tool, but if the Stanley gives me more bang for the buck, then I'd think it makes sense to go in that direction. I don't buy tools as status symbols. Tools are meant to do work and so that's what I expect out of them. So let me make it clear that this isn't a question of what plane to buy. This is a question of what you experienced folks prefer in your own shops and workbenches, and what you've learned in your years of craftsmanship. You've already tread the path of experience and I'm not ashamed to say I'd like to take advantage of that. I am here to learn, so please guide my footsteps with the lamps of your knowledge and I know I'll come out on top. Quote
RichardA Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 I can't speak to what the LN's or the LV's are like... word is that they plane wood like it was butter! I have Stanley's, and with the proper set up and sharpening. I can plane wood like it was butter or cheese. I to , think planes are meant to be users, not dust collectors. Most of the planes I have were gifts, yard sale items or Ebay. I discovered that when taking older planes and reconditioning them, I learn more about what you can do with them, and what you can do to get a great performance from them. And they don't cost a first born child. But, the knowledge you get from them is priceless! Quote
G S Haydon Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 New Stanley's Meh, so so. I bought some. Decent, could be really good. Second hand Stanley via http://www.hyperkitten.com/tools/or Superior http://www.supertool.com/ or even the ebay thang. LN & LV will be great also. Quote
..Kev Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 I have LN and really like them! I also have an old Stanley that does the job as well but, requires a little more attention to the blade. Quote
zberger7646 Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 Is it possible to use a LN blade with the Stanley 62? Quote
Shane Jimerfield Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 I have LN, old stanleys and Woodrivers. LN is uber fantastic. Old Stanleys require work and that can be good. Helps you understand planes. They can be great performers with quite a bit of work. WR are great for the price. They require a bit more than a LN or Veritas out of the box, but when you get past that, well, they become more indistinguishable. If you work with lots of figured wood then you will have to become good at sharpening to razor sharpness. If you don't and want to save a few hundred bucks on your plane inventory to buy a nice hand saw then go Woodriver and hone your sharpening skills. p.s. figured woods = scrappers... Quote
Freddie Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 If you like nice shiny things, then you will enjoy Lie Nielsen. The big misconception about the different brands is which ones are better performers. Lie Nielsen will work out of the box, but if you don't know how to sharpen or use the tool that honeymoon won't last too long. Once you've perfected your sharpening regiment, you'll be able to produce the same fine work whether it is a $400 LN or a $15 flea market find. Some people just want to spend more money, or get more satisfaction using a tool that is well made, I know I do. My first planes were a Stanley block from Lowes and a Woodriver #4. I could have continued on that path but decided to start going for the LN's and Veritas because as much as I enjoy woodworking, I also enjoy tools, especially sexy ones. Quote
TerryMcK Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 I have all three brands you quoted and even some other brands. They all work supremely well for me. Modern Stanleys can be disappointing needing lots of work tuning to get good results but perseverance when tuning can pay off. Older Stanleys can be better probably something to do with being better made than their modern counterparts. LN and LV work straight out of the box brand new. Woodriver/quangsheng do too. So to your question "what do I prefer? " - Well its LN/LV of course ... Oh and Stanley ... And Quangsheng. See I like them all 1 Quote
Popular Post Trip Posted December 28, 2014 Popular Post Report Posted December 28, 2014 Need LN? No. Your question is about usage – what planes do we prefer? Answer: a well-tuned plane with a flat sole, adjustable frog, lots of mass and well-bedded thick sharp iron… Brand is not important... On an absolute scale, neither is fit/finish.... However, I like using a tool that's well made with good fit/finish.. So for me, there are qualities beyond just how well a tool works that are important... As an aside, it tends to occur more with hand tools than power tools --- not sure why, but it is what it is… Many years ago, my dad told me there is something satisfying about using a good tool… I prefer my Snap-on socket driver over my Husky -- they both turn a socket equally well -- but the Snap-on just 'feels right'... Same with work benches -- on an absolute scale, round dog holes make more sense -- but there's just something about square that seems right... It’s buy/build economics… You can buy it out of the box (LN), you can build it (restore something vintage /w a Hock iron) or some combination… But no matter what you do, it’ll cost you – time, $$ or both… The days of finding a mint 1939 Orange Bedrock smoother for $1.50 are long over… It still happens, just not to me (or anyone I know)… I use BD iron-body Bailey style planes because it’s the pattern I’m used to… If my dad used wood-body planes, then that’s probably what I’d use… BTW: I do use some wooden-body planes – and they work just fine… I prefer the mass of iron-body for bench planes, but I’ve got some wood-body specialty planes that have a nice feel and work very well… In my case, I purchased the fit/finish -- most of my planes are LN... LV brings more inovation to the table, but LN excells at fit/finish on a Bedrock pattern... For me, it's a perfect fit... 4 Quote
Eric. Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 Never ceases to impress me...Trip's ability to put into words exactly what I'm thinking but too lazy to articulate coherently. Quote
Popular Post ..Kev Posted December 28, 2014 Popular Post Report Posted December 28, 2014 Never ceases to impress me...Trip's ability to put into words exactly what I'm thinking but too lazy to articulate coherently. That's why you're just staff and he's a mentor 5 Quote
estesbubba Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 That's why you're just staff and he's a mentor And why one gets pigtails and the other doesn't. 1 Quote
..Kev Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 And why one gets pigtails and the other doesn't. Ouch.. Quote
networkspeedy Posted December 28, 2014 Author Report Posted December 28, 2014 And why one gets pigtails and the other doesn't. I missed the "pig" prefix for a second and I'm like whaaaa? Really? I should get to know these guys better. Quote
Popular Post Byrdie Posted December 28, 2014 Popular Post Report Posted December 28, 2014 Most every response starts with the same term - need. Simply put, what you need in a plane is a sharp blade, a flat bottom and a length of body appropriate to the task at hand. Graham does some pretty nice work with some rehabbed wood bodies. I don't have the budget for LN, LV or Veritas so I just bought a Stanley rabbeting plane. I spent an hour lapping the sole, 20 minutes adjusting the bits and 15 minutes dressing the blade. It does exactly what I bought it to do. I have a Bailey #6 that I bought in an antique shop, a wood body about the same length, a Buck Bros. that's about the size of a smoother (4 1/2?) that I bought in a charity auction and my first plane that's done the brunt of the work in my shop is a no name, house brand block plane. Would I mind having some tool porn in my shop? Duh! But I've got what I need to get the job done. It's the way we use our tools that make us artist or craftsmen, not the name brand or the color of the paint scheme. 4 Quote
..Kev Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 Most every response starts with the same term - need. Simply put, what you need in a plane is a sharp blade, a flat bottom and a length of body appropriate to the task at hand. Graham does some pretty nice work with some rehabbed wood bodies. I don't have the budget for LN, LV or Veritas so I just bought a Stanley rabbeting plane. I spent an hour lapping the sole, 20 minutes adjusting the bits and 15 minutes dressing the blade. It does exactly what I bought it to do. I have a Bailey #6 that I bought in an antique shop, a wood body about the same length, a Buck Bros. that's about the size of a smoother (4 1/2?) that I bought in a charity auction and my first plane that's done the brunt of the work in my shop is a no name, house brand block plane. Would I mind having some tool porn in my shop? Duh! But I've got what I need to get the job done. It's the way we use our tools that make us artist or craftsmen, not the name brand or the color of the paint scheme. Very wise words indeed! Quote
networkspeedy Posted December 28, 2014 Author Report Posted December 28, 2014 Nope. This is where we part ways my friend. My tools have to be the same color or my OCD pills start getting too expensive. Just kidding of course. Now let me check my spelling for the 4th time... Quote
..Kev Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 Nope. This is where we part ways my friend. My tools have to be the same color or my OCD pills start getting too expensive. Just kidding of course. Now let me check my spelling for the 4th time... It's quite funny you bring that up! Fact is that many people buy a tool more because it matches others than because it serves the purpose intended.. Quote
Shane Jimerfield Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 My socks don't even match most days. I can't seem to figure it out, because they matched when I bought them. Quote
Freddie Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 It's quite funny you bring that up! Fact is that many people buy a tool more because it matches others than because it serves the purpose intended.. Kind of like that concave spokeshave right? Quote
Eric. Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 That's why you're just staff and he's a mentor And why one gets pigtails and the other doesn't. No argument. My IQ has been swirling down the toilet ever since I was pulled over to the dark side. Don't know what it is, but something about that mentor badge makes you smarter. Without it I just kind of feel like...Freddie. 1 Quote
..Kev Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 Kind of like that concave spokeshave right? On the right track Freddie.. That was a tool that I fully admit hasn't seen more than a test drive but, it came with the set so, who was I to complain? And that one does look cool hanging out with the others. Quote
networkspeedy Posted December 28, 2014 Author Report Posted December 28, 2014 I'm getting email updates to this topic that don't appear when I visit the website. Does this happen to anyone else? Quote
..Kev Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 I'm getting email updates to this topic that don't appear when I visit the website. Does this happen to anyone else? There were a couple posts removed Speedy.. You didn't miss anything 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.