Recommended Posts

Posted

On a job-site table saw thread, ParticleBoard made the following recommendation:

 

If I could only have a job site saw I wouldn't own a "table" saw. I would probably jump into Festool with both feet. The biggest issue with space limitations is the ability to joint and plane. I know three home developers that have banned job site saws all together and the trend is growing.

 

I am space limited, and currently own a Bosch 4100 job site saw. I have owned it for a year and am happy with it.  It has done everything I have asked it to do.  However, there are some things that I won't ask it to do, like a 4x8 sheet of plywood.

Sooooo, I am about 90% convinced to transition to Festool, and plan to jump in one foot at a time. I have been reviewing the Festool marketing videos, other Festool videos, and reading a lot of Festool customer reviews.

I plan to transition over a 12 month period...selling old stuff before buying new.

My first question has to do with dust collectors.  Based on my research, I believe the CT 26 E HEPA Dust Extractor will meet my needs. I can't really figure out the difference between the 26, 36, or 48, other than $$.

But my real question is will I need an add on like the Oneida Ultimate dust deputy?

http://www.woodwerks.com/oneida-ultimate-dust-deputy.html

 

If the Oneida Ultimate dust deputy makes sense, I will probably go ahead and buy it, since it will work with my Ridgid shop vac.

Any comments on the Festool dust collectors will be appreciated.

Thanks

Posted

Need is a relative term. The dust extractors will work perfectly fine without a pre separator, but you'll go through a lot more bags that way. So the trade off is the extra cost (in space and money) of the pre separator vs. the cost and hassle of more frequent bag changes.

Posted

I have the CT26 in my shop. Never filled a bag up in a single day, rarely in a single week ! I dump them out and reuse several times. So I see no need to buy the UDD, unless you were going to hook it up to a drum sander ! The motor is the same on the 26 36 & 48 so it's just a bigger bag and machine around the same guts.

I use a dust deputy on my drum sander with a Large Ridgid vac and it works pretty good but when I get a 19/38 Supermax it's getting hooked to a dust collector not a vac.

The tracksaw is great for sheet goods and so many other things as well but a good solid cabinet saw is still the center of my shop.

  • Like 1
Posted

26 will work great!  You may want to consider a couple of them so you're not constantly dragging it around the shop.  I also think the DD would be a perfect addition!

Posted

.... Never filled a bag up in a single day, rarely in a single week ! I dump them out and reuse several times.....

 

Thanks...even though I didn't ask the exact question, that is the exact information I was looking for.

 

 

 

....

The tracksaw is great for sheet goods and so many other things as well but a good solid cabinet saw is still the center of my shop.

 

 

I have access to a good solid cabinet saw, but it is across the street, 4 houses down.  But for what I envision I will be making over the next couple of years, the Festools look very tempting.  And when the cabinet saw is required, then I'm headed across the street, 4 houses down.  In fact, tonight, I cut the boards for my Roubo bench top on the cabinet saw.

Posted

I have a 50" cabinet saw, and my Festool track saw is the first saw I go to to break down sheet goods. Also good for trimming a table edge, cut down an inside door to fit the door in a frame. I have a ct48 vacuum. It's big, I would not transport it to a jobsite. It's good for the shop due to its size. For transporting, the ct26 is your best bet for capacity and portability. As for the dust deputy, I have one I use with my rigid shop vac, I connect it to my smaller tools like spindle sander, and for cleaning up the shop. The udd will add some additional height and isn't really necessary.

Posted

I have a ct26 and I love it - I use it for my festool stuff, as well as my pc biscuit joiner and my kreg pocket hole jig. It's awesome to have great suction, and have the tool power the vac for stuff like biscuits and pocket screws and sanding.

I have a dd, but have recently disconnected it and put it in the basement. It just takes up a crazy amount of space in my shop. It's normally hooked up to a Ridgid vac, which I just buy bags for now (with a HEPA filter) to keep the fines at bay.

For me, buying bags is worth the extra cost to not trop over the vacs all the time!

I would have to agree with the above posts - a good TS is the heart of my shop - I would sacrifice almost all my other tools to keep it.

While a tracksaw is on my short list, I currently break down sheet goods with an inexpensive circular saw and edge guide. Gets me really close, and then I trim off the last bit on the TS.

Posted

Ftrpilot, how much area do you have to work in?

 

I am in my 2 car garage...and I would like to park both cars at night in the garage.  Recently, I have only been parking one car at night.

Posted

I am in my 2 car garage...and I would like to park both cars at night in the garage.  Recently, I have only been parking one car at night.

So your working with about the same footprint as I am. My garage space is 12x18.5'. I'm about to post a tiny shop tour, may give you an idea or two about how you could keep the t's and still have space

Posted

On a job-site table saw thread, ParticleBoard made the following recommendation:

 

 

I am space limited, and currently own a Bosch 4100 job site saw. I have owned it for a year and am happy with it.  It has done everything I have asked it to do.  However, there are some things that I won't ask it to do, like a 4x8 sheet of plywood.

Sooooo, I am about 90% convinced to transition to Festool, and plan to jump in one foot at a time. I have been reviewing the Festool marketing videos, other Festool videos, and reading a lot of Festool customer reviews.

I plan to transition over a 12 month period...selling old stuff before buying new.

My first question has to do with dust collectors.  Based on my research, I believe the CT 26 E HEPA Dust Extractor will meet my needs. I can't really figure out the difference between the 26, 36, or 48, other than $$.

But my real question is will I need an add on like the Oneida Ultimate dust deputy?

http://www.woodwerks.com/oneida-ultimate-dust-deputy.html

 

If the Oneida Ultimate dust deputy makes sense, I will probably go ahead and buy it, since it will work with my Ridgid shop vac.

Any comments on the Festool dust collectors will be appreciated.

Thanks

 

I have two Festool vacs: the CT26 and the latest version of the Midi, along with an older Fein Turbo II and the new Fein 912. The new Fein sucks better and makes less noise than any of the others and costs less than the CT26.

 

You pays your money and takes your choice. My advice is to check around before slugging back the green Kool-Aid, I have enough of their tools to know they aren't the be-all, end-all of power tool manufacturers. They have their roses and they have their thorns.

 

Best,

Bill

  • Like 2
Posted

FtrPilot, I work AND park two cars in my garage. Granted, at 24'x36', it is bigger than some, but all my stuff still has to roll away when the dust stops flying. I use a shop vac for sanders and bandsaw, which make mostly finer dust. Everything else gets a broom.

I have the advantage of living out in the country, so when weather permits, I work out in the driveway and let nature do her thing with the mess. About the only time I use my dust collector is if it is too cold or wet to use the planer outside.

Posted

I have a CT26 with the UDD. I first used it with a Shop-Vac commercial unit, knowing I would add the CT26 later. I don't do any outside work - only in my shop, so portability is not an issue.  That said, I recommend the UDD. It's much faster and easier to empty than the CT26 and does what it's designed to do really well. I get almost no dust at all in the CT26 filter bag, so in the long run you'll break even on the cost of the UDD from not replacing bags. 

 

I know this sounds crazy and I have no way to measure it, but it seems to make the CT26 more efficient. If I hook up the CT26 to my bandsaw without the UDD and then with the UDD I get very different results.  With the UDD it sucks the front cover in (Inca 710 20"). You can feel the air being pulled in around the blade insert. Before moving into a permanent shop and having a true dust collector, I used the setup on all my tools - jointer, planer, TS, etc.  Not ideal, but it worked amazingly well!

Posted

So your working with about the same footprint as I am. My garage space is 12x18.5'. I'm about to post a tiny shop tour, may give you an idea or two about how you could keep the t's and still have space

 

Thanks...

 

 

I have a CT26 with the UDD. I first used it with a Shop-Vac commercial unit, knowing I would add the CT26 later. I don't do any outside work - only in my shop, so portability is not an issue.  That said, I recommend the UDD. It's much faster and easier to empty than the CT26 and does what it's designed to do really well. I get almost no dust at all in the CT26 filter bag, so in the long run you'll break even on the cost of the UDD from not replacing bags. 

 

I know this sounds crazy and I have no way to measure it, but it seems to make the CT26 more efficient. If I hook up the CT26 to my bandsaw without the UDD and then with the UDD I get very different results.  With the UDD it sucks the front cover in (Inca 710 20"). You can feel the air being pulled in around the blade insert. Before moving into a permanent shop and having a true dust collector, I used the setup on all my tools - jointer, planer, TS, etc.  Not ideal, but it worked amazingly well!

 

Some great info...thanks.

 

 

FtrPilot, I work AND park two cars in my garage. Granted, at 24'x36', it is bigger than some, but all my stuff still has to roll away when the dust stops flying. I use a shop vac for sanders and bandsaw, which make mostly finer dust. Everything else gets a broom.

I have the advantage of living out in the country, so when weather permits, I work out in the driveway and let nature do her thing with the mess. About the only time I use my dust collector is if it is too cold or wet to use the planer outside.

 

Glad to know that I am not the only one stuck in a garage.  Thanks...,

Posted

There are other options.  I have the TS75 and the Domino XL 700 and will eventually replace my aging sanders and add a router. I am in the final throes of building my last (retirement) shop.  The workshop area is 30 x 17 (actually 12 when it all said and done).  I thought seriously about one of the Festool dust extractors but did not want something else getting in the way.  So I bought a central vac.  It allows me to put it on a wall, out of the way, the ducting is cheap and easy and it came with a 30' "garage" hose that is easily adapted to the Festools I have.  The specs are equivalent to Festool

and I am extremely happy with it.  I thought about a Dust Deputy but the bags are only $4.00.  It is dedicated to my SCMS, router station with a 3rd outlet for future needs.  The hose will reach any area that I have a need.  I installed a switched outlet so I can easily turn it on.  The cost was about same as a Festool, just under $600.00, but for me it was a better solution.  I use a HF DC for the rest of my tools.

post-16772-0-06461800-1430875057_thumb.j

post-16772-0-49394600-1430875058_thumb.j

  • Like 1
Posted

Very neat and tidy Bob!  Since you live so close to me, I would love to see it some time!

Your kidding right? It would be an honor.  Couple of conditions though... 

1.  No comparing skill sets... I started  woodworking out of necessity, self taught, no talent

2.  Understand my wife (a quilter) will bug you about what you did for yours... yes my wife knows what I am doing online. What can I say, been married for 41 years. 

Posted

Your kidding right? It would be an honor.  Couple of conditions though... 

1.  No comparing skill sets... I started  woodworking out of necessity, self taught, no talent

2.  Understand my wife (a quilter) will bug you about what you did for yours... yes my wife knows what I am doing online. What can I say, been married for 41 years. 

 

Sounds perfectly fair!  I have only 1 condition.

 

1.  Since my wife is also a quilter, our wives can never meet since I'm sure it will cost me a lot of money!

 

I'll drop you a pm with contact info.

Posted

I sort of skimmed the responses, so I'm not sure if your question was answered.

The only difference between the different CTs is the capacity. The vacs suction is the same no difference.

I have a CT 26 and I bought a CT22 used. The 26 is a nice sized one.depending on the size of your project, I have to empty mine about once a week. Best it get a,one life bag while your at it. It will save you money in the long run and frustration as it's easier to dump the contents.ny might also consider getting a 36 mm hose it helps the dust extraction for the TS and miter saw , router quite a bit. The smaller did you'll need for sanders etc.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 41 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined