bushwacked Posted May 4, 2015 Report Posted May 4, 2015 I am curious why I dont really see all that much on these? Are they a nice to have but can be overlooked once you have a nice dust collection system setup? I was looking into the JET air filtration system when I get my new house garage shop going. Should I pick one up when I dive into the dust collection setup or is it even needed? The $3-400 wont break me, but I am curious if it is even worth the money. It is one of those nice to haves but low on the priority list? Quote
Tom Cancelleri Posted May 4, 2015 Report Posted May 4, 2015 I have the Jet AFB1000B. I have dust collection on my machines however there's still stuff floating around in the air. It guys a fair amount of fine. You'd be surprised when cleaning the filter at how much it actually gets. 1 Quote
AstroDave Posted May 4, 2015 Report Posted May 4, 2015 I also have the Jet AFB100B... I just yesterday cleaned the filter and was shocked at the amount of fine dust that was collected. So I think it's definitely a need to have. With regard to which unit to go with I don't know... I went with the Jet because I got a good deal. However I have heard good things about the JDS units... http://jdstools.com/product/air-tech-hp-2/ Quote
Eric. Posted May 4, 2015 Report Posted May 4, 2015 I wouldn't bother with a filter unless I was in a basement shop and I didn't want the dust getting into the rest of the house. Nothing replaces a respirator if you're concerned about health issues...you'll still be breathing all the airborne particles before they're filtered as they float around the shop. Every time you open or close a door, move a board, turn on a machine, whatever...dust gets kicked back into the air. So in a garage shop, I find it fairly useless. Invest that money in a better DC system so you can collect more fine particulates at the source. Quote
wdwerker Posted May 4, 2015 Report Posted May 4, 2015 It might help reduce the dust getting into your finishing if you don't have a seperate place from the shop to let things dry. 1 Quote
dwacker Posted May 4, 2015 Report Posted May 4, 2015 Save your money, dust should be collected at the source. Yes they will collect some dust but so will flypaper. Unless you are doing something like sanding and can have the filter within inches of the dust maker they will not improve overall air quality. Quote
Brendon_t Posted May 4, 2015 Report Posted May 4, 2015 I share a garage with the wife and the washing machine/ folding table. I find that even keeping the garage door open for a while, fine dust still settles quite a bit over night. Call it a waste of money but I'm pretty sure my wife would appreciate me picking one up. Quote
dwacker Posted May 4, 2015 Report Posted May 4, 2015 I share a garage with the wife and the washing machine/ folding table. I find that even keeping the garage door open for a while, fine dust still settles quite a bit over night. Call it a waste of money but I'm pretty sure my wife would appreciate me picking one up. If you want to keep the wife happy buy a half dozen box fans and stranded furnace filters. Fire all of them up when you close up shop for the night. Put them at different levels pointed different directions. If you can't keep eliminate the dead spots and keep the dust in suspension its not going to do you much if any good. Quote
Dan S Posted May 4, 2015 Report Posted May 4, 2015 I don't have one yet, but it's on the list. They are something that's an addition to your dust collector, not an alternative to it. No matter how good your dust collector is, you will never get everything at the source. If sized properly, these systems will minimize the fine layer of dust that collects on horizontal surfaces in your shop. Quote
Mick S Posted May 5, 2015 Report Posted May 5, 2015 I think many people look at these filters almost like an overhead downdraft table - an updraft table? That's not really what they're for. I turn mine on to run for a couple of hours when I leave the shop to clear the fine particles from the ambient air. They'll pick up much of the really dangerous stuff that most dust collectors miss. 1 Quote
PeteJr Posted May 5, 2015 Report Posted May 5, 2015 These are designed to provide clean filtered air. As such I have positioned these around the perimeter of my shop. You must collect dust at the tool first then use these to filter out fine airborne dust. You should also wear a high quality dust mask whenever possible. Quote
bushwacked Posted May 5, 2015 Author Report Posted May 5, 2015 Ya I always wear my mask ... my main thing was while I am not there, or my wife or kid is walking through the garage to get into the house I am trying to get a lot of the extra particles captured so they do not breathe it in Quote
tim0625 Posted May 5, 2015 Report Posted May 5, 2015 I periodically go back to the youtube video on "Tyme's dustless shop" just for ideas and inspiration. He collects most all of the dust at the tool with an Oneita 5 hp cyclone. I would love to get to the place one day that I could have a nearly dustless shop.....and I think it can be done......but I'm going to have to throw some serious stuff into it: time, effort, concentrated focus, and ......money. In the end, it will be worth it. Quote
dwacker Posted May 5, 2015 Report Posted May 5, 2015 You can evaluate the effectiveness of your filter by using 18" of survey ribbon. The ribbon should be pulled 45 degrees toward the intake. This is the effective area and the same test osha uses for machine hoods. The results are pretty disappointing which is why osha does not even recognize these filter as part of the air improvement system. I had four of the powermatics in my home shop and they basically did very little and did nothing more than light house keeping. My shop is probably one of the easiest to filter just because I don't have a bunch of cabinets and objects affecting air circulation and even with four they were just a waste of electricity. Quote
ponderingturtle Posted May 5, 2015 Report Posted May 5, 2015 Given how often the use of these seems to be turn on when I leave the shop and let it run for a few hours, it would be an entirely different expectation out of what it would do than an active hood, or dust collector. So the intent is entirely different. I don't know if they are effective for what people think they do in that kind of usage either but it is at least a different intent than the methods you are evaluating would be. Quote
Dan S Posted May 5, 2015 Report Posted May 5, 2015 Given how often the use of these seems to be turn on when I leave the shop and let it run for a few hours, it would be an entirely different expectation out of what it would do than an active hood, or dust collector. So the intent is entirely different. If you have to let it run for a few hours, it's probably not sized and/or positioned correctly. Properly sized, the system should be able to circulate the volume of air in your shop in 5 to 10 minutes. After a few hours the dust will have settled to the ground on it's own. Check this FWW article. It has a graph that compares multiple filters vs. a baseline (no filter). It's one of the few decent "scientific" articles done by FWW, that shows how effective air filters can be. http://www.finewoodworking.com/fwnpdfFREE/011213054.pdf Quote
dwacker Posted May 5, 2015 Report Posted May 5, 2015 Given how often the use of these seems to be turn on when I leave the shop and let it run for a few hours, it would be an entirely different expectation out of what it would do than an active hood, or dust collector. So the intent is entirely different. I don't know if they are effective for what people think they do in that kind of usage either but it is at least a different intent than the methods you are evaluating would be. Actually no. When we discuss using it for housekeeping its the exhaust that does the real work. Quote
Raefco Posted May 5, 2015 Report Posted May 5, 2015 Here is my homemade unit, I can move it around the shop. It does a pretty good job getting the fines out of the air and it doubles as a sanding table. I made it with a furnace plenum, a flea market box fan and 3 furnace filters. I dont think I would be as happy with a fixed in place unit. Quote
Mick S Posted May 5, 2015 Report Posted May 5, 2015 If you have to let it run for a few hours, it's probably not sized and/or positioned correctly. Properly sized, the system should be able to circulate the volume of air in your shop in 5 to 10 minutes. After a few hours the dust will have settled to the ground on it's own. Check this FWW article. It has a graph that compares multiple filters vs. a baseline (no filter). It's one of the few decent "scientific" articles done by FWW, that shows how effective air filters can be. http://www.finewoodworking.com/fwnpdfFREE/011213054.pdf The unit has a timer on it with settings for either 2 or 4 hours and one for continuous. I set it for two hours when I leave the shop. Quote
AceHoleInOne Posted May 5, 2015 Report Posted May 5, 2015 I have a shop made one using plywood, an attic fan from the home center and 2 1500 20x20 3M furnace filters. I'll tell you what, they do catch a lot of dust. After 2 weeks in my shop. I take compressed air and blow the filters...you should see the dust exiting those filters. They do work and very well at that. Get one and you'll be glad you did. -Ace- Quote
Brendon_t Posted May 5, 2015 Report Posted May 5, 2015 I have a shop made one using plywood, an attic fan from the home center and 2 1500 20x20 3M furnace filters. I'll tell you what, they do catch a lot of dust. After 2 weeks in my shop. I take compressed air and blow the filters...you should see the dust exiting those filters. They do work and very well at that. Get one and you'll be glad you did. -Ace- Attic fans are no joke. If I turn mine on (actually two) before opening windows, I can feel the pressure drop in my inner ear. Quote
dwacker Posted May 5, 2015 Report Posted May 5, 2015 I have a shop made one using plywood, an attic fan from the home center and 2 1500 20x20 3M furnace filters. I'll tell you what, they do catch a lot of dust. After 2 weeks in my shop. I take compressed air and blow the filters...you should see the dust exiting those filters. They do work and very well at that. Get one and you'll be glad you did. -Ace- Thats not really a measure of effectiveness any filter will collect dust if there is enough dust in suspension at the intake. Its a better measure of how ineffective you are at collecting at the source collection. The only way we have to measure effectiveness is just a guestimation with the old fashioned white glove test. Quote
Dan S Posted May 5, 2015 Report Posted May 5, 2015 Thats not really a measure of effectiveness any filter will collect dust if there is enough dust in suspension at the intake. Its a better measure of how ineffective you are at collecting at the source collection. The only way we have to measure effectiveness is just a guestimation with the old fashioned white glove test. As other have said, not everything can be collected at the source. Do you run your dust collector every time you use a handsaw, hand plane, cordless drill, drill press, hand sand something? Quote
AceHoleInOne Posted May 5, 2015 Report Posted May 5, 2015 Thats not really a measure of effectiveness any filter will collect dust if there is enough dust in suspension at the intake. Its a better measure of how ineffective you are at collecting at the source collection. The only way we have to measure effectiveness is just a guestimation with the old fashioned white glove test. Well....I like many other's on the forum, I don't work in a perfect shop as you my friend. So I do the best with what I have, thank you very much. And as Dan said above, other operations in the shop don't have dust pipes hooked up. So quit being a woodworking snob and get off my back every-time I post something. Its getting a little old don't ya think!!!!! Ok now I will sit back and see if the "Forum Police" will delete this. -Ace- Quote
Eric. Posted May 5, 2015 Report Posted May 5, 2015 Oh hell no. This endless pissing match between you and Don is about the most amusing thing that happens here on a daily basis. The funniest part is that you let it get to you. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.