N00b-in-training Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 Just saw the new Powermatic Tenoning Jig. Wow it looks awesome! Too bad PM is a little proud of it and is charging $330, goodness that's expensive. I bought a 'traditional' tenoning jig a while back but returned it after a few uses. It's just too easy to throw in a dado stack and get it dialed in. Quote
Brendon_t Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 The only pm tenon jig I've ever seen has been around forever at $145. Where did you see a new one? Quote
JerrySats Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 The only pm tenon jig I've ever seen has been around forever at $145. Where did you see a new one? PM sent out emails yesterday about the new jig. Woodcraft has it on their Web site now. Quote
Brendon_t Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 I guess pm is the only email mailing list that I'm NOT on. Quote
woodwhisperer Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 I actually have one guys. Of course I didn't pay for it and had no idea what the retail price would be. I'll be working with it for a while and I'll report back on it as soon as I can find the time. You know, baby and all. Here's a little unboxing I did during the live build-a-thon. The thing is certainly built like a tank but I haven't actually used it yet. Quote
bgreenb Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 The jig does look very slick, and they've made some very cool engineering choices, but I just don't see how a tenoning jig saves you time over just using a dado stack and miter gauge/sled. You still have to make the shoulder cuts to use the tenoning jig, so you're still likely using a miter gauge/sled setup. And cutting each cheek with the dado stack only requires flipping the board over, not unclamping and reclamping the board in the jig. True, you have to swap to a dado stack, but it seems like that time is at least equaled by the amount of time it would take to set up the jig.What am I missing? Quote
Tom Cancelleri Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 The jig does look very slick, and they've made some very cool engineering choices, but I just don't see how a tenoning jig saves you time over just using a dado stack and miter gauge/sled. You still have to make the shoulder cuts to use the tenoning jig, so you're still likely using a miter gauge/sled setup. And cutting each cheek with the dado stack only requires flipping the board over, not unclamping and reclamping the board in the jig. True, you have to swap to a dado stack, but it seems like that time is at least equaled by the amount of time it would take to set up the jig.What am I missing?I'm with you on that Brian. I am surprised it's that cheap. I say cheap compared to what I thought it was going to be. I was figuring $389 or $429 for it. Still, 330 is a pretty hefty price for a tenoning jig. Quote
woodwhisperer Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 What am I missing?Quality, adjustability, and consistency. Cutting a tenon with the grain produces a really smooth and consistent cheek. Also, table saw height adjustment is rough at best. A tenoning jig allows you to make micro-adjustments and dial things in to perfection. And because the boards are clamped and the jig rides in the miter slot, the work is pretty well locked in place. Using a dado stack, something as simple as hand pressure can make small variances in the final thickness of the tenon.While it doesn't really save you time in setup, it could save time if you have to make more tenons at some point. The jig holds it's settings well between uses.Now all that said, I can't say those are all GOOD arguments. I nearly always make my tenons using the dado stack. I find the surface good enough and I can use a shoulder plane to do the final tuning if needed. But I suppose some folks are truly looking for perfection and a surface that requires absolutely no work right off the saw. I can't speak for everyone's use-case though. But it's pretty clear that in today's market, a table saw tenoning jig is a tough sell. 1 Quote
Brendon_t Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 Wow, that thing took some serious thinking through. It looks like a great jig. It also seems pricy. I do look forward to hearing some reviews on it. For those that cut the mortise on the router, would you have to buy some aluminum setup blocks or just use the router bit going you get the blades turned into the widest open angle? Quote
bgreenb Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 Quality, adjustability, and consistency. Cutting a tenon with the grain produces a really smooth and consistent cheek. Also, table saw height adjustment is rough at best. A tenoning jig allows you to make micro-adjustments and dial things in to perfection. And because the boards are clamped and the jig rides in the miter slot, the work is pretty well locked in place. Using a dado stack, something as simple as hand pressure can make small variances in the final thickness of the tenon.Ok, I can definitely see that. And if you have a TON of tenons to cut I could see how it would save time not having to do a pass with the rabetting block plane or router plane to dial each tenon in. And I hear you on the micro adjustment vs. the sloppy table saw blade height mechanism. Still, I'll keep cutting tenons with my dado stack and RBP and put that $330 toward other stuff that I probably also don't need (Like I said though, this definitely looks head and shoulders above other tenoning jigs on the market). Quote
krtwood Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 Seems like they missed an opportunity to make it with another stop like Matthias' tenoning jig so you can cut both sides of the tenon from the same reference surface. The way they show setting it up with a HCM chisel, what are the odds that your mortise is absolutely perfectly centered? Quote
woodwhisperer Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 (edited) what are the odds that your mortise is absolutely perfectly centered?If you did it right, it will be. Most times, if centering is crucial, I'll do a pass from each face using the router. That ensures a centered mortise. If the centering isn't crucial, like a table leg with a slight reveal where the apron connects, it won't matter at all. So personally, I'm cool with a guaranteed centered tenon if it simplifies setup. The question I have is how much more complicated is it to setup if you want an offset tenon? Edited September 16, 2015 by thewoodwhisperer Quote
Eric. Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 Another advantage of a tenon jig is angled tenons. Can't do that with a miter gauge. That's about all I use mine for. Otherwise it's a great doorstop. Quote
rodger. Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 I wonder what festool would charge for a high end tenoning jig. Quote
woodwhisperer Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 In Germany, the tenons magically grow on trees. Quote
Brendon_t Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 And Swiss wood already has holes in it for mortises. Quote
Tom King Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 depth of cut too-one pass to finished tenon cheek. I'll take a tenoning jig any day over putting a dado stack on and nibbling away. Quote
Immortan D Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 And Swiss wood already has holes in it for mortises.No need for that in the UK. They grow furniture. In Germany, the tenons magically grow on trees. Yeah, they call them dominos. 1 Quote
shaneymack Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 I wonder what festool would charge for a high end tenoning jig. Wouldn't matter as long as it came in a systainer. Would sell like hotcakes. :D Sent from my SM-P550 using Tapatalk Quote
drzaius Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 And Swiss wood already has holes in it for mortises.Your thinking of the cheese. Quote
krtwood Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 If you did it right, it will be. Most times, if centering is crucial, I'll do a pass from each face using the router. That ensures a centered mortise. If the centering isn't crucial, like a table leg with a slight reveal where the apron connects, it won't matter at all. So personally, I'm cool with a guaranteed centered tenon if it simplifies setup. The question I have is how much more complicated is it to setup if you want an offset tenon?I would expect all you need is to make a spacer that is the thickness of the tenon + blade kerf and put it between the stop and the part that butts up against it. Make the spacer a little over-sized and sneak up on the fit by planing or sanding it down. When I saw the two adjustable stops on the jig I just assumed that the second one was for setting up the opposite side but you'd need a third one the way they did it. Quote
Guest Posted September 16, 2015 Report Posted September 16, 2015 I have been moving my tenons to the bandsaw. I do the shoulder cuts on the tablesaw and the cheek cuts on the bandsaw. I think David Marks did it this way on woodworks (he sometimes did use a tenoning jig on the tablesaw). I have been happy with the results. And of course saves the step of setting up a dado stack. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted September 17, 2015 Report Posted September 17, 2015 I cut straight tenon cheeks with a pair of matched rip blades, spacers, and a fence riding jig. I have spacers to match most of my HCM chisels. Everything references off one face, and it all works quite nicely. The spacers can be fine tuned with dado shims for other uses.Of course, I do this less and less since I bought a Domino last year. In the case of angled tenons, I'd immediately choose the Domino in any case I could.If you're going to do a lot of tablesawn tenons, the PM device looks very versatile. Quote
Brendon_t Posted September 17, 2015 Report Posted September 17, 2015 Barry, this in intriguing to me and Im sure I have never seen a setup like that. Care to post a picture? Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.