Lee Bussy Posted January 28, 2016 Report Posted January 28, 2016 While the other thread is ... um ... amusing, I thought I'd start a new one to get an answer to a question. When I bought biscuits, I put some desiccant in the jar to keep them from swelling. While I have pounded biscuits in, I find it much easier to just let them slip in. One post recently led me to believe some folks have concern that the looser ones will not tighten up in the gap - I always thought that the moisture in the glue handled that. Am I correct? I certainly could have been wrong all these years. If so there's some people looking to find me and talk about their bookcases and mantles. Next I see this thing being discussed: Why would I need one of these? Is it because people make their own? Because not everyone uses desiccant? The best I can come up with is maybe it's in case the biscuits are already swelled a bit and no amount of drying will make them smaller? Inquiring minds want to know. Quote
Lee Bussy Posted January 28, 2016 Author Report Posted January 28, 2016 3 minutes ago, Mike. said: 1) too tight a fit and the biscuit could swell up with the glue and telegraph through to your surface 2) too tight and fit and you will be fighting them when trying to glue up your project. I definitely noticed the "telegraph" on this last project. I ran the table top through a surface sander after it dried so it was not too bad to recover from, but it was there. It also made me wonder if hammering in swelled biscuits could cause splitting? 5 minutes ago, Mike. said: All that being said, i have found biscuits to be more trouble than they are worth for panel glue-ups. Square edges, flat stock and cauls should be all you need. However some people find them very handy. The one place I've seen them help is the slip/squeeze you get when applying pressure. They allow the joints to move very little so there's not so many things to chase. Quote
drzaius Posted January 28, 2016 Report Posted January 28, 2016 4 minutes ago, Mike. said: Biscuits should be used as an alignment aid only. They offer no to little structural support. unlike a sloppy tenon, which will cause a loose joint, a loose biscuit won't cause much harm. A biscuit that is too tight might cause problems. I'm a big fan of biscuits in certain situations. As an alignment tool for edge gluing is not one of them. They just add work & complexity to the glue up. And they don't do a great job of aligning, not as good as cauls, certainly. For corner & butt joints in sheet goods for quick & dirty cabinets, boxes etc (caskets) they are very good & surprisingly strong. Quote
sheperd80 Posted January 28, 2016 Report Posted January 28, 2016 Ive never used dessicant. I like em fairly tight, but if i cant push em in by hand then ill recut the slot and slop it out just slightly. Snug, but with room to swell without "telegraphing" is what i look for. If theyre too loose theyre practically worthless for alignment. We use them on butt joints alot for mdf coffered ceilings and beams. In that application theyre great. Of course we dont use regular wood glue on mdf aymore either. Ever. PL costruction adhesive only, so they dont swell much. Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G890A using Tapatalk Quote
Denette Posted January 28, 2016 Report Posted January 28, 2016 Biscuits should be used as an alignment aid only. They offer no to little structural support. unlike a sloppy tenon, which will cause a loose joint, a loose biscuit won't cause much harm. A biscuit that is too tight might cause problems. I'm a big fan of biscuits in certain situations. As an alignment tool for edge gluing is not one of them. They just add work & complexity to the glue up. And they don't do a great job of aligning, not as good as cauls, certainly. For corner & butt joints in sheet goods for quick & dirty cabinets, boxes etc (caskets) they are very good & surprisingly strong. Okay, so here's a new question for you guys: what is the proper caul technique? I've tried to use cauls before to very mixed results. It seems to me that biscuits are a much more clean and streamlined solution than having to clamp additional pieces onto a tabletop on which I'm already fighting glue squeeze-out. In my experience (admittedly I don't own a biscuit jointer) biscuits seem like a quicker solution that would let me clean up the gluey mess without having to wrestle more clamps and boards than necessary. Am I just cauling wrong? Quote
sheperd80 Posted January 28, 2016 Report Posted January 28, 2016 For me, all the cauls do is keep the lamination flat. They dont necessarily line up the pieces very well. They just prevent bowing. Maybe im doin it wrong too but i use slightly bowed 2xs with tape on em and theyre not precise or strong enough to squeeze out little deflections at the joints. Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G890A using Tapatalk Quote
drzaius Posted January 28, 2016 Report Posted January 28, 2016 9 minutes ago, Arrdenet said: Okay, so here's a new question for you guys: what is the proper caul technique? I've tried to use cauls before to very mixed results. It seems to me that biscuits are a much more clean and streamlined solution than having to clamp additional pieces onto a tabletop on which I'm already fighting glue squeeze-out. In my experience (admittedly I don't own a biscuit jointer) biscuits seem like a quicker solution that would let me clean up the gluey mess without having to wrestle more clamps and boards than necessary. Am I just cauling wrong? If your boards are well milled & you use cauls, the glued edges can easily be within just a couple of thou of being perfectly flush. I find that with biscuits for alignment they can be as much as 1/64 out. And I've got a good Lamello machine. I don't know how you're using cauls, but if the panel is very wide it helps to use cambered cauls. They need to match though, so you don't introduce any curvature to the panel. Put packing tape or wax on the cauls so clean up is easier & you don't have them glued to the panel. There's no need to fight squeeze out, just be prepared for it. With more experience you get to be a better judge of just how much glue to use, but if in doubt, too much is better than too little. Quote
Eric. Posted January 28, 2016 Report Posted January 28, 2016 The proper fit of a biscuit is just like any other joint - the goal is a "slip fit," which means it goes together without having to pound it with a mallet (ideally just with hand force), but it holds itself together against the force of gravity. Once PVA glue is added the joint will swell slightly to a perfectly tight fit. The problem with biscuits, at least every batch of biscuits I've ever used, is that they tend to have fairly inconsistent thicknesses, at least in the context of fitting joints where just a couple thousandths of an inch will make for a fit that's too tight or too loose. So the weakest link with perfect-fitting biscuits is something that's basically out of your control and you're at the mercy of the manufacturing process...some will always be a bit too tight, and some will always be a bit too loose. Even the Dominoes have some variation in thickness but it's not nearly as bad as biscuits. As long as you're not using biscuits for structural joinery - which you shouldn't be - it's fairly moot...just cut your slots and slap them in there. If you find one biscuit is way too tight or way too loose, toss it aside and grab another. 2 Quote
Chestnut Posted January 28, 2016 Report Posted January 28, 2016 I can speak to experience that Biscuits don't add any strength. An assembly table that i made using biscuits failed on me while i was standing on it. There was a whole lot of other stupidity going on but the bruise i got was impressive. I use them a lot for sheet goods but have since switched to M&T where i need strength. They are great for alignment in the middle of sheets as well something that becomes difficult using dowels or other methods except dado. I find them faster than dado as well but that's because i don't have a large table saw (yet) with a stack available. Quote
wdwerker Posted January 28, 2016 Report Posted January 28, 2016 I use 8/4 scraps as cauls . I try to make them a bit thicker than the 8/4, so maybe 2 1/4 X 1 3/4 X about 29- 32" long. I put a camber on one edge with the jointer using pressure at first then lightening up towards the center from each end using very light cuts. I cover the cambered edge with clear packing tape which prevents glue from sticking. On a 3 ft long panel I use 3 pairs of cauls, center and a couple of inches in from each end. Long counters get a pair every 18 to 24" or where there is a misaligned spot . Nowadays I use my Domino on long solidwood counters plus a few cauls to keep things nice and flat. i keep my biscuits in seal a meal bags a handful at a time. Bag them up when the box is new. Lamello brand biscuits are much more accurately manufactured and cost more per box too, just like the Lamello machines cost more and are more accurate. I need to sell a couple of my Lamello machines, got 3 rarely use them now that I have the domino. But they do have a few uses that dominos don't. Quote
drzaius Posted January 28, 2016 Report Posted January 28, 2016 1 minute ago, Chestnut said: I can speak to experience that Biscuits don't add any strength. An assembly table that i made using biscuits failed on me while i was standing on it. There was a whole lot of other stupidity going on but the bruise i got was impressive. For biscuits to have any strength, you need to thoroughly coat both the biscuit and the sides of the slot. As in, complete coverage and lots of glue. Quote
woodbutcher74 Posted January 28, 2016 Report Posted January 28, 2016 I have taken swollen biscuits and compressed them in my vice just before inserting them in the slot. 1 Quote
Chet Posted January 28, 2016 Report Posted January 28, 2016 47 minutes ago, wdwerker said: Lamello brand biscuits are much more accurately manufactured Steve, years ago Porter Cable made some nice ones but apparently they don't anymore because I can't find them. Who carries the Lamello? Even if I need to get them shipped. Quote
Lee Bussy Posted January 28, 2016 Author Report Posted January 28, 2016 3 minutes ago, Chet K. said: Steve, years ago Porter Cable made some nice ones but apparently they don't anymore because I can't find them. Who carries the Lamello? Even if I need to get them shipped. http://www.amazon.com/Lamello-144020-Beechwood-Biscuits-1000-Pieces/dp/B0006N2ONM/ ... that's the only place I've seen so far. ETA: Damn ... seconds! Quote
Chet Posted January 28, 2016 Report Posted January 28, 2016 1 hour ago, Mike. said: there is new site called amazon. they sell almost everything. Ha,Ha,Ha I know, I know Amazon this, Amazon that... But you never know someone might of said that Woodcraft or Rockler carries them and I might have been tempted to drive and get them when needed. I am one of those weird guys from a generation that liked to see and handle the things before we buy. Quote
trialbyfire Posted January 28, 2016 Report Posted January 28, 2016 there is new site called amazon. they sell almost everything. Ha,Ha,Ha I know, I know Amazon this, Amazon that... But you never know someone might of said that Woodcraft or Rockler carries them and I might have been tempted to drive and get them when needed. I am one of those weird guys from a generation that liked to see and handle the things before we buy. http://www.woodcraft.com/search2/search.aspx?query=biscuit/URL] I'm fairly certain I have seen them in store as well. Quote
Lee Bussy Posted January 28, 2016 Author Report Posted January 28, 2016 3 hours ago, wdwerker said: I need to sell a couple of my Lamello machines, got 3 rarely use them now that I have the domino. But they do have a few uses that dominos don't. Or you could give them to your son. Wanna adopt me? I almost fell over when I saw how much those cost. 1 Quote
wdwerker Posted January 28, 2016 Report Posted January 28, 2016 2 hours ago, Lee Bussy said: Or you could give them to your son. Wanna adopt me? I almost fell over when I saw how much those cost. I would let one go for $300 plus freight. It is the Top Ten Model. I paid $750 years ago. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.