Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Should I get rid of my new jet planer?

Featured Replies

So I bought a jet 16" open stand straight knife planer a couple weeks ago to add to the shop. It's my first planer and my first thought was that it's powerful and one sexy piece of equipment. I've only planed a little bit of fir and cedar, nothing hard. I bought it new bit noticed some pretty terrible planer marks indicating a flaw or nick in the knives.

I never intended on getting into figured wood so didn't spring for a helical head planer. Of course the first maple I picked up for cheap has figure in it. I'm getting even worse planer marks and bad chip out in that. So on to my question...

I have a few choices.

-Get these knives sharpened and see if that helps and how long they last.

-Get new knives for $140 to $180

-get a helical head for $1167 (slightly more than I paid for the planer)

-sell it to try to recoup some of the cost and get the powermatic 15hh for $2195 (before tax)

I've been sticking to powermatic tools in my purchases but I like jet as well. Any words of advice from those experienced with straight knife planers would be great. Is it worth it when it comes to hardwood? How long do the blades last before sending them off for sharpening? Should I just spring for the helical head and call it good?

Sent from my SM-T800 using Tapatalk

Since it's a couple weeks old, don't see why the blades would need sharpening or replacing unless you ran something with a nail in it or something or a ton of hardwood through it.  I'd say make sure to get the grain direction of the wood going the right way and take lighter cuts.  I ran some nice curly maple the other day through my straight knife planer and it came out fine, I was surprised though haha.

28 minutes ago, Gixxerjoe04 said:

I'd say make sure to get the grain direction of the wood going the right way and take lighter cuts.

I was going to say the same thing about the direction of the wood.  If you send it against the grain any planer will rip up your wood.

Watch the grain direction, try running curly stock at a skewed angle if possible( barely diagonal through the planer). Very light cuts ! Another trick is to wipe the grain w mineral spirits before planing ( wipe not soak )

New factory sharpened knives may not be as sharp as a really good local sharpener can do. Getting the knives set exactly is a bit of a learning curve, be patient .

Jet owns Powermatic, many tools share castings. Motors, accessories and level of quality control differentiate the brands and prices.

  • Author

I've tried flipping the boards every direction as well as running at an angle. The only difference is tear out and planer marks in different locations. There's no way I've hit anything and I've inspected the blades although not super close with a flashlight or anything. I can feel a slight imperfection on the blades at the location causing the worst marks (a raised ridge on the boards).

The blades FEEL sharp but that doesn't necessarily mean they are. I've tried very light cuts and it doesn't make a difference either. I'm leaning toward having these professionally sharpened and trying again. I even tried sanding some of the marks out with 80 grit and it just wasn't happening.

I'll try to get some more maple with no figure as well. Depending on the results then, the only route I see would be the helical head.

What kind of life is normal for straight blades and hardwood?

Sent from my SM-T800 using Tapatalk

You may have had dirt or something imbedded  in a board that nicked the blades. I have slid a blade sideways when that has happened so the nicks don't line up anymore.

I figured these little lines on HSS blades was just part of the game with planers. With my planer they show up all the time and usually blade replacement time is when they are so bad the cross most of the board. Mine i know are from dirt on the board or other debris that is hard and nicks them. You can offset the blades on the planar head or you can offset the board and run it a 2nd time for your last pass.

I've never used anything but straight knives in planers or jointers, and have no reason to use anything else.  I'm very careful what gets run though.  Boards are carefully handled at every step before milling.  If there is any question about a board being dirty, it gets scrubbed with a Scrub plane. 

If I'm running something important that might be prone to tearout, I sharpen the knives really sharp with my waterstones just like I would with a plane iron or chisel.  I don't have a setup to grind knives if they are that dull, but I do take them out and sharpen by hand if really sharp is better.  I've changed knives so many times that it's just a few minute job though.

I keep one planer for rough sizing on big jobs, and one for final finish.  I don't bother to hand sharpen the knives in the rough planer.  Most of the time we only use the finish planer.

One thing about any little lines though, is that they stick up, and are easy to smooth off with a Smoothing plane.

  • Author

The planer

7867dc61569c7de0492e156141d9f4dd.jpg

Here are some pictures of the lines and tearout. Sort of difficult to see in the pictures but very easy to see raised ridges in person. The wood was clean and kiln dried. I know I've read if it's too dry that could cause problems. I don't have a moisture meter. Also I'm running the gear box on the slow feed rate.

69533027086ca8e77ec75a457d0b3c59.jpg4037de4e8efb565c193c8fb27bb07721.jpgfb587f8ae1e11a1b6896a658fb2cf076.jpg

I am using dust collection. It's a 2hp cyclone system

af68a96d810697608ab1cb343a456285.jpg

Sent from my SM-T800 using Tapatalk

  • Author
I can only see hints of lines in the third wood picture.  Those knives have hit something besides wood.

I agree, and they did that on the first board I sent through which was a new clean 2x4 to test. The planer was new and no hint of sawdust on it but I question the knives.

I guess I'll send them to be sharpened.

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

You mentioned that you first ran some fir, cedar, and a 2x4. All of those usually have lots of little knots. When the planer pulls a 3/4 inch knot loose it is like a rock bouncing around inside the planer. Those will tear up a set of hss knives.

Don't run construction lumber through your good tools unless you use old blades and knives. Get a new set of knives and keep these for rough surfacing construction lumber and reclaimed wood. My Dewalt has indexed knives and I can change them out in 10 minutes but it's still a pain.

Oh, for that curly maple you need a helical cutter or drum sander to machine it to the final surface . You can try to take very light cuts with sharp blades but my planer does better with a more aggressive cut.

Sent from my woodshop using duct tape, twine, and a bit of sawdust.

  • Author
You mentioned that you first ran some fir, cedar, and a 2x4. All of those usually have lots of little knots. When the planer pulls a 3/4 inch knot loose it is like a rock bouncing around inside the planer. Those will tear up a set of hss knives.

Don't run construction lumber through your good tools unless you use old blades and knives. Get a new set of knives and keep these for rough surfacing construction lumber and reclaimed wood. My Dewalt has indexed knives and I can change them out in 10 minutes but it's still a pain.

Oh, for that curly maple you need a helical cutter or drum sander to machine it to the final surface . You can try to take very light cuts with sharp blades but my planer does better with a more aggressive cut.

Sent from my woodshop using duct tape, twine, and a bit of sawdust.

Good advice, I'll keep that in mind. I was excited to send some boards through it and figured fir 2x4's couldn't hurt it if I'm going to send hard maple through it.

The planer did come with a metal jig for setting the knives which I'm guessing should make it pretty quick and simple. I also have a One Way multi-guage for more precision setting.

I seem to go for excess (within reason) when it comes to buying machinery because I don't want to outgrow something. Buy once cry once right? That's why I went right for the bigger planer, cyclone dust collector, PM drill press, etc. So I might spring for the helical cutter head. I should probably get a bandsaw first though before I start upgrading other tools.

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

  • 4 weeks later...
  • Author

Update: I got my knives back from being sharpened. There was less tear out on the figured stuff but it still wasn't perfect.

I managed to pick up some straight grain ash though and I'm VERY happy with the results of the cut on that and a few live edge slabs.

beb5beccc398030a0775f498feb842d3.jpg

f6885be297097ea7483f6c684621b020.jpg

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

I'm not familiar at all with that planer.  Does it have different feed rates?  Glad it's working better. I never expect perfect from a planer, but I don't expect a lot of tearout either.

  • Author

Yes it has 2 feed rates. I'm very happy with it considering most people say not to expect finish quality out of stand planers.

I did find a good deal on a performax 22-44 so I added that to the arsenal.

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

  • Popular Post

I had the 15" JET planer with straight knives and ran it for 16 years (I just upgraded summer of 2015 as I outgrew it.) It is a solid machine for a small shop and it gave me great results. But I also came to understand the results I could reasonably expect from it. 

How often you change the blades is relative to the material you are machining. I am a small pro shop doing all kinds of work, and sometimes I get jobs doing interiors with reclaimed wood. Reclaimed material wears HSS knives out FAST and I usually replace them once a day and, on occasion, 2 times a day during the milling process. 

If I am milling all clean hard woods such as oak, maple, and poplar, I usually end up changing to fresh knives once every other week. Those results are with me functioning as a small pro shop with no employees. 

The planer is a machine that mills material to thickness, not a machine that provides a finished surface. I get nick trails in my wood too, that is just normal as the blades get nicks in them. I never bother to offset the knives to get rid of the nick trails, they come out later in the rest of the work flow. 

Normally, I don't have a problem sanding out nick trails, they are removed during the finish sanding. If I have some that are a bit stubborn, I hit them with a few swipes of a card scraper and erase them easily. Then I return to finish sanding with the random orbital.

Typically, I can go from the planer to the random orbital starting at 150 then on to 180.. If 150 isn't doing the trick, then I drop to 120. You will have to see what works for you and the situations will vary depending on the material. For instance, cherry sands out very easily from the planer compared to oak or ash.   

The grain patterns in wood that make it so beautiful, is also what makes it challenging to mill without tear out. Previous suggestions in this thread all help in this situation, but with varying degrees of success because every board is different.

Sending the stock through at an angle definitely helps. 

I have prepped the stock with either water or mineral spirits, and both worked to improve the situation. No - the water never caused a problem with my machine, but that was wiped down to raise the grain, not soaked. 

As I got more heavily into woodworking and production from the shop, I bought a dual head drum sander which was a total game changer since it produces no tear out. 

My work flow changed for dealing with challenging materials. I plane the material as close as I dare to my finished thickness, observing how deep tear out is, then I finish out with the sanding machine. The drum sander takes longer to thickness lumber compared to the planer, but there is no tear out, which in the long run saves time and heart ache. 

The drum sander leaves it's own track lines similar to the planer as things get burnt onto the sandpaper. This occurs since the head does not oscillate which allows a little bit of glue missed durning cleanup to melt onto the sandpaper, or maybe a little bit of pitch, or even sanding a knot which causes the sandpaper to heat up and glaze in that spot. 

Once you get a glazed ring on the sandpaper, it will not sand the surface at that spot and leave a slightly raised track line similar to nick trails from a planer. Once again, I don't sweat it because even the sanding machine does not produce the finished surface. 

Just as with the planer, I take the stock from the machine and finish it out with the random orbital, usually starting at 120 or 150 as the need dictates. If there are stubborn track lines, I erase them with the card scraper. Keep in mind: even the sanding machine does not give a finish surface. But it puts you close and it definitely saves time. 

The big benefit of the sanding machine is that once you do a glue-up, the grain in the boards will always be oriented different directions and sending through the planer is a bad choice, the sanding machine will be able to surface everything without producing tear out.

Even with cabinet doors, you can send the door through for a light pass after it is all assembled, and even though you are sanding entirely cross grain on the rails, there is no tear out. The joints will all be sanded perfectly flush, and the doors just need to be followed up with a finish sanding from the random orbital. 

I hope this information helps. I included the sanding machine in the response, because now that you have them both, they are machines that play key roles in an overall workflow in your shop. And it is important to understand what you can expect from each of them. 

Good luck!

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.