Recommended Posts

Posted

I've been doing a ton of reading in this forum (great stuff here, btw) as I'm looking to upgrade my table saw. Right now I have a Dewalt DE7480 job site table saw. I bought it when my wife and I did a flooring install in our house, which I used an excuse to buy a bunch of power tools. I did no research at the time, just aisle shopping at Home Depot. I probably should've gotten a miter saw for that job, but I wanted to get into woodworking and thought the table saw would serve me better in the long run.

Now I've gotten a few projects under my belt and want to upgrade. I initially thought that the Delta 36-725 would be the way to go, but because of this forum I've discovered Saw Stop, Grizzly, and a whole slew of other options. 

What I'd really like to do is buy a 110v table saw that will last me for a long time. Price is not much of a concern, but space is. I'm working out of one side of a two-car garage. Maybe once I'm able to expand into a bigger space I'll look at a 220v cabinet saw, but that just isn't in the cards right now. 

Here are the saws I have looked at recently:

  • SawStop Professional 110v - $2300
  • SawStop Contractor - $1599
  • Grizzly G0715P - $825
  • Jet ProShop - $1349
  • Laguna Fusion - $1299

One thing I don't understand is why the SawStop Professional is so much more than the others. I know that there is a premium for the safety feature of the SawStop, but what puts the professional so much higher than the others? Is it just the cabinet itself, or is there more to it than that?

And for the other saws, is there a huge difference between any of them? Am I looking at all having basically the same features just at different price points? Unless I want the SawStop, what would be the point in spending $1350 for the Jet vs. $825 for the Grizzly?

Are there other 110v saws I need to consider? 

Posted
45 minutes ago, kon_jelly said:

I've been doing a ton of reading in this forum (great stuff here, btw) as I'm looking to upgrade my table saw. Right now I have a Dewalt DE7480 job site table saw. I bought it when my wife and I did a flooring install in our house, which I used an excuse to buy a bunch of power tools. I did no research at the time, just aisle shopping at Home Depot. I probably should've gotten a miter saw for that job, but I wanted to get into woodworking and thought the table saw would serve me better in the long run.

Now I've gotten a few projects under my belt and want to upgrade. I initially thought that the Delta 36-725 would be the way to go, but because of this forum I've discovered Saw Stop, Grizzly, and a whole slew of other options. 

What I'd really like to do is buy a 110v table saw that will last me for a long time. Price is not much of a concern, but space is. I'm working out of one side of a two-car garage. Maybe once I'm able to expand into a bigger space I'll look at a 220v cabinet saw, but that just isn't in the cards right now. 

Here are the saws I have looked at recently:

  • SawStop Professional 110v - $2300
  • SawStop Contractor - $1599
  • Grizzly G0715P - $825
  • Jet ProShop - $1349
  • Laguna Fusion - $1299

One thing I don't understand is why the SawStop Professional is so much more than the others. I know that there is a premium for the safety feature of the SawStop, but what puts the professional so much higher than the others? Is it just the cabinet itself, or is there more to it than that?

And for the other saws, is there a huge difference between any of them? Am I looking at all having basically the same features just at different price points? Unless I want the SawStop, what would be the point in spending $1350 for the Jet vs. $825 for the Grizzly?

Are there other 110v saws I need to consider? 

For the space conscious, I was in the same boat i work out of an 8' x 14' basement shop, it really irritated me that the base 30" sawstop doesn't get it's top of the line fence. When you go with the 30" version you get their inferior fence that it seems like they only put on that saw. In my opinion a lot of the saw is in the fence. The reason the SS costs more is because it's top quality the only thing I've seen readily available that matches it's quality is the PM1000 ... well kinda. Mine came with chipped paint, which is meh, I've also seen on here a SS saw come with warped extension tables.

My advice is go cabinet style, skip the contractor saws. Gut the mobile base for your saw. I have the HTC 2000 base under my PM1000 and band saw and love it. The griz is a good economical option though there have been alignment issues with it. I don't really know anything about Laguna other than i have one of their band saws and the thing is great!

Posted

Since you are not price driven but, seem unwilling to run a 220 circuit, a cab-saw style hybrid is probably in your future.  Having done the contractor to hybrid to cab-saw shuffle myself I would argue that you can skip the hybrid step and go straight to the cabinet saw and save some money. 

On my hybrid I found the 30" rip capacity to be too small MOST of the time.  It was a Biesemeyer fence so I just moved the front tube over one set of screw holes to the right and found 40" to be just fine MOST of the time.  This will vary with what you want to build.  The cabinet saw footprint is smaller than a contractor so that will help your space concerns.

Posted

It's not that I am unwilling to run a 220 circuit (I actually have one right now for my EV), it's just that I don't see the need for the additional cost considering the kind of woodworking I'm doing and my limited space. Unless I'm mistaken all the 220v circuit gets me is a larger motor (usually 3hp vs. 1.75hp), right? Unless there are some amazing saws for less than that SawStop Professional at 220v I just don't see the need to do it.

I guess I could be convinced, though. 

But I guess my main post boils down to two things:

  1. What do you get with the SawStop Professional vs. the SawStop Contractor? Assuming I get the cast iron wings on the contractor, what does the additional $700 get me? Their site isn't very helpful on this
  2. If I'm not going to spend the money on a SawStop, what would be the best 110v saw to get? Is the Grizzly on the same level as the Jet and Laguna listed? Are there others that should be considered?
Posted

  A fundamental difference between contractor format and cabinet saw format is the cabinet saw has a smaller footprint, cabinet mounted trunnions which make alignment much easier and more precise as well as an overall more solid chassis. This is not to say that there are not some excellent contractor saws,  there are. I was very happy to get the real estate back when I moved the smaller footprint cabinet saw. As you probably know the PCS comes in 110 Volt lower powered version if that is your preference. 

 It is always easy to spend someone else's money :-)  You mentioned price was not of paramount concern and this is why I recommended simply going to the more powerful saw so that you would never have any regrets. It may be that the lower powered saw will meet all of your needs. My hybrid met all of my needs, it just required a little more delicacy from me to get through the tasks. In fact, if not for an unexpected windfall that allowed me to move to the saw stop I would probably still be using my 22124 hybrid.

In all fairness though there are a few, if any, hybrids that equal 22124. I'm not saying that just because I owned one. I'm saying that because it was the only one that I would have owned. 

This seems to be coming off kind of snooty. That is not my intention. You know your needs better than any of us and seem to be doing a good job of doing your homework. 

Posted

I had a 1.5 HP Jet contractor saw with a 52" Bies fence. Good saw. Decided to upgrade & did a ton of research over about a year before getting a SawStop PCS 3 HP, 36" fence.

The old 52" just took up too much room & there were only a handful of times in 15 years that I used that capacity. I haven't missed it at all. The following comments refer to SawStop machines.

If you're going with a quality saw, get the 3 HP. The 1.5 HP did OK most of the time, but I would not go back. The 36" fence also comes with the very good dust collection guard. The 30" "premium" fence is definitely not premium & I wouldn't even consider it.

The optional PCS mobile base is very good, but the ICS base is even better.

The PCS has better dust collection than the contractor model & the contractor has the motor hanging out the back which takes up more space.

The SawStop quality and customer service is topnotch.

Posted
10 minutes ago, gee-dub said:

This seems to be coming off kind of snooty. That is not my intention. You know your needs better than any of us and seem to be doing a good job of doing your homework. 

Not snooty at all! I appreciate the advice. I could definitely see moving to 220v if I were to make a more permanent shop, but I don't think it's very feasible in our current house and we don't plan on moving anytime soon. ? 

4 minutes ago, drzaius said:

If you're going with a quality saw, get the 3 HP. The 1.5 HP did OK most of the time, but I would not go back. The 36" fence also comes with the very good dust collection guard. The 30" "premium" fence is definitely not premium & I wouldn't even consider it.

The optional PCS mobile base is very good, but the ICS base is even better.

The PCS has better dust collection than the contractor model & the contractor has the motor hanging out the back which takes up more space.

The SawStop quality and customer service is topnotch.

I'm definitely set on the 1.75hp for now. But I think the rest of your comment has convinced me the cabinet is the way to go. I was on the fence (heh) about the 30" vs the 36" but I'll probably go with the 36". 

Mobile base I'd add later if I needed to. Right now I don't expect to have to move it at all once I get it in place. 

Again, definitely appreciate all the advice!

Posted

I would re think the mobile base. You will end up needing to move it at some point and it will be a serious pita to try and move. Adding the built in Sawstop base after would be quite difficult.

Fwiw, I have a Sawstop as well and it is an incredible machine worth every penny.

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

Posted
34 minutes ago, shaneymack said:

I would re think the mobile base. You will end up needing to move it at some point and it will be a serious pita to try and move. Adding the built in Sawstop base after would be quite difficult.

True words; I speak from experience. The mobile base is designed to be installed as part of the uncrating & assembling process. I had to back order the ICS base & install it after assembling the saw. It actually wasn't hard, but I had to use a hoist to lift the saw vertically  & then lower it into the base.

kon, good call on the fence. The 30" just is not very solid & easily flexes under pressure from the side.

  • Like 1
Posted
2 hours ago, kon_jelly said:

If I'm not going to spend the money on a SawStop, what would be the best 110v saw to get? Is the Grizzly on the same level as the Jet and Laguna listed? Are there others that should be considered?

You seem pretty set on the sawstop. I'll just comment on this, I personally think jet and Laguna would be better than the Grizzly. Other saws to consider are options from Powermatic. The PM2000 is 3hp and 220 yes but starting out at $3,000 it's comparable the SS 36" 1.75 hp with the ICS base. The Pm2000 comes with a built in base. Powermatic does have 10% sales occasionally as well that would knock the PM200 down to $2700. PM1000 is comparable to the 1.75 PCS and starts at $2,000 w/o a base though.

Powermatic doesn't have the blade stop thingy though.

Posted

I was looking at a PM2000, but read lots of reports of the mobile base being finicky, not working well, & requiring many turns of the hand wheel to actuate it. That & a poor experience with head office customer service sent me elsewhere.

The SS blade break didn't really factor into my decision, but it is nice knowing it's there.

Posted

I have the Laguna Fusion saw and am very happy with it.  The fence is adequate and stiff but it is aluminum.   The reason I bought the Laguna was that it has a rip capacity of 36".  30" was not enough for cabinets and I did not have room for 50".

  • Like 1
Posted

The foot print of a hybrid and a cabinet saw are roughly the same.  The rip capacity of the fence is what determines how much space the saws take up, not the voltage they run on.  The jump to 220v is pretty significant because it includes the industrial cabinet saw class, which can offer the most saw in your price range.    Not only do they offer about 50% more power (which is noticeable), but the underpinnings are simply more robust.  Hand wheels are bigger and work better, they have more mass and lower vibration, are heavier duty and made for a lifetime of hard service, have better long term reliability, etc., and tend to be more pleasant to use.

The Grizzly G1023RL and G0690 are about the same price as a Jet or Laguna hybrid, but are in a completely different class of saw. (kinda like stepping up from an S10 class saw to a Silverado for the same price).  The Jet Proshop and Fusion are both good hybrid saws, and will certainly suffice, but neither represents the most saw for that price IMO.   At one time, the Laguna Platinum 3hp cabinet saw was identical to the G0690...they've since changed the Platinum to a newer design with vertical dovetail ways....my point is that even the older Platinum model was certainly considered a step up from the Fusion, and so is the G0690.  If your going to spend in the $1500 range, the G1023RL or G0690 offer the most saw for the money.

The PCS is a great saw, and it won't bite the hand that feeds it.  It cost more due in part to the safety brake, plus it's also extremely well made.  The T-Glide fence upgrade makes a lot of sense IMO for this class of saw, because the "Premium" fence really isn't all that premium, so that $2300 saw jumps up to more like $2700 with a proper fence and a mobile base.  That setup is within a few hundred bucks of the 3hp model.  I realize it's more money (your money), but my opinion is that if you're going to get a anything approaching a $3K saw, the PCS 3hp with the T-Glide is where the value sweet spot is IMO.  

If you end up sticking with a 120v saw, the PCS 1.75hp is still the top dog IMO, but if the price deters you, I'd go with the Jet Proshop over the Fusion.  Under the hood the two saws are actually really similar, but the Proshop offers a once piece steel fence rail vs the two-piece aluminum on the Fusion.  Grizzly has the G0715P and the G0771 to consider in this class.  The G0715P has a history of alignment issues that has supposedly been resolved, but I continue to read about the issue, including a recent report here.   If you get one that's not plagued by the alignment problem, it's a nice saw and a great value.  The G0771 offers a lot of bang for the buck, has cabinet mounted trunnions, but has a lesser fence....that doesn't make it a bad fence, but wanted to point out what you give up.  

It's possible to get what you pay for if you're careful and selective.  It's important to buy the individual saw, and not the brand name, because each model is unique.  In most cases, there are pluses and minuses with each price increase or decrease.  Pick and choose which features are most important to you, and aim at getting the most saw for you dollar.  All the saws mentioned have potential to do excellent work.  Regardless of which saw you get, setup and blade choice will ultimately dictate how well the saw performs.  Set aside some money for a good blade or three.  Decent blades start at ~ $30 and go well over $100. 

The ABCs of Table Saws

Tips for Picking Saw Blades

Extending the Rip Capacity on a Table Saw

Posted
11 hours ago, knotscott said:

If you end up sticking with a 120v saw, the PCS 1.75hp is still the top dog IMO, but if the price deters you, I'd go with the Jet Proshop over the Fusion.  Under the hood the two saws are actually really similar, but the Proshop offers a once piece steel fence rail vs the two-piece aluminum on the Fusion.  Grizzly has the G0715P and the G0771 to consider in this class.  The G0715P has a history of alignment issues that has supposedly been resolved, but I continue to read about the issue, including a recent report here.   If you get one that's not plagued by the alignment problem, it's a nice saw and a great value.  The G0771 offers a lot of bang for the buck, has cabinet mounted trunnions, but has a lesser fence....that doesn't make it a bad fence, but wanted to point out what you give up.  

So in your estimation, if I don't spend the additional money for the SawStop would a G0771 with an upgraded fence be better than the G0715P? And is it easy to find replacement fences? The price difference between those and the SawStop is huge, so if performance is on par it'd be a tough choice.

And thanks for the links - lots of good info!

Posted
2 hours ago, kon_jelly said:

So in your estimation, if I don't spend the additional money for the SawStop would a G0771 with an upgraded fence be better than the G0715P? And is it easy to find replacement fences? The price difference between those and the SawStop is huge, so if performance is on par it'd be a tough choice.

And thanks for the links - lots of good info!

"Better" is always subjective, but given that there are still recent reports of the alignment issue with the G0715P, if I were in your shoes, I'd grab the G0771 and would upgrade the fence with something like a Shop Fox Classic, Delta T3, etc.  I don't want to go as far as to say the performance will be "on par" with the SS, but once dialed in properly with a good blade, you shouldn't be able to tell which saw made the cut.  You'll have to mind your digits though!

Posted

Just in case it helps with your decision process . . . when I find myself snagged or feeling a bit drowned in options I reverse my approach.  I determine the product that would be everything I could ever want.  I then start stepping down until I find a factor I am unwilling to do without; a feature, an option, versatility, reliability or whatever.  When I hit that step I then go back one or two and I've found my product

Posted

If cost is not a primary concern, and the value of your fingers is high, then just bite the bullet and get the SawStop 1.75 36" cabinet + mobile base.  I don't think I have ever heard someone complaining or regretting buying a SawStop.  It is simply a top notch product.  And get a very high quality combination blade for it, and you are set.

  • Like 1
Posted

I echo these guys. I have a delta contractors saw that does a great job and will be last in line for an upgrade in my current tools.  That said it is in the line for upgrade.  If you go the contractor saw rout you can get a great saw that I'd bet you will be happy with.  I'd also bet that after a while, you would likely be like me thinking how nice it would be to have that 3hp motor and grumbling about having to measure out and secure straight edges to make a 31" inch cut with a circ saw because your fence is only 30". If money isn't the sticking point...the old saying is measure twice cut once!

Posted
9 minutes ago, kon_jelly said:

You guys are killing me. I've reached out to my go-to contractor to find out how much it would be to run a 220v line to the other side of my garage. ? 

When your thinking of spending quality table saw quantities of money, don't let yourself get caught up in scrimping on a couple of hundred bucks to get a circuit run for it. After using the new saw for a couple of months you won't miss the money at all.

Posted
You guys are killing me. I've reached out to my go-to contractor to find out how much it would be to run a 220v line to the other side of my garage. ? 

Now you're talking !!

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

Posted
1 hour ago, kon_jelly said:

You guys are killing me. I've reached out to my go-to contractor to find out how much it would be to run a 220v line to the other side of my garage. ? 

Congrats! I don't think you will be disappointed if you go with a 3hp saw from any of the major manufacturers, but I highly recommend Powermatic.

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 66 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined