Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Unplanable wood?

Featured Replies

So, I am working on this ash slab for a coffee table.  I am stripping it down yet again to refinish it, but that is a whole other story.

Anyway, I have my #4 fresh off the strop, I have the cap iron really close and the mouth close too.  I have the depth of cut set so fine I am barely taking dust, just starting to move it down after stropping.  I stop adjusting and start giving it a few strokes to see if I am happy there, and it is doing pretty well, working easy and just barely taking a cut.  I get to a part where the grain reverses, which is all over, it is ash.  A grain end catches and a big strip tears our.  I am dumbfounded, and in shock, I stand up with my jaw hanging open and the plane drops from my hand, of course landing on the top and putting another big dent in it.  

 

Now what?  I am blaming myself for something I did wrong.  Like really beating myself up on this.  I may have just ruined a 24" x 42" x almost 2" thick piece of slab ash that I have about a month of work into.  I have no clue what I did or how I am going to fix it......perhaps a couple of bow tie inlays (a Dutchman?).  I am seriously freaked out here.

  • Replies 53
  • Views 14k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Several days later, with lots of planing and lots of sanding and 2 coats of BLO.  I am pointing out the same areas where the plane dropped on the top and made the big dents.  You can compare it to the

  • Pay a few dollars to a friendly guy at a local small cabinet shop and let him put it through their drum sander. Sometimes it's easier to do that and cost effective in the short term if you don't curre

  • Or............he used a figure of speech that must have gone over your head. I don't think he is complaining about only pulling dust, or he would not have experienced tearout. He is talking about the

Posted Images

Pictures would help.

Can you steam the dent out?  Put some water on it and put an iron to the dent until it disappears.  This has worked well for me in the past with dents.

As for the tear out, if it's a big chunk, you might be able to glue it back in place.  If not, it sounds like you have enough thickness to plane the whole slab down to get rid of it.  Otherwise, maybe filling with epoxy is an option.  Not sure how that would look with ash though.  

  • Author
3 minutes ago, Dknapp34 said:

Pictures would help.

Can you steam the dent out?  Put some water on it and put an iron to the dent until it disappears.  This has worked well for me in the past with dents.

As for the tear out, if it's a big chunk, you might be able to glue it back in place.  If not, it sounds like you have enough thickness to plane the whole slab down to get rid of it.  Otherwise, maybe filling with epoxy is an option.  Not sure how that would look with ash though.  

Thanks, it is a pretty tear out.    The dent is too.  Not sure if it will steam out, but I will try that for sure before any other more invasive ways.  I don't know if I have the talent to plane down that whole slab thinner, or the heart either, I liked the thickness, it was part of the whole reason for the build and is the same thickness (or multiples of) other features.  Before I started the finishing and dry fit.....

 

 

DSC_8751.JPG

Did you make sure to recover the torn out chip from the hand plane you might be able to stick it back in with CA glue.

When i was working with the ash for this top i made i tried using my block plane to clean up a few things and the tear out was terrible i sucked it up and used used the sander.

14107779_10101081067095009_8313453233731

My only suggestion is to learn how to sharpen a card scraper (if you don't already) and try that you might be able to recover the damage by gluing the piece back in and scraping everything smooth.

  • Author
1 minute ago, Chestnut said:

Did you make sure to recover the torn out chip from the hand plane you might be able to stick it back in with CA glue.

When i was working with the ash for this top i made i tried using my block plane to clean up a few things and the tear out was terrible i sucked it up and used used the sander.

14107779_10101081067095009_8313453233731

My only suggestion is to learn how to sharpen a card scraper (if you don't already) and try that you might be able to recover the damage by gluing the piece back in and scraping everything smooth.

Thanks, I will have to look around.  I will have to go out to the shop eventually, the video camera is out there and I can't leave it.  Frost tonight.  I was using a card scraper, I guess I should have stuck with that.   Had the sander too.   I was removing the failed finish at the time and figured I would give it a light pass and make sure everything was just right to finish up.  Clever eh? (sarcasm).  I was this close to having it finished when I had to strip it back.

 

 

DSC_8775.JPG

I've experienced "unplanable" woods and switched back to my ROS without giving it to much thought. Maybe a smoother with 55* frog could work, or one of those scraping planes, but I don't currently own any of them in order to try.

1 minute ago, Jim DaddyO said:

Thanks, I will have to look around.  I will have to go out to the shop eventually, the video camera is out there and I can't leave it.  Frost tonight.  I was using a card scraper, I guess I should have stuck with that.   Had the sander too.   I was removing the failed finish at the time and figured I would give it a light pass and make sure everything was just right to finish up.  Clever eh? (sarcasm).  I was this close to having it finished when I had to strip it back.

:( Dig the top though. I think i learned my lesson with Ash. I think hand planes handle it ok on more flat sawn surfaces but my entire top was Qtr sawn. I love that you put the white strip in the middle looks great, but I'm a sucker for ash for some reason.

For my tear out i sanded it as much as i could and left it. The point i was at any more work would just draw attention to it more. The top was for a friend of mine and i can't even find the spots that tore out now only a month later.

  • Popular Post

Drum sander.  Game over.

1 minute ago, Eric. said:

Drum sander.  Game over.

You used to have a scraping plane, and you sold it. Was it useless?

  • Author

No, I never had a scraping plane.  Just the bench planes for surfaces.  This may just take a lot of work with the card scraper.  I am tempted to use the belt sander, but that would probably to more harm than good.  I would take a free drum sander if anyone has one kicking about they don't want and can pay for the shipping....lol.  Wondering about the big dents and steam though.  The plane landed pretty hard.  Aided by frustration.

 

 

DSC_8783.JPG

DSC_8788.JPG

You can't use a card scraper to get rid of that problem...it'll just create a huge dish on your surface.  Unfortunately you'll have to remove a good amount of thickness of the entire board if you want it to remain flat.

I know drum sanders cost money, but so does every other tool.  They shine in situations like this.

3 minutes ago, Eric. said:

You can't use a card scraper to get rid of that problem...it'll just create a huge dish on your surface.  Unfortunately you'll have to remove a good amount of thickness of the entire board if you want it to remain flat.

I know drum sanders cost money, but so does every other tool.  They shine in situations like this.

Agreed. If money is an issue, a belt sander or ROS will take more time but will work eventually. Start at 40 grit and work way up through the grits once you've gotten to flat material.

41 minutes ago, Eric. said:

Drum sander.  Game over.

Wide belt sander. Game overer.

 

11 minutes ago, Bulldog said:

Wide belt sander. Game overer.

 

Wide belt is beyond the scope of most reasonable hobby shops.  But hey, if you're rich and your shop is in an aircraft hangar, go for it.  Drum sander is right in the wheelhouse for the serious hobbyist.

  • Popular Post

Pay a few dollars to a friendly guy at a local small cabinet shop and let him put it through their drum sander. Sometimes it's easier to do that and cost effective in the short term if you don't currently own suitable equipment.

Using a belt sander and ROS is asking for further trouble with flatness. Why spoil the job for the sake of paying somebody a few bucks and a little damaged pride as you didn't do everything yourself.

I've been playing around with Ash recently, and I've found that a LAJ is pretty good, but even that leaves some small tear out. The cardscraper is your friend at that point.

For this ding though, I agree with everybody else, see how much repair you can do. Steam the dent, try CA-gluing the chip-out back in. If those don't work, trying won't have made the problem any worse.

 

Crazy Idea: What about cutting out the problematic strip and re-gluing the tabletop with a strip of contrasting wood? Embrace the mistake.

If you like the thickness I think I would go with a Dutchman.  If you have scrap from the same boards you may be able to get a good match.  This assumes you can't find the chip out.

I've used them in the past for similar reasons.  I've had good luck making the Dutchman very slightly over sized, tapering the edges and tapping the piece in so it compresses a little as it goes in.  I also make the insert piece diamond shaped to avoid a 90 degree glue line across the grain. Once sanded flat and finished, no one else seems to notice. Of course I do, but it bothers me less and less as time goes on.

Also, hide glue seems to show up less in the finish.

Good luck.

4 hours ago, Immortan D said:

You used to have a scraping plane, and you sold it. Was it useless?

I still have it, actually...however...

It would have been useless in this situation...the tearout is too deep.  Only removing 1/16" or more of thickness from the entire board will remedy this problem in any acceptable way.  That surface is ruined.

All these ideas about patches and gluing stuff back together and filling voids with this or that non-wood material...no good.  I mean they would all work but they would all look terrible.  The Dutchman would work to cover the affected areas but I personally find that kind of stupid...you'd have to wonder why a Dutchman was placed out in the middle of a board for no apparent reason.  Probably to hide some nasty tearout.

The board needs to be resurfaced.  End of story.  Anything else will be inferior.

16 minutes ago, Eric. said:

I still have it, actually...however...

It would have been useless in this situation...the tearout is too deep.  Only removing 1/16" or more of thickness from the entire board will remedy this problem in any acceptable way.  That surface is ruined.

All these ideas about patches and gluing stuff back together and filling voids with this or that non-wood material...no good.  I mean they would all work but they would all look terrible.  The Dutchman would work to cover the affected areas but I personally find that kind of stupid...you'd have to wonder why a Dutchman was placed out in the middle of a board for no apparent reason.  Probably to hide some nasty tearout.

The board needs to be resurfaced.  End of story.  Anything else will be inferior.

Oh I was pretty sure you had it for sale on the marketplace thread and assumed it was gone.

Anyways If I had to smooth "unplanable" wood (before ruining the surface) and wanted to do it with handplanes: what plane would you recommend? high angle smoother or a scraping plane? I've never used either yet I need to pick one.

I'd use a card scraper.

I did have the little scraper plane for sale but no one bought it.  Anyway, it's too pretty to sell even if I hardly ever use it. :)

40 minutes ago, Eric. said:

I'd use a card scraper.

OK that makes sense.

I still wonder in what situation a scraper plane would be the best choice. That plane puzzles me. Oh well...

6 minutes ago, Immortan D said:

OK that makes sense.

I still wonder in what situation a scraper plane would be the best choice. That plane puzzles me. Oh well...

In an older work flow where scraping is more used, I imagine it is a hand comfort relief. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.