Recommended Posts

Posted

Anyone have a good recommendation for a router to use in a lift?  I picked up a scratch-and-dent Woodpeckers router lift (PRL-V2) on sale and now I need another router to live in it full time.  

As a side note, I'm really happy with the scratch-and-dent purchase from Woodpeckers.  Saved $100 and if there are any cosmetic defects, I honestly can't see them. 

Posted

Most routers (not labeled as laminate trimmers) sold in the US have a pretty standard size motor that should fit your lift. Most folks lean toward the highest HP you can find, but frankly I've never had a problem using the cheap 2 hp unit in my table. Porter Cable units are always popular, but Bosch, Dewalt, Makita, Hitachi, and Milwaulkee all have good units as well. Since you are moving it to a lift, look at fixed-base units to avoid extra cost for plunge bases & accessories you don't need.


  • Like 2
Posted

Like Kev said the Porter Cable 7518 is a great choice.  You will never want for more power and if you are going to leave it in the lift only you can purchase just the motor which will save you some money,  not a lot but some.

Porter Cable 7518

Posted

The question is which set of motor pads did the lift come with, despite the impression some are giving all router motors are NOT the same size.  Even the 7518 and 5625 are different sizes (the Milwaukee is just a hair smaller, enough to need shimming if you have the 7518 pads).  

Posted

Good point about the motor pads. I purchased it with the Bosch 1617 motor pads, because that's the router I have now.  But since I'll need a new router to use as a dedicated router for the lift I probably should have thought this through better first.  I can purchase new motor pads from Woodpeckers for $30, or maybe they would exchange the ones I have for different ones.  I'm kind of leaning towards @wtnhighlander's advice though, and just getting another Bosch and using the motor pads I have, since this would save me a significant amount of money.  I don't run a ton of stock through my router table.  I use it mainly for flush trimming, routing fairly simply edge profiles and an occasional stopped mortise.  I've never had a problem with my Bosch handling anything before.  I wonder if I'm being short sighted here and will regret down the road not sucking it up and getting the bigger motor.

Posted

Like I mentioned above, I have the PC 7518 in my table and the Bosch 1617 is my hand held.  They are both great machines.  Both have soft start and adjustable speed which is important, you don't want to run large diameter bits at high speed.  So basically what it boils down to is the PC has one more horse power.  Maybe what you should try is using your existing Bosch 1617 in the lift do some of the type of work you plan on using it for and see how it goes.  I know it is a hassle to change back and forth but better to make an educated decision then a guess that may end up as a frustration because of a lack of power. 

I will add that the other day I was using my table for a 5/8 inch radius round over and I don't think I would have been happy doing that with the Bosch.  I think I would have had to go so slow that there would have been some burning of the wood.

Posted

I prefer either the big Milwaukee or PC in a router table, but then I think 5hp is minimum for a shaper.  

There is a rather significant price difference for the options, a 1617 is $150 on eBay and a 7518 motor will run you right at $300 so add the pads and you are around $340 so $190 difference.  IF it is in the budget the bigger motors are a no brainer for a table if not I honestly might deal with the trouble of switching the 1617 in and out until I had the money for a big motor.

Posted

I have the Milwaukee 5625 3hp router in a Jessem Master Lifter lift and I absolutely love it. It has excellent speed and load control. The collets.are easy to use and grip well. You can even use it without a lift if you want - the base has adjustment in it, although it is a bit crude. It runs fairly quiet too. Tbe collet can be raised above the table for bit change. I have used the big PC routers as well and I prefer the Milwaukee.

Posted
8 hours ago, wtnhighlander said:

If I did any work that required a 3hp router table, I think I'd move on to a shaper.

(can you hear me, PB?)

I think I'm with you on this one.  I'll save a significant amount of money by using another 2 1/4 hp 1617.  If I ever want to do something that requires a lot of hp, like raised panels, I can figure out an alternative way to do it.  More than one way to skin a cat.  Plus, the money I save can be used towards more tools, since there seems to be a never ending list of things I want to get.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted
On 11/15/2016 at 8:03 PM, Dknapp34 said:

Anyone have a good recommendation for a router to use in a lift?  I picked up a scratch-and-dent Woodpeckers router lift (PRL-V2) on sale and now I need another router to live in it full time.  

As a side note, I'm really happy with the scratch-and-dent purchase from Woodpeckers.  Saved $100 and if there are any cosmetic defects, I honestly can't see them. 

Are you looking to spend $300 on a router or looking for something smaller?

Posted

The two standard answers to this question have not changed in a decade; Porter-Cable 7518 or Milwaukee 5625.  I've run a 5625 in a PRL for nearly 10 years and it has done nothing but run.  The bearings, speed control and collets work the same as they did on day one.  They do over-build their collets a bit (here's one next to a DeWalt)

collet-compare-1.jpg

but, I believe they are in line with the Porter-Cable (same wrench size too).  I would add the $100 you saved on the lift to the cost of a 2-1/4HP router and step up to one of these locomotives.

 

  • Like 1
Posted
21 minutes ago, gee-dub said:

 

The two standard answers to this question have not changed in a decade; Porter-Cable 7518 or Milwaukee 5625.

 

So true. I have the PC 7518 and it is a tank. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I cut this 3/4" profile in wenge in a single pass with my Bosch MRF23EVS router.  It is 2.3hp and was $130 for a refurb. 

I don't think you can use it with a lift, however.  it is a trigger switch in the handle.  However it has an above table micro adjust.  

But 2.3hp on a dedicated circuit was plenty of power to make a 3/4" profile in wenge. 

image.jpegimage.jpeg

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 50 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined