Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Looking for advice on bench

Featured Replies

I'm going to preface this post with the fact that I am an amateur woodworking looking to expand into fine woodworking and expand the garage into more of a shop.

So with that being said I have been using a workmate and just the standard kitchen cabinets as a workbench, I'm on a tight budget and do this as a hobbyist almost part time income.

I have a design for a bench and I have a few questions about the top slab:

Should I build a large flat top or a split roubo design?

Would dimensional SPF lumber be solid enough for me to use as a half decent bench until I can zero in on a bench design better suited for my specific needs later on.

Essentially I am planning on a 36x70 top and the base to be off center slightly with a 36x50 footprint. I'd like to make a leg vise and have a tail vise as well.

Any advice on these would greatly help me out. Thanks in advance

Sent from my SM-G903W using Tapatalk

What kind of tools do you plan to use, more power tools or hand tools?  Power tools require a little less of a bench as far as pounding on them goes.  I built my bench from doug fir.  It's soft, but not unworkable, I was in a similar position to you when I started, had more time than money.  I'd look up the hardness of the lumber you have available and start from there. 

One thing to look for when buying construction lumber for a bench is that it is kiln dried (KD).  You don't want to mess with green lumber for a bench. 

  • Author
What kind of tools do you plan to use, more power tools or hand tools?  Power tools require a little less of a bench as far as pounding on them goes.  I built my bench from doug fir.  It's soft, but not unworkable, I was in a similar position to you when I started, had more time than money.  I'd look up the hardness of the lumber you have available and start from there. 

One thing to look for when buying construction lumber for a bench is that it is kiln dried (KD).  You don't want to mess with green lumber for a bench. 

I'd really like to start using more hand tools than power tools but they all cost an arm and a leg in the long run. Right now I have alot more power than hand but it's also nice to have a bench that can be used somewhat as an assembly table. So I think using SPF or construction grade lumber will work just fine for me at this point. I can move into a nice maple bench later on.

Also did you build a split top or a solid top for yours?

Sent from my SM-G903W using Tapatalk

By all means, construction lumber will do you just fine, not only for your first bench but for any bench.  I've made two benches from the lousiest, leftover spruce in the pile.  One even had some old pressure-treated crap from a demolished deck.  Never once did I find myself thinking, "Golly, I wish I had spent more money on materials."

36" strikes me as excessive.  My second bench was 24" deep and I could have gone narrower still.  The split top design was conceived for hobbyists, since the two slabs can be flattened independently using a portable thickness planer.  Clearly, then, the max width for the top would be your planer width times two plus whatever the gap.

If you have any aspirations of doing hand tool work, build thick and heavy.  Power tools can work on a rickety dining table, but with hand tools you need to be able to put your weight against something that won't move.

 

  • Author
By all means, construction lumber will do you just fine, not only for your first bench but for any bench.  I've made two benches from the lousiest, leftover spruce in the pile.  One even had some old pressure-treated crap from a demolished deck.  Never once did I find myself thinking, "Golly, I wish I had spent more money on materials."

36" strikes me as excessive.  My second bench was 24" deep and I could have gone narrower still.  The split top design was conceived for hobbyists, since the two slabs can be flattened independently using a portable thickness planer.  Clearly, then, the max width for the top would be your planer width times two plus whatever the gap.

If you have any aspirations of doing hand tool work, build thick and heavy.  Power tools can work on a rickety dining table, but with hand tools you need to be able to put your weight against something that won't move.

 

I was thinking of building it fairly stout. About 6" thick top and approximately 2x6 material for the base structure so I have lots of girth. I think I will use the split top method. It will save on material cost and I can have a small little gully for hand tools if I need to place a big object down. Thanks for the 2 cents it's all adding up here guys.

Sent from my SM-G903W using Tapatalk

I would skip the 6" top.  It will be hard to find holdfasts and other accessories at 6".  I would use 2x10, rip them in half and final mill to about 4". 

4 minutes ago, Chewie17 said:

I was thinking of building it fairly stout. About 6" thick top and approximately 2x6 material for the base structure so I have lots of girth.

My personal opinion is 6" is to thick.  I don't think standard hold downs will work with that thickness and you're going to have a hell of time building it because of the weight.  I would not do anything over 4,  As far as the split top goes, that is a personal preference and they don't work for me.  I put in 2 partitioned spits so I could take advantage of the clamping options they provide, and I have never regretted the decision. 

  • Author

For some reason I always felt like 4" wasn't think enough for a top but here again the weight would be killer with thicker material. This will be my first workbench so it's a good learning experience for me but I'd rather ask for advice than curse myself for not listening to more experienced persons.

Sent from my SM-G903W using Tapatalk

The weight is really only necessary for things like hand planing and chiseling.  For power tools, it will make practically no difference.  You might want to consider a first bench like the Paulk workbench: 

And then build a hand tool bench later.  It seems like a lot of folks end up having two benches, 1 for assembly/power tools (like using a track saw or router) and another for hand tools.  

  • Author
The weight is really only necessary for things like hand planing and chiseling.  For power tools, it will make practically no difference.  You might want to consider a first bench like the Paulk workbench: 

And then build a hand tool bench later.  It seems like a lot of folks end up having two benches, 1 for assembly/power tools (like using a track saw or router) and another for hand tools.  

Ron Paulk makes a really sweet bench I know I'll want to be doing more hand tool work in the future. I like taking my time with things and for me I tend to get a better quality with a hand tool than a power tool. So I am building this bench with the intent to use it with hand tools in the near future.

I will go with a 4" top and about 26" but split top. The base will be slightly less than that but still stout enough to use hand tools when I want to.

Sent from my SM-G903W using Tapatalk

I use a 24" x 60" bench made of SPF. No split. Top is about 3" thick after a couple of re-flattenings. It is plenty stout enough for hand tool work, but I do have ballast on the lower shelf, so it doesn't scoot across the floor. Softwood works fine with a hold-fast, but gets chewed up. Construction grade lumber is also more likely to warp the slab, I had to plane mine once to remove twist, and later to clean up the splinters from beating the crap out of it. Still perfectly servicable, but ugly.

Doing it again, I would consider a top with 3 sections of 11" or 12" each, with two splits. The splits add clamping options, and the extra width lets it do double-duty as a tablesaw outfeed and assembly surface in my smallish workspace. I might use a harder species for the top, but probably not the legs. I also think I would put an apron on one side, Nicholson-style, rather than use vices on the face AND end. Maybe.

I like the split top on my Roubo I use it for clamping on a regular basis.

11 hours ago, andrew-in-austin said:

The weight is really only necessary for things like hand planing and chiseling.  For power tools, it will make practically no difference.  You might want to consider a first bench like the Paulk workbench: 

And then build a hand tool bench later.  It seems like a lot of folks end up having two benches, 1 for assembly/power tools (like using a track saw or router) and another for hand tools.  

That looks like a commercial work bench.Festool commercial :lol:

Aj

18 minutes ago, Aj3 said:

That looks like a commercial work bench.Festool commercial :lol:

I see what you did there...

-E

15 hours ago, Chewie17 said:

I'd really like to start using more hand tools than power tools but they all cost an arm and a leg in the long run. Right now I have alot more power than hand but it's also nice to have a bench that can be used somewhat as an assembly table. So I think using SPF or construction grade lumber will work just fine for me at this point. I can move into a nice maple bench later on.

Also did you build a split top or a solid top for yours?

Sent from my SM-G903W using Tapatalk

Mine is a solid top.  I haven't glued it together yet and I was using it for planing over the weekend and it was working great.  I had originally planned on drawboring the legs to the top but I'm not sure it's necessary now.  I'll probably still do it just for the practice. 

 

My bench top is 3" thick maple.  Softer, more flexible wood I would think about 3 1/2 to 4".  I made mine with a spit top - two 12" wide pieces with a 2" gap and I use the gap for clamping-----a lot, love it.  I made a couple of "trays" that fit in the slot and I can slide them along to be wherever I want.  One tray is for small stuff like screws and one has slots for chisels, rasps, small squares and other tools that I don't want hitting the floor accidentally.  my bench build was very satisfying.  Have fun!

I don't think any of us can tell you what your bench needs to be.  Anything from a laminated plywood top and a sturdy base to a beautiful work-of-art Roubo could be very serviceable for you.  It needs to have enough mass for stability and a flat top.  Beyond that is up to you...

A six inch top is excessive though.  3-4" is certainly the norm.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.